There doesn't seem to be another obsessive over analyzing here, for a proper Flyertalk forum.

So what are your thoughts on the AGR redemptions, relative to value?

The Chart

From a quick look, it seems like Business class in the Northeast is a complete waste of points, since it's 3500 points extra for an upgrade that may only cost $36. OTOH, on the multi-zone trips, Business class seems like something you should always take over coach because it's only about 15-25% more points.

Actually, that coach fare for the Northeast seems like the best deal in general. 3000 points for tickets that regularly run $100+. Compared to some single zone tickets that I was pricing that that were more like $60-75, that would be almost double the points.