Originally Posted by
RichardInSF
While I believe your explanation is more than sufficient to keep us all patient for another week or two, I just wish to emphasize my gut feeling that this is not an issue where time alone will heal all wounds. I suspect I am not alone in still eagerly awaiting your views.
You're not alone!
My own position is that TB have fixed things themselves - but with Randy having stepped in there is a bit of a question mark over how valid TB's 'fix' is. We really need Randy's specific comments as to whether the motions that TB have passed have been acccepted or not, and his comments generally.
Originally Posted by
KathyWdrf
Sometimes I think this whole recent brouhaha is an example of "no good deed going unpunished."
I know the requester personally, and am convinced of her and her daughter's good intentions. Furthermore, I'm convinced that the TalkBoard members all meant well, yet got excoriated ruthlessly for their actions.
I think we need to await Randy's comments before getting into this debate (or even better not getting into this debate!
), but for me the issue was never about either
jan_az or her daughter who I have no doubt have good intentions - it was about the motion as worded which made no reference at all to
jan_az and her daughter.