My First Premier Silver Upgrade Eligible Flight Question
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 57
My First Premier Silver Upgrade Eligible Flight Question
I'm booked in a regular economy seat for a flight tomorrow (Sunday) evening. Normally I fly on EMB 145 flights with no Business/First, so I normally check in exactly 24 hrs before flight time to increase my chance of an economy plus seat. If there is a United First seat available when will it clear - 24 hours before or on the day of departure. If the latter, should I wait to check in until the flight day?
Thank all!
Thank all!
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: DAY
Programs: UA 1K 1MM; Marriott LT Titanium; Amex MR; Chase UR; Hertz PC; Global Entry
Posts: 10,159
I'm booked in a regular economy seat for a flight tomorrow (Sunday) evening. Normally I fly on EMB 145 flights with no Business/First, so I normally check in exactly 24 hrs before flight time to increase my chance of an economy plus seat. If there is a United First seat available when will it clear - 24 hours before or on the day of departure. If the latter, should I wait to check in until the flight day?
Thank all!
Thank all!
They will clear upgrades right up until boarding is complete. Keep an eye on the upgrade list on the app to judge your chances.
#4
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: SFO/SJC
Programs: UA Silver, Marriott Gold, Hilton Gold
Posts: 14,884
Upgrades are cleared two ways....in advance, in the 'black box' process and from those on the standby upgrade list, at the gate, usually just prior to boarding.
The in advance process is available until some time not too far before the flight...think it used to typically be about 3 hours. Not sure if that's changed. It is supposed to run upgrades at all the elite upgrade windows, and will clear folks, assuming upgrade space is availble. It also runs, supposedly, every time an upgrade-eligible passenger checks in - as a gold and plat, I have occasionally checked in in economy, and found myself upgraded because the BP shows a seat in F. It's been a while, but it happens.
Checking in won't affect your ability to clear an upgrade in advance (the only disclaimer I know of to this is if you have another person on your PNR, it will split, so you will be on the list as two individuals, as opposed to a party of 2 - this has advantages and disadvantages, depending on your preferences). But you can still be upgraded in advance after check in. I've also had that happen several times in the last few years.
The in advance process is available until some time not too far before the flight...think it used to typically be about 3 hours. Not sure if that's changed. It is supposed to run upgrades at all the elite upgrade windows, and will clear folks, assuming upgrade space is availble. It also runs, supposedly, every time an upgrade-eligible passenger checks in - as a gold and plat, I have occasionally checked in in economy, and found myself upgraded because the BP shows a seat in F. It's been a while, but it happens.
Checking in won't affect your ability to clear an upgrade in advance (the only disclaimer I know of to this is if you have another person on your PNR, it will split, so you will be on the list as two individuals, as opposed to a party of 2 - this has advantages and disadvantages, depending on your preferences). But you can still be upgraded in advance after check in. I've also had that happen several times in the last few years.
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Honolulu Harbor
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 15,019
The language states (paraphrasing): "Silvers are eligible for complimentary upgrades AS EARLY as 24 hour prior to flight". Even if there are open F seats, that doesn't mean United is going to give out upgrades. They might hold the seats for last minute buyers or try to sell the upgrades. United decides in its own time when to allocate any open F seats for complimentary upgrades. Keep your expectations very low and you won't be disappointed.
Last edited by IAH-OIL-TRASH; Feb 3, 2018 at 9:40 am Reason: speling
#6
Moderator: Budget Travel forum & Credit Card Programs, FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: YYJ/YVR and back on Van Isle ....... for now
Programs: UA lifetime MM / *A Gold
Posts: 14,428
Actually ....
While your odds for an upgrade, unless you are flying at the same time as Super Bowl is on, is pretty much nil as a Silver, the LAST tiebreaker after all other deciding factors have been taken into account is time of checkin @:-)
While your odds for an upgrade, unless you are flying at the same time as Super Bowl is on, is pretty much nil as a Silver, the LAST tiebreaker after all other deciding factors have been taken into account is time of checkin @:-)
#7
Join Date: Oct 2017
Location: Kansas City, MO
Programs: DL Plat, UA Plat
Posts: 150
No, you still want to check in at T-24. Taking the free upgrade to E+ does not remove you from the upgrade list for First. An upgrade to F also won't clear for a silver until you're checked in, so you want to check in as early as possible if you want to have a shot.
I was upgraded on two recent flights where I checked in right at T-24. I was near the top of the very short upgrade list at check-in time and the upgrades cleared within an hour of checking in. Checked back shortly before the flight and there were 10+ new people below me on the upgrade list, presumably other silvers who checked in after me. Early bird gets the worm.
Also, as others have said, upgrades for silver will be rare if you're flying out of a hub. I fly out of an outstation, so I'm usually going the opposite direction of the really high status fliers, which helps.
I was upgraded on two recent flights where I checked in right at T-24. I was near the top of the very short upgrade list at check-in time and the upgrades cleared within an hour of checking in. Checked back shortly before the flight and there were 10+ new people below me on the upgrade list, presumably other silvers who checked in after me. Early bird gets the worm.
Also, as others have said, upgrades for silver will be rare if you're flying out of a hub. I fly out of an outstation, so I'm usually going the opposite direction of the really high status fliers, which helps.
#8
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 21,400
To be clear -- time of check in is the last tiebreaker, after status and the fare class purchased. So, if you were on a relatively expensive ticket, you would have remained ahead of the other silvers even if you had checked in a little later. (Although, I do echo the advice for a Silver to check in at T-24 except when trying to avoid getting the PNR split, as encampbe alluded to).
It's also possible that the other people on the list were non-revs, who would also have appeared after you regardless of check-in time.
It's also possible that the other people on the list were non-revs, who would also have appeared after you regardless of check-in time.
#9
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Houston Texas USA
Programs: UA Gold MM, SWA A-List
Posts: 150
No, you still want to check in at T-24. Taking the free upgrade to E+ does not remove you from the upgrade list for First. An upgrade to F also won't clear for a silver until you're checked in, so you want to check in as early as possible if you want to have a shot.
I was upgraded on two recent flights where I checked in right at T-24. I was near the top of the very short upgrade list at check-in time and the upgrades cleared within an hour of checking in. Checked back shortly before the flight and there were 10+ new people below me on the upgrade list, presumably other silvers who checked in after me. Early bird gets the worm.
Also, as others have said, upgrades for silver will be rare if you're flying out of a hub. I fly out of an outstation, so I'm usually going the opposite direction of the really high status fliers, which helps.
I was upgraded on two recent flights where I checked in right at T-24. I was near the top of the very short upgrade list at check-in time and the upgrades cleared within an hour of checking in. Checked back shortly before the flight and there were 10+ new people below me on the upgrade list, presumably other silvers who checked in after me. Early bird gets the worm.
Also, as others have said, upgrades for silver will be rare if you're flying out of a hub. I fly out of an outstation, so I'm usually going the opposite direction of the really high status fliers, which helps.
#10
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: PWM
Programs: AA Plat
Posts: 1,335
This is not true. A silver can certainly be upgraded before checking in. Also, the list was very small when you checked in because only passengers who have checked in are on that list and you checked in right at T-24 hours. As others have said, the upgrade list you see after you check in is not the same list used to upgrade passengers ahead of the flight. The fact that you checked in and were upgraded shortly after checking in is a coincidence. And the 10+ people below you on the upgrade list would likely have been below you even had you checked in much later (unless you all had the same fare).
Anecdotally (and this is pure conjecture) I believe that checking in early can improve one's chances.
One memorable case was back in Feb 2016 I cleared DEN-DFW on an A319 on a Saturday at noon as a Silver on an N fare pretty far in advance (12 hours?). That alone, is remarkable considering that a/c only has 8 F seats! There were probably 8+ ppl on the upgrade list when we took off. Surely there weren't 8 Silvers on an N fare on a Saturday! The canonical explanation is they were all non-revs or late SDCers. But the noncanonical is I actually skipped higher elites based on my early check in (well in advance of 24 hours). That is, the computer was actually clearing pax out of order. Yes, it's controversial to say that but it's just a feeling, not a scientific fact. Back then I didn't know how to check for non-revs or else I would have. I caught 3/4 upgrades that day but that was the only cleared flight with a weirdly long list!
Unfortunately since the process is so opaque, there's no way to know the instrument, status, fare, and check in of each person on the list! That would solve a lot of our headaches!
Last edited by sexykitten7; Feb 3, 2018 at 3:30 pm Reason: Added 8F comment
#11
Moderator: Budget Travel forum & Credit Card Programs, FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: YYJ/YVR and back on Van Isle ....... for now
Programs: UA lifetime MM / *A Gold
Posts: 14,428
Last month on a Monday evening I ended up #5 on u/g list onA319
Asked for and received both snack box and drink
#12
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 21,400
Agreed. Saturdays, any time after noon, are among the sweet spots for upgrades, especially for lower-tier elites, as few people want to travel then. Early Sunday morning is another one.
The fact that you were able to secure an N fare in the first place is a sign that elite load (and load in general) was likely to be light on that plane. (For anyone who's not aware: N is currently Basic Economy, but in 2016 it was still a deeply discounted coach fare, lower than G). I agree that there probably weren't 8 other silver elites at N or below, but it wouldn't surprise me at all if there were 8 non-revs.
The fact that you were able to secure an N fare in the first place is a sign that elite load (and load in general) was likely to be light on that plane. (For anyone who's not aware: N is currently Basic Economy, but in 2016 it was still a deeply discounted coach fare, lower than G). I agree that there probably weren't 8 other silver elites at N or below, but it wouldn't surprise me at all if there were 8 non-revs.
#13
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Honolulu Harbor
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 15,019
I'm not sure @jm0933 is so far off.
Anecdotally (and this is pure conjecture) I believe that checking in early can improve one's chances.
One memorable case was back in Feb 2016 I cleared DEN-DFW on an A319 on a Saturday at noon as a Silver on an N fare pretty far in advance (12 hours?). That alone, is remarkable considering that a/c only has 8 F seats! There were probably 8+ ppl on the upgrade list when we took off. Surely there weren't 8 Silvers on an N fare on a Saturday! The canonical explanation is they were all non-revs or late SDCers. But the noncanonical is I actually skipped higher elites based on my early check in (well in advance of 24 hours). That is, the computer was actually clearing pax out of order. Yes, it's controversial to say that but it's just a feeling, not a scientific fact. Back then I didn't know how to check for non-revs or else I would have. I caught 3/4 upgrades that day but that was the only cleared flight with a weirdly long list!
Unfortunately since the process is so opaque, there's no way to know the instrument, status, fare, and check in of each person on the list! That would solve a lot of our headaches!
Anecdotally (and this is pure conjecture) I believe that checking in early can improve one's chances.
One memorable case was back in Feb 2016 I cleared DEN-DFW on an A319 on a Saturday at noon as a Silver on an N fare pretty far in advance (12 hours?). That alone, is remarkable considering that a/c only has 8 F seats! There were probably 8+ ppl on the upgrade list when we took off. Surely there weren't 8 Silvers on an N fare on a Saturday! The canonical explanation is they were all non-revs or late SDCers. But the noncanonical is I actually skipped higher elites based on my early check in (well in advance of 24 hours). That is, the computer was actually clearing pax out of order. Yes, it's controversial to say that but it's just a feeling, not a scientific fact. Back then I didn't know how to check for non-revs or else I would have. I caught 3/4 upgrades that day but that was the only cleared flight with a weirdly long list!
Unfortunately since the process is so opaque, there's no way to know the instrument, status, fare, and check in of each person on the list! That would solve a lot of our headaches!
Are you getting upgraded all the time by checking in early? Just got my upgrade OGG-LAX tomorrow afternoon. Checked in at T-20 or so. Looks like there's 4-5 Silvers who got their CPUs ahead of me since I checked in so late
#14
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 57
So about 15 minutes after I was checked in, I was upgraded. Guess it pays to fly during Super Bowl. Next question - I really prefer an aisle seat. It's indicated on my profile. So when I was upgraded, I got a window, and then called the premier desk to see about a aisle which they gave me. Is there any way to set an aisle seat as an upgrade preference?
#15
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: New York NY
Programs: UA Gold, CO Plat, CO Million Miler
Posts: 2,617
So about 15 minutes after I was checked in, I was upgraded. Guess it pays to fly during Super Bowl. Next question - I really prefer an aisle seat. It's indicated on my profile. So when I was upgraded, I got a window, and then called the premier desk to see about a aisle which they gave me. Is there any way to set an aisle seat as an upgrade preference?