FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   MilesBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz-370/)
-   -   Airline programs that still offer permanent status without BIS miles? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz/1322020-airline-programs-still-offer-permanent-status-without-bis-miles.html)

bar001 Mar 6, 2012 6:59 pm

Airline programs that still offer permanent status without BIS miles?
 
Hi,

I got on the AA wagon too late to earn million milers status and permanent gold status etc. I do not fly enough to achieve this with Butt in seat miles but, with AA i earn around 30,000 miles per month with bankdirect and other programs they have.

I would like to find out if there are still any AIRLINE programs that are still offering permanent statuses (that get perks such as free lounges, etc etc.) to miles that are earned through other programs they run, not just BIS miles.

I like the AA program and it works for me because I'm based in central Texas so they fly from all the airports around me (and I like the fact that they are one world alliance as I fly BA to LON about once a year.) But as they changed the program at the end of last year, and because I do not fly enough, I can never achieve a permanent status.

Anyone know any programs I should be looking at?

Thanks!

84fiero Mar 7, 2012 12:42 am

No program that I know of for lifetime status purposes. Some opportunities to buy or earn EQMs for annual status other than BIS (e.g., Delta Amex, US Buy-up to Preferred, etc) but that's it AFAIK.

ashprag Mar 7, 2012 1:00 pm

Why Bank Direct?
 
Why is OP using bank Direct? AFAIK, they have very ugly economics behind the mileage program, you can ear better cash values in other finance institution for the safe principle?

mikelat Mar 7, 2012 9:24 pm

I think AA was one of the last to recognize non-BIS miles towards lifetime status. You may be out of luck in finding another program that will allow you to earn towards life time status with credit card and non-flight miles.

sdsearch Mar 8, 2012 2:09 pm


Originally Posted by bar001 (Post 18149165)
I got on the AA wagon too late to earn million milers status and permanent gold status etc. I do not fly enough to achieve this with Butt in seat miles but, with AA i earn around 30,000 miles per month with bankdirect and other programs they have.

I would like to find out if there are still any AIRLINE programs that are still offering permanent statuses (that get perks such as free lounges, etc etc.) to miles that are earned through other programs they run, not just BIS miles.

You seem to be confused about status levels. Gold Status at AA (and equivalent lowest level at other airlines) doesn't give you any lounge status. And Platinum Status (which requires 2 million miles for lifetime at AA) gets you lounge status only on days you're traveling internationally (on an AA ticket).

All lifetime Gold status would have gotten you was access to preferred seating at booking (but will that go away after 2013? we're not sure), priority boarding, free checked bag, etc. Most of those things (except the preferred seats) are available with the "right" credit card at some other airlines, though not (yet?) at AA.

Anyway, as already explained by others, AA was the last airline to offer permanent status with non-BIS miles. So now that it stopped offering it, no one else does.

Some credit cards do give you lounge access through a program called Priority Pass, but usually they're cards with high annual fees. (You can also buy Priority Pass membership on its own, but you would want to verify that it has lounge access in the specific airport terminals you tend to be in. A lounge in, for example, JFK terminal 3 does you no good if you're flying through terminal 8!)

oldpenny16 Mar 8, 2012 2:20 pm

Yes, with the changes in the AA miles program rules, no other airline gives status for non-BIS miles.

I changed credit cards to ones that earn cash back and no longer seek AA miles at every opportunity. Does AA miss the loss of income?

I have also cut back on AA eshopping due to a lack of interest in AA miles and a desire to use coupons and other means of discounts.

Fly2Where Mar 8, 2012 4:49 pm


Originally Posted by sdsearch (Post 18162067)
And Platinum Status (which requires 2 million miles for lifetime at AA) gets you lounge status only on days you're traveling internationally (on an AA ticket).

actually AA plt giver could fly any OW carrier and use any one OW lounge *with few exception applies (ie dosmestic flight in US)

sdsearch Mar 9, 2012 10:36 am


Originally Posted by Fly2Where (Post 18163062)

Originally Posted by sdsearch (Post 18162067)
And Platinum Status (which requires 2 million miles for lifetime at AA) gets you lounge status only on days you're traveling internationally (on an AA ticket).

actually AA plt giver could fly any OW carrier and use any one OW lounge *with few exception applies (ie dosmestic flight in US)

As long as your AA FF # (since that's where you have your status) is what's on the ticket, and your status is recognized as a result of that. So what I meant by "AA ticket" is that this is easest if you book OW flights through AA. (It's possible when booking otherwise, but not alwyas as simple, especially since you giving another OW airline your AA FF # does not make them instantly see your status, does it?)

mikeef Mar 9, 2012 11:50 am

AFAIK, the EQM earned through the Delta credit card do count toward lifetime status, but you may want to check with the DL gurus.

Mike

ExitRowAisle Mar 9, 2012 11:52 am


Originally Posted by ashprag (Post 18154722)
Why is OP using bank Direct? AFAIK, they have very ugly economics behind the mileage program, you can ear better cash values in other finance institution for the safe principle?

I'm all ears. Let's hear about the finance institutions that offer a better after-tax rate for $200k that don't require additional work on the part of the customer.

ExitRowAisle
A Dissatisfied 2nd Class Starwood Platinum Member

Photonerd71 Mar 9, 2012 6:04 pm


Originally Posted by sdsearch:18162067

Originally Posted by bar001 (Post 18149165)
I got on the AA wagon too late to earn million milers status and permanent gold status etc. I do not fly enough to achieve this with Butt in seat miles but, with AA i earn around 30,000 miles per month with bankdirect and other programs they have.

I would like to find out if there are still any AIRLINE programs that are still offering permanent statuses (that get perks such as free lounges, etc etc.) to miles that are earned through other programs they run, not just BIS miles.

You seem to be confused about status levels. Gold Status at AA (and equivalent lowest level at other airlines) doesn't give you any lounge status. And Platinum Status (which requires 2 million miles for lifetime at AA) gets you lounge status only on days you're traveling internationally (on an AA ticket).

All lifetime Gold status would have gotten you was access to preferred seating at booking (but will that go away after 2013? we're not sure), priority boarding, free checked bag, etc. Most of those things (except the preferred seats) are available with the "right" credit card at some other airlines, though not (yet?) at AA.

Anyway, as already explained by others, AA was the last airline to offer permanent status with non-BIS miles. So now that it stopped offering it, no one else does.

Some credit cards do give you lounge access through a program called Priority Pass, but usually they're cards with high annual fees. (You can also buy Priority Pass membership on its own, but you would want to verify that it has lounge access in the specific airport terminals you tend to be in. A lounge in, for example, JFK terminal 3 does you no good if you're flying through terminal 8!)


Actually the citi world elite card gives you lounge access (admirals club membership) with AA. Along with priority boarding, checked bags and 10k eqms fir each 40k charged. You can search for all the bennies but it is basically gold without the mileage bonus.

javabytes Mar 9, 2012 7:16 pm


Originally Posted by mikeef (Post 18168016)
AFAIK, the EQM earned through the Delta credit card do count toward lifetime status, but you may want to check with the DL gurus.

This is true. But the difficult thing is that you only earn a certain amount of EQM (in DL terms, MQM) based on meeting spending thresholds - usually 25k in spend for 10k MQM, or 30k spend for 15k MQM. You don't earn MQMs (only redeemable miles) for every $1 in regular spend, which makes it more difficult than AA.

In theory, you could have multiple cards for personal and business, and earn a good chunk of MQMs every year. (Plenty of people do this.) But the spend requirements are high if you're going to accrue anything serious.

Also, if you cruise over to the DL boards, you will hear a lot of complaints about how DL's Million Miler program is weak compared to other US airlines.

mikelat Mar 9, 2012 11:29 pm


Originally Posted by Photonerd71 (Post 18170231)
Actually the citi world elite card gives you lounge access (admirals club membership) with AA. Along with priority boarding, checked bags and 10k eqms fir each 40k charged. You can search for all the bennies but it is basically gold without the mileage bonus.

Note quite for every 40k:

Each calendar year when you reach $40,000 in spending on purchases with your Citi ExecutiveSM / AAdvantageŽ World EliteTM MasterCardŽ credit card, you will earn 10,000 AAdvantageŽ elite qualifying miles from American Airlines to put you on the fast track to American Airlines AAdvantageŽ elite status membership.
From http://www.aa.com/i18n/urls/citiexecutive.jsp

4. ELITE QUALIFYING MILES:
One time per calendar year (referring to January through December billing statements), the primary Citi ExecutiveSM / AAdvantageŽ World EliteTM MastercardŽ cardmember will earn 10,000 Elite Qualifying Miles (EQMs) after he or she reaches the first $40,000 in eligible purchases on his or her Citi ExecutiveSM / AAdvantageŽ World EliteTM MastercardŽ account during such calendar year (purchases posted to your January to December billing statements), regardless of the date the account is opened

Counsellor Mar 11, 2012 10:38 am


Originally Posted by mikeef (Post 18168016)
AFAIK, the EQM earned through the Delta credit card do count toward lifetime status, but you may want to check with the DL gurus.

Mike

Yes, but it will take a while -- at 15K MQM per year, getting to one million can be done in only 67 years! :D

javabytes Mar 14, 2012 11:37 pm


Originally Posted by Counsellor (Post 18178586)
Yes, but it will take a while -- at 15K MQM per year, getting to one million can be done in only 67 years! :D

Between the different cards (Plat and Reserve, consumer & business) big spenders can pull in 50k MQM in a year.

Counsellor Mar 15, 2012 7:18 am

Then that's something to consider. It took me a bit over 20 years to rack up the million BIS miles on United (then called the "Flat Butt Club").

mikeef Mar 15, 2012 7:36 am


Originally Posted by javabytes (Post 18203566)
Between the different cards (Plat and Reserve, consumer & business) big spenders can pull in 50k MQM in a year.

Since we're going this route, there are a number of credit cards that offer MQMs for big spend. T&C indicate that you can have more than one card and earn a mileage boost from each. Of course, we're talking well over 100K in spend per year.


Built-in Miles Boost...
Cardmembers may be permitted to have more than one Options, classic, Gold, or Platinum or Delta Reserve SkyMiles Credit Card from American Express account; however, Cardmembers are only eligible to receive one annual Eligible Spending bonus for each type (i.e., Options, classic, Gold, Platinum or Reserve) of Delta SkyMiles Credit Card account from American Express. All Delta SkyMiles program rules apply. To review the rules, please visit delta.com/memberguide.

Medallion Qualification Miles earned in 2011 above member's earned Medallion threshold level will be rolled over to 2012 and will count toward 2012 Medallion status qualification. In addition, all Medallion Qualification Miles earned between Jan 1 and Dec 31, 2011 will count towards 2012 Medallion status.

jjmiller69 Mar 15, 2012 8:34 am


Originally Posted by javabytes (Post 18203566)
Between the different cards (Plat and Reserve, consumer & business) big spenders can pull in 50k MQM in a year.

This is true and by being Gold every year you will get some upgrades and 100% miles bonus too(this doesn't count for MQM's). But it comes with alot of spending which many of us can't do. I've been Plat and Gold the last 5 years by bis. One of the best things is the carry over on extra MQM's over one thresh hold but not enough for the next higher level. This year I'm going to try to get some MQM's with Amex. I'm giving in. lol :)

javabytes Mar 15, 2012 11:33 am


Originally Posted by mikeef (Post 18204989)
Since we're going this route, there are a number of credit cards that offer MQMs for big spend. T&C indicate that you can have more than one card and earn a mileage boost from each. Of course, we're talking well over 100K in spend per year.

The T&C you quoted state you can only earn a mileage boost from one card of each type. $50k spend on a DL Plat AmEx earns 20k MQM, $60k spend on a Reserve card earns 30k MQM, for a total of 50k MQM annually with $110k spend. I know this sum is doable. I'm not sure if they treat business cards separately (i.e. you could have 4 AmEx cards, Plat + Reserve for each individual and business, and earn 100k).

sdsearch Mar 15, 2012 2:48 pm

One thing not yet mentioned: Many of the benefits associated with status are also available when booking First or Business class tickets, and perhaps in some cases some of them also when booking "anytime" (not "saver") award tickets. So by getting enough miles through spend to book those classes (instead of just "saver" Coach), it lessens the need for elite status if most of your travel can be on award tickets. That's obviously not a practical solution for those who travel a lot of paid flights and want status on those, but it may be something to consider for those who only travel occasionally and yet would like elite perks.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 3:06 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.