![]() |
Originally Posted by ilgoldstein
(Post 9684027)
Got to thinking about Ohms Law again. I'm trying to figure out if I'm missing something here.
The light bulb is rated in watts at a certain voltage, isn't it? The resistance of the bulb (as measured by an ohm meter for example) is a constant. See http://www.ac.wwu.edu/~vawter/Physic...esistOhms.html So if P = I E, and P=100w, E = 120v, then I = .83A E = I R, and R is constant (139.5). so double the voltage, same load, you double the current. At 240v, same R, I = 1.66A So P = 240v x 1.66A = almost 400w. |
Originally Posted by Yaatri
(Post 9684015)
The resistance of 110 V bulb is about a quarter of the resistance of a 220 V bulb for the same wattage. If you power a 110V bulb with a 220V source, it will draw draw four times as much power and twice as much current...
That said, the original question postulated European (hence 230v) bulbs. That raises other issues, but not this one. |
Yes, a proper bulb changes the entire equation. I assume the switch could handle the extra voltage, but I would check that. Of course, a local hardware store could easily answer all the questions, but that would be too easy and deprive us of an interesting exercise.
I wonder if the lamp would be CE approved? |
the real question is............how many FTers does it take to change a lightbulb?
Most electrical lamp stuff for usa market is built 110-220 ac/dc, with the 110 not being exactaly 110, and the 220 not being exactally 220. if it indicates it is 220, it will run on 220 or 240v ac with no problem. the only components in most lamps are a switch, a socket, a plug, and a few pieces of wire. you should be able to find the voltage limit on the socket, switch and plug. the biggest problem that one would encounter with wire is exceeding the current (amperage) limitation. that occurs when going to lower voltage, and increasing the amperage.as in taking a 100 watt 240 volt lamp and running it at 12 volts 100 watts. in the usa, there are other completely ....... voltages between 250 and 440. they are usually only in commercial buildings, that combine various forms of 3 phase. i do not know about socket/bulb compatibilities. |
Originally Posted by Efrem
(Post 9684126)
Correct; the above posts do the math. However, if you put a 120v bulb on a 240v line, it will burn out in less time than it takes to read this sentence. You'll get a lot of light out of it while it lasts, though.
That said, the original question postulated European (hence 230v) bulbs. That raises other issues, but not this one.
Originally Posted by ilgoldstein
(Post 9687690)
Yes, a proper bulb changes the entire equation. I assume the switch could handle the extra voltage, but I would check that. Of course, a local hardware store could easily answer all the questions, but that would be too easy and deprive us of an interesting exercise.
I wonder if the lamp would be CE approved? |
Originally Posted by Yaatri
(Post 9688683)
...Higher voltage is of no consequence...
Rewiring a lamp is the simplest electrical job there is, with the possible exception of replacing the batteries in a TV remote. Do it. |
Originally Posted by Efrem
(Post 9689614)
Not if the higher voltage is enough to short the insulation inside the cord, which (if a U.S. cord) may not have been designed to handle it. At that point the current that the bulb would draw is irrelevant. You have a short circuit.
Rewiring a lamp is the simplest electrical job there is, with the possible exception of replacing the batteries in a TV remote. Do it. Birds hang from high tension wires, you could too, with bare hands, without being electrocuted, as long as you don't ground yourself. ;) Since you are on FT, I am sure you travel around the world. Do you re-wire all your small appliances, such as dual voltage shavers, hair dryers, cell phone/pda charging units? Think about it. Unless you are talking about really high voltages approaching breakdown voltage of the insulation, higher voltage is of no consequence in these cases. |
Originally Posted by Yaatri
(Post 9690277)
...Birds hang from high tension wires, you could too, with bare hands, without being electrocuted, as long as you don't ground yourself. ;)
Originally Posted by Yaatri
(Post 9690277)
Since you are on FT, I am sure you travel around the world. Do you re-wire all your small appliances, such as dual voltage shavers, hair dryers, cell phone/pda charging units? Think about it. Unless you are talking about really high voltages approaching breakdown voltage of the insulation, higher voltage is of no consequence in these cases.
We are talking about peak (not RMS) voltages that could exceed the breakdown voltage of the internal insulation of cords used in U.S. lamps. This is not something worth taking a risk on, given the trivial effort and/or cost involved in rewiring a lamp. |
Originally Posted by Efrem
(Post 9690853)
Totally irrelevant, to the point that it raises questions about how well the poster understands electricity. There is no potential difference between the two points where the bird's feet touch on the same wire.
Every one of those examples is intended to be used at 240v and is designed with that in mind. Lamps are not. Again, this raises questions about the extent to which the poster understand the issues. We are talking about peak (not RMS) voltages that could exceed the breakdown voltage of the internal insulation of cords used in U.S. lamps. This is not something worth taking a risk on, given the trivial effort and/or cost involved in rewiring a lamp. Once again, it's the current and hence the thickness of the wires that are of concern between wiring for 220 and 100 V appliances. Voltage is minimal comapred to the breakdown potentials that are tens of thousands of volts per milimetre. The voltage we are talking about, of the order of a 100 Volts, is as good as zero when compared to the break down potential. I am afraid, you are the one missing the point my friend. Moreover the difference between peak and RMS is factor of square root of 2, far far lower than the voltages involved in breakdown of insulation. It appears you are the one who needs to understand the terms you interject here. Even air has dielectric strength of 3MV/m or 3000 volts per mm. Any insulation will have a higher dielectric strength than that of air. Nylon's dielectric strength is 14000 volts per mm. So your argument is completely bogus. The example of the bird is very relevant. If the difference between 100 and 200 volts were of concern to insulation, dielectric strength of air should be of concern to you when hanging from a bare high tension wire. Dielectric strength of damp air would be much less than the 3000 Volts/meter. It's not the potential difference between the bird's feet or your hands that's the issue here. The issue is the insulation of the air between the HT and LT wires. On a dry day when you get a shock when touching a door knob, it's due to dielectric breakdown of air. The voltages involved are very high, much much higher than the 220V volts you are hung up on. The reason you don't die is that the current is very small. |
Originally Posted by Yaatri
(Post 9691111)
Once again, it's the current and hence the thickness of the wires that are of concern between wiring for 220 and 100 V appliances.
However, most wires used in North American appliances are rated at either 125V, 300V, or 600V. Virtually all consumer-grade switches are rated at ~125V. While, in practice, this is not very likely to cause a problem, the use of 125V-rated wires and/or switches would still, technically, be a safety violation. |
This was around twenty years ago, but when my family moved to Germany, we took lamps with us. Using plug adapters and 220v bulbs with our existing lamp fixtures worked fine for us for the almost 3 year time we were there. I did inadvertently install a 110v bulb once, and it flashed briefly before burning out, similar to what often happens normally when a bulb burns out.
|
Originally Posted by slawecki
(Post 9688433)
the real question is............how many FTers does it take to change a lightbulb?
|
The real answer is can anyone figure out how many bonus miles we can get from buying the parts online to rewire? If it's greater than 1 then you know the correct answer :-)
|
Originally Posted by Efrem
(Post 9690853)
We are talking about peak (not RMS) voltages that could exceed the breakdown voltage of the internal insulation of cords used in U.S. lamps. This is not something worth taking a risk on, given the trivial effort and/or cost involved in rewiring a lamp.
|
Originally Posted by Yaatri
(Post 9690277)
I believe, in U.K the bulbs are bayonet mount with two electrodes, as opposed to screw mount with one electrode. Saying Europe isn't enough.
Although your average supermarket will only sell bayonet, you can get a screw in at larger stores for old lamps: when I bought an old house which was re-wired in the 60s I had to buy the screwins until I'd rewired the house (and I'd got rid of the small round pin bakalite sockets... oddly, wired into the lighting circuit :eek:). Remember, even in the UK, there can be different standards... |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 2:15 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.