The largest expert travel community:
  • 699,685 Total members
  • 5,996 Users online now
  • 1,620,813 Threads
  • 28,654,767 Posts
Crewed Talk

Sick Crews Are in a No-Win Situation

Sick Crews Are in a No-Win Situation
Amanda Pleva

It’s that time of year – the stocking are hung by the chimney with care, brightly-colored decorations and lights adorn homes and trees…and everyone is getting sick. In fact, I’m sick as a dog while I write this. All I want to do is stay in bed all day with a massive cup of steaming hot tea, hair a mess, binge-watching The Walking Dead. But I can’t, and that’s because I have to go to the airport. It’s only for a mandatory work training session this time, but it wouldn’t be unusual for me to be heading off to fly in my current state, nose redder than Rudolph on a bender.

In that respect, I’m far from alone. Flight attendants get sick time we are permitted to take, but it can be very dangerous to use. We get the same amount of sick time as, say, an average office worker, but if we happen to fall ill over time periods where staffing might be more thinly stretched, the sick days count as double. Many airlines assign points to certain days or time periods, making sick calls count more heavily against us when staffing might be spread more thinly. And as one would assume, our close interaction with the public makes us more vulnerable to getting sick. So get a mild cold earlier in the year just to have The Big One hit any time over the holiday season – when everyone gets sick – now you’re facing disciplinary action. It can happen that easily.

It’s a tough call for airlines, because assigning different point value to certain days or times of year prevents less honest people from regularly using sick time to secure holidays off as opposed to paying their dues until their seniority builds. If everyone were able to pull that trick, it would result in tons of canceled flights or pulling senior crews to work them for much higher wages (as American is doing with their pilots right now). Unfortunately, cold and flu season coincides with holidays, so legitimately unwell pilots and flight attendants feel uncomfortable racking up points if they must call out from a trip or two to take care of themselves. Also, it isn’t out of the ordinary to wake up on a layover to find you’re feeling like you’ve been run over by a truck and now your options are to either operate the flight back home or to call out sick in a non-base city and probably delay or potentially cancel the flight, drawing the ire of your company, passengers and crew. The choice is usually very clear – suffer through it for everyone’s sake.

All of this is even harder on the new hires, who are on probation and more closely watched. Worse yet, they tend to have tougher schedules, working unnatural hours and often flying multiple legs a day, which does a number on the immune system. When sick time stays on the record for a rolling year, getting sick twice can lead to some tough decisions. And to make matters worse, most airlines don’t accept doctor notes, so there’s no excusing anyone who happens to have bad luck health-wise.

Flight attendants and pilots alike feel immense pressure to fly while sick. The obvious answer to increase staffing over valuable time periods would be to offer pay incentives (not every airline, for instance, offers an increased pay rate over Christmas), but airlines, their investors and passengers would be less than pleased with that scenario, since it would increase fares. (Wall Street has made their views on crew wages very clear.) This, then, leaves us at a stalemate.

So, after this training session, I plan to do just what I was looking forward to – rest, hydration and bad television: the trifecta of healing. All I can do is take care of myself while I’m infirm and hope to nip it in the bud before my next trip. But if I’m not, it’ll unfortunately be a tough call as to what to do, since Christmas is on the horizon and these are high-point days for sick calls. I hope it doesn’t come to flying sick, but it’s just the unenviable position myself and my colleagues are put in this time of year. Pass the echinacea and wish me luck!

[Photo: Shutterstock]

View Comments (5)

5 Comments

  1. fairhsa

    December 5, 2017 at 5:22 pm

    I assume this is a US-centric article? Most countries have laws about sick leave which do not allow companies to reduce the number of days by some arbitrary points system.

  2. Endventure

    December 9, 2017 at 11:03 pm

    This issue is similar in healthcare workers….call out and force team members to work extra shifts or come in and expose vulnerable patients. It’s also truly a no win situation. I was on a flight tonight sitting next to a gal who admitted she had been diagnosed with influenza earlier in the day and wanted to just sleep, Even though she had started taking Tamiflu to reduce her symptoms, she was still in the range of shedding her virus. I work with a vulnerable pediatric population thus despite having my flu shot (which is about 60% effective this year), I will have to make decisions about my own health and potential to spread the virus. One can be contagious several days before symptoms begin. I don’t have a great answer for what to do but the conundrum of calling out sick and it’s downstream effects versus coming in and spreading disease to others is an issue in many occupations…especially where tight quarters are guaranteed…like the airline and healthcare industries. The points system described above is especially egregious.

  3. Asiaflyguy

    December 12, 2017 at 10:55 am

    You are not unique and you always seem to have an uncanny way of thinking FA’s are unique from other industries. I was sick too for the last three weeks, am a high mileage road warrior, so could not stay home in bed either, though would not have binged watched the walking dead…

    If your sick you are sick and if you cannot take time off, perhaps you should be penning a note to your union delagate

  4. sweeper20

    December 12, 2017 at 11:32 am

    Thank you Asiaflyguy – I was thinking the exact same thing.

  5. flyboy_421

    December 14, 2017 at 10:37 am

    The pressure is really unfortunate. Flight crews pilots especially are required by law to be safe to fly. If the pilot self determines that they are unsafe to fly due to illness they are not legally allowed to fly the plane. The pilot is the final word on this not the airline, and should an accident occur the pilot would be held responsible.

You must be logged in on the FORUM to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

More in Crewed Talk

How to Make Holiday Travel a Little Less Miserable

Amanda PlevaNovember 28, 2017

Stop, or Your Crew Will Shoot – Will Body Cameras Become Part of the Uniform?

Amanda PlevaNovember 14, 2017

A Primer For Would-Be Flight Attendants

Amanda PlevaNovember 7, 2017

Copyright © 2014 Top News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by Wordpress.