Last edit by: WineCountryUA
The short answer is no and that is the general practice across the domestic carriers. There are few exceptions.
Additionally, average domestic fare is too low to fund the space needed.
Why can non-domestic carriers do this in their domestic zone? The amount of in country travel / first class is very small in comparison to the USA (in most cases) plus their train competition offers lounge access.
While there are some who have access due to UC membership or status, for other access it is only if
Premium cabin passengers for "transcontinental business class " (SFO/LAX<> EWR/JFK) or "United Business class within the U.S." (SFO<> BOS)
or Active duty U.S. military personnel under certain circumstances
For more on the "exceptions" see Consolidated "United Club Access Questions" Thread
So why not all domestic F passengers, besides it is not the practice? Essentially there is not enough lounge space and it would be too expensive to build enough space.Premium cabin passengers for "transcontinental business class " (SFO/LAX<> EWR/JFK) or "United Business class within the U.S." (SFO<> BOS)
or Active duty U.S. military personnel under certain circumstances
For more on the "exceptions" see Consolidated "United Club Access Questions" Thread
Additionally, average domestic fare is too low to fund the space needed.
Why can non-domestic carriers do this in their domestic zone? The amount of in country travel / first class is very small in comparison to the USA (in most cases) plus their train competition offers lounge access.
Why no United Lounge access with UA domestic first class tickets?
#76
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: SF Bay Area
Programs: UA 1K, Hyatt Globalist, Virtuoso Travel Agent, Commercial Pilot
Posts: 2,117
#77
Moderator: United Airlines
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: SFO
Programs: UA Plat 1.995MM, Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott Plat/LT Gold, Hilton Silver, IHG Plat
Posts: 66,821
P is the fare class which is discount Business via http://www.cwsi.net/united.htm ....
#78
Join Date: Mar 2012
Programs: Mileage Plus 1K; Marriott Platinum; Hilton Gold
Posts: 6,355
Even if you buy a one-time pass, domestic UA clubs aren't very special - snacks and cheap wine and beer. But for a place to sit and recharge your phone or get some work done, they are just fine - except for when they are SRO. The Centurion lounge in SFO is the nice one, and that takes an Amex Platinum.
....
....
#79
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2014
Location: MSP
Programs: DL PM, UA Gold, WN, Global Entry; +others wherever miles/points are found
Posts: 14,404
For example, a domestic United First cabin would normally use the letters F, A, Z, and P for its inventory. On each flight, they have an algorithm backed up by an army of analysts who choose how many seats should be made available at each level, based on how much they expect people to be willing to pay. Then, buying a seat in each bucket costs a different amount, with F being the most expensive and P being the least expensive. They are all United First seats, and all the same to you the customer, but it allows UA to change the price on the flight if e.g. it's Spring Break for posh Northeast schools and they expect to be able to sell the whole cabin to expensive fares and make only the 'F' code available.
The wiki linked by WineCountryUA has a good reference of what all the letters mean.
#80
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Crystal City, VA
Programs: United Mileage Plus 1K 2 MM, HHonors Diamond, Hyatt Platinum
Posts: 2,627
I always thought that the lounge situation (between N. America and Europe) was more dictated by historical consumer patterns. Often in other countries, there might be separate international and domestic airports in the capital and major cities. Domestic flights within a European country are usually short haul (when they exist). People were more used to taking trains than the highly-regulated state airlines (before the LLCs). The lounges were often at the international airports, back past the duty-free shops, for the business and first class pax.
A lot of the flying in the US is domestic, and some of it can even be rather long-haul. The airlines didn't offer that many ticket-based lounges domesticallly, but could offer a spot to hang out for their status pax (even today the United Club has variable annual pricing, based on status). It was considered a business expense, in some ways, as that's who the bulk of the road warriors. My previous company used to give Red Carpet Club memberships to some of the more frequent travelers. This probably went away when the IRS declared that Club memberships were no longer tax deductible.
So, history, geography, and the expectations of the flying public...
A lot of the flying in the US is domestic, and some of it can even be rather long-haul. The airlines didn't offer that many ticket-based lounges domesticallly, but could offer a spot to hang out for their status pax (even today the United Club has variable annual pricing, based on status). It was considered a business expense, in some ways, as that's who the bulk of the road warriors. My previous company used to give Red Carpet Club memberships to some of the more frequent travelers. This probably went away when the IRS declared that Club memberships were no longer tax deductible.
So, history, geography, and the expectations of the flying public...
#82
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Cleveland, Ohio, USA
Programs: UA PM, DL PM, Bonvoy Titanium, HH Gold
Posts: 1,292
Completely agree. I don't understand the love but maybe because I use lounges to work. Much rather be at the desks in the UC at SFO than trying to find a place to work at the CL. Plus, getting a drink can be ridiculously long at the CL bar.
#83
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 6,338
I always thought that the lounge situation (between N. America and Europe) was more dictated by historical consumer patterns. Often in other countries, there might be separate international and domestic airports in the capital and major cities. Domestic flights within a European country are usually short haul (when they exist). People were more used to taking trains than the highly-regulated state airlines (before the LLCs). The lounges were often at the international airports, back past the duty-free shops, for the business and first class pax.
A lot of the flying in the US is domestic, and some of it can even be rather long-haul. The airlines didn't offer that many ticket-based lounges domesticallly, but could offer a spot to hang out for their status pax (even today the United Club has variable annual pricing, based on status). It was considered a business expense, in some ways, as that's who the bulk of the road warriors. My previous company used to give Red Carpet Club memberships to some of the more frequent travelers. This probably went away when the IRS declared that Club memberships were no longer tax deductible.
So, history, geography, and the expectations of the flying public...
A lot of the flying in the US is domestic, and some of it can even be rather long-haul. The airlines didn't offer that many ticket-based lounges domesticallly, but could offer a spot to hang out for their status pax (even today the United Club has variable annual pricing, based on status). It was considered a business expense, in some ways, as that's who the bulk of the road warriors. My previous company used to give Red Carpet Club memberships to some of the more frequent travelers. This probably went away when the IRS declared that Club memberships were no longer tax deductible.
So, history, geography, and the expectations of the flying public...
#84
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Dulles, VA
Programs: UA Life Gold, Marriott Life Titanium
Posts: 2,757
20 years ago, I hit Chairman's Preferred on US Air for the first time. That was the equivalent of 1K. I got US Air Club for free with status, and thought that was a good deal. I was told that there were only 17,000 or so CPs, so including club membership for free was a solid benefit for a relatively small batch of customers.
TWA had the same deal for their top tier. However, the other major airlines had too many top-tier passengers to make it economically viable. Now that we're down to just three big airlines that do clubs, there's no chance that club access is going to be easily doled out.
I gave up my RCC/UC membership 4 years ago, and unless I go back to flying domestically 2-3 times a month, I won't pay for a membership. The prices are pretty high these days and getting worse.
TWA had the same deal for their top tier. However, the other major airlines had too many top-tier passengers to make it economically viable. Now that we're down to just three big airlines that do clubs, there's no chance that club access is going to be easily doled out.
I gave up my RCC/UC membership 4 years ago, and unless I go back to flying domestically 2-3 times a month, I won't pay for a membership. The prices are pretty high these days and getting worse.
#85
Suspended
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: CA, FL, and China.
Programs: UA1K (no longer serviced!), Bonvoy P, Hyatt G
Posts: 704
It's kind of funny that a GS flying domestic first class can't get into the united club.
It's okay, you can keep the minute maid and instant oatmeal.
It's okay, you can keep the minute maid and instant oatmeal.
#86
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: BOS
Programs: Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott/SPG/Hilton Gold, PreCheck + Clear
Posts: 2,306
But I think most would agree they don't visit UCs for the food as much as they do to avoid the madness of the terminal. The complimentary drinks are also a vast improvement over the swill they were serving in 2015. Personally, I'm fortunate in that my home UC at BOS is spectacular, but if I'm famished I'll still grab something at Legal before my flight.
And to be fair, the oatmeal is not instant, and it's quite good.
#87
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
The real question is whether anybody makes decisions about air carrier based on free lounge access for paid domestic F. I suspect that UA, AA & DL have all tested that and found, as the US market repeatedly demonstrates, that price & convenient schedule are the market movers. In other words, UA is not losing market share, so why give something for free which those who want will pay.
With Pre-Check and the demise of checked luggage through better planning, there is little reason to be at the airport early and thus business travelers would value the UC for connections and IRROPS. At the same time, most larger airports have much better food options than in the past, making even good lounge food not particularly competetive with the selection & quality available to all.
Indeed, the expedited airport experience --- from stepping out of the car to the seat onboard --- is something consumers do care about.
With Pre-Check and the demise of checked luggage through better planning, there is little reason to be at the airport early and thus business travelers would value the UC for connections and IRROPS. At the same time, most larger airports have much better food options than in the past, making even good lounge food not particularly competetive with the selection & quality available to all.
Indeed, the expedited airport experience --- from stepping out of the car to the seat onboard --- is something consumers do care about.
#88
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: yxh
Programs: 35 K
Posts: 191
Lounge Access on United First
Sorry for asking but I have been trying to find out if I will have lounge access on my flight Dec 18/21 YYC - IAH - MIA. I have booked United Business/First but when I look on the United site it states Polaris Bussiness. I previously had status with AC but with no flying since March 2020 that is gone.
Thanks for any onfo.
Thanks for any onfo.
#89
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 21,386
Sorry for asking but I have been trying to find out if I will have lounge access on my flight Dec 18/21 YYC - IAH - MIA. I have booked United Business/First but when I look on the United site it states Polaris Bussiness. I previously had status with AC but with no flying since March 2020 that is gone.
Thanks for any onfo.
Thanks for any onfo.