FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   oneworld (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld-411/)
-   -   DONE4 advice? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld/527217-done4-advice.html)

imarks Feb 16, 2006 1:18 pm

DONE4 advice?
 
I'm BA EC Gold and will be travelling with my girlfriend who will be BA Silver by the time we start the trip. We're based in London but Istanbul looks like a good departure point ;)

Being new to the OWE concept, we're a bit confused. Nevertheless, our initial planned itinerary is:

IST-LHR-BKK-HKG-NRT-HKG-PER-ASP-MEL-SYD-AKL-SCL-LIM-EZE-GRU-GIG-LHR-IST

I'm aware that this doesn't use all the available segments for each continent, but time is a bit of an issue. I'd appreciate any advice and have a few questions:

* What is the best-value way to fly LHR/IST initially? Y would be fine.
* Do we have to fly the final LHR-IST segment?
* Would someone mind PMing me the email address for BA Istanbul?
* If I decided to splash out, how well would this itinerary work as an AONE4? It probably has too many flights without F to make this worthwhile, but is there a clever way to re-work it to take advantage of an AONE4?
* Have I missed out anywhere important?!
* Assuming we do the trip in one go, how long would this trip take, allowing for a couple of days in the key locations. This isn't purely a MR - we'd like to enjoy the places we visit and get a taste for future trips!

Thanks very much!

SanDiego1K Feb 16, 2006 1:36 pm

I ran your itinerary thru the OneWorld RTW validator:

1: IST-LHR: 1st of 4 (Europe)
2: LHR-BKK: intercontinental
3: BKK-HKG: 1st of 4 (Asia)
4: HKG-NRT: 2nd of 4 (Asia)
5: NRT-HKG: 3rd of 4 (Asia)
6: HKG-PER: intercontinental
7: PER-ASP: 1st of 4 (Southwest Pacific)
8: ASP-MEL: 2nd of 4 (Southwest Pacific)
9: MEL-SYD: 3rd of 4 (Southwest Pacific)
10: SYD-AKL: 4th of 4 (Southwest Pacific)
11: AKL-SCL: intercontinental
12: SCL-LIM: 1st of 4 (South America)
13: LIM-EZE: 2nd of 4 (South America)
14: EZE-GRU: 3rd of 4 (South America)
15: GRU-GIG: 4th of 4 (South America)
16: GIG-LHR: intercontinental
17: LHR-IST: 2nd of 4 (Europe)

You've got 3 more segments you could use. It's an easy add at the end to chose LHR (or LGW) - xxx-LHR. You just have to be sure to keep only 2 stopovers in Europe.

imarks Feb 16, 2006 2:34 pm


Originally Posted by SanDiego1K
You've got 3 more segments you could use. It's an easy add at the end to chose LHR (or LGW) - xxx-LHR. You just have to be sure to keep only 2 stopovers in Europe.

Thanks for the great tip. I'll include a London-Middle East-London trip that I can use at a later date, noting the max 2 stopovers in Europe. ^

Gardyloo Feb 16, 2006 2:38 pm


Originally Posted by imarks
* What is the best-value way to fly LHR/IST initially? Y would be fine.
* Do we have to fly the final LHR-IST segment?
* Would someone mind PMing me the email address for BA Istanbul?
* If I decided to splash out, how well would this itinerary work as an AONE4? It probably has too many flights without F to make this worthwhile, but is there a clever way to re-work it to take advantage of an AONE4?
* Have I missed out anywhere important?!
* Assuming we do the trip in one go, how long would this trip take, allowing for a couple of days in the key locations. This isn't purely a MR - we'd like to enjoy the places we visit and get a taste for future trips!

1. We found that a simple RT to IST on BA (or OK in our case via PRG) is the cheapest, but YMMV. Only a couple LCCs fly to IST and they all seem to use Sabitha airport, quite a distance from the city, and they all seem to arrive in the middle of the night.

2. Haven't been able to get a definitive answer on the "fly the last leg" question. I imagine it happens, but nobody wants to blether about it. Supposedly they could do dire things to you, like increasing the ticket price retroactively, but I doubt if any such thing occurs. Since it would be a BA seg and you're BAEC Gold you might want to weigh the upshot of not finishing the itinerary.

3. You have PM.

4. Moving up to A would increase the ticket price significantly and there aren't that many 3/4 class flights in your itin. I'd be inclined to spend the extra money on upgraded hotels or ground activities.

5. You could add a couple more European flights and increase your tier point yield. There are several >2000 mi segments available - DXB, TFS, TLV...

6. The timing is up to you. Bear in mind southern hemisphere seasons.

Sounds like a blast - happy planning!

Guy Betsy Feb 16, 2006 6:05 pm

LHR-IST .. many airlines. Check out any High St travel agencies , or the net, or Time Out..

Darren Feb 16, 2006 6:59 pm

Just a head's up, there is no OW airline with GIG-GRU v.v. traffic rights. I seem to recall you can buy a ticket for less than $100 on a variety of carriers.

imarks Feb 17, 2006 3:42 am


Originally Posted by Darren
Just a head's up, there is no OW airline with GIG-GRU v.v. traffic rights. I seem to recall you can buy a ticket for less than $100 on a variety of carriers.

Thanks for the info.

I'd prefer not to have to buy an additional ticket to link up the itinerary. Can anyone suggest a better routing for the South American part of this itinerary, maximising visits to the best cities (I've never been before) and minimising additional flights?

NoWindowSeat Feb 17, 2006 4:28 am


Originally Posted by imarks
Thanks for the info.

I'd prefer not to have to buy an additional ticket to link up the itinerary. Can anyone suggest a better routing for the South American part of this itinerary, maximising visits to the best cities (I've never been before) and minimising additional flights?

Very difficult to include both GRU and GIG to a same xONEx ticket if you want to do something other than Brazil in S.A. as it seems to require a transit via SCL each time...skip either GRU or GIG and you'll be just fine.... AKL-SCL-LIM-EZE-SCL-GIG-LHR....

SanDiego1K Feb 17, 2006 9:54 am

The most expensive and difficult place to reach in South America is Easter Island. You should consider using two of your flights to go there as it is amazing. It is the most remote, inhabited island in the world, and it is fascinating to see the mois.

Caveat: you will have to consider your schedule, as flights only go to Easter Island two or three days/week.

imarks Feb 18, 2006 7:59 am


Originally Posted by SanDiego1K
The most expensive and difficult place to reach in South America is Easter Island. You should consider using two of your flights to go there as it is amazing. It is the most remote, inhabited island in the world, and it is fascinating to see the mois.

Caveat: you will have to consider your schedule, as flights only go to Easter Island two or three days/week.

What an excellent idea ^ ...I've been reading up on Easter Island and it does sound amazing.

A question regarding flying LAN using a DONE4... I've read some posts that suggest rules dictate you fly in Y, regardless of it being a business class RTW ticket. Can anyone shed some light on this?

On a related note, I've read that AKL-SCL is very difficult to get availability on. Is this true?

Thanks :)

Kiwi Flyer Feb 18, 2006 1:20 pm

AKL (or SYD)-SCL vv is difficult to get first class availability. This is due to only 5 F seats on each of the 3 flights per week. Most of these are sold F not A fare class, so RTW (which books into A) and awards are extremely hard to come by. There are much more business class seats so that is easier.

Dont forget Qantas has a codeshare on this flight - so if unavailable on LA flight number check if it is available under QF code.

NoWindowSeat Feb 19, 2006 4:21 am


Originally Posted by imarks
A question regarding flying LAN using a DONE4... I've read some posts that suggest rules dictate you fly in Y, regardless of it being a business class RTW ticket. Can anyone shed some light on this?

This is totally bu****it...where did you hear this? The only two cases when you have to travel in Y with a DONEx ticket are:

1. When there's only one class of service
2. "D" fare class is fully booked and you want to take that particular flight in any case. Then you can travel in Y, availability permitting, of course.

I have found LA/LP D-availability to be actually rather good.

QF NB Feb 19, 2006 4:58 am


IST-LHR-BKK-HKG-NRT-HKG-PER-ASP-MEL-SYD-AKL-SCL-LIM-EZE-GRU-GIG-LHR-IST
Hi imarks,

You probably already know this, but Business Class is not available Perth to Alice Springs. QantasLink operates this route with all economy 717s. If you where to slum it in economy you would still have an excellent flight [QantasLink is great].

Note that if you decide to re route, no QantasLink flights offer Business Class. While the BAe146 retains the J cabin, it is sold as all economy.

Hope that helps somewhat

christep Feb 19, 2006 8:28 am


Originally Posted by NoWindowSeat
2. "D" fare class is fully booked and you want to take that particular flight in any case. Then you can travel in Y, availability permitting, of course.

And to be strictly accurate what you would need in that case in availability in L, not Y.

imarks Feb 19, 2006 8:47 am


Originally Posted by NoWindowSeat
This is totally bu****it...where did you hear this? The only two cases when you have to travel in Y with a DONEx ticket are:

1. When there's only one class of service
2. "D" fare class is fully booked and you want to take that particular flight in any case. Then you can travel in Y, availability permitting, of course.

I have found LA/LP D-availability to be actually rather good.

Well that's good news, although I found a couple of references to it on FT. One is here:
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/showt...9422&p=3484575

I also read a post about someone having to fly from AKL to South America via North America because availability was so difficult to get on the LA AKL/SCL route. I'll try to find and post the link!


Originally Posted by QF NB
Hi imarks,

You probably already know this, but Business Class is not available Perth to Alice Springs. QantasLink operates this route with all economy 717s. If you where to slum it in economy you would still have an excellent flight [QantasLink is great].

Note that if you decide to re route, no QantasLink flights offer Business Class. While the BAe146 retains the J cabin, it is sold as all economy.

Hope that helps somewhat

Yes, I'd noticed - at least it's allowed as part of a xONEx itinerary! And good news that QantasLink is great - thanks. Presumably they're the same thing as 'National Jet Systems' - the airline shown in the oneworld timetable application?

christep Feb 19, 2006 8:52 am


Originally Posted by imarks
Well that's good news, although I found a couple of references to it on FT. One is here:
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/showt...9422&p=3484575

I made the comment in that thread because of what I read here: http://www.hardlink.com/~markdu/OWFi...kingCodes.html which says that F and J OneWorld tickets on Domestic Chilean LA flights book in Y.

If anyone has real experience to the contrary then obviously that overrides a hypthetical reading of the rules.

NoWindowSeat Feb 19, 2006 9:24 am


Originally Posted by imarks
Well that's good news, although I found a couple of references to it on FT. One is here:
http://<b>http://www.flyertalk.com/f...&p=3484575</b>

I also read a post about someone having to fly from AKL to South America via North America because availability was so difficult to get on the LA AKL/SCL route. I'll try to find and post the link!

That post just refers to domestic Chile flights with possibly only one class of service (actually they are talking about SCL-IPC route in particular, which is 2 class so business cabin with DONE...) to me there's nothing about D class booking into Y on LA in general...please do not worry about that anymore...

Regarding the SCL-AKL/SYD vv flights, there is a well known problem with A class availability with only 5 seats total in F...regarding D class, the situation shouldn't be a problem.

christep Feb 19, 2006 9:43 am

SCL-IPC is a domestic Chile service. The rule I quoted appears to apply to all domestic Chilean services, without making any exceptions. If a OW ticketing agent quoted that rule to me I can't see how I could make any case for travelling in anything other than Economy, regardless of my class of ticket.

But again if you have actually travelled on that route using a DONEx (or AONEx) and not been in Y then I accept that the rule is open to different interpretations.

SanDiego1K Feb 19, 2006 9:55 am

I flew SCL-IPC in Biz on an AONE ticket. (And while the flight is sold as two class, on the day of departure I was given a seat assignment in the front cabin.)

Gardyloo Feb 19, 2006 11:53 am


Originally Posted by christep
SCL-IPC is a domestic Chile service.

Even though the plane goes on to PPT? LA sells J tickets on that route.

NoWindowSeat Feb 19, 2006 12:10 pm


Originally Posted by Gardyloo
Even though the plane goes on to PPT? LA sells J tickets on that route.

This is totally irrellevant issue to argue over, no matter what the rules say, the real life is that a DONEx ticket allows one to travel in business class on all LAN operated flights which do feature atleast 2 classes of service, SCL-IPC vv being one of those.

Star file says
"AY/EI/LA/LP Domestic D class booking in Y"

None of these airlines have J cabin on their domestic flights (= the real reason behind the rule, not trying to keep DONEx pax in the back...) however, SCL-IPC continues to PTT, as have already been mentioned, and must therefore be classified as a part of an international route

Long post short: all DONEx pax, happy J-travel to IPC (D availability permitting ;)

imarks Feb 19, 2006 1:41 pm


Originally Posted by NoWindowSeat
This is totally irrellevant issue to argue over, no matter what the rules say, the real life is that a DONEx ticket allows one to travel in business class on all LAN operated flights which do feature atleast 2 classes of service, SCL-IPC vv being one of those.

Star file says
"AY/EI/LA/LP Domestic D class booking in Y"

None of these airlines have J cabin on their domestic flights (= the real reason behind the rule, not trying to keep DONEx pax in the back...) however, SCL-IPC continues to PTT, as have already been mentioned, and must therefore be classified as a part of an international route

Long post short: all DONEx pax, happy J-travel to IPC (D availability permitting ;)

Thanks, it all makes sense now and I'm glad we've cleared this up :D

Sorry to be a nuisance, but I have some more questions!

* Can I contact the UK/US BA RTW desk by email?
* How does seat selection work? Would MMB on ba.com work for all the flights or just the BA ones, assuming I'm booking through BA?
* Is there any way one can use BA miles to upgrade some of the flights (MFU)?

Thanks again - this forum is an amazing resource and I hope to give as much help as I've received when I become a bit more experienced at this :)

Kiwi Flyer Feb 19, 2006 4:59 pm


Originally Posted by NoWindowSeat
Regarding the SCL-AKL/SYD vv flights, there is a well known problem with A class availability with only 5 seats total in F...regarding D class, the situation shouldn't be a problem.


That may be about to improve (well from July). According to this post the service will be increasing to 6 per week.

imarks Mar 17, 2006 1:15 pm

I'm still finalising my itinerary and have started thinking about where to stay. I don't have upper tier status with any hotel programs but thought this trip would be a good opportunity to rack up some stays/points. For the route I'm doing (includes Europe, Asia, SWP & South America), which of the major hotel programs would you recommend? Is there any way of getting status before the trip on the strength of all the bednights I'll likely be booking? Thanks.

Japhydog Mar 17, 2006 2:01 pm


Originally Posted by imarks
I'm still finalising my itinerary and have started thinking about where to stay. I don't have upper tier status with any hotel programs but thought this trip would be a good opportunity to rack up some stays/points. For the route I'm doing (includes Europe, Asia, SWP & South America), which of the major hotel programs would you recommend? Is there any way of getting status before the trip on the strength of all the bednights I'll likely be booking? Thanks.

Check and see if your FF program provides free/quick upgrade status for hotel programs (I know some do). With your proposed itinerary I'd do Hilton or SPG. I think Hilton gives better benefits for lower-tier status, but SPG just bought Le Meridien so there are lots of properties to choose from.

Cheetah_SA Mar 30, 2006 12:13 pm


Originally Posted by imarks
* How does seat selection work? Would MMB on ba.com work for all the flights or just the BA ones, assuming I'm booking through BA?

Looks like nobody answered this one and I have a vested interest in the reply. :)
I have an AONEWC4 booked (but not issued) through BA. Using MMB on BA.com I can choose/alter seats on BA and Comair (the local franchise) flights. But I can't on BA codeshares (QF flights using the BA flight number). The CX and QF flights don't even appear on MMB.

Is there any way I can select seats on those flight online? Do I have to wait till after the ticket is issued? Or will I have to ask BA to do it for me?

serfty Mar 30, 2006 4:02 pm

Qantas have no facility to pre-allocate seats online. If CX do have such a facility, you may need to have an Asia Miles/MPC frequent flyer number against their segments.

All you have to do is contact BA and they should be able to do it for you.

Cheetah_SA Mar 31, 2006 4:19 am

Ta muchly. ^


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:42 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.