Welcome to Flyer Talk rliess

oneworld emerald (OWE) is not necessarily better than star alliance gold (*G)

some OWE benefits are better than the corresponding *G benefit
some *G benefits are better than the corresponding OWE benefit
some airlines have extra benefits for their own elites
some airlines have a second level of *G (eg HON Circle for LH) with further benefits

which is best depends on your travel patterns and which benefits you value the most