Go Back  FlyerTalk Forums > Travel&Dining > Luxury Hotels and Travel
Reload this Page >

New Zealand Luxury Hotels - trip report (part I)

New Zealand Luxury Hotels - trip report (part I)

Old May 10, 09, 9:56 pm
  #1  
Original Poster
Four Seasons Contributor Badge
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Asheville, NC
Programs: Virtuoso, FSPP, STARS, MO FAN Club, PEN Club, Bellini Club, Dorchester Diamond Club, Travel Leaders
Posts: 1,844
New Zealand Luxury Hotels - trip report (part I)

I just returned from a 12 day trip to New Zealand during which I stayed in a number of luxury hotels and had site inspections of others. I want to share my impressions ó but in light of some responses that have been made to prior trip reports, I want to offer this disclaimer: this is just my own, personal opinion of the the hotels. Others may very well come to different conclusions, which is as it should be. I cannot pretend to judge the service that guests will receive as (obviously) hotel managers will go out of their way to impress travel agents.

I have been asked: Whatís the best place to stay in New Zealand? on a number of occasions. After spending twelve nights in this beautiful country, my respectful response is ... thatís the wrong question to ask. New Zealand is a country roughly the size of Colorado with an incredible variety of things to see and do. Begin with this question: what kind of experience do you want to have in New Zealand?
  • Do you want to see incredible alpine beauty?
  • Do you want to visit wineries?
  • Do you enjoy fly fishing or hunting?
  • Are you into adventure travel ó (e.g., hiking or trekking)?
  • Do you go for activities that give you an adrenaline rush (e.g., bungy jumping)?
  • Are you a golfer?
  • Will your budget permit touring or transferring by helicopter?
  • Do you want to self-drive throughout this country of two-lane roads or arrange for private drivers who know the attractions of New Zealand intimately and can save you from having to search out many of the secluded properties and attractions?
Answering questions like these will enable you to develop an itinerary that will provide you with a great trip. No matter where you want to go in New Zealand, there are luxury hotels that would appeal to discriminating FlyerTalk travelers.

Some basic geography


SOUTH ISLAND. New Zealand has two major islands. The South Island is sparsely populated with most of its residents living in Christchurch. Come here for the incredible alpine scenery. Milford Sound is the most famous attraction, but Iím told that Doubtful Sound has less tourists but is just as wonderful. Near Queenstown is the original Bungy Jump site in New Zealand.

NORTH ISLAND. The North Island is the more populous island, but outside of Auckland, thereís really not much population. Come here if you are interested in Mauri culture. Wellington in the south is the nationís capital city; its beautiful Museum of New Zealand is a contemporary building with a fabulous exhibit of Maori culture - and free admission.

The Hawkeís Bay region has some of the finest wineries of New Zealand. The Art Deco city of Napier is worth a visit with a guided tour.

Driving north, Lake Taupo is a recreational area in the center of the North Island with opportunities for fishing and boating.

Further north, Lake Rotorua is a popular tourist area with a beautiful lake and some interesting tourist experiences. Kiwi Encounter is an interesting educational experience about the Kiwi, New Zealandís national bird whose survival is endangered. Kiwi eggs are gathered and brought here where the eggs are incubated and the chicks raised to maturity before releasing them into safe habitats. The earthís crust is thin here, and you can witness a lot of geo-thermal springs bubbling to the surface or visit the crater of an extinct volcano.

Auckland is New Zealandís largest city. Youíll fly into Auckland if coming from the United States (there are direct flights into a number of different NZ destinations from Australia) but you donít necessarily need to spend any time in Auckland. Itís a very pleasant city that reminds me of Vancouver, BC. The Auckland War Memorial Museum has a good display of Mauri culture.

(to be continued)
DavidO is offline  
Old May 10, 09, 10:00 pm
  #2  
Original Poster
Four Seasons Contributor Badge
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Asheville, NC
Programs: Virtuoso, FSPP, STARS, MO FAN Club, PEN Club, Bellini Club, Dorchester Diamond Club, Travel Leaders
Posts: 1,844
New Zealand Luxury Hotels - trip report (part II)

Where to stay


Once you’ve determined what kind of New Zealand experience you’d like to have and figured out your destinations, here are some thoughts on where to stay.

The Virginia Fischer lodges. Five of New Zealand’s luxury lodges were designed by Virginia Fischer, and there’s a rather interesting story behind this fact. 25 years ago, the owner and developer of the yet-to-be-built Huka Lodge was having trouble finding the right individual to design the interior of his lodge. He met Virginia in a totally non-business context. In the course of talking about his lodge and his vision for it, Virginia offered to take on the job. Though she was not a professional interior designer at the time, he took a chance with her, and the rest is history. I like her design style very much. She creates large, bright, airy spaces using a lot of wood (floors, walls, ceilings, and exposed beams) while making creative use of different textures and colors. Her bathrooms are large with double vanities, walk-in showers, and “bathtubs with a view.”

Huka Lodge, Taupo. The essence of Huka Lodge is experienced sitting in the Main Lodge — a large, comfortable lounge with sofas, a cozy fire, green pattered carpeting, and big picture windows overlooking the Waikato River. Guests gather in this supremely beautiful setting at any time of day and for drinks and canapes before dinner.

Situated just 300 meters from Huka Falls, Huka Lodge offers luxurious accommodations and great food. Of the 20 suites along the river, four have gas fireplaces, and each offers with a view across the lawn down to the river and the forest beyond. Huka Lodge has access to a vast variety of outdoor activities from fly fishing, hiking, golf, horseback riding, water sports on Lake Taupo, winetasting, and sightseeing. (Although it is central to a lot of activities, there is a bit of a drive to many of them.)

Wharekauhau Lodge, near Wellington, pronounced fah-ree-ko-ho, is located near Wellington, the capital city of New Zealand — either a 7 minute flight by small plane to the lodge’s private airstrip or a 90 drive over the mountains. The estate is on a working farm and was constructed a decade ago. The main Lodge building features large sitting rooms, a dining room, and a breakfast room right in the kitchen, and the guest cottages are scattered through the property, most with beautiful water views. Each cottage offers canopied king beds, a large sitting area in front of a gas fireplace, large dressing room, and a large bathroom (with two colors of beautiful limestone) with soaking tub overlooking the water, step-in shower, and twin vanities. The interiors feature painted T-111 paneling, rough hewn beams, glossy painted trim, with wonderful colors and fabrics in a range from off-white to ivory to peach and tan. The tariff includes breakfast and a five-course tasting menu, and our meal was superb ... highlighted by one of the most wonderful chocolate desserts I have ever experienced. By all means, take advantage of the tour of the farm offered by the Lodge. Especially interesting to me was the opportunity to watch the sheep dogs herding sheep.

Kauri Cliffs, Bay of Islands. Located near Kerikeri, you can either drive or take a short 45 minute flight from Auckland via a very small, 20 passenger plane. Although arriving at this property at nearly the same time as a tropical cyclone boasting wind gusts over 65 mph, my enthusiasm for this property is not dampened. Golf is the major reason to stay here; the property features one of Golf Digest’s top 50 courses of the world. Fifteen holes offer views of the Pacific Ocean, and six holes are played alongside cliffs that plunge into the sea. There are three beaches available to guests; the best swimming is at Waiaua Beach with its fine, white sand. Guest suites are spacious, a minimum of 840 square feet, with stunning views of the Pacific from both the bedroom and soaking tub, and a gas fireplace in each suite. The tarriff includes a breakfast and a three-course dinner.

The Farm at Cape Kidnappers, near Napier, is the sister property of Kauri Cliffs. The buildings are designed with a farm motif. The golf shop, for instance, resembles a large barn - and in the guest rooms, the door between the bedroom and the bathroom resembles a sliding barn door. Rooms are large and comfortable with the softest, silkiest Frette sheets and plumpest, cuddliest towels I have ever encountered. I was in a Ridge Suite with a great view of the Pacific Ocean and the lights of Napier beyond the bay. The three-course dinners were excellent as was the cooked-to-order breakfast, both of which are included in the daily tariff. This is a very large property with a spectacularly beautiful golf course, rated one of the top courses in the world.

Eichardt’s Private Hotel, Queenstown, was recently renovated by Virginia Fischer. The rooms are a traditional “country” style with a contemporary touch. However, she had to work with existing spaces in an old building. The Lakefront suite that I was shown had a strange layout, the room being too long and narrow for my taste. The sitting area had windows and a patio door overlooking the lake, but the sleeping area was farther back in the room, away from the windows (somewhat like the layout of the Garden Wing rooms of the Oriental Bangkok). If you want lakeviews from your room in Queenstown, this is your choice, but I feel that The Spire is the best luxury option in Queenstown.


Queenstown. Flying into Queenstown was one of the highlights of my trip, a fitting introduction to this stunningly beautiful corner of the world. The Air New Zealand 737 flew through a mountain valleys, banking to the right over the lake, and descending through another mountain valley to the runway.

The Spire Hotel is a small boutique luxury hotel with only 10 rooms. My room, really a suite, was spacious with a large patio overlooking the village church. Beautiful contemporary interior design featured a very comfortable Eames reading chair facing a gas fireplace and the immense wall-mounted Panasonic plasma TV. The room had the latest in electronics, all controlled by a high-tech remote control that completely baffled me! The room had a gas fireplace, a large dressing area, a large bathroom with soaking tub, walk-in shower, and dual vanities. The Spire is upscale, visually appealing, and will not disappoint. Rates include breakfast, free internet, and free airport transfers. The hotel prides itself on great service; the manager is always ready to recommend the best places to eat and shop (and to drive guests there), and the hotel’s own dining room is superb.

Eichardt’s Private Hotel is the Virtuoso hotel in Queenstown, and it is all about the view. See my review above. However, definitely come here for lunch. The Seafood Chowder came with a well-deserved reputation. A cream-based chowder with some cheese, it was chock-full of seafood — mussels, clams, scallops, prawns, calamari, and chunks of fish I can’t name — and was absolutely wonderful.


The Sofitel offers what guests have come to expect from this chain, solid 4-star rooms with a French flair. The lead-in Superior rooms offer good space and attractive furnishings. The attractive bathrooms have tubs, separate walk-in showers, and a single vanity. The Sofitel Suite is spacious, and the Penthouse a real WOW. There is not much of a view from the rooms; the lakeview rooms offer just a “peak” at the lake. The lobby was plain and non-descript, no natural light, and not a welcoming place to gather.

Hotel St. Moritz describes itself as 5-star, but that’s not what I saw. The property offers good value, especially for families, and the lakeview rooms provide a very nice view. The rooms are in need of a soft goods renovation - new furniture and more upscale decorations. However, they do offer good space at a reasonable price. Suites, in addition to sleeping 4, provide washer-dryers, mini-fridges, a cooking surface and microwave - and connect to separate bedrooms, creating a true two bedroom Suite.

Blanket Bay is an absolutely wonderful property. Celebrating its 10th anniversary, the hotel is situated directly on Lake Wakatipu with no other resorts anywhere in sight. Come here to enjoy the scenery and enjoy the splendid isolation. The rooms are large and comfortable, and bathrooms all feature tubs, walk-in showers, and dual vanities. The best rooms in the hotel, the suites at either corner of the top floor, provide corner views of the lake and mountains. The Chalet Suites also provide great lake views and, with a connecting living room between two guestrooms, offer a great option for families. Free internet, a great recreation room with pool table and shuffleboard table, free minibar (everything except hard liquor) are included in the rates. A very romantic destination — and if you want to surprise someone with a proposal, reserve the private “wine cellar,” for a romantic, candlelit dinner.

In and around Christchurch

Otahuna Lodge. Let’s start with one of the most charming properties in New Zealand. Located about 30 minutes from downtown Christchurch, Otahuna Lodge is a large, comfortable home that has been converted into an exquisite luxury lodge. When it was built in 1894, it was the largest private residence in New Zealand. Recognized as an architectural icon with a place on the Historic Places Trust, this Queen Anne style residence was purchased by its current owners who have lovingly created one of the most comfortable lodges I have ever seen. Every room is unique, and the Master Suites are especially attractive. The room rate includes a 5 course tasting meal, with each course paired with wines. As much as possible, the produce used for meals are grown in the lodge’s own organic vegetable garden. The staff are warm and hospitable, a culture that begins with the owners. You’ll especially enjoy the chef, Jimmy, and ask for a tour of the garden as well! Come to Otahuna to relax, to commune with nature, to fish, and as a base from which to explore the sights of the Canterbury region of New Zealand.

The George, Christchurch, is a member of the Small Luxury Hotel collection and the nicest hotel in the city. A boutique hotel (53 rooms) with a great location right by Victoria Square, guests enter through a unassuming yet comfortable lobby. The hotel will be closed during the month of August in order to complete a soft goods renovation of floors 1-3. We saw some rooms on floor 4 with the new interior design that is coming next fall. The attractively decorated lead-in Executive Rooms are fairly small, what one would associate with a Superior room category; the room we were shown had just a tub with shower. Most guests would prefer one of only 4 Junior Suites which were about the size I would normally associate with a Deluxe room. If you stay here, ask to be blocked in a Junior Suite with a view of the Square. The Park Suites are corner rooms, large and bright with a great view of the Park.

In and around Wellington

See review of Wharekauhau Lodge above.

In and around Napier (Hawke’s Bay)

See review of Cape Kidnappers above.

Greenhill Lodge is an intimate, 7-room lodge in the heart of the Hawke’s Bay region, the Napa Valley of New Zealand. An historic Victorian house on a hilltop overlooking farms and grazing land, the beautifully renovated estate offers comfortable accommodations for guests wanting wine tours. The lodge offers the ambiance of an elegant B&B, and if the canapes we tasted are any indication, you’ll enjoy their ŗ la carte breakfasts and four-course dinners. Although the three rooms, three suites, and separate villa are more modest in size than many of the properties reviewed here, this is still an excellent choice for guests. A beautiful property in a wonderful setting, all at a reasonable price-point. Ask as well about their “Behind the Label” wine experience hosted by an accomplished enologist who can arrange for exclusive visits to many excellent vineyards. Guests receive free greens fees at Hastings Golf Club in Bridge Pa, rated on of NZ’s top ten courses.

In and around Taupo

See review of Huka Lodge above.

In and around Rotorua

Treetops Lodge is located 20 minutes from Rotorua and is an unique property offering an eco-wilderness adventure with every possible luxury. The lodge is in the midst of thousands of acres owned by Treetops. Come here to fish, to explore nature, or simply to enjoy a retreat away from the fast-paced world. Come also to experience the Maori culture of New Zealand; we were greeted in the Maori language by a member of the hotel’s staff (all staff members are native to New Zealand). Rated Travel + Leisure’s #1 resort in New Zealand, rooms at Treetops Lodge are large and comfortable — baths all have dual vanities and walk-in showers — and the Villas are exceptionally beautiful, large, high-ceilinged rooms with gorgeous views looking out on Treetop’s property (2,500 acres). There is a special emphasis here on ecological responsibility; all wood and stone used in the construction of the property came from the grounds of Treetops. 100% of their power is hydro-electric, derived from waterfalls on the property, and Treetops even sell excess electricity back to the utility. Organic vegetable and meats are used for meals, and all are raised on the property. Springs provide the resort’s water. Lead-in suites are surprisingly affordable, especially in the off-season.

Peppers on the Point is right on Lake Rotorua. Originally the lakeside home of a very wealthy family, it has been converted into a small boutique hotel that retains the style of the era in which it was built. We received an exceptionally warm welcome. Rooms are large with direct views of the lake and old antique furnishings. Bathrooms feature not only large jacuzzi soaking tubs but also massaging showers. The hotel has just constructed a chapel which would be a great site for a wedding or recommitment ceremony. On the Point is the best restaurant in Rotorua, a good possibility for a romantic dinner for two.

Auckland

The Westin Auckland Lighter Quay. I spent one night at this hotel located in the harbour area in downtown Auckland. With beautiful contemporary architecture, the hotel lobby is especially attractive in the evening when lit by candles that reflect off the black marble floors and glass walls. My Deluxe guestroom (SPG Gold upgrade) was large and decorated in a somewhat minimalist style in shades of tan, beige, and black. The hotel charges 25 NZD nightly for internet, but the connection was fast and reliable; my Skype call to the US was crystal clear. Impressive bathroom with large soaking tub, glass-enclosed step-in rain shower with excellent water pressure, but only one vanity. This is convenient location from which to tour Auckland; you are a short walk from the harbour with its many restaurants.

Mollies. Mollies is the archetypical boutique hotel. If what you want in Auckland is a large, comfortable hotel room, a convenient location, and an efficient concierge desk, book the Westin. But if you want an unique and quite personal experience, consider Mollies. This hotel was originally built for the first Mayor of Auckland. It was converted into a boarding house, and then a hotel, by Molly, the mother of the current owner, Frances Wilson - a noted opera coach. The hotel is decorated with antiques, and the wall treatment is Venetian plaster.

Staying at Mollies is an event. Guests mingle for cocktails and canapes every evening at 6:30 in the drawing room and enjoy a brief, extremely well-done operatic performance at 7:30. I’m not a particular fan of opera, but this was enjoyable — short and sweet with classic opera pieces that should be familiar to most. The setting is conducive to conversation between guests, and you will get to know some interesting and sophisticated fellow travelers.

My Junior Suite at Mollies was everything I would expect from that room category. I had a comfortably sized corner room with a separate sitting area and a small balcony. The room had all the expected amenities, and the bathroom was large with a double vanity, jacuzzi tub, and a very large walk-in shower. From April through December, Virtuoso guests are virtually guaranteed upgrades to a Villa (suite). The top room category is a Premium Villa which are larger, feature great views, and have baby grand pianos in the room; the most requested room is #8.

Last edited by DavidO; May 10, 09 at 10:20 pm
DavidO is offline  
Old May 10, 09, 11:08 pm
  #3  
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Sydney
Programs: MH(Gold) QF CX(Diamond)
Posts: 556
Thank you. Very helpful info as we're heading to Queenstown in October.
Ozchinois is offline  
Old May 11, 09, 8:47 am
  #4  
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Here there and everywhere
Posts: 6,301
Fascinating report, David. I completely agree about Otahuna Lodge (my favourite), Kauri Cliffs and Cap Kidnappers, but Treetops is terribly tired, albeit well-meaning. I don't think you can recommend this for high-end guests here anymore.
vuittonsofstyle is offline  
Old May 11, 09, 7:28 pm
  #5  
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 102
Wharekauhau is fabulous. The food, the staff, the grounds, the region... what a dream. Oh to be back there right now... p.
patricksw is offline  
Old May 11, 09, 7:30 pm
  #6  
CMV
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Arlington, VA
Programs: BA Gold, Delta Gold, UA Gold
Posts: 386
Originally Posted by vuittonsofstyle View Post
Fascinating report, David. I completely agree about Otahuna Lodge (my favourite), Kauri Cliffs and Cap Kidnappers, but Treetops is terribly tired, albeit well-meaning. I don't think you can recommend this for high-end guests here anymore.
I respectfully disagree. We stayed in the Lakeview Villa in late 2007 and had an amazing stay. Service that anticipated our needs, was warm, gracious and not intrusive. Very good food, the vast majority sourced locally or from on-site. Beautiful accommodations -- we had a wonderful view of the forest and lake below, a wood burning fireplace with a fire built daily for us, comfortable bed and large sitting room. We also had various 'surprises' that made the stay even more fun -- the sweets in our room one day when we returned (from a long hike, if I recall correctly), the homemade charcuterie the chef was experimenting with and offered to us. There are others I'm forgetting. We also enjoyed hiking the grounds and taking a ride in the Range Rover to see wildlife, etc. I also think the main lodging, built around and incorporating the existing water on the property, is stunning.

I'm curious why you think it's tired, vuittonsofstyle?

And thank you, David, for another great report.
CMV is offline  
Old May 11, 09, 8:59 pm
  #7  
Ambassador: Emirates Airlines
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 17,305
Another place to try in New Zealand :-

http://eaglesnest.co.nz/

About 3 hours north of Auckland.

Cheers,
Rick
DYKWIA is offline  
Old May 13, 09, 6:08 pm
  #8  
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: SW WA
Posts: 3,582
I can also heartily recommend Grasmere Lodge, which is 90 minutes from Christchurch, up in the mountains as you approach Arthurs Pass. The scenery is stunning, service & food top notch, and the room we had was beyond fantastic (we stayed in the Riverview Cottage). ^

Included in our stay was an excellent tour of the local area on our first day, which included a very light trek to see salmon spawning and other natural sights. The next day we had a tour of the working farm (we paid an extra supplement for this), which included a sheepdog exhibition and a sheep shearing demonstration. We got to feed some of the sheep, which I found to be a highlight. Graeme, the resident nature guide, is extremely knowledgeable about both the local flora and fauna and also the workings of sheep farming. Tom, the owner and manager, is an affable guy who joins the guests for pre-dinner drinks and is himself a wealth of knowledge about other NZ luxury lodges.

All in all, highly recommended.
Buster is offline  
Old May 14, 09, 9:53 am
  #9  
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Here there and everywhere
Posts: 6,301
[QUOTE=CMV;11732784]I respectfully disagree. We stayed in the Lakeview Villa in late 2007 and had an amazing stay. Service that anticipated our needs, was warm, gracious and not intrusive. Very good food, the vast majority sourced locally or from on-site. Beautiful accommodations -- we had a wonderful view of the forest and lake below, a wood burning fireplace with a fire built daily for us, comfortable bed and large sitting room. We also had various 'surprises' that made the stay even more fun -- the sweets in our room one day when we returned (from a long hike, if I recall correctly), the homemade charcuterie the chef was experimenting with and offered to us. There are others I'm forgetting. We also enjoyed hiking the grounds and taking a ride in the Range Rover to see wildlife, etc. I also think the main lodging, built around and incorporating the existing water on the property, is stunning.

I'm curious why you think it's tired, vuittonsofstyle?

Also there in 2007 and thought the land was paradise and the concept laudable. Despite the very good mood lighting, I thought the rooms and suites could do with an up-date as ours was quite dingy, the TV was old, sofa needed replacing and fridge had seen better days. Wardrobes were too small and badly thought through. Food was superb. Service was patchy but always friendly. Friends of mine have been there since and underlined what I thought - wonderful place but needs a bit of work on the interiors.
vuittonsofstyle is offline  
Old Jan 2, 10, 5:54 pm
  #10  
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 1
A bit out of the way but I can recommend Summer Spring Luxury Lodge in Golden Bayhttp://www.summerspring.co.nz, A really great accommodation, more luxury because of location and seclusion. Beautiful area and well worth the drive to get to.
pwhittaker is offline  
Old Jan 4, 10, 1:03 am
  #11  
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 125
Regarding Huka Lodge, having stayed there a few years ago, all I can say is it was underwhelming...our room got destroyed by 2 30 meters trees while we were sleeping -hard to say if we're lucky to be alive or unlucky to have something like that happening to us, either way, staff reaction wasn't exactly as expected...
Nice settings though, but beware of those trees
gougoul is offline  
Old Jun 14, 10, 1:21 pm
  #12  
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: The road less traveled
Programs: UA Gold MM, AA Gold, Marriott Titanium, HHonors Diamond, Natl Emerald EE, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 5,012
Thanks for this. As I'm planning my honeymoon in the South Island, this has been incredibly helpful. Perhaps this is a silly question ... but for the rates charged (upwards of NZ$1,000 for a couple per night), did you feel like you were getting your money's worth? That's about US$700/night, which puts these properties at much higher rates than even some of the top luxury hotels in the world. Even if you figure US$200-$300 for dinner (and it doesn't sound like the quality of the food is at that level), US$500/night for a room+breakfast seems quite steep for me.
JohnnyP is offline  
Old Jun 14, 10, 3:28 pm
  #13  
Original Poster
Four Seasons Contributor Badge
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Asheville, NC
Programs: Virtuoso, FSPP, STARS, MO FAN Club, PEN Club, Bellini Club, Dorchester Diamond Club, Travel Leaders
Posts: 1,844
Originally Posted by JohnnyP View Post
Thanks for this. As I'm planning my honeymoon in the South Island, this has been incredibly helpful. Perhaps this is a silly question ... but for the rates charged (upwards of NZ$1,000 for a couple per night), did you feel like you were getting your money's worth? That's about US$700/night, which puts these properties at much higher rates than even some of the top luxury hotels in the world. Even if you figure US$200-$300 for dinner (and it doesn't sound like the quality of the food is at that level), US$500/night for a room+breakfast seems quite steep for me.
The New Zealand luxury lodges are some of the most wonderful, luxurious accommodations you'll ever stay in. In addition, because they are small and intimate, the price point tends to be higher... but these prices do make sense when compared to top luxury hotels of the world. If you book through Virtuoso, you'll also get additional value-added amenities (that differ by property).
DavidO is offline  
Old Jun 14, 10, 8:24 pm
  #14  
BPA
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: HNL
Programs: UA 1K MM; FS By Invitation; SPG PLAT Ambassador; HA Pualani Gold; LHW Leaders' Club; SLH; Avis First
Posts: 35
Originally Posted by DavidO View Post
The New Zealand luxury lodges are some of the most wonderful, luxurious accommodations you'll ever stay in. In addition, because they are small and intimate, the price point tends to be higher... but these prices do make sense when compared to top luxury hotels of the world. If you book through Virtuoso, you'll also get additional value-added amenities (that differ by property).
I agree with DavidO's comments regarding the price of NZ luxury lodges and his comments about Blanket Bay and Otahuna Lodge. After several days in Auckland, I spent a week on the South Island towards the end of 2009 and stayed at those properties. Before judging price, one must first ask themselves what kind of experience is being sought. If you are looking at the top of the market, I would be prepared to spend at least $1000 per night. Other "top of market" choices do not seem to exist on the South Island or even in NZ.

Big luxury chains remain absent from the market, which I believe helps to keep the experience "authentic." With no Amans, Peninsulas, Four Seasons, Mandarin Orientals, Banyan Trees, or Ritzs, small luxury lodges like those mentioned in this thread are the only way to go if you are in the luxury market. All other properties besides the small luxury lodges will be several notches below.

I can only comment on Blanket Bay, Otahuna, and the Sofitel in Queenstown. I save those comments for another post as the details of each property has been ably covered by DavidO.

For me, perhaps the most significant factor justifying the high price is the physical location of places like the Otahuna and especially Blanket Bay - just utterly breathtaking (especially Blanket Bay - phenomenal - thanks to Virtuoso, we were upgraded to one of the best rooms in the house - a corner room with our own private terrace with gorgeous lake views). Other considerations in favor of small luxury lodges include personal service (especially at the Otahuna where you share a few drinks with the owner, and whose staff will fix you up a delicious midnight meal upon request). The feeling evokes a sense of comfort as if you are staying at the estate of a wealthy friend (one night at Blanket Bay, we ended up drinking the night away and cleaning out the complimentary bar with the nightkeeper who happily shared his viewpoints and perspectives as a New Zealand native and resident).

No ostentacious chintz, no gold leaf, no jackets, no ties, and no pretension. Just comfort and well-being as you take in one of the most beautifully stunning places of nature in the world.
BPA is offline  
Old Jun 15, 10, 5:36 am
  #15  
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: my heart is on the shores of the north Italian lakes
Programs: LX Senator Lifetime, Relais&Chateaux Club5C, ex ! "Amanjunkie", ex LHW LC, hate chain hotels
Posts: 2,280
Queenstown is probabably among the best places for small or extended walks in the world.

I can agree with previous posters about Blanket Bay with its stunning heated and walled (to protect from the wind) open air pool. Nothing is too much trouble for the staff and a highlight is dining on the terrace outside near a roaring wood fire. Unfortunately this property is not part of Relais & Chateaux because the manager is member of the board of Small Luxury Hotels . Sorry for the charming owners I met last Christmas.

There is something new around Queenstown: Matakauri Lodge will (re)open on 27 August 2010. It is the same owners as Kauri Cliffs and Cape Kidnapper, so I trust them.

Regarding town accomodation: Eichardts is underwhelming and overpriced and The Spire the place to go (ask for a room on the church side for more peace and quiet).
behuman is offline  

Thread Tools
Search this Thread