{Fare Gone} Air France : IST - SJO $2,341 First Class$2,639 RT (mixed Business)
#226
#227
Join Date: Jun 2015
Programs: Delta GM; FB Plat; HHonors Diamond; Hertz PC; National EE
Posts: 190
The say-so of a minimum-wage call-centre agent who is merely reading from your ticket confirmation is no more valid than the originally-provided ticket confirmation.
#228
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,697
You may indeed find such a judge...but that at least concedes that you accept that the airline does not consider itself "outfoxed" by any such ticket-holder having a minimum-wage call-centre employee merely read back to the ticket-holder what has already been put into writing, and is likely to "change its mind" at a later stage.
(This idea that, in such cases, the spoken word is of more value than the written word is frankly preposterous!!! A bit like the German website where selecting a seat and selecting a low-sodium meal is [jokingly] seen as being the way to "protect" such an error-fare booking )
However, the airline would then no doubt find another judge who will agree that, if the contract itself was faulty, the mere utterance of the terms of such contract by a low-grade employee can be interpreted as nothing more than a statement of the contents of that contract, and not as a binding acceptance on behalf of the airline to honour the terms of that contract. The dispute is not over whether such a contract was issued, nor of the terms of such a contract, but whether such a contract can be enforced.
The decision on whether any individual ticket will be cancelled or not will be taken at a much higher level than that of customer-facing employees.
(This idea that, in such cases, the spoken word is of more value than the written word is frankly preposterous!!! A bit like the German website where selecting a seat and selecting a low-sodium meal is [jokingly] seen as being the way to "protect" such an error-fare booking )
However, the airline would then no doubt find another judge who will agree that, if the contract itself was faulty, the mere utterance of the terms of such contract by a low-grade employee can be interpreted as nothing more than a statement of the contents of that contract, and not as a binding acceptance on behalf of the airline to honour the terms of that contract. The dispute is not over whether such a contract was issued, nor of the terms of such a contract, but whether such a contract can be enforced.
The decision on whether any individual ticket will be cancelled or not will be taken at a much higher level than that of customer-facing employees.
Last edited by irishguy28; May 9, 2018 at 10:19 am
#231
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,697
#232
Join Date: Jun 2015
Programs: Delta GM; FB Plat; HHonors Diamond; Hertz PC; National EE
Posts: 190
I don't have a ticket. It's up to the people that bought one to gi to court if they so wish. And the jurisdiction depends on where they are located and through what channel they bought the ticket, not the country of departure.
#233
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,697
Wow. So a court in any country can make a ruling and compel Air France to do something with a ticket that doesn't concern that country in any way (other than the passenger having some link to that country)
I was going to say that the law has gotten very lax all of a sudden, but I guess it must be exactly the opposite! It's good to know that Air France (either in France, or Turkey, or South Africa/Costa Rica/Argentina/etc etc) can now be compelled into a certain action based on a court located in any other territory...
A ruling that is unenforcable isn't worth the paper it's written on (or the tape recording on which the court employee read it to you over the phone )
I was going to say that the law has gotten very lax all of a sudden, but I guess it must be exactly the opposite! It's good to know that Air France (either in France, or Turkey, or South Africa/Costa Rica/Argentina/etc etc) can now be compelled into a certain action based on a court located in any other territory...
A ruling that is unenforcable isn't worth the paper it's written on (or the tape recording on which the court employee read it to you over the phone )
#234
Join Date: Aug 2017
Posts: 8
I personally think that FT should not use the term EF. We search online for the "best offer", and if we spot one we go for it. If an offer is indeed an EF, it is the airlines responsibility to label it as such and deal with the consequences.
#235
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: SJJ/AMS
Posts: 4,647
Indeed.
It all starts with: overblown excitement, praise of various nature to the airline in question with a number of claims that they are looking for a swift cash injection, posters stating that if it doesn't get honoured then it's just a game at the end of the day etc.
It all ends with: EU261 as a first (even if it does not apply) followed by anger towards the airline/the way they have handled it, let's all go to court, I'll never fly them again (as if they could give a toss), class action, Prague Spring II, I'm out-of-pocket now because it's taking them ages to issue a refund, I'll book a BA ticket and send the bill to Air France.
All, needless to say, not necessarily in that particular order.
G
It all starts with: overblown excitement, praise of various nature to the airline in question with a number of claims that they are looking for a swift cash injection, posters stating that if it doesn't get honoured then it's just a game at the end of the day etc.
It all ends with: EU261 as a first (even if it does not apply) followed by anger towards the airline/the way they have handled it, let's all go to court, I'll never fly them again (as if they could give a toss), class action, Prague Spring II, I'm out-of-pocket now because it's taking them ages to issue a refund, I'll book a BA ticket and send the bill to Air France.
All, needless to say, not necessarily in that particular order.
G
#236
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: YUL, GVA, CTS
Programs: Flying Blue Platinum, Milage Plus
Posts: 62
If only it were that simple.
The say-so of a minimum-wage call-centre agent who is merely reading from your ticket confirmation is no more valid than the originally-provided ticket confirmation.
I am not sure why you were lucky last time around, but having a recording of an agent which merely agrees with the later-disputed ticket in no way counts as ammo in such cases.
Otherwise, the motto would be "IMMEDIATELY call the airline", rather than "DON'T call the airline" 😅
The say-so of a minimum-wage call-centre agent who is merely reading from your ticket confirmation is no more valid than the originally-provided ticket confirmation.
I am not sure why you were lucky last time around, but having a recording of an agent which merely agrees with the later-disputed ticket in no way counts as ammo in such cases.
Otherwise, the motto would be "IMMEDIATELY call the airline", rather than "DON'T call the airline" 😅
It was not a random agent, it was an Air France agent (from the Platinum line more over) that was working in his own system, with his own tickets so he must knows how to read a ticket. (Well I hope!)
The fact that he confimed I was on La Premičre means that now they cannot say : it was an online mistake, we wasn’t aware of. They were aware of the price I paid, and the cabin class I was on, and they confirm it. They tried to downgrade me after, I filed a call listening form, and suddenly, 48-72 hours after, my tickets were re-instated.
As an opposite, my second SFO-LHR booking that I made without calling AF was CXXed and I try to get it re-instated, they didn’t want to do anything else that giving a 1000USD voucher.
So see, even if a “minimum-wage-call-centre agent” confirm your ticket class, they (well AF at least) hounour it.
I think the OP will be able to fly his P ticket without battling too much, if it’s AF agent that confirmed his ETKT on the phone and not an agent from any other OTA, of course.
#237
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,697
#238
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: SJJ/AMS
Posts: 4,647
G
#239
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: YUL, GVA, CTS
Programs: Flying Blue Platinum, Milage Plus
Posts: 62
I am just trying to give tricks on how it worked for me. If you don’t want the tips, it’s fine but may be others will. Or may be you’re just sad your wasn’t hounoued...
#240
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: PRG, DRS, VIE
Programs: Marriott Titanium, BA Gold, A3 Gold
Posts: 939
Are you aware that all of the calls with CC are actually automitaically recorded (and also evaulated)?!