Portland, ME - where to stay?
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: NYC (Primarily EWR)
Programs: UA 1K / *G, Marriott Bonvoy Gold; Avis PC
Posts: 8,999
Portland, ME - where to stay?
I see there's a food thread already for PWM, so I will check out that one for where to eat However, my wife and I are doing a 3-day getaway in late August to Portland, and we haven't booked a hotel yet. No hotel status, just a hotel.com/Rocket Miler, so open to pretty much anything that isn't going to cost me a fortune. That said, I know this is high season up here, and most hotels are over $300/night, which I am fine with. Going over $400/night wouldn't be optimal unless someone here convinces me otherwise
So question is: where's the best spot to stay? I'd like to have a combination of location and view (harbor view for sure), but otherwise pretty standard amenities - not looking for a suite or anything fancy otherwise. FWIW, my initial once-over seems has me leaning towards the Westin Harborview, although it's not right on the harbor.
I only went to Portland for a friend's bar mitzvah 15 years ago, so I'm pretty much a newbie to the area. Any thoughts / tips much appreciated!
So question is: where's the best spot to stay? I'd like to have a combination of location and view (harbor view for sure), but otherwise pretty standard amenities - not looking for a suite or anything fancy otherwise. FWIW, my initial once-over seems has me leaning towards the Westin Harborview, although it's not right on the harbor.
I only went to Portland for a friend's bar mitzvah 15 years ago, so I'm pretty much a newbie to the area. Any thoughts / tips much appreciated!
#3
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: SEA
Posts: 3,952
Hilton Garden Inn is good. Hyatt Place is a brand new property, not a converted Amerisuites, and is my favorite (but I'm loyal to Hyatt). The new Westin, which is the gutted and remodeled Eastland Park hotel, is also pretty nice.
If you can swing it, my call would be the Hyatt Place room or suite with a balcony on the Fore Street side (facing Casco Bay). In the summer, that balcony will have a great view and be a nice place to hang out after you get back for the day. The Old Port is still small enough that you can walk to any restaurant.
If you can swing it, my call would be the Hyatt Place room or suite with a balcony on the Fore Street side (facing Casco Bay). In the summer, that balcony will have a great view and be a nice place to hang out after you get back for the day. The Old Port is still small enough that you can walk to any restaurant.
#4
Original Poster
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: NYC (Primarily EWR)
Programs: UA 1K / *G, Marriott Bonvoy Gold; Avis PC
Posts: 8,999
Hilton Garden Inn is good. Hyatt Place is a brand new property, not a converted Amerisuites, and is my favorite (but I'm loyal to Hyatt). The new Westin, which is the gutted and remodeled Eastland Park hotel, is also pretty nice.
If you can swing it, my call would be the Hyatt Place room or suite with a balcony on the Fore Street side (facing Casco Bay). In the summer, that balcony will have a great view and be a nice place to hang out after you get back for the day. The Old Port is still small enough that you can walk to any restaurant.
If you can swing it, my call would be the Hyatt Place room or suite with a balcony on the Fore Street side (facing Casco Bay). In the summer, that balcony will have a great view and be a nice place to hang out after you get back for the day. The Old Port is still small enough that you can walk to any restaurant.
#5
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: SEA
Posts: 3,952
What is the construction at the Hyatt Place like? The ones I've been to in the past (in Austin TX and Charlottesville PA) were virtually identical - that is to say that while the setup / space was solid, the new construction seemed a bit on the cheap side (the walls are very thin - we heard the next-door neighbors enjoying each other's company, if you catch my drift), and there was absolutely no differentiating factor between the hotels - had a very cookie-cutter feel to it. If this is different, I wouldn't mind, but I have different feelings about spending $350+/night vs. the ~$125/night I spent at those other locations.
The construction quality is the same as any other new construction (not renovated Amerisuites) HP. I'm local, but we've done a few weekends at this property, haven't heard our neighbors. What I will say is that you WILL hear some noise from the bars if you're facing Fore Street, since the windows aren't soundproof, but I haven't minded (and it's not kept my 3 year old awake). But since you mentioned noise, it's worth mentioning that.
If you want to go higher end, the Portland Harbor Hotel is across the street and a nice place. However, I prefer the HP for the balcony rooms, or the Westin for the rooftop bar.
Portland doesn't have a true high end property in the Old Port. Everyone is going to have the following in common: Mid-range with a decent but not spectacular breakfast, no destination restaurant on the property, somewhat expensive parking ($18-25/day), and a good location (since the Old Port is small). Therefore, the decision really comes down to brand loyalty, if any, price and room features.
When I was blogging more steadily, I wrote up a review of the HP Old Port: https://saverocity.com/arewethereyet...rtland-review/
I'm going through to see if I have any pics of the other hotels. I know we've stayed at them.
#6
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: New England (BOS/BDL)
Posts: 124
I stayed at the Hyatt Place Portland last summer when it was first built and didn't have -any problems with noise between rooms. Every place in Old Port is kind of noisy though since the bars play music until late at night. Even on the 6th floor we heard a lot of street noise but it didn't bother me or my infant. The views were great.
The Portland Harbor Hotel is also nice.
The Portland Harbor Hotel is also nice.
#7
Original Poster
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: NYC (Primarily EWR)
Programs: UA 1K / *G, Marriott Bonvoy Gold; Avis PC
Posts: 8,999
Appreciate the feedback folks - ended up going with the Westin, as the price is a bit better ($350 for a harbor-view room v. $430 for a balcony room at HP).
#8
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: SEA
Posts: 3,952
Wow, $430? It's official, our local economy is doing better this summer than last. Glad you were able to get something with a view at the Westin. I was just in that area today, you'll enjoy the place.
#9
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: The County, Maine
Posts: 829
If you want to eat seafood where the locals eat head over to Ken's in Scarborough or The Rising Tide Restaurant just down the road. Good, fresh local seafood at fair prices. Here's a little help to check them out. These are only 2. Head out and explore and you're sure to find many that are just as good. Sorry I'm a little late to the conversation but I hope this helps those that might still be coming to our great state.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/kens-place-scarborough
http://www.risingtiderestaurant.com/...rant_Home.html
#10
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: SEA
Posts: 3,952
Nah! It's just Portland Maine in the summer where hotels sucker punch those from "away" into paying exorbitant prices during the summer and foliage season to recover for the lack of business they experience from November to May and make Boston properties look like bargain city. Make it when you can because it's going to be a long winter.
If you want to eat seafood where the locals eat head over to Ken's in Scarborough or The Rising Tide Restaurant just down the road. Good, fresh local seafood at fair prices. Here's a little help to check them out. These are only 2. Head out and explore and you're sure to find many that are just as good. Sorry I'm a little late to the conversation but I hope this helps those that might still be coming to our great state.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/kens-place-scarborough
http://www.risingtiderestaurant.com/...rant_Home.html
If you want to eat seafood where the locals eat head over to Ken's in Scarborough or The Rising Tide Restaurant just down the road. Good, fresh local seafood at fair prices. Here's a little help to check them out. These are only 2. Head out and explore and you're sure to find many that are just as good. Sorry I'm a little late to the conversation but I hope this helps those that might still be coming to our great state.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/kens-place-scarborough
http://www.risingtiderestaurant.com/...rant_Home.html
If Ken's is full, Bayley's down the street is not what I'd consider a substitute. Both are order at the window fried seafood shacks, but that's about where it ends. If Ken's is full, continue on to Rising Tide. I've never eaten at the Clambake on the same road (Pine Point Rd), but I've also never heard that I should. Pine Point Grille is a newer place, a bit nicer than Ken's and those places (meaning table service). I've eaten there a few times and have liked it.
I drive down Pine Point Rd every day
#11
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Mar 2001
Posts: 55,189
ke bargain city. Make it when you can because it's going to be a long winter.
If you want to eat seafood where the locals eat head over to Ken's in Scarborough or The Rising Tide Restaurant just down the road. Good, fresh local seafood at fair prices. Here's a little help to check them out. These are only 2. Head out and explore and you're sure to find many that are just as good. Sorry I'm a little late to the conversation but I hope this helps those that might still be coming to our great state.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/kens-place-scarborough
http://www.risingtiderestaurant.com/...rant_Home.html
If you want to eat seafood where the locals eat head over to Ken's in Scarborough or The Rising Tide Restaurant just down the road. Good, fresh local seafood at fair prices. Here's a little help to check them out. These are only 2. Head out and explore and you're sure to find many that are just as good. Sorry I'm a little late to the conversation but I hope this helps those that might still be coming to our great state.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/kens-place-scarborough
http://www.risingtiderestaurant.com/...rant_Home.html
#12
Community Director Emerita
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: Anywhere warm
Posts: 33,739
I stayed at the Hyatt Place Portland last summer when it was first built and didn't have -any problems with noise between rooms. Every place in Old Port is kind of noisy though since the bars play music until late at night. Even on the 6th floor we heard a lot of street noise but it didn't bother me or my infant. The views were great.
#13
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: The County, Maine
Posts: 829
I found what I think is a great little restaurant located in a small shopping mall in Portsmouth, NH, just a 15 minute drive across the bridge from Kittery. It's called Hebert's Restaurant. The portions were huge and the prices extremely reasonable. Plus you can use restaurant.com certificates to bring the cost down even more. They also have a 50's style diner in the rear of the restaurant if you want to try that out.
http://www.hebertsrestaurant.com/index.html
You won't get oceanfront views at this place, but will experience great seafood. I don't care if a place is fancy just as long as it's good.
#14
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: The County, Maine
Posts: 829
I envy you but where I'm from up North my business takes me down to Calais, Machias and Jonesport two times a week and there are some pretty good places to eat along the way. I've also got an "in" to buy my lobsters, crabmeat, haddock and shrimp right off the boat and not at out of state prices. Last year I was paying $2.50 a pound for lobster. So it's not too bad up here.
Last edited by general45; Aug 21, 2015 at 3:10 pm
#15
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: SEA
Posts: 3,952
I envy you but where I'm from up North my business takes me down to Calais, Machias and Jonesport two times a week and there are some pretty good places to eat along the way. I've also got an "in" to buy my lobsters, crabmeat, haddock and shrimp right off the boat and not at out of state prices. Last year I was paying $2.50 a pound for lobster. So it's not too bad up here.