Transferring miles among various programs?
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2011
Programs: Aeroplan, BA Avios, Delta Skymiles, AAdvantage
Posts: 138
Probably mentioned a few times here but here goes;
I have several miles in several programs. I'd like some feedback on what's my best options.
My programs are Aeroplan, Skymiles, Aadvantage and AE rewards miles.
I'm not sure AC is the best option anymore for travel. I've been flying Delta recently and as much as it's comfortable and nice service, their points structure is a bit of a shocker - on top of that, they'll be switching redemption amounts June 2014. I flew previously with AA because it was the cheapest in taxes / airport fees and I took advantage of some sweet bonuses in the past. Not amazingly comfortable in econo class. I just signed up for an AE card with some nice bonuses after a low spend. Anyone know where I should transfer to?
Should I leave them spread out like that? Consolidate somewhere? Swap from one program to an other?
(To use with partners?)
I often travel from YUL/BTV/PBG (ALB sometimes too) to Mainly FLL/MIA an at least once a year to France or Israel.
Much appreciated!
Phil
I have several miles in several programs. I'd like some feedback on what's my best options.
My programs are Aeroplan, Skymiles, Aadvantage and AE rewards miles.
I'm not sure AC is the best option anymore for travel. I've been flying Delta recently and as much as it's comfortable and nice service, their points structure is a bit of a shocker - on top of that, they'll be switching redemption amounts June 2014. I flew previously with AA because it was the cheapest in taxes / airport fees and I took advantage of some sweet bonuses in the past. Not amazingly comfortable in econo class. I just signed up for an AE card with some nice bonuses after a low spend. Anyone know where I should transfer to?
Should I leave them spread out like that? Consolidate somewhere? Swap from one program to an other?
(To use with partners?)
I often travel from YUL/BTV/PBG (ALB sometimes too) to Mainly FLL/MIA an at least once a year to France or Israel.
Much appreciated!
Phil
Last edited by Cphil1; Sep 10, 2013 at 11:51 pm
#3




Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 6,458
Probably mentioned a few times here but here goes;
I have several miles in several programs. I'd like some feedback on what's my best options.
My programs are Aeroplan, Skymiles, Aadvantage and AE rewards miles.
I'm not sure AC is the best option anymore for travel. I've been flying Delta recently and as much as it's comfortable and nice service, their points structure is a bit of a shocker - on top of that, they'll be switching redemption amounts June 2014. I flew previously with AA because it was the cheapest in taxes / airport fees and I took advantage of some sweet bonuses in the past. Not amazingly comfortable in econo class. I just signed up for an AE card with some nice bonuses after a low spend. Anyone know where I should transfer to?
Should I leave them spread out like that? Consolidate somewhere? Swap from one program to an other?
(To use with partners?)
I often travel from YUL/BTV/PBG (ALB sometimes too) to Mainly FLL/MIA an at least once a year to France or Israel.
Much appreciated!
Phil
I have several miles in several programs. I'd like some feedback on what's my best options.
My programs are Aeroplan, Skymiles, Aadvantage and AE rewards miles.
I'm not sure AC is the best option anymore for travel. I've been flying Delta recently and as much as it's comfortable and nice service, their points structure is a bit of a shocker - on top of that, they'll be switching redemption amounts June 2014. I flew previously with AA because it was the cheapest in taxes / airport fees and I took advantage of some sweet bonuses in the past. Not amazingly comfortable in econo class. I just signed up for an AE card with some nice bonuses after a low spend. Anyone know where I should transfer to?
Should I leave them spread out like that? Consolidate somewhere? Swap from one program to an other?
(To use with partners?)
I often travel from YUL/BTV/PBG (ALB sometimes too) to Mainly FLL/MIA an at least once a year to France or Israel.
Much appreciated!
Phil
If you have a lot of credit card spend consider using miles that are transferrable (like the AMEX SPG) so you hae a lot of flexibility.
AE in Canada has very crappy transfer partners and I would recommend against transferring to Delta as the ratio is only 1:0.75. The best is probably Aeroplan and Avios (which has a 50% ratio, so hold out for that). If you need any help with your miles feel free to send me an email (see my blog for that).
Unfortunately nearly all of the points.com transfer ratios suck.
#4


Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: BOS, BWI, DCA, IAD
Programs: American, Delta, JetBlue, United
Posts: 2,404
You can't move miles from one program to another, and you would probably do best trying to accumulate miles as much as possible in a single program in the future. DL miles are notoriously hard to redeem, so DL would probably not be a good choice.
As far as your existing miles are concerned, AA permits OW redemptions for half the miles required for RT. If that's true of AC as well (I don't know AC's policies, but its partner UA is the same as AA in this respect), you may be able to draw on both programs to book the equivalent of a RT flight. It's not quite the same as transferring miles, but it is a way to apply miles from two programs to one trip.
As far as your existing miles are concerned, AA permits OW redemptions for half the miles required for RT. If that's true of AC as well (I don't know AC's policies, but its partner UA is the same as AA in this respect), you may be able to draw on both programs to book the equivalent of a RT flight. It's not quite the same as transferring miles, but it is a way to apply miles from two programs to one trip.
#6
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2011
Programs: Aeroplan, BA Avios, Delta Skymiles, AAdvantage
Posts: 138
Thanks for the heads up!
There seems to be a 1:1 transfer ratio for amex to AP. maybe ill look into that.
There used to be a trick to transfer AP to AA via RBC/Esso, 10:9 ratio. Im not sure if thats still ongoing. But if it is, its not a huge loss.
Points.com is horrible at trades, plus u have to pay something out of pocket!
Ill keep looking around and apprexiate future pointers!
Phil
There seems to be a 1:1 transfer ratio for amex to AP. maybe ill look into that.
There used to be a trick to transfer AP to AA via RBC/Esso, 10:9 ratio. Im not sure if thats still ongoing. But if it is, its not a huge loss.
Points.com is horrible at trades, plus u have to pay something out of pocket!
Ill keep looking around and apprexiate future pointers!
Phil
#7




Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 6,458
Thanks for the heads up!
There seems to be a 1:1 transfer ratio for amex to AP. maybe ill look into that.
There used to be a trick to transfer AP to AA via RBC/Esso, 10:9 ratio. Im not sure if thats still ongoing. But if it is, its not a huge loss.
Points.com is horrible at trades, plus u have to pay something out of pocket!
Ill keep looking around and apprexiate future pointers!
Phil
There seems to be a 1:1 transfer ratio for amex to AP. maybe ill look into that.
There used to be a trick to transfer AP to AA via RBC/Esso, 10:9 ratio. Im not sure if thats still ongoing. But if it is, its not a huge loss.
Points.com is horrible at trades, plus u have to pay something out of pocket!
Ill keep looking around and apprexiate future pointers!
Phil
#8
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: San Antonio
Programs: AS MVP
Posts: 2,276
Probably mentioned a few times here but here goes;
I have several miles in several programs. I'd like some feedback on what's my best options.
Anyone know where I should transfer to?
Should I leave them spread out like that? Consolidate somewhere? Swap from one program to an other?
(To use with partners?)
I often travel from YUL/BTV/PBG (ALB sometimes too) to Mainly FLL/MIA an at least once a year to France or Israel.
Much appreciated!
Phil
I have several miles in several programs. I'd like some feedback on what's my best options.
Anyone know where I should transfer to?
Should I leave them spread out like that? Consolidate somewhere? Swap from one program to an other?
(To use with partners?)
I often travel from YUL/BTV/PBG (ALB sometimes too) to Mainly FLL/MIA an at least once a year to France or Israel.
Much appreciated!
Phil
#9
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Philadelphia/NY/CA
Programs: US Airways/SPG/Club Carlson (Gold)/United/Marriott Rewards Premier (Silver)/Priority Club Platinum
Posts: 332
If your balances are at a point where they can be used and used up, you may want to begin crediting to Alaska - they partner with AA, DL, BA and others and are easy to search and redeem. They even have a 25K bonus on their credit card (annual fee not waived) https://www.applyonlinenow.com/CACCa...=CPYZ&lc=en_CA
But ya about this topic. I have never tried making transfers, but I feel like it's best to have miles/points in different programs that way you have many options.
Last edited by World-Wide; Sep 11, 2013 at 10:25 pm
#10




Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 668
I agree with you as long as you accumulate in different programs belonging to different alliances (for airlines); otherwise, it would be best to accumulate in one program.


