Last edit by: 1k650
Post your trip dates and itinerary here:
DPS-HKG - 09/6/2018 - MCI777
HKG-SFO - 09/7/2018 - MCI777 ( just flew SFO-HKG-DPS a few days ago)
LAX-BKK - 10/07/2018 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 10/22/2018 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 10/10/2018 - jerrflyer
LAX-BKK - 10/15/2018 - cmdsea
BKK-LAX - 04/04/2019 - cmdsea
SFO-PVG - 10/24/2018 - 1k650
DPS-SFO - 11/14/2018 - 1k650
LAX-DPS - 10/27/2018 - FoxFlyer
DPS-LAX - 11/01/2018 - FoxFlyer
BKK-LAX - 11/01/2018 - EmailKid
LAX-BKK - 11/01/2018 - fijaircan
BKK-LAX - 11/11/2018 - fijaircan
LAX-BKK - 11/17/2018 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 11/27/2018 - EVA777
LAX-PVG - 01/10/2019 - George84
PVG-LAX - 01/14/2019 - George84
LAX-PVG - 01/17/2019 - SGan317
PVG-LAX - 01/21/2019 - SGan317
SFO-BKK 01/07/19- frank10b
BKK-SFO 01/16/19 - frank10b
SFO-BKK 01/09/2019 - IluvSQ
BKK-SFO 01/25/2019 - IluvSQ
LAX-PVG 01/19/2019 - vincewy
PVG-LAX 01/26/2019 - vincewy
LAX-HKG 2/2/19 - genesq
HKG-LAX 2/17/19 - genesq
LAX-DPS 2/13/19 - maverikbc
DPS-LAX 3/4/19 - maverikbc
LAX-BKK 2/14/19 - chiefnwa
BKK-LAX 2/24/19 - chiefnwa
SFO-BKK 2/17/19 - bretmd
BKK-SFO 2/24/19 - bretmd
SFO-PVG - 2/22/2019 - gpen1827
PVG-SFO - 3/4/2019 - gpen1827
LAX-BKK 2/22/2019 MCI777
BKK-LAX 2/27/2019 MCI777
SFO-SGN - 02/25/2019 - Flyer89
SGN-LAX - 03/02/2019 - Flyer89
SFO-BKK - 2/27/2019 - 1k650
DPS-SFO - 3/20/2019 - 1k650
LAX-BKK - 03/01/2019 - sydneyguy1234
BKK-LAX - 03/04/2019 - sydneyguy1234
LAX-BKK - 03/02/2019 - firemandan9
BKK-LAX - 03/10/2019 - firemandan9
LAX-BKK - 03/02/2019 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 03/17/2019 - EVA777
SFO-PVG - 03/17/2019 - omghaxcode
PVG-SFO - 03/24/2019 - omghaxcode
LAX-PVG - 03/23/2019 - legalalien, Ml007, Mileage Lover
PVG-LAX - 03/30/2019 - legalalien, Ml007
PVG-LAX 03/31/2019 Mileage Lover
LAX-HKG 09/22/2018 atiger29
LAX-HKG 11/14/2018 Tafflyer
HKG-PVG 11/18/2018 Tafflyer
PVG-LAX 04/02/2019 Tafflyer
DPS-HKG - 09/6/2018 - MCI777
HKG-SFO - 09/7/2018 - MCI777 ( just flew SFO-HKG-DPS a few days ago)
LAX-BKK - 10/07/2018 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 10/22/2018 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 10/10/2018 - jerrflyer
LAX-BKK - 10/15/2018 - cmdsea
BKK-LAX - 04/04/2019 - cmdsea
SFO-PVG - 10/24/2018 - 1k650
DPS-SFO - 11/14/2018 - 1k650
LAX-DPS - 10/27/2018 - FoxFlyer
DPS-LAX - 11/01/2018 - FoxFlyer
BKK-LAX - 11/01/2018 - EmailKid
LAX-BKK - 11/01/2018 - fijaircan
BKK-LAX - 11/11/2018 - fijaircan
LAX-BKK - 11/17/2018 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 11/27/2018 - EVA777
LAX-PVG - 01/10/2019 - George84
PVG-LAX - 01/14/2019 - George84
LAX-PVG - 01/17/2019 - SGan317
PVG-LAX - 01/21/2019 - SGan317
SFO-BKK 01/07/19- frank10b
BKK-SFO 01/16/19 - frank10b
SFO-BKK 01/09/2019 - IluvSQ
BKK-SFO 01/25/2019 - IluvSQ
LAX-PVG 01/19/2019 - vincewy
PVG-LAX 01/26/2019 - vincewy
LAX-HKG 2/2/19 - genesq
HKG-LAX 2/17/19 - genesq
LAX-DPS 2/13/19 - maverikbc
DPS-LAX 3/4/19 - maverikbc
LAX-BKK 2/14/19 - chiefnwa
BKK-LAX 2/24/19 - chiefnwa
SFO-BKK 2/17/19 - bretmd
BKK-SFO 2/24/19 - bretmd
SFO-PVG - 2/22/2019 - gpen1827
PVG-SFO - 3/4/2019 - gpen1827
LAX-BKK 2/22/2019 MCI777
BKK-LAX 2/27/2019 MCI777
SFO-SGN - 02/25/2019 - Flyer89
SGN-LAX - 03/02/2019 - Flyer89
SFO-BKK - 2/27/2019 - 1k650
DPS-SFO - 3/20/2019 - 1k650
LAX-BKK - 03/01/2019 - sydneyguy1234
BKK-LAX - 03/04/2019 - sydneyguy1234
LAX-BKK - 03/02/2019 - firemandan9
BKK-LAX - 03/10/2019 - firemandan9
LAX-BKK - 03/02/2019 - EVA777
BKK-LAX - 03/17/2019 - EVA777
SFO-PVG - 03/17/2019 - omghaxcode
PVG-SFO - 03/24/2019 - omghaxcode
LAX-PVG - 03/23/2019 - legalalien, Ml007, Mileage Lover
PVG-LAX - 03/30/2019 - legalalien, Ml007
PVG-LAX 03/31/2019 Mileage Lover
LAX-HKG 09/22/2018 atiger29
LAX-HKG 11/14/2018 Tafflyer
HKG-PVG 11/18/2018 Tafflyer
PVG-LAX 04/02/2019 Tafflyer
[PREM FARE GONE] HX: LAX-PVG rt in J ~$580ish
#871
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 4,964
You will need to get passport checked so might as well do it at checkin desks since its a bit easier there than at the gate.
#874
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: LAX
Programs: UA 1K MM; Bonvoy Titanium; most other FF programs...
Posts: 654
The LA flights on the A350 have always been 1-2-1... the “new” configuration is just reverse herringbone 1-2-1. While it is nice to have a newer aircraft, the original 1-2-1 is totally fine (and for some seats on the sides, a little more private).
And when I was flying on this great fare, I noticed the new bird was about once a week (mostly on Friday in both directions), but that may have shifted in the past month since I completed my journey.
And when I was flying on this great fare, I noticed the new bird was about once a week (mostly on Friday in both directions), but that may have shifted in the past month since I completed my journey.
Last edited by FoxFlyer; Dec 5, 2018 at 1:25 pm
#875
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: TPA
Programs: DL Diamond, HH Diamond, IHG Plat, Marriott Gold
Posts: 1,256
The LA flights on the A350 have always been 1-2-1... the “new” configuration is just reverse herringbone 1-2-1. While it is nice to have a newer aircraft, the original 1-2-1 is totally fine (and for some seats on the sides, a little more private).
And when I was flying on this great fare, I noticed the new bird was about once a week (mostly on Friday in both directions), but that may have shifted in the past month since I completed my journey.
And when I was flying on this great fare, I noticed the new bird was about once a week (mostly on Friday in both directions), but that may have shifted in the past month since I completed my journey.
#876
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: FLL / BKK
Posts: 703
They took delivery of another A350 (B-LGH) on November 21st. This aircraft is on the way to LAX for the first time today. Not sure when the next A350 is due but I would think by Feb. LA should always see the new seats. I found the "old" seats to be great with plenty of room. Both of my trips so far have been on the old configuration both ways. If they are using the standard reverse herringbone that other carriers use I would rather have the old style seat.
#877
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: DCA/IAD
Programs: AA plat, SPG gold
Posts: 721
Friday lax-hkg had the new configuration. Monday return, old configuration.
In my opinion the older one seemed as if it had more foot room, however the newer one had more storage space around the seat. Same movie selection but the personal phone with the new configuration was cool.
Outbound service was great, comparable to other Asian airlines. Return not so much. Felt similar to a US airline in J, slow and unattentive.
Also quick data point, none of my flights were credited because my fortune wings account does not have my middle name added as my ticket did. I recently emailed HX a copy of my passport and boarding passes so hopefully this resolves any problems.
In my opinion the older one seemed as if it had more foot room, however the newer one had more storage space around the seat. Same movie selection but the personal phone with the new configuration was cool.
Outbound service was great, comparable to other Asian airlines. Return not so much. Felt similar to a US airline in J, slow and unattentive.
Also quick data point, none of my flights were credited because my fortune wings account does not have my middle name added as my ticket did. I recently emailed HX a copy of my passport and boarding passes so hopefully this resolves any problems.
Last edited by lakers6902; Dec 11, 2018 at 4:51 am
#878
Join Date: Nov 2007
Programs: AA, AS, BA, DL Plat, Chase UR, Diners, UA, F9, WN, SPG Gold, HH Diamond, Amex MR.
Posts: 436
SFO-HKG-PVG RT just completed. Solid 4-Star Airline Experience.
Check-in: Fast and easy. Added Fortune Wings # at check-in. Needed to do it again on return flight. Be ready to hand numbers to agents at PVG on paper or phone to avoid miscommunication.
Lounge: Air France lounge at SFO was surprisingly good with good food. The new Autus at HKG lounge was very nice with some good food. Was crowded on return flight in AM when SFO & LAX passengers are there. The showers are very nice. PVG (China Eastern?) lounge was nice too with good food selection & nice, clean bathrooms early in the AM.
Flight Delays: Both SFO-HKG and HKG-SFO had an hour of tarmac delays & these delays weren't made up in the air. HKG-SFO plane had "computer problems" delaying the departure. It was the same plane both times (old config) and the side of the right bathroom mirror was cracked. Cabin seat & bathroom cleanliness was average / acceptable.
Plane Food: Mixed quality. Eat in the lounge instead if you can. SFO-HKG sardine appetizer was very good. Salad good. Vegetarian meal was very good. Pepper steak meal was poor USA outbound, very good USA inbound. Poor dim sum as others have noted, I only tried it on USA outbound. HKG-SFO scallop appetizer was OK. One flights was out of port; the other out of scotch. Wine & Champagne are average $10-$20 bottles.
Plane Comfort: Enjoyed the close couples seating. I had selected seats via HK web chat. Trans-Pac J cabin gets too hot. Dress appropriately. Thin Van Laack PJ bottoms and a t-shirt, with a backup sweater or long-sleeve t-shirt is ideal. Nice blankets and pillows. We had trouble sleeping in the center seats a bit because of the noise created by other passengers. There is probably an art to sleeping on these planes too, by using a combination of seating and sleeping positions throughout the flight. For example, I liked using a combination of the lie-flat and the reclined position.
Plane Service: Service on HKG-SFO was good but a little slow with a very full front cabin. Service on HKG-SFO was very good and the FAs really cared. They haven't figured out how to time food delivery so couples get served simultaneously.
FF: Fortune Points posted 3-days later for first flight and Gold Status match success email received a couple days later.
Being in J on short HKG-PVG both ways greatly appreciated. Coach was fairly full on all segments, and we were exhausted on these flights. The pillows on the short segments are plumper and softer; I enjoyed that i could side-sleep with by Bose over-ears with these pillows. I also really liked the side bulkhead seats on the short segments - they feel more private. The short segments seats aren't lie flat, but they are big and recline far back.
Overall, I am very grateful to HK air for honoring the mistake fair, and I hope to fly them again. While it ain't anywhere near Cathay First, I would choose them over United or BA business class unless I had good reason not to do so.
Check-in: Fast and easy. Added Fortune Wings # at check-in. Needed to do it again on return flight. Be ready to hand numbers to agents at PVG on paper or phone to avoid miscommunication.
Lounge: Air France lounge at SFO was surprisingly good with good food. The new Autus at HKG lounge was very nice with some good food. Was crowded on return flight in AM when SFO & LAX passengers are there. The showers are very nice. PVG (China Eastern?) lounge was nice too with good food selection & nice, clean bathrooms early in the AM.
Flight Delays: Both SFO-HKG and HKG-SFO had an hour of tarmac delays & these delays weren't made up in the air. HKG-SFO plane had "computer problems" delaying the departure. It was the same plane both times (old config) and the side of the right bathroom mirror was cracked. Cabin seat & bathroom cleanliness was average / acceptable.
Plane Food: Mixed quality. Eat in the lounge instead if you can. SFO-HKG sardine appetizer was very good. Salad good. Vegetarian meal was very good. Pepper steak meal was poor USA outbound, very good USA inbound. Poor dim sum as others have noted, I only tried it on USA outbound. HKG-SFO scallop appetizer was OK. One flights was out of port; the other out of scotch. Wine & Champagne are average $10-$20 bottles.
Plane Comfort: Enjoyed the close couples seating. I had selected seats via HK web chat. Trans-Pac J cabin gets too hot. Dress appropriately. Thin Van Laack PJ bottoms and a t-shirt, with a backup sweater or long-sleeve t-shirt is ideal. Nice blankets and pillows. We had trouble sleeping in the center seats a bit because of the noise created by other passengers. There is probably an art to sleeping on these planes too, by using a combination of seating and sleeping positions throughout the flight. For example, I liked using a combination of the lie-flat and the reclined position.
Plane Service: Service on HKG-SFO was good but a little slow with a very full front cabin. Service on HKG-SFO was very good and the FAs really cared. They haven't figured out how to time food delivery so couples get served simultaneously.
FF: Fortune Points posted 3-days later for first flight and Gold Status match success email received a couple days later.
Being in J on short HKG-PVG both ways greatly appreciated. Coach was fairly full on all segments, and we were exhausted on these flights. The pillows on the short segments are plumper and softer; I enjoyed that i could side-sleep with by Bose over-ears with these pillows. I also really liked the side bulkhead seats on the short segments - they feel more private. The short segments seats aren't lie flat, but they are big and recline far back.
Overall, I am very grateful to HK air for honoring the mistake fair, and I hope to fly them again. While it ain't anywhere near Cathay First, I would choose them over United or BA business class unless I had good reason not to do so.
Last edited by super-mileage-fan; Dec 11, 2018 at 5:37 pm Reason: typos
#879
Join Date: Jan 2018
Posts: 38
I flew LAX - HKG - BKK and back a week ago.
Check in was easy. That 4AM return flight is rough! 3 of my 4 segments were on A350s (old config) then BKK->HKG was on what felt like 90s A330. Very dated 2-2-2 config.
Something interesting happened on my LAX legs both ways. On the way to HKG - some passenger was chatting up the FA in the front galley then little later in the flight sat down next to me (I was K single window seat). He sat in the middle seats and received some meal about an hour before we were served. It smelled awesome and caused me to want food so I ordered a hot in flight snack. Afterwards he disappeared from the biz cabin. Overall he probably spent 30% of the time (that I personally noticed) in biz. When he was chatting with the FA - he mentioned it was a quick trip back to HKG for something or other then he would turn back around and head straight back to the states. Which made me believe he wasnt a FA himself.
Then on my LAX-BKK flight - the seat behind me was empty but mid way through the flight I could feel some kicking around in the footwell compartment that was next to my chair. Turned around and there was this guy getting comfortable there. Again the same thing - hes there for part of the flight - then disappeared!
I was super curious... the first guy got served a meal... so he couldnt have been someone that snuck into biz? The second guy - completely disappeared midway into the flight - I dont think he was served a meal. I've never flown premium class before - but is this all normal?
Check in was easy. That 4AM return flight is rough! 3 of my 4 segments were on A350s (old config) then BKK->HKG was on what felt like 90s A330. Very dated 2-2-2 config.
Something interesting happened on my LAX legs both ways. On the way to HKG - some passenger was chatting up the FA in the front galley then little later in the flight sat down next to me (I was K single window seat). He sat in the middle seats and received some meal about an hour before we were served. It smelled awesome and caused me to want food so I ordered a hot in flight snack. Afterwards he disappeared from the biz cabin. Overall he probably spent 30% of the time (that I personally noticed) in biz. When he was chatting with the FA - he mentioned it was a quick trip back to HKG for something or other then he would turn back around and head straight back to the states. Which made me believe he wasnt a FA himself.
Then on my LAX-BKK flight - the seat behind me was empty but mid way through the flight I could feel some kicking around in the footwell compartment that was next to my chair. Turned around and there was this guy getting comfortable there. Again the same thing - hes there for part of the flight - then disappeared!
I was super curious... the first guy got served a meal... so he couldnt have been someone that snuck into biz? The second guy - completely disappeared midway into the flight - I dont think he was served a meal. I've never flown premium class before - but is this all normal?
#881
Join Date: Nov 2015
Location: YVR
Programs: DL Gold, Hilton Diamond, IHG Diamond, Best Western Diamond Selec
Posts: 537
who asked you? Your check in agent? I find it bizarre as they're with separate alliance.
#882
Join Date: Nov 2015
Location: YVR
Programs: DL Gold, Hilton Diamond, IHG Diamond, Best Western Diamond Selec
Posts: 537
when we apply with the start date, I guess it'd be safe to set a few days prior to the schedule in case there's any involuntary schedule change?
#883
Join Date: Sep 2016
Programs: *A
Posts: 7
the current one the deadline is approaching at the of the month. My trip is in Feb, so I wonder if I should apply for this year's version, or apply next month for next year's version. There's no guarantee we get the same offer or better next month, but it seems annual, the current one came out Jan 15.
when we apply with the start date, I guess it'd be safe to set a few days prior to the schedule in case there's any involuntary schedule change?
when we apply with the start date, I guess it'd be safe to set a few days prior to the schedule in case there's any involuntary schedule change?
They even told me the end date of the challenge based on the starting date.