Go Back  FlyerTalk Forums > Travel&Dining > Travel Products
Reload this Page >

Tumi 19 degree vs Rimowa Topas got carry on

Tumi 19 degree vs Rimowa Topas got carry on

Old Mar 16, 2018, 9:45 am
  #16  
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Germany
Programs: TK elite+(*gold), Marriott Lifetime Platinum, HH Diamond, IHG Diamond, (Ex-Hyatt Diamond/Globalist)
Posts: 220
Long term durability of TUMI 19 degree?

Originally Posted by alphaod

I've put some miles on the 19, seems the black finish seems more durable than the Topas. Done a couple trips on the smaller jets and it fits in the overhead alright.

But it does seem to have some space compromised by the wheels a bit more on the 19.
Hi alpaod,
now after using it for 4 months from your last post, how is the TUMI holding up?
How does the black finish on the aluminium look now?

It would be great if you could share your experience on this after 4 months or even post a picture.

I want to buy the TUMI 19 degree in black alu, it looks so stylish. I think "pure" aluminium with the silver color just sucks and looks cheap. But after reading about the topas stealth, I am afraid I might regret my decision - some claim after a few weeks of use the black coating would be damaged so much it just looks cheap, ugly and broken, that you could repair dents but not scratches to the coating, and that it would happen after cheking it in once or twice and even when using it as carry on for more than 10 trips a year...
I searched for hours but couldn't find a single report on or photo of a used TUMI 19 degree in black alu...

Thanks and best reagrds,
zap!
zap7 is offline  
Old Mar 17, 2018, 9:00 am
  #17  
 
Join Date: Dec 2017
Location: Planet Earth
Programs: IHG Diamond Amb, Hilton Diamond, Hyatt Globalist, Bonvoy Gold, Hertz PC, AA Plat Pro
Posts: 148
Originally Posted by zap7
Hi alpaod,
now after using it for 4 months from your last post, how is the TUMI holding up?
How does the black finish on the aluminium look now?

It would be great if you could share your experience on this after 4 months or even post a picture.

I want to buy the TUMI 19 degree in black alu, it looks so stylish. I think "pure" aluminium with the silver color just sucks and looks cheap. But after reading about the topas stealth, I am afraid I might regret my decision - some claim after a few weeks of use the black coating would be damaged so much it just looks cheap, ugly and broken, that you could repair dents but not scratches to the coating, and that it would happen after cheking it in once or twice and even when using it as carry on for more than 10 trips a year...
I searched for hours but couldn't find a single report on or photo of a used TUMI 19 degree in black alu...

Thanks and best reagrds,
zap!
FYI the 19 in standard alum is a bit darker than the Rimowa. Though not quite gun metal, there is a stark difference when comparing it side by side to a Rimowa. I have the 19 and my wife has a Topas, and we travel together 90% of the time. We have never checked in our bags, so I can't speak for major dents, but from regular wear and tear the 19 holds up better due to the design. The 19 is a bit more sturdy and the diagonal grooves help with distorting scratches better than the parallel grooves on the Rimowa. I love my 19 but will admit the wheels on the Topas are much better, and you do get a bit more packing room with the Topas as well.

Last edited by FlyingKansan; Mar 17, 2018 at 9:01 am Reason: fix
FlyingKansan is offline  
Old May 11, 2018, 7:10 pm
  #18  
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: NYC
Programs: Marriot Am, MU Pt
Posts: 3,092
Originally Posted by zap7
Hi alpaod,
now after using it for 4 months from your last post, how is the TUMI holding up?
How does the black finish on the aluminium look now?

It would be great if you could share your experience on this after 4 months or even post a picture.

I want to buy the TUMI 19 degree in black alu, it looks so stylish. I think "pure" aluminium with the silver color just sucks and looks cheap. But after reading about the topas stealth, I am afraid I might regret my decision - some claim after a few weeks of use the black coating would be damaged so much it just looks cheap, ugly and broken, that you could repair dents but not scratches to the coating, and that it would happen after cheking it in once or twice and even when using it as carry on for more than 10 trips a year...
I searched for hours but couldn't find a single report on or photo of a used TUMI 19 degree in black alu...

Thanks and best reagrds,
zap!

I thought after half a year [and about 20 trips) with the carry-on and about two and half months [six trips] with "short trip" (26") it's better now to report on how these cases are doing compared to my Rimowa suitcases which are much older now.

International carry-on:
After half a year I would say it's doing pretty well. It's a very stylist suitcase still, but there are definitely many scratches among the ridges of the wavy aluminum surface. It doesn't look cheap at all and in fact it's very nicely worn. I'd say it wears better than the Rimowa since the aluminum seems harder and thicker on the Tumi therefore no dents. Of course this is a two-edged sword as you'll see in the my report of the [26"] short trip Tumi.

Front:


Back:


Chips in the finish up close:


Short trip 26" checked bag:
This case is only two and half months old, but it has seen six flights, three abroad (France, China, and Japan) on various airlines. On one trip the case was heavily scratched, but no dents. I'd say it's held up pretty well. I don't baby my suitcases, I don't wrap them and I drag them on whatever surfaces I go through. I don't do the silly plastic sleeves people do. On the international trip one of the wheels broke off, but the Tumi store fixed it in a few minutes no cost to me, but after it was a bit wobbly, so I reattached it at home and it seemed better after. On my last trip coming back from Japan, I am very sad to say that instead of denting, one of the corner plates cracked. Again I think the thicker Tumi is more brittle in this instance. This was very disheartening to see. However, I got to experience the Tumi replacement guarantee so they replaced the suitcase with a new one in the shop.

Front:


Back:


Cracked corner:


Topas Stealth
In comparison here is my Rimowa Topas Stealth having seen years of use and over a million miles. It was heavily dented over the years, but the local Rimowa shop banged it back together so it's quite good now. Same Japan trip, this case now has a hole in it. So instead of cracking there is a hole, I'm not sure how they fix this... if anything the airline has agreed to cover the cost of the repair or replacement (funny I also bought baggage insurance by accident for this trip).

Scratched finish:


Hole in the suitcase from the last trip but otherwise fine corners:
FlyingKansan likes this.
alphaod is offline  
Old Feb 28, 2022, 2:31 pm
  #19  
 
Join Date: Feb 2017
Posts: 6
Originally Posted by alphaod
I thought after half a year [and about 20 trips) with the carry-on and about two and half months [six trips] with "short trip" (26") it's better now to report on how these cases are doing compared to my Rimowa suitcases which are much older now.

International carry-on:
After half a year I would say it's doing pretty well. It's a very stylist suitcase still, but there are definitely many scratches among the ridges of the wavy aluminum surface. It doesn't look cheap at all and in fact it's very nicely worn. I'd say it wears better than the Rimowa since the aluminum seems harder and thicker on the Tumi therefore no dents. Of course this is a two-edged sword as you'll see in the my report of the [26"] short trip Tumi.

Front:


Back:


Chips in the finish up close:


Short trip 26" checked bag:
This case is only two and half months old, but it has seen six flights, three abroad (France, China, and Japan) on various airlines. On one trip the case was heavily scratched, but no dents. I'd say it's held up pretty well. I don't baby my suitcases, I don't wrap them and I drag them on whatever surfaces I go through. I don't do the silly plastic sleeves people do. On the international trip one of the wheels broke off, but the Tumi store fixed it in a few minutes no cost to me, but after it was a bit wobbly, so I reattached it at home and it seemed better after. On my last trip coming back from Japan, I am very sad to say that instead of denting, one of the corner plates cracked. Again I think the thicker Tumi is more brittle in this instance. This was very disheartening to see. However, I got to experience the Tumi replacement guarantee so they replaced the suitcase with a new one in the shop.

Front:


Back:


Cracked corner:


Topas Stealth
In comparison here is my Rimowa Topas Stealth having seen years of use and over a million miles. It was heavily dented over the years, but the local Rimowa shop banged it back together so it's quite good now. Same Japan trip, this case now has a hole in it. So instead of cracking there is a hole, I'm not sure how they fix this... if anything the airline has agreed to cover the cost of the repair or replacement (funny I also bought baggage insurance by accident for this trip).

Scratched finish:


Hole in the suitcase from the last trip but otherwise fine corners:



Can you provided an updated comparison now that you've had these bags for a few more years?


Can you also provide more photos of the Stealth? I'm considering the stealth over the silver, as I prefer the sleeker look without being too ostentatious (yes, the slight irony of buying a Rimowa is not lost on me), but I'm worried at how easily and quickly it shows wear and tear.
l0ck is offline  
Old Mar 1, 2022, 3:08 am
  #20  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: HEL
Programs: lots of shiny metal cards
Posts: 14,083
The general issue with coloured metallic luggage is that the powder coating gets scratched relatively easily revealing the underlying aluminium, which is ugly. With the aluminium ones, scratches are less visible.

Checked luggage gets banged up, no escaping that.
WilcoRoger is offline  

Thread Tools
Search this Thread

Contact Us - Manage Preferences - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.