Last edit by: WineCountryUA
The way of the Dodo? - 1K upgrades, PP or CPU
#181
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: NYC
Programs: UA-1K MM, AA-Gold, DL-Silver, AS-MVP
Posts: 2,508
I don't think it is that much more frustrating than before on finding PZ space and using PP. My first search today and I found PZ1 on BOS-LHR on 15AUG. (4th search and I found PZ1 on EWR-LHR on 15AUG).
I have also found PZ availability or cleared waitlist on 4 out of 5 TATL flights this year. Certainly I think there are more people traveling now and less incentive for UA to open up PZ and more incentive for them to upsell their J seats. They still need to make up for the loss of business travelers.
But my travel pattern is rather flexible, I can travel mid-week, and I don't mind investing the time in looking for PZ space. I also book a lot of J fares, so never really use up all my PP.
And does DL or AA actually have more upgrade availability than UA? Their business cabins are usually smaller than UA.
I have also found PZ availability or cleared waitlist on 4 out of 5 TATL flights this year. Certainly I think there are more people traveling now and less incentive for UA to open up PZ and more incentive for them to upsell their J seats. They still need to make up for the loss of business travelers.
But my travel pattern is rather flexible, I can travel mid-week, and I don't mind investing the time in looking for PZ space. I also book a lot of J fares, so never really use up all my PP.
And does DL or AA actually have more upgrade availability than UA? Their business cabins are usually smaller than UA.
#182
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2014
Location: MSP
Programs: DL PM, UA Gold, WN, Global Entry; +others wherever miles/points are found
Posts: 14,395
Well, Delta is in the process of ending all own-metal two-class (Y to J, skipping PE) upgrades, but if you pay for PE their availability for J is significantly better (equivalent of P class being used for upgrades on UA). And right now DL regional certificates are also good for the equivalent of P class, which is very nice. So a bit of YMMV over there.
#183
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Washington, DC
Programs: UA 1K 1MM, AA, DL
Posts: 7,418
Seems like there are two gripes:
1) It is hard to search for flights with available PZ space. That's been a problem for a while, and is annoying.
2) There are a lot of PP chasing not many premium seats. That's a result of an uptick in travel and a lot of travelers willing to pay for premium cabin, along with a lot of PP sloshing around out there. Not much you can do if people are willing to pay for premium cabin - upgrades always come after them. As for PP, I've always been troubled by their expiration . . . I'd say let people keep using them, though with the priority to which they're entitled if they drop in status, indefinitely. Eventually people will use them up anyway.
1) It is hard to search for flights with available PZ space. That's been a problem for a while, and is annoying.
2) There are a lot of PP chasing not many premium seats. That's a result of an uptick in travel and a lot of travelers willing to pay for premium cabin, along with a lot of PP sloshing around out there. Not much you can do if people are willing to pay for premium cabin - upgrades always come after them. As for PP, I've always been troubled by their expiration . . . I'd say let people keep using them, though with the priority to which they're entitled if they drop in status, indefinitely. Eventually people will use them up anyway.
#184
Join Date: May 2001
Location: RNO, NV, USA.
Programs: UA 2MM
Posts: 5,059
simonoaks - I agree. You are raising several important points. Thinking of TPAC flights to NRT or ICN, from SFO/LAX, it is definitely more frustrating/ impossible to locate PZ space, even with flexible travel plans. Asia is opening up to tourism and many flights are 100% full a week before departure. Prices of even coach are very high. Although there is no “change fee” as such, you cannot change flights to improve upgrade chances, as you would need to buy up to a U ticket. 😳 I too have over 500 PP. This has all changed in the last few months.
#185
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 21,369
#186
Moderator: United Airlines
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: SFO
Programs: UA Plat 1.99MM, Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott Plat/LT Gold, Hilton Silver, IHG Plat
Posts: 66,780
Asia has its own issues at the moment
But the limited premium cabin upgrade and awards TATL are as true but that is due partially for the high premium leisure demand
#187
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Houston TX
Programs: UN 1K MM, Marriott-LT TitanElite, Hyatt Glob; HH-Gold
Posts: 74
Getting Frustrated with my useless Plus Points
I am a consistent 1K and have applied my plus points to multiple flights. In the past, I would not book a flight unless I could book using them. Unfortunately, since COVID, I haven't found any flights that I can book using them and I still want to go on vacation. I figured I should be able to clear the waitlist, and have booked "waitlisting." I am not clearing. The frustration is once I apply my PlusPoints and wait for an upgrade, I am no longer able to see what United would "charge" me if I purchased the upgrade. Is anyone aware of a loophole where I could see what United would charge to upgrade once PlusPoints are applied?
I have a flight from SFO to SIN on Saturday that I will not clear. I have a flight to EWR to CDG in Sept and flights to HI next year that I'm "waitlisted." I have 470 Plus Points and can't use them. I have never used this forum to "vent" but clearly I'm doing that now. However, my main question is... is there a way to see what United would charge me to upgrade without canceling my Plus Points?
I have a flight from SFO to SIN on Saturday that I will not clear. I have a flight to EWR to CDG in Sept and flights to HI next year that I'm "waitlisted." I have 470 Plus Points and can't use them. I have never used this forum to "vent" but clearly I'm doing that now. However, my main question is... is there a way to see what United would charge me to upgrade without canceling my Plus Points?
#188
Join Date: May 2007
Programs: UA 1K, Hyatt Globalist
Posts: 5,447
Call or Twitter DM. An agent should be able to see what the "TOD" upgrade offer currently is.
#189
Join Date: Jul 2011
Programs: AA Plat, UA 1K>Plat>moving to Silver
Posts: 2,083
I am a consistent 1K and have applied my plus points to multiple flights. In the past, I would not book a flight unless I could book using them. Unfortunately, since COVID, I haven't found any flights that I can book using them and I still want to go on vacation. I figured I should be able to clear the waitlist, and have booked "waitlisting." I am not clearing. The frustration is once I apply my PlusPoints and wait for an upgrade, I am no longer able to see what United would "charge" me if I purchased the upgrade. Is anyone aware of a loophole where I could see what United would charge to upgrade once PlusPoints are applied?
I have a flight from SFO to SIN on Saturday that I will not clear. I have a flight to EWR to CDG in Sept and flights to HI next year that I'm "waitlisted." I have 470 Plus Points and can't use them. I have never used this forum to "vent" but clearly I'm doing that now. However, my main question is... is there a way to see what United would charge me to upgrade without canceling my Plus Points?
I have a flight from SFO to SIN on Saturday that I will not clear. I have a flight to EWR to CDG in Sept and flights to HI next year that I'm "waitlisted." I have 470 Plus Points and can't use them. I have never used this forum to "vent" but clearly I'm doing that now. However, my main question is... is there a way to see what United would charge me to upgrade without canceling my Plus Points?
However, if you are willing to fly on other airlines (I am, though I have been 1K off and on for a number of years) and have miles that are transferable from various credit cards, there is more upgrade for miles space on BA and AF/KLM these days. BA can be searched for on their site. AF/KLM can be searched for using ExpertFlyer. I have already booked a number through the end of the year. Both are much higher quality than UA.
#190
Join Date: Aug 2021
Location: IAD
Programs: UA Plat, HH Diamond, Supersonic (BA1Y, BA1223)
Posts: 221
#191
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: PHX
Programs: AS 75K; UA 1MM; Hyatt Globalist; Marriott LTP; Hilton Diamond (Aspire)
Posts: 56,423
#192
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: DAY
Programs: UA 1K 1MM; Marriott LT Titanium; Amex MR; Chase UR; Hertz PC; Global Entry
Posts: 10,157
Yes a truly brilliant thread title.
And let's be clear, the primary extinction event was the UA policy change to stop running sweeps prior to T-24. I would be sitting in F this evening - and easily - if UA had a run a sweep at T-96 or T-72.
Here's how disgusted I am - now booking away primarily to WN for my weekly commute. Lower fares, equivalent schedule, and I don't have to cross the bay, saving minimum of 30 minutes each direction. If I'm going to sit in cattle class, might as well choose based on fare and convenience.
And let's be clear, the primary extinction event was the UA policy change to stop running sweeps prior to T-24. I would be sitting in F this evening - and easily - if UA had a run a sweep at T-96 or T-72.
Here's how disgusted I am - now booking away primarily to WN for my weekly commute. Lower fares, equivalent schedule, and I don't have to cross the bay, saving minimum of 30 minutes each direction. If I'm going to sit in cattle class, might as well choose based on fare and convenience.
I had a CPU clear at T-72 hours recently. ~1 hour UAX flight on a CR5 with empty F cabin.
Overall, the lack of upgrade and award space (at reasonable levels) is atrocious currently. Fingers crossed things get better after this crazy summer season.
I have flown AA this month, which I never thought would happen. Sign of the times....
#193
Join Date: Oct 2021
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 343
Just as a data point, I think they are still running sweeps before T-24, they just being dramatically more stingy with releasing them.
I had a CPU clear at T-72 hours recently. ~1 hour UAX flight on a CR5 with empty F cabin.
Overall, the lack of upgrade and award space (at reasonable levels) is atrocious currently. Fingers crossed things get better after this crazy summer season.
I have flown AA this month, which I never thought would happen. Sign of the times....
I had a CPU clear at T-72 hours recently. ~1 hour UAX flight on a CR5 with empty F cabin.
Overall, the lack of upgrade and award space (at reasonable levels) is atrocious currently. Fingers crossed things get better after this crazy summer season.
I have flown AA this month, which I never thought would happen. Sign of the times....
#194
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Houston TX
Programs: UN 1K MM, Marriott-LT TitanElite, Hyatt Glob; HH-Gold
Posts: 74
I had previously had this issue, and it ws suggested I use the UA app instead of the website. When I view a flight now tho, in either the app or web, I do see the purchase option tho, even though I have +P upgrade requested. I dont really know why it just started working... In the app, the upgrade 'offer' is near the bottom of the reservation details (on android). On the web, the splash is very clear! I have +Ps posted on the flight below.
**UPDATE on my situation** - we did not clear Biz/First. We did clear Premium Economy. Our flights are sold out and upon checking in, they are asking for volunteers. Tomorrow, there are 11 1st class seats available. I called United to see if it would even be possible to clear if we voluntary moved flights to tomorrow. I learned that Global Services is allowed to use their Plus Points on Mileage tickets. That's a nice perk for them. No way I could clear tomorrow. 7 Global Services wait listed and another 5 1Ks. When I will shared that I will never achieve Global Services because all of my business travel is domestic and not far, she told me that United does send invitations to consistent 1Ks. She wasn't aware how many years or what the circumstances were, but that it was possible. I had never heard that either. She also shared lifetime GS after 4 MM. Yea... I know that. I'm just trying to get my 2MM before I retire. 4MM is not even possible
Wish me luck.... 17 hours and an inability to sleep sitting up! This will be fun
#195
Join Date: Jan 2005
Programs: SQ, QF, UA, CO, DL
Posts: 2,879
Yes - I have this also. When I click on upgrade and select cash, it shows that I am not eligible.
**UPDATE on my situation** - we did not clear Biz/First. We did clear Premium Economy. Our flights are sold out and upon checking in, they are asking for volunteers. Tomorrow, there are 11 1st class seats available. I called United to see if it would even be possible to clear if we voluntary moved flights to tomorrow. I learned that Global Services is allowed to use their Plus Points on Mileage tickets. That's a nice perk for them. No way I could clear tomorrow. 7 Global Services wait listed and another 5 1Ks. When I will shared that I will never achieve Global Services because all of my business travel is domestic and not far, she told me that United does send invitations to consistent 1Ks. She wasn't aware how many years or what the circumstances were, but that it was possible. I had never heard that either. She also shared lifetime GS after 4 MM. Yea... I know that. I'm just trying to get my 2MM before I retire. 4MM is not even possible
Wish me luck.... 17 hours and an inability to sleep sitting up! This will be fun
**UPDATE on my situation** - we did not clear Biz/First. We did clear Premium Economy. Our flights are sold out and upon checking in, they are asking for volunteers. Tomorrow, there are 11 1st class seats available. I called United to see if it would even be possible to clear if we voluntary moved flights to tomorrow. I learned that Global Services is allowed to use their Plus Points on Mileage tickets. That's a nice perk for them. No way I could clear tomorrow. 7 Global Services wait listed and another 5 1Ks. When I will shared that I will never achieve Global Services because all of my business travel is domestic and not far, she told me that United does send invitations to consistent 1Ks. She wasn't aware how many years or what the circumstances were, but that it was possible. I had never heard that either. She also shared lifetime GS after 4 MM. Yea... I know that. I'm just trying to get my 2MM before I retire. 4MM is not even possible
Wish me luck.... 17 hours and an inability to sleep sitting up! This will be fun