What kind of elite status did hotel GM have?
#1
Suspended
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2016
Posts: 319
What kind of elite status did hotel GM have?
I work in hotel business and find that ironically, most of the staff ( say 90%) did not have elite status, they usually stay at their hotel chain by employee rate which means you get the standard room for a cheap price, and of course no SNP. I even hear that Marriott does not encourage their employee to hold Plat status( I heard about this but I can not confirm).
So I am just curious some big shot in a hotel , such as GM or director of blah blah, some of them like to criticize their competitor and feels like they are invincible, but I feel that they probably did not hold status of any kind.
So IF a GM of Marriott A check into another Marriott by employee rate, did he or she automatically get VIP treatment? Or just like everyone else?
When he or she leave his /her hotel and check into another of its sister hotel off duty, did GM automatically get recognized or just like everyone else?
Do you think that most directors or GM of a franchise hotel hold Elite status?
So I am just curious some big shot in a hotel , such as GM or director of blah blah, some of them like to criticize their competitor and feels like they are invincible, but I feel that they probably did not hold status of any kind.
So IF a GM of Marriott A check into another Marriott by employee rate, did he or she automatically get VIP treatment? Or just like everyone else?
When he or she leave his /her hotel and check into another of its sister hotel off duty, did GM automatically get recognized or just like everyone else?
Do you think that most directors or GM of a franchise hotel hold Elite status?
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: IAD/DCA
Posts: 31,797
what?
owners could get starwood "VIP" status, there were threads on that
edit >
actually i dont think most of OP's threads are any different than many other threads here, FT has a lot of comparing brands and programs. and OP is not one of those who claims their their preferred brand / program is the only good one, etc.
owners could get starwood "VIP" status, there were threads on that
edit >
actually i dont think most of OP's threads are any different than many other threads here, FT has a lot of comparing brands and programs. and OP is not one of those who claims their their preferred brand / program is the only good one, etc.
Last edited by Kagehitokiri; Dec 11, 2018 at 12:36 pm
#4
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Aug 2002
Programs: UALifetimePremierGold, Marriott LifetimeTitanium
Posts: 71,107
Half of his post doesn't even make sense/is mixing a variety of things so hard to actually respond.
But then again, on a scale of 1-100, whether a GM has Plat status probably falls closer to the 1 category for me in terms of do I even care.
Cheers.
But then again, on a scale of 1-100, whether a GM has Plat status probably falls closer to the 1 category for me in terms of do I even care.
Cheers.
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: BOS/UTH
Programs: AA LT PLT; QR GLD; Bonvoy LT TIT
Posts: 12,753
I would guess no, but it's just a guess. I have absolutely no supporting, or even relevant, data.
#6
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Harrisburg, PA / Savannah, GA (when home!)
Programs: DL-Diamond; UA-Silver (moan); Hilton-DIA; Marriott-PPE; IHG-Plat; NC-Exec Elite
Posts: 553
this thread sucks. who cares, but if I was a GM and wanted something special, I'd probably just e-mail the GM at the property I was going to be staying
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: South Florida
Programs: AA LTG (EXP), Hilton Silver (Dia), Marriott LTP (PP), SPG LTG (P) > MPG LTPP
Posts: 11,329
I work in hotel business and find that ironically, most of the staff ( say 90%) did not have elite status, they usually stay at their hotel chain by employee rate which means you get the standard room for a cheap price, and of course no SNP. I even hear that Marriott does not encourage their employee to hold Plat status( I heard about this but I can not confirm).
So I am just curious some big shot in a hotel , such as GM or director of blah blah, some of them like to criticize their competitor and feels like they are invincible, but I feel that they probably did not hold status of any kind.
So IF a GM of Marriott A check into another Marriott by employee rate, did he or she automatically get VIP treatment? Or just like everyone else?
When he or she leave his /her hotel and check into another of its sister hotel off duty, did GM automatically get recognized or just like everyone else?
Do you think that most directors or GM of a franchise hotel hold Elite status?
So I am just curious some big shot in a hotel , such as GM or director of blah blah, some of them like to criticize their competitor and feels like they are invincible, but I feel that they probably did not hold status of any kind.
So IF a GM of Marriott A check into another Marriott by employee rate, did he or she automatically get VIP treatment? Or just like everyone else?
When he or she leave his /her hotel and check into another of its sister hotel off duty, did GM automatically get recognized or just like everyone else?
Do you think that most directors or GM of a franchise hotel hold Elite status?
As side note, I did have a stay a few years ago and apparently an employee had the room before me and left his folio behind. It showed a very nice discounted rate and turned out to be someone I knew from a prior life!!! Both of us had moved on to other things, but shows you never know what's across that next bridge.
#8
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Denver, CO
Programs: Delta GM, Delta Amex Plat,
Posts: 148
Associate rates don't earn any elite nights or points. Unless your the GM of a large resort or convention center-type property, there is minimal business travel involved.
I would say the generally accepted practice in the industry is the take care (upgrades, amenities, etc.) of other associates when at all possible with the understanding that they the hotel will accommodate all other Elite members, VIPs, etc. first. Case in point, I was once upgraded some unbelievable corner suite overlooking Times Square at the Marriott Marquis the weekend after NYE when they were like 17% staying on the associate rate (paying like $60/night). Some months later I returned to the same hotel, checked in w/ the same FDM and was told all they had was a handicap-accessible double queen room (i booked/wanted a King) with a terrific view of some dumpsters. You win some, you lose some.
If it was a real special trip (birthday, anniversary, etc.) I would email ahead. I proposed to my wife in SF and was staying at the RC. I had emailed ahead to let them know and they went out of their way to make it special for us, even though we weren't able to have an upgrade or anything else as there was a massive Indian wedding happening the same weekend.
Just my experience as a GM, albeit pre-merger. Not sure how much has changed in the past few years...
I would say the generally accepted practice in the industry is the take care (upgrades, amenities, etc.) of other associates when at all possible with the understanding that they the hotel will accommodate all other Elite members, VIPs, etc. first. Case in point, I was once upgraded some unbelievable corner suite overlooking Times Square at the Marriott Marquis the weekend after NYE when they were like 17% staying on the associate rate (paying like $60/night). Some months later I returned to the same hotel, checked in w/ the same FDM and was told all they had was a handicap-accessible double queen room (i booked/wanted a King) with a terrific view of some dumpsters. You win some, you lose some.
If it was a real special trip (birthday, anniversary, etc.) I would email ahead. I proposed to my wife in SF and was staying at the RC. I had emailed ahead to let them know and they went out of their way to make it special for us, even though we weren't able to have an upgrade or anything else as there was a massive Indian wedding happening the same weekend.
Just my experience as a GM, albeit pre-merger. Not sure how much has changed in the past few years...
#9
Used to be bulldoggolfer05
Join Date: May 2007
Location: São Paulo, BR/Miami Beach, FL/NYC/DXB
Programs: HGP DMD, HHonors DMD, SPG PLT, MR PLT
Posts: 2,295
Marriott employees are not allowed to maintain a Marriott Rewards account therefore per the T&C of the program, it is impossible for a General Manager to have any status at all.
In real world practice though, it is possible for a General Manager to earn status the same way any other member does but if Marriott Rewards makes the connection between the employee and the account, they can close the account and revoke any status/points.
I was a [legacy] Gold member prior to taking a brief job (less than six months) with Marriott a number of years back. Stays on the Associate Rate [AR] were never booked under my account, but if the AR was unavailable or not significantly lower than publicly available rates, I would book under my MR account to receive elite benefits and status. Ultimately I ended up graduating to Platinum status but when Marriott Rewards connected my account with my employment shortly before I left the company (not for this reason), they emailed me quoting the T&C, clawed back the stays and points, and dropped my status back to Gold
In real world practice though, it is possible for a General Manager to earn status the same way any other member does but if Marriott Rewards makes the connection between the employee and the account, they can close the account and revoke any status/points.
I was a [legacy] Gold member prior to taking a brief job (less than six months) with Marriott a number of years back. Stays on the Associate Rate [AR] were never booked under my account, but if the AR was unavailable or not significantly lower than publicly available rates, I would book under my MR account to receive elite benefits and status. Ultimately I ended up graduating to Platinum status but when Marriott Rewards connected my account with my employment shortly before I left the company (not for this reason), they emailed me quoting the T&C, clawed back the stays and points, and dropped my status back to Gold
#10
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: ANC
Programs: AS (75K+ miles flown) | Marriott Rewards | MLife Sapphire | Identity Silver | Hertz Gold Plus |
Posts: 209
Marriott employees are not allowed to maintain a Marriott Rewards account therefore per the T&C of the program, it is impossible for a General Manager to have any status at all.
In real world practice though, it is possible for a General Manager to earn status the same way any other member does but if Marriott Rewards makes the connection between the employee and the account, they can close the account and revoke any status/points.
I was a [legacy] Gold member prior to taking a brief job (less than six months) with Marriott a number of years back. Stays on the Associate Rate [AR] were never booked under my account, but if the AR was unavailable or not significantly lower than publicly available rates, I would book under my MR account to receive elite benefits and status. Ultimately I ended up graduating to Platinum status but when Marriott Rewards connected my account with my employment shortly before I left the company (not for this reason), they emailed me quoting the T&C, clawed back the stays and points, and dropped my status back to Gold
In real world practice though, it is possible for a General Manager to earn status the same way any other member does but if Marriott Rewards makes the connection between the employee and the account, they can close the account and revoke any status/points.
I was a [legacy] Gold member prior to taking a brief job (less than six months) with Marriott a number of years back. Stays on the Associate Rate [AR] were never booked under my account, but if the AR was unavailable or not significantly lower than publicly available rates, I would book under my MR account to receive elite benefits and status. Ultimately I ended up graduating to Platinum status but when Marriott Rewards connected my account with my employment shortly before I left the company (not for this reason), they emailed me quoting the T&C, clawed back the stays and points, and dropped my status back to Gold