FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   oneworld (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld-411/)
-   -   which prog. the best for ......? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld/1248571-prog-best.html)

bertheike Aug 17, 2011 3:18 am

which prog. the best for ......?
 
If you can transfer 420k miles from an intern. AMEX $ card into one of the following progs. CX / BA / IB / ( MH ), which one is the best prog. if one want to redemm business/first Europe<> USA and Europe<> China/HKG ?
Any other sugestions to transfer via a 3rd. party are also welcomed. But it def. should be oneworld, to use on BA/CX , because *aliance I have million of miles.

pogonation Aug 17, 2011 8:20 am

Don't transfer to IB! You will get the least value for your miles.

Comparisons:

BA:

Europe - USA
C = 100k
F = 150k

Europe - China/HKG
C = 160k
F = 240k

CX

CX is done by mileage so here are some examples (red = 1 carrier. blue = 2 or more carriers):

LHR-JFK:
C = 80k
F = 120k

C = 80k
F = 105k


LHR-ORD:
C = 80k
F = 120k

C= 85k
F= 115k


LHR-LAX:
C = 120k
F = 180k

C = 115k
F = 155k


For rewards to China/HKG:

LHR-HKG/China
C = 120k
F = 180k

C = 115k
F = 155k



MH

Since it is not part of *A yet we can't really speculate how good the burning will be. But you may be able to take guesses based upon their own mileage system:

Europe - KUL - HKG/China
C = 102k


To me it looks as though CX is your best choice! :)

Mwenenzi Aug 17, 2011 8:12 pm

You also need to consider what $$ you will pay in surcharges. MH surcharges are high IIRC

bertheike Aug 20, 2011 3:16 am

Thanks for your quotation.
Most travel is UK-MIA/TPA/PLS ( would be on BA solely )
And UK-HKG, which could be on BA/CX or QF.
Now I cover this by BMI and China with the USair miles on LH first.
So I want to transfer the AMEX points to a oneworld, to choose from them, even thought availability is more worse.
The best would be AA, but IDC issued in UK has no option to transfer to AA.

Originally Posted by pogonation (Post 16939233)
Don't transfer to IB! You will get the least value for your miles.

Comparisons:

BA:

Europe - USA
C = 100k
F = 150k

Europe - China/HKG
C = 160k
F = 240k

CX

CX is done by mileage so here are some examples (red = 1 carrier. blue = 2 or more carriers):

LHR-JFK:
C = 80k
F = 120k

C = 80k
F = 105k


LHR-ORD:
C = 80k
F = 120k

C= 85k
F= 115k


LHR-LAX:
C = 120k
F = 180k

C = 115k
F = 155k


For rewards to China/HKG:

LHR-HKG/China
C = 120k
F = 180k

C = 115k
F = 155k



MH

Since it is not part of *A yet we can't really speculate how good the burning will be. But you may be able to take guesses based upon their own mileage system:

Europe - KUL - HKG/China
C = 102k


To me it looks as though CX is your best choice! :)



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:58 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.