How much revenue lost due to sudden drop in gift card sales?
#1
How much revenue lost due to sudden drop in gift card sales?
Just think of the loss the companies like Blackhawk will take due to countless GC buyers suddenly halting their purchases. Any estimates on lost revenues? I know there are other avenues of MS but Amex BB and Serve were the most utilized due to lowest fees and convenience (Walmart and online loads). any thoughts?
#2
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 102
The opposite may be true... with much less customers that drain their gift cards completely and quickly, and thus the majority of cards being sold for <$200 much less as gifts, balances on the cards presumably will be higher and thus the companies will presumably profit from the interest on the card balances.
#3
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: WI
Posts: 181
The opposite may be true... with much less customers that drain their gift cards completely and quickly, and thus the majority of cards being sold for <$200 much less as gifts, balances on the cards presumably will be higher and thus the companies will presumably profit from the interest on the card balances.
#8
Join Date: Jul 2013
Posts: 1,036
#9
Our stores in central Ohio are always stocked with VGC and MGC. I know many people who got shut down today who will not be buying anymore GCs for MS. Serve and BB was just too easy and profitable compared to other avenues. Simon malls was one of my favs. I bet those receptionists are going to be selling much less GCs now. Oh well, the hard core MSers will find a way but meanwhile the sales will drop IMO. Hope that means more deals on GCs this year. We shall see.
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: IAH
Programs: DL DM, Hyatt Ist-iest, Stariott Platinum, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 12,784
I can't imagine us buying $500 VGCs was ever profitable for them. Even if you assume they kept the whole $4.95/5.95 purchase fee, and assumed the low end 2% swipe fee, the CC swipe would cost them $10.12 and they lose a few bucks per swipe. I'm sure that's why many grocery stores don't accept credit cards for large VGC transactions at all.
#12
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 197
Was thinking a similar thing, the other businesses that are part of the GC piece and the potential impacts.
Grocery Stores / Office Stores etc - GC purchase amount, foot traffic, other purchases while being in the store.
GC Bank Issuers - Activation fees and other associated fees depending on use
Walmart - If nothing else foot traffic into the store (potential for other sales) plus processing and card swipes.
Amex - Membership base plus loss of Serve/Bluebird etc using accounts for legitimate bill pay and or other services. Also knock on customer loyalty impact for other Amex services/products. A lot of talk across the threads about this. Also not good when you also tack on the amount of business they have lost recently (partnerships etc).
Not an exhaustive list I know and am sure I am missing some of the other key elements but was just a thought when looking at the impacts that this move by Amex could have.
There's also the thought about rewards cards and other signups. We all know that for the truly dedicated there will always be a way to maximize but with avenues drying up, fees for those remaining increasing (2-3% for CC bill pay service providers) and rewards not going as far (mileage for tickets increasing on most airlines through devaluation) it will be interesting to see what the 2016 portfolio of CC products and offerings looks like
WC
Grocery Stores / Office Stores etc - GC purchase amount, foot traffic, other purchases while being in the store.
GC Bank Issuers - Activation fees and other associated fees depending on use
Walmart - If nothing else foot traffic into the store (potential for other sales) plus processing and card swipes.
Amex - Membership base plus loss of Serve/Bluebird etc using accounts for legitimate bill pay and or other services. Also knock on customer loyalty impact for other Amex services/products. A lot of talk across the threads about this. Also not good when you also tack on the amount of business they have lost recently (partnerships etc).
Not an exhaustive list I know and am sure I am missing some of the other key elements but was just a thought when looking at the impacts that this move by Amex could have.
There's also the thought about rewards cards and other signups. We all know that for the truly dedicated there will always be a way to maximize but with avenues drying up, fees for those remaining increasing (2-3% for CC bill pay service providers) and rewards not going as far (mileage for tickets increasing on most airlines through devaluation) it will be interesting to see what the 2016 portfolio of CC products and offerings looks like
WC
#13
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
This was a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of the business net revenue. But, it was filled with AML risk and hassle. Not one part of the business chain will lose a nickel on this. People still need groceries.
#14
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 197
Agreed but think its interesting to look at the potential for impact, no matter how small, the decision AMEX made today can have across those other areas. People do still need groceries but not $200 groceries plus $500 GC for total transaction of $700 per visit
#15
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: S Cal
Programs: AA Lifetime Plat, United Silver, Marriott Plat, IHG Plat
Posts: 1,142
The US stock market is way down so far this year, and that's before AmEx dropped the hammer on us. I doubt anyone on CNBC mentioned Serve when they discussed why the stock market was down again today.