FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Midwest (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/midwest-455/)
-   -   BBQ in Chicago (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/midwest/308690-bbq-chicago.html)

wjm7733 Apr 27, 2005 12:32 pm

What a great thread! My family and I are planning a trip from Memphis (arguably the barbeque capital of the World) to Chicago to see the Cubbies play this summer.

I sat down yesterday to think out a plan and at the top of my list wrote "Chicago BBQ."

I am looking forward to perusing this thread for ideas! I'll post our experiences here when we return (not going until late July).

ElmhurstNick Apr 27, 2005 2:11 pm


Originally Posted by wjm7733
What a great thread! My family and I are planning a trip from Memphis (arguably the barbeque capital of the World) to Chicago to see the Cubbies play this summer.

I sat down yesterday to think out a plan and at the top of my list wrote "Chicago BBQ."

I am looking forward to perusing this thread for ideas! I'll post our experiences here when we return (not going until late July).

No! NO!! NO!!!

With all due respect, one does not travel from Memphis to Chicago for great BBQ. That is like traveling from New York to Memphis for a great bagel.

One comes to Chicago to try:
  • Chicago-style Pizza
  • Vienna Hot Dogs
  • Italian Beef
  • Mexican Food (both cheap and expensive)
  • I'm sure I'm missing something...

UAVirgin Apr 27, 2005 2:22 pm


Originally Posted by ElmhurstNick

One comes to Chicago to try:
  • Chicago-style Pizza
  • Vienna Hot Dogs
  • Italian Beef
  • Mexican Food (both cheap and expensive)
  • I'm sure I'm missing something...

I wouldn't put Chicago high on the list for mexican, but that's just me. I would add a good Brat (might have to go up to WI for it).

ILuvParis Apr 27, 2005 4:30 pm


Originally Posted by ElmhurstNick
No! NO!! NO!!!

With all due respect, one does not travel from Memphis to Chicago for great BBQ. That is like traveling from New York to Memphis for a great bagel.

One comes to Chicago to try:
  • Chicago-style Pizza
  • Vienna Hot Dogs
  • Italian Beef
  • Mexican Food (both cheap and expensive)
  • I'm sure I'm missing something...

Maybe they don't want that dry crap! ;)

BTW, normally, visiting Flyertalkers post where they will be eating and invite the locals along! ;) :D

wjm7733 Apr 27, 2005 8:09 pm


Originally Posted by ElmhurstNick
No! NO!! NO!!!

With all due respect, one does not travel from Memphis to Chicago for great BBQ. That is like traveling from New York to Memphis for a great bagel.

One comes to Chicago to try:
  • Chicago-style Pizza
  • Vienna Hot Dogs
  • Italian Beef
  • Mexican Food (both cheap and expensive)
  • I'm sure I'm missing something...

Point well taken!! :) All of the above will be added to the list of must eats. Look for another post from me in late July on where we plan to eat!

glg Apr 27, 2005 9:26 pm


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
I wouldn't put Chicago high on the list for mexican, but that's just me. I would add a good Brat (might have to go up to WI for it).

Not if "Mexican" means Tex-Mex to you, no. But if you want some solid actual Mexican food, like he said, both the cheap (the abundance of taquieras in some of the Mexican 'hoods) and the expensive (Frontera, Ixcapulzalco, I haven't had the opportunity to try Topolobampo yet, but it gets rave reviews) are very good in Chicago.

UAVirgin Apr 27, 2005 9:49 pm


Originally Posted by glg
Not if "Mexican" means Tex-Mex to you, no. But if you want some solid actual Mexican food, like he said, both the cheap (the abundance of taquieras in some of the Mexican 'hoods) and the expensive (Frontera, Ixcapulzalco, I haven't had the opportunity to try Topolobampo yet, but it gets rave reviews) are very good in Chicago.

I wasn't bad mouthing Chicago mexican food. I've had some good Mexican food in Chicago but it's simply not top of mind for me or most people. I've not eaten at the Frontera or Ixc but my impression is that they are more trendy than authentic. I do love Tex-Mex, but that ain't mexican food. I'm talking fresh tamales & tortillas, real carnitas ... I guess I lean more towards the places in the 'hoods'. When I lived in Chicago I thought of deep dish pizza pie, chicago dogs, brats, and places like Berghoff's, and of course many of the BBQ joints talked about in this thread.

Sweet Willie Apr 28, 2005 6:31 am


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
I wasn't bad mouthing Chicago mexican food. I've had some good Mexican food in Chicago but it's simply not top of mind for me or most people.

I find that amazing as Chicago has the 3rd or 4th largest Hispanic population in the US.

What a wealth of great chow all right in front of Chicagoland's noses.

But back to BBQ, had Twin Anchors w/a client from out of town who had heard about them, I then took them to Lem's. While he was not comfortable with the area around Lem's, the way he devoured the rib tips, left no doubt in my mind which ribs he preferred (as well as myself)

ILuvParis Apr 28, 2005 8:26 am


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
I find that amazing as Chicago has the 3rd or 4th largest Hispanic population in the US.

What a wealth of great chow all right in front of Chicagoland's noses.

But back to BBQ, had Twin Anchors w/a client from out of town who had heard about them, I then took them to Lem's. While he was not comfortable with the area around Lem's, the way he devoured the rib tips, left no doubt in my mind which ribs he preferred (as well as myself)

Was this a progressive dinner, Willie? :cool:

Wingman32 May 16, 2005 2:53 pm

Being an addison, il native, I have to say famous dave's can make me pretty happy when i get a barbecue craving.

Though somewhat unconvential, I find that the BBQ chicken or the steaks at Wildfire are among some of the best I've ever had! (Oakbrook & Downtown)

ILuvParis May 16, 2005 4:33 pm


Originally Posted by Wingman32
Being an addison, il native, I have to say famous dave's can make me pretty happy when i get a barbecue craving.

Though somewhat unconvential, I find that the BBQ chicken or the steaks at Wildfire are among some of the best I've ever had! (Oakbrook & Downtown)

I'm a big fan of Wildfire in Schaumburg. I found a dirty fork on the table as we (two of us) were sitting down. The waitress apologized and another thought was not given to it. Were the drinks comped? No. Did we get a free dessert? No. Then entire meal: drinks, appetizers, entrees and desserts all comped. That is class! Good food too!

Sweet Willie Oct 8, 2005 4:18 pm


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
It had been awhile since I’ve had some BBQ, I looked in my 98 page word document of Chicago places to try, out of the BBQ places leaped Honey 1 BBQ.

Only BBQ available on the menu are links, rib tips and ribs.

Links were ehh, so-so.

Ribs were good-very good

By far the best meat was the rib-tips. Deep smokey flavors and a sauce that has a heat quotient that builds up on you. Don’t get me wrong, it is not overly hot, after a few tips I noticed my lips were burning slightly, in a good way. Some of the best tips in Chicago.

Fries as with almost every single BBQ joint in Chicago sucked. For some reason these places can dole out the loving long-term care needed to smoke meats but some quick frying they can’t master. My guess is, they know one doesn’t come for the fries.

Honey 1 BBQ
Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-12am, Sun 12pm-6pm

Honey 1 now has a new location as of late September, they are now located:

Honey 1
2241 N Western
Chicago, IL
773-227-5130

Sweet Willie Oct 8, 2005 4:23 pm


I find that the BBQ chicken or the steaks at Wildfire are among some of the best I've ever had! (Oakbrook & Downtown)
Just a clarification, that isn't BBQ, it is grilled meats with BBQ sauce.
BBQ is using smoke/heat to cook the meat. Not saying that grilled items with BBQ sauce are bad, I and many other people call that BBQ'ing but it really isn't, its grilling w/BBQ sauce added, BIG difference in the taste compared to actual smoke BBQ'ing which is what Honey 1, Lem's, Barbara Ann's and some others (not many in Chicagoland) do.

MANCHESTER Nov 28, 2005 3:54 am


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
Wife and I ate at the Weber Grill Restaurant, 920 N. Milwaukee (just north of Lake-Cook rd.), Wheeling phone: 847.215.0996

Yes it is THE weber grill maker who has opened this restaurant, they also have a location in Lombard at 2331 Fountain Square Drive, phone: 630.953.8880

Real charcoal on a real grill? I'm thinking great eats. Disappointment.

I tried the BBQ Sampler which has ribs (baby back), sausage link, pulled pork and 1/4 chicken.

The ribs were so-so, most people do better at home easily. The sausage link was something you'd buy in the grocery store (fine if I'm cooking, but not when I'm paying some decent $$). Pulled pork had ZERO flavor. The 1/4 chicken was good and very moist, cooked perfect, but then again most can cook chicken on the grill at home.

Wife had the BBQ shrimp/chicken platter. Shrimp were done right (not always easy to do) and again so was the chicken.

We each had one draft beer apiece, the meals and an ok fried calamari appetizer. Bill was $58!! Which was WAY TOO MUCH for food that I can cook better at home.

The manager stated that Weber was going to open other restaurants, but did not say where.


Hi All,

I see the above review is quite old for the Weber Grill. Am in Chicago in Feb & really want to try it.....any improvements been made or is it a real waste of time?

Sweet Willie Nov 28, 2005 7:11 am


Originally Posted by MANCHESTER
Hi All,

I see the above review is quite old for the Weber Grill. Am in Chicago in Feb & really want to try it.....any improvements been made or is it a real waste of time?

We now have a Weber a couple blocks from my office so I have been more than a few times for meals (lunch & dinner). If you at all charcoal grill yourself, Weber is a waste of time and $$$. If you don't grill then you will probably like it. That being said there are many more better tasting and better value restaurants to visit in Chicago before Weber if you have not been to the city in awhile.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:23 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.