FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Los Angeles (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/los-angeles-507/)
-   -   Rideshare at LAX (Uber/Lyft) (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/los-angeles/1989926-rideshare-lax-uber-lyft.html)

chrisl137 Oct 16, 2019 7:22 pm


Originally Posted by Moderator2 (Post 31636212)
Continuing the fun with numbers exercise, let's assume at a peak hour there is a bus arriving every 5 minutes with 40 people aboard. Add another 120 people an hour walking to the lot (from T-1 and elsewhere) and we're at a 600 person queue in an hour. With strong dispatch oversight by LAWA, I guess it could work. A couple of necessities would be near instant availability of vehicles and an equal number of riders splitting the business 50/50 between the two providers.

13,500 rides per 16 hours is 844 rides per hour - your case of 600/hr is on the lighter side and gives a leisurely 7 minutes per load, where you assume each person gets their own ride, which is reasonable for a large fraction of pickups. If the distribution were very lumpy and all the ride demand were squished into 5 hours (demand for 2700 rides/hour), then each ride has to get loaded, moved, and the next vehicle in at 1 minute 40 seconds to keep the wait at zero.

I suspect part of Uber's complaint is that there's a difference in ridership between them and Lyft, and the way the queuing will work it will encourage people to even out the selection with their ride choices.

ETA: the goal from LAWA's point of view is to design the facility so that the wait time is determined by the availability of vehicles and drivers more than the facility capacity, and I think they've done a reasonable job of that, and even at 10% growth per year til 2023 when the people mover opens, they're still doing ok at 4 minutes per ride-load to keep the wait at zero.

chillymac Oct 16, 2019 9:34 pm

I heard about this and decided to change my next (8) flights to BUR.
I thought it worked well the way it was but saying that I typically arrive at 6 a.m. when there was no traffic. I would not mind a walk in the morning to the pick-up area but even a 15 min delay in the morning can mean an extra hour on the freeway. So I will let LAX figure this out without me.

LAXlocal Oct 18, 2019 6:57 pm

if 600-800 rides per hour is a real number are there going to be that many Uber Lyft cars per hour around LAX and where are they going to line up ?

I think 5 minutes is too short of a time if they have luggage , and you have bottlenecks getting the cars into the lot and out again.....

then you have the shuttle buses to get in the way.......

I hope they put a time lapse camera over in the corner so they can see where the problem areas are and tweek the set-up

chrisl137 Oct 18, 2019 7:16 pm


Originally Posted by LAXlocal (Post 31643664)
if 600-800 rides per hour is a real number are there going to be that many Uber Lyft cars per hour around LAX and where are they going to line up ?

I think 5 minutes is too short of a time if they have luggage , and you have bottlenecks getting the cars into the lot and out again.....

then you have the shuttle buses to get in the way.......

I hope they put a time lapse camera over in the corner so they can see where the problem areas are and tweek the set-up

Those are the current actual numbers of Uber/Lyft rides at LAX. It's about 100,000 cars/day through the loop and 27% of it is rideshare. If you assume half pickup/half drop off, that's the 844/hr average as the current number of rideshares coming and going.

I haven't seen many people take 5 minutes to load a rideshare car - I think the only time I've taken that long was putting a couple of bicycles in the back of one where they had to rearrange stuff a bit. When I fly with a bike in a case it's still only about a minute to get the bike into an XL.

I suspect the buses will be using different roads than the rideshares - buses will come in and out from the horseshoe, and the cars will come in and out on Skyway or 96th or something like that.

chrisl137 Oct 19, 2019 12:33 pm

Just saw a post on Facebook from LAXit that they're testing the new traffic pattern (LAWA buses on the inside, cars on the outside) from 9am to noon this morning. It's only another half hour from when I'm posting, so probably not useful to anybody, but if anyone from FT happens to have done a pickup during that time, it would be interesting to get a report.

ryw Oct 19, 2019 10:44 pm

I’m curious how much luggage some folks have! Even with a roller, in my experience once an Uber/Lyft pulls up, I’m in and we’re pulling away in less than a minute. (Obviously some folks have different needs, but I think a 5 minute loading period is way more than enough time for most passengers).

My bigger concern is less about loading time per vehicle and the potential bottleneck of getting in and out of the lot (a left turn into the lot, and just one entrance and exit?)

pbfoot Oct 22, 2019 6:03 pm

Does anyone know if this will apply to black / lux? Otherwise going to be a boon for black car services.

chrisl137 Oct 22, 2019 8:19 pm


Originally Posted by pbfoot (Post 31656643)
Does anyone know if this will apply to black / lux? Otherwise going to be a boon for black car services.

Those are both TCP and should be able to pick up at the lower level islands.

chrisl137 Oct 24, 2019 1:02 am

Just got back from LAX. They've extended the islands another 4 feet or so towards the terminals - I don't recall seeing that monday morning when I left, and I looked, because there was a ton of construction work going on around the first islands as you approach T1, presumably to channel buses and cars appropriately. The extra 4 feet of sidewalk by the islands makes them *much* more tolerable. The big bollards had made it hard to move along the islands, and they've left the bollards there, and added the sidewalk outside of them on the one side. It looks like when it's done they'll have two lanes between the terminal and the islands.

The whole loop was packed with vehicles. The cars in what will soon be the bus lane seemed to be moving pretty quickly, but out in the main drag it was very slow. The Lot E bus took about 20 minutes to get from T4 to T6, and then Century was packed on the way out.

bzcat Oct 27, 2019 9:45 pm

I saw the extended sidewalks outside T4 and T5 as well. There are also temporary K rails being positioned in the inner loop. I think LAWA will deploy them on the 29th to block the entrances to the inner lane.

chrisl137 Oct 27, 2019 9:53 pm

I was wondering about those K rails - it wasn't clear if they were for blocking the inner lane entrances, or because drivers have become especially bad and were jumping up onto the islands (the way things have been it wouldn't surprise me). Most of them seemed about the right length to pull into the gaps to limit vehicle exchange between the inner and outer lanes, but they were positioned to keep cars off the islands.

I had a flight planned to arrive about 10:30 pm back into LAX on the 28th, just hours before the changeover, but extended the trip so I'm coming back on the 2nd. I'll be taking a rideshare and will report on how it goes.

alwaysflyingLA Oct 27, 2019 10:04 pm

LAXit pick-up plaza design and terminal traffic pattern redesign drawings
 
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...4c708a036.jpeg
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...94398092a.jpeg
https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...a4c28eb6d.jpeg
https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...df9afa7f0.jpeg
Here are some details regarding LAWA’s new setup. LAXit bus goes around the pick-up plaza.

ianmanka Oct 28, 2019 11:35 am


Originally Posted by stimpy (Post 31595787)
What about limousine/town car pickups? There are a lot less of those. Maybe they will still be allowed?


Originally Posted by ianmanka (Post 31603677)
My guess is all TCP vehicles will have to use this system.


Originally Posted by JBD (Post 31610950)
ianmanka you seem very well informed and I thank you for your posts, but I sure hope you're wrong!

Yes, I'm wrong, I got TCP and TNC acronyms confused.

The Skift chart is the best representation of what's changing in less than 24 hours:

https://i.imgur.com/1fvqcly.png

Eurynom0s Oct 28, 2019 1:23 pm

I got an email from Lyft today that seems to confirm they're going with the "get a number to show to your driver" system:


We've added new features to give you a smoother and faster pickup experience during LAX construction. Our Fast Match feature helps get you to where you're going quicker — with a dedicated line and unique code.
So hopefully this does indeed the way people were talking about, where you're not matched to a specific driver, and just get in line and show the code to whichever driver happens to be next in line once you hit the front of the line.

bzcat Oct 28, 2019 3:15 pm

The bus schedule plan makes absolutely no sense. Why would LAWA allocate 5 buses to T1/T2 route when projected occupancy is so low? And why have a T3/T4 bus that skips a stop (TBIT) just to confuse everyone?

The bus routes needs to be simplified and needs to be based on the airlines served and not the actual terminal location.

Bus 1 (aka the Southwest/Delta bus): T1/T2/T3 then express to LAXit
Bus 2 (aka the TBIT bus): express to TBIT then express to LAXit
Bus 3 (aka the AA bus): express to T4/T5 then express to LAXit
Bus 4 (aka the Alaska/UA bus): express to T6/T7/LAXit


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 3:08 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.