FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   United Airlines | MileagePlus (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/united-airlines-mileageplus-681/)
-   -   List of non-reclining dom F seats (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/united-airlines-mileageplus/1891194-list-non-reclining-dom-f-seats.html)

sexykitten7 Jan 29, 18 6:30 pm

List of non-reclining dom F seats
 
Does anyone have a list of domestic F seats that don't recline? I was once screwed by the last row of a 16F cabin (738?) on a red-eye MUA. It really wasn't worth the miles to upgrade! Just sat in row 3 on an A320 last night and that was fine.

I've scoured seat guru but it's a mixed bag (some have no comments, others have comments but not colored, some are yellow/red). Also looked at most of the "Everything You Wanted to Know" wikis but they don't address this problem. I'm sure there are anecdotes buried within those threads though.

I figure we could sort by full recline, partial, none if people want to contribute data. But I find it hard to imagine no one's started this resource yet!

Full
RJs
Airbuses

Partial
738: 4ABEF (1/3 of normal)
739: 5EF (1/3 of normal)
753: 6ABEF (2/3 of normal)

None
739 5AB

findark Jan 29, 18 6:36 pm

There are coatracks behind F on the Airbus planes, and no bulkheads on RJs. The 739s are notorious for Row 5's lack of recline and proximity to the lavatory. I had though the other 737s were okay, but I was on a new-build 738 on Saturday and it seemed like Row 4 was flush with the bulkhead :eek:

I don't believe I have ever flown in the last row of a 737 or 753, but I'm probably forgetting once or twice.

sfo789 Jan 29, 18 6:52 pm

739: 5EF recline about 1/3 of normal, 5AB not at all
738: 4 reclines about 1/3 of normal (even the older ones have been like this IME)
753: Could be wrong, but I have sat in 5B and 5E and both seemed to recline marginally less
320/319: With the new forward-sliding seat, I believe all seats are fine

Not sure on 73G but given the 737 swaps that occur, I think a no-back-row rule is prudent.

Plane-is-home Jan 29, 18 7:15 pm


Originally Posted by sfo789 (Post 29355490)
739: 5EF recline about 1/3 of normal, 5AB not at all
738: 4 reclines about 1/3 of normal (even the older ones have been like this IME)
753: Could be wrong, but I have sat in 5B and 5E and both seemed to recline marginally less
320/319: With the new forward-sliding seat, I believe all seats are fine

Not sure on 73G but given the 737 swaps that occur, I think a no-back-row rule is prudent.

i never book row 5 on 737 or 3 on A320 just to be protected when they do equipment swaps

sexykitten7 Jan 29, 18 7:29 pm

Thanks for the feedback! Will update OP.

Good points about never choosing the last row. In my case last night, it was either a row 2 middle or row 3 window so I chanced it. Plus only an hour flight time.

Bizarre that UA doesn't think F pax deserve a reclining seat (and that we don't see more of these complaints on FT)!

WineCountryUA Jan 29, 18 7:41 pm


Originally Posted by sexykitten7 (Post 29355612)
... Good points about never choosing the last row. ....

on the 737 family, not really an issue with any other aircraft


Originally Posted by sexykitten7 (Post 29355612)
.... (and that we don't see more of these complaints on FT)!

Look in the Where to sit threads for the 737s, you will find discussion there.

fumje Jan 29, 18 7:44 pm


Originally Posted by WineCountryUA (Post 29355648)
on the 737 family, not really an issue with any other aircraft

Yes, although the coats / wall are behind row 3 on the A320, they don't seem to impede the recline. The wall does clearly, perceptibly limit the recline on the 737, though.

wtigerFF Jan 29, 18 7:44 pm


Originally Posted by Plane-is-home (Post 29355553)


i never book row 5 on 737 or 3 on A320 just to be protected when they do equipment swaps


I don't know what the algorithm is but I've been in Row 2 of an A320 and was bumped back in to Y when there was an a/c swap to an A319. I don't think that avoiding the last row will necessarily protect you from anything. It certainly didn't protect me. There was even an open F seat but the Gate Agent refused to give it to me because he said that he had a paying F customer on the upgrade list. I had upgraded a month earlier using an RPU and had chosen that route because I could upgrade it using an RPU.

In any case, I do avoid the back row of F if possible because it often has limited recline

DJ_Iceman Jan 29, 18 7:45 pm


Originally Posted by WineCountryUA (Post 29355648)
on the 737 family, not really an issue with any other aircraft.

Yup, absolutely. I actually like the last row of F so I can recline fully without worrying about the person in the seat behind me. This has screwed me at times when it comes to meal selection or an aircraft swap where it seems they rebook from the front to the back, but overall I prefer the last row of F.

sol95 Jan 29, 18 8:11 pm


Originally Posted by sexykitten7 (Post 29355612)
Thanks for the feedback! Will update OP.

Good points about never choosing the last row. In my case last night, it was either a row 2 middle or row 3 window so I chanced it. Plus only an hour flight time.

Bizarre that UA doesn't think F pax deserve a reclining seat (and that we don't see more of these complaints on FT)!

umm...F doesn't have middle seats. Either window or aisle...

sfo789 Jan 29, 18 8:39 pm


Originally Posted by sfo789 (Post 29355490)
753: Could be wrong, but I have sat in 5B and 5E and both seemed to recline marginally less

Sorry, typed this too fast earlier -- of course, I mean 6BE. Row 5 is normal, but I think 6 has at least slightly limited recline on the 753.

sexykitten7 Jan 29, 18 8:51 pm


Originally Posted by sol95 (Post 29355732)
umm...F doesn't have middle seats. Either window or aisle...

LOL You know what I meant! In the middle of the plane. No window view aka aisle.

sol95 Jan 30, 18 3:13 am


Originally Posted by sexykitten7 (Post 29355854)
LOL You know what I meant! In the middle of the plane. No window view aka aisle.

LOL

The irony of seeking precise listings of specific F seat reclines while failing to properly identify specific seats in their own posts...by that logic, we can close this thread with the statement, "All F seats recline...sort of." :P

DetroitFlyer Jan 30, 18 6:41 am

I believe it's confirmed that the 753s will get the new F seats already installed on Airbuses, so they eventually will all recline. Not sure about the 738s/739s.

ermintrude Jun 30, 19 1:26 am

Does the rear row in F in the A319 (UA config 12 seat) recline?
 
I hate no recline - crazy that UA put those hard barriers behind the last F row in many planes ........ I think they are starting to take them out?? Anyway looked on expert flyer and seat guru and no joy.... If you know please let me know, Cheers

Edit -States A319 but I think it's an A320


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:41 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright 2021 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.