FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - First Bag Fees & 2009 OnePass Program Changes
Old Sep 6, 2008 | 10:25 am
  #319  
SAT Lawyer
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Programs: UA Gold MM; AA Gold MM; WN A-List; IHG Diamond Ambassador; Marriott Gold; Hyatt Explorist
Posts: 24,564
Let me illustrate a prime example of how badly CO's changes will impact me and how they make it all but impossible to justify choosing CO over WN on one of my main routes. I travel from San Antonio to Edinburg, Texas, very frequently to attend hearings and take depositions. Many other lawyers in San Antonio, Houston, Austin, and Dallas do the same. My flights are also chock full with doctors, pharmaceutical sales representatives, engineers, and other professionals traveling to "the Valley," many of whom, like me, make day trips or have single-night stays. Here is how my options stack up:
WN
Route: SAT-HRL (Harlingen) nonstop
Travel time: 1 hour flight + 45 minute drive
Round-trip cost: $283.00 for an Anytime fare
Round-trip reward: 2 Rapid Rewards credits (8 of these net a free ticket)

CO
Route: SAT-IAH-MFE (McAllen) one-stop
Travel time: 3-4 hours for flights/layover + 15 minute drive
Round-trip cost: $345.00 for a full Y fare
Round-trip mileage pre-changes: 3000 EQM + 4500 RDM (5.5 of these net a free ticket)
Round-trip mileage post-changes: 1521 EQM + 2028 RDM (12 of these net a free ticket)
Now, how can I justify giving CO my business? It costs my clients more money, takes me twice as long door-to-door, and I'll wind up with roughly half the elite qualifying miles and less than half the redeemable miles. Yeah, I'll be in first class, but a one-hour flight on WN with seemingly endless drink coupons ain't that much worse. And instead of being a Platinum, I might be a Silver, and now OnePass awards effectively become twice as expensive as they were before.

Last edited by SAT Lawyer; Sep 6, 2008 at 10:41 am
SAT Lawyer is offline