Think It's a Fantastic Idea
 

IF someone is willing to do the work of compiling the op.

Comparing the rewards charts to certain places especially. The FF departments certainly are already aware of competitors' charts and if not, it might drive some rewards downward.

Of course there are some hidden gems that should stay under the radar a little and could be discussed vaguely & in pm's. But most of them have been mentioned already in blogs. Example: the AA (and probably other carriers) extra segment additions.

Here's what I know. Somebody who's contributed to this thread has done exactly what the OP has requested, albeit with one limited but profitable promotion. And someone else has not.

From those who demand a lot, eventually a lot is expected.

I don't think it's going to do much good....it was done on the China thread - a lot of really good information was organized - and just about everyone still posts without reading it first.

I feel like I have to answer so many newbies every day, all asking the same thing. Part of it is them, but the other factor is that everyone has different opinions.

Wiki. :-:

Trying to maintain something like this in a thread format is just going to be a mess.

agree 100%. wiki is the best way to consolidate conventional wisdom.