Originally Posted by mduell;16224832L
I think you're putting way too much faith in the mental capacity of the GA. I this scenario the GA already started with the "untruths" and lying:
So their should be no fight left in the "liar" GA at this point. Seems the agent whose credibility is in question was far more reliable in their statements than the op. Again, no need to make up bs stories about connections to Vladivostok or lie about having hazardous materials in your bag. I don't give the ga too much credit, they came thru, and delivered what was committed to, so I gave them the correct amount of credit. Those that bet incorrectly gave not enuf credit. Those that believed the op had an 8 am flight to yvr as he stated gave too much credit to him. |
Originally Posted by fastair
(Post 16226666)
ok, so the ga said it would make it, it did. Also, what carrier operates an 8am flight sea-yvr? I don't accept that everything posted from 1 side is speakers factual. The op questioned the agent's statement that the bag would make it (was correct) while he claims to be on a non-existent flight on any carrier that goes from sea-yvr at 8am.
Seems the agent whose credibility is in question was far more reliable in their statements than the op. Again, no need to make up bs stories about connections to Vladivostok or lie about having hazardous materials in your bag. I don't give the ga too much credit, they came thru, and delivered what was committed to, so I gave them the correct amount of credit. Those that bet incorrectly gave not enuf credit. Those that believed the op had an 8 am flight to yvr as he stated gave too much credit to him. In this case, according to the OP the GA "insisted there was no way my bag would miss my connection". Would you agree with that kind of statement? I'd say there was a darn good chance (with a 20 min connection and two gates as far apart as possible at UA's SFO T3) that the bag would not make it. It seems clear the GA was promising/guaranteeing something that was completely out of their control. And the OP was lucky and fortunate that the bag made it. And hopefully the hard disk is still functional. Regarding the 8am flight from SEA to YVR, this might simply be a misunderstanding. His original statement was "An plus I leave Seattle at 8 am heading to Vancouver, then onward to about 10 other cities over next few days" -- that doesn't necessarily mean a flight to YVR. Later the OP said he was going to be with family in Seattle til Saturday. Could be a road trip with family. If the OP is still following this thread, a clarification might help here. |
I note the OP never posted the size of the bag in question.
The obnoxious anti-carry-on bag gate agents usually test everyone. Since the OP was singled out, I suspect the bag was well oversized. |
Originally Posted by tlawrence85
(Post 16221407)
While I don't agree with what the flight attendant did according to the OP (singling him out and making him check his bag), I'd be careful to claim this as a "right". I'm not sure this so-called right is guaranteed by anything (e.g. law, CoC, etc)...
|
Originally Posted by notquiteaff
(Post 16227128)
I believe it was you who insisted in previous threads that you'd never even tell people whether they'd have enough time to go to the bath room before departure, reasoning that you don't know how long they'll need and what they'll do once they are in there. Fine, I agree.
In this case, according to the OP the GA "insisted there was no way my bag would miss my connection". Would you agree with that kind of statement? I'd say there was a darn good chance (with a 20 min connection and two gates as far apart as possible at UA's SFO T3) that the bag would not make it. It seems clear the GA was promising/guaranteeing something that was completely out of their control. And the OP was lucky and fortunate that the bag made it. And hopefully the hard disk is still functional. Regarding the 8am flight from SEA to YVR, this might simply be a misunderstanding. His original statement was "An plus I leave Seattle at 8 am heading to Vancouver, then onward to about 10 other cities over next few days" -- that doesn't necessarily mean a flight to YVR. Later the OP said he was going to be with family in Seattle til Saturday. Could be a road trip with family. If the OP is still following this thread, a clarification might help here. |
Originally Posted by fastair
(Post 16226666)
ok, so the ga said it would make it, it did. Also, what carrier operates an 8am flight sea-yvr? I don't accept that everything posted from 1 side is speakers factual. The op questioned the agent's statement that the bag would make it (was correct) while he claims to be on a non-existent flight on any carrier that goes from sea-yvr at 8am.
Seems the agent whose credibility is in question was far more reliable in their statements than the op. Again, no need to make up bs stories about connections to Vladivostok or lie about having hazardous materials in your bag. I don't give the ga too much credit, they came thru, and delivered what was committed to, so I gave them the correct amount of credit. Those that bet incorrectly gave not enuf credit. Those that believed the op had an 8 am flight to yvr as he stated gave too much credit to him. the 8 am "flight" was a toyota camry i picked up from hertz to drive up :) |
Originally Posted by Always Flyin
(Post 16227624)
I note the OP never posted the size of the bag in question.
The obnoxious anti-carry-on bag gate agents usually test everyone. Since the OP was singled out, I suspect the bag was well oversized. |
Originally Posted by Pyridoxine
(Post 16224140)
This wasnt just a MR, i was in new york on work from april 6-10, vegas for NAB from 11-14, seattle till sat to visit family, then the last 3 days were just tagged on for a MR. There was other purpose for the trip and other stuff was needed than just a couple changes of clothes
|
All of the wasted angst. Twenty minutes for the Ramp to manage transfer bags was plenty of time. I would be wiling to bet real money they had the OP's bag off the plane before the OP was off the plane.
|
Originally Posted by JeffS
(Post 16228062)
All of the wasted angst. Twenty minutes for the Ramp to manage transfer bags was plenty of time. I would be wiling to bet real money they had the OP's bag off the plane before the OP was off the plane.
Was forced to gate check a bag last year in MCO because I was late boarding. I jammed my necessary items into a small garbage bag provided by the GA and surrendered my bag in a hurry so as to not the delay the flight. My bag didn't arrive with me in SFO and, in fact, showed-up 3 days late. I found out that my bag got routed to PHL and was lost there for two days. But I got 15,000 miles and money to buy clothing for my trouble, and profuse apologies. I was taught a valuable lesson from this experience and the embarrassment of having to delay a business meeting so that I could buy a new suit and necessities, etc.---NEVER EVER GATE CHECK! |
Originally Posted by Pyridoxine
(Post 16227918)
the 8 am "flight" was a toyota camry i picked up from hertz to drive up :)
I don't think that you will hear any more from him! |
Originally Posted by JeffS
(Post 16228062)
All of the wasted angst. Twenty minutes for the Ramp to manage transfer bags was plenty of time. I would be wiling to bet real money they had the OP's bag off the plane before the OP was off the plane.
|
Originally Posted by mre5765
(Post 16228042)
Fair enough. I think you needed to pack a light carry on for your mr and a checked bag for the other stuff.
That could make sense in most situations, however, This trip is the one where i get my first stage status as a 2p. So during the trip i would have had to pay the bag fees for each leg. And since i never went home between these trips, the checked bag would have been following me around to my tours of many airports, on only MRs i do pack much lighter. After all was said and done, I am very thankful that my bag did make it, and heck im glad even I made the flight. I noticed later that united didnt even expect ME to make the flight, and had auto rebooked me the next morning. So the ground crew in SFO gets much props from me, they hauled ... and got my bag there. And as for those that questioned the facts i gave.....why would i make stuff up, fudge details, then go post them on an internet message board? I dont get any benefeit besides knowledge for future trips to try and avoid similar situations. |
Originally Posted by Pyridoxine
(Post 16229589)
TAfter all was said and done, I am very thankful that my bag did make it, and heck im glad even I made the flight. I noticed later that united didnt even expect ME to make the flight, and had auto rebooked me the next morning. So the ground crew in SFO gets much props from me, they hauled ... and got my bag there.
And as for those that questioned the facts i gave.....why would i make stuff up, fudge details, then go post them on an internet message board? I dont get any benefeit besides knowledge for future trips to try and avoid similar situations. As for those who questioned your facts . . . It may not necessarily be the case here, but there are always those who will question the facts when the OP's "facts" place the airline in wrong. |
Originally Posted by controller1
(Post 16229639)
Glad both you and your bags made it.
As for those who questioned your facts . . . It may not necessarily be the case here, but there are always those who will question the facts when the OP's "facts" place the airline in wrong. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 2:18 pm. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.