Then why have I switched to AA as my primary carrier?

I think you mean I am not bashing UA as much as you would like. I am one of the few people who doesn't bandy about an airline as a religious affliation.

I have not rated this just looking at the best feature or worst feature but what one is likely to encounter over a long period. So a good dinner service on a specific flight when most flights have zip even in FC or a great first suite on a few aircraft while are truly uncomfortable in most other plane or categories doesn't earn high grades unless one travels only in flagship suites and only with flagship dinner service.
And more important, my ratings come from what I have experienced, not from what I have read.

Of course, your evaluation may vary from mine.