Beware - KLM Wanted to Charge me the Wrong Amount to Change a Ticket
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,746
Beware - KLM Wanted to Charge me the Wrong Amount to Change a Ticket
And, surprise, the wrong amount was higher than what I actually would have owed for the change.
Specifics - I had tickets for two from AMS to NCE. Total cost for the two tickets when I bought them last month was $320.40 (bought on klm.us.)
I looked this morning and saw that the fares had gone down on that route - klm.us would sell me tickets for my original flight or some other ones the same day for $252 with a new reservation.
I then went back into my existing reservation and used the change flights dialog. Even though the difference in fare for the two tickets was now $68.40, klm.us was only going to credit me $4.40 if I made the change, rather than the $68.40.
One clue that their system is screwed up (and perhaps a clue to the cause of the problem) - in the change dialog, it gave me a choice of the Light Fare and the Standard fare - both of which were showing the same $4.40 refund.
So I did the sensible thing - canceled the existing reservation for the $320.40 refundable voucher - and made a new reservation for $252.
I suppose if the ticket was bought after 1 March I would have had to call KLM reservations as there would not have been the refundable voucher option.
So check closely when you change your itineraries.
Edit: Upon further thought, my guess is that the $4.40 refund might just be due to the slide in the Euro versus the dollar since the tickets were purchased. Then there is probably something in the system that prevents it from using a lower fare if fares have gone down, which is why the Light and Standard fares had the same refund value. My understanding is that changes before the first flight are supposed to be charged based on current fares, not historical fares, but it does not seem to be operating that way.
Specifics - I had tickets for two from AMS to NCE. Total cost for the two tickets when I bought them last month was $320.40 (bought on klm.us.)
I looked this morning and saw that the fares had gone down on that route - klm.us would sell me tickets for my original flight or some other ones the same day for $252 with a new reservation.
I then went back into my existing reservation and used the change flights dialog. Even though the difference in fare for the two tickets was now $68.40, klm.us was only going to credit me $4.40 if I made the change, rather than the $68.40.
One clue that their system is screwed up (and perhaps a clue to the cause of the problem) - in the change dialog, it gave me a choice of the Light Fare and the Standard fare - both of which were showing the same $4.40 refund.
So I did the sensible thing - canceled the existing reservation for the $320.40 refundable voucher - and made a new reservation for $252.
I suppose if the ticket was bought after 1 March I would have had to call KLM reservations as there would not have been the refundable voucher option.
So check closely when you change your itineraries.
Edit: Upon further thought, my guess is that the $4.40 refund might just be due to the slide in the Euro versus the dollar since the tickets were purchased. Then there is probably something in the system that prevents it from using a lower fare if fares have gone down, which is why the Light and Standard fares had the same refund value. My understanding is that changes before the first flight are supposed to be charged based on current fares, not historical fares, but it does not seem to be operating that way.
Last edited by BigFlyer; Mar 9, 2022 at 12:05 pm
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
The fare rules of the ticket you purchased almost certainly would not have allowed a refund if you changed your flights to cheaper ones. The fare difference must always be paid if you move to a more expensive flight, but the opposite is not the case, unless specifically allowed in the fare rules, which it generally is not for such a relatively cheap ticket. This is also the case if the price on the flights you already purchased are offered at a cheaper rate than what you originally paid.
#3
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,746
The fare rules of the ticket you purchased almost certainly would not have allowed a refund if you changed your flights to cheaper ones. The fare difference must always be paid if you move to a more expensive flight, but the opposite is not the case, unless specifically allowed in the fare rules, which it generally is not for such a relatively cheap ticket. This is also the case if the price on the flights you already purchased are offered at a cheaper rate than what you originally paid.
AFAIK KLM/AF is the only carrier allowing changes and/or vouchers on Basic Economy (Light) fares, so I really can't complain. With that ability to get a voucher/change flight even with lowly Silver status there is no significant difference between Light and Standard - Silver get you a checked bag and free seat selection.
However, it would be nice if they spelled out what you could and couldn't do with a change. From my search of the KLM website it does not say you can get a refund credit if you go to a lower fare - but it also doesn't say that you can't.
#4
Join Date: May 2015
Location: RBA / TBS
Programs: AF Gold / Accor Gold / Hilton Diamond / TP Silver / A3 Gold
Posts: 2,744
You need to check the rules of the fares you purchase , there everything is explained , often in complicated terms i agree , but it is there
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
Deleted as incorrect info.
All bookings can still be "postponed" for a non-refundable voucher though this may change in the future.
All bookings can still be "postponed" for a non-refundable voucher though this may change in the future.
Last edited by irishguy28; Mar 9, 2022 at 2:36 pm
#6
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,746
The ability to cancel for a voucher has ended; this was a pandemic measure and it applies for tickets booked before 1 March for travelling commencing before 1 July.
For tickets booked on or after 1 March, as well as tickets booked before 1 March for travel starting on or after 1 July, whether you can cancel your ticket for a full refund is governed solely by the fare rules applicable to the ticket; the blanket pandemic measure of allowing refunds no longer applies.
For tickets booked on or after 1 March, as well as tickets booked before 1 March for travel starting on or after 1 July, whether you can cancel your ticket for a full refund is governed solely by the fare rules applicable to the ticket; the blanket pandemic measure of allowing refunds no longer applies.
3. Request a non-refundable travel voucher
If you choose to postpone your trip, we will provide you with a non-refundable travel voucher.- Your travel voucher is valid for 1 year after the date of issue.
- You can use your voucher within the validity period to book a flight that takes place after the expiry date of the voucher.
- If the value of your voucher is higher than the price of your new booking, you'll receive another voucher for the remaining balance.
- If the value of your voucher is lower than the price of your new booking, you will need to pay the fare difference.
- Your travel voucher is non-refundable and non-transferable.
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
#8
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,746
Although I do wonder - the refundable vouchers had a sunset date when they were introduced, and there is currently no sunset date for the vouchers. The voucher option is listed on the booking page where they show all of the types of fares after you have selected your flights. There is a "**" next to the "non-refundable" verbiage that says " Refundable in form of a voucher if you cancel before the 1st flight in your trip. Voucher is valid for 1 year from the date of issue, non-refundable and non-transferable."
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
Note that you do not have the ability to CHANGE light tickets beyond what is allowed under the normal fare rules. As you saw already, when you tried to make a change, you "lost" a lot of money. You were lucky that you realised that you could still CANCEL and rebook, rather than CHANGING.
In the future, you will no longer have this option to cancel for a voucher. Making the exact same change you made just now, you would not receive a voucher. You would just get the new ticket and no refund.
Here's what my (refundable) voucher, issued this very morning, says:
Last edited by irishguy28; Mar 9, 2022 at 2:56 pm
#10
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,746
You say it like those are two unconnected things - but they are one and the same. The ability to CANCEL all tickets (not just Light ones) is an "add-on" and leads inevitably to a voucher.
Note that you do not have the ability to CHANGE light tickets beyond what is allowed under the normal fare rules. As you saw already, when you tried to make a change, you "lost" a lot of money. You were lucky that you realised that you could still CANCEL and rebook, rather than CHANGING.
In the future, you will no longer have this option to cancel for a voucher. Making the exact same change you made just now, you would not receive a voucher. You would just get the new ticket and no refund.
All vouchers currently being issued are valid for 1 year from the date of issue as you noted later in your post:
So make sure to use any non-refundable voucher date within a year of its issue.
Here's what my (refundable) voucher, issued this very morning, says:
Note that you do not have the ability to CHANGE light tickets beyond what is allowed under the normal fare rules. As you saw already, when you tried to make a change, you "lost" a lot of money. You were lucky that you realised that you could still CANCEL and rebook, rather than CHANGING.
In the future, you will no longer have this option to cancel for a voucher. Making the exact same change you made just now, you would not receive a voucher. You would just get the new ticket and no refund.
All vouchers currently being issued are valid for 1 year from the date of issue as you noted later in your post:
So make sure to use any non-refundable voucher date within a year of its issue.
Here's what my (refundable) voucher, issued this very morning, says:
I'm not sure what "it can be used to purchase an Air France or KLM ticket using AF/KL/DL/VS fares."
Then at the bottom it says "VALID ON AF/KL/DL/VS FOR 1 YEAR.."
Can it be used for a DL domestic flight?
#11
Join Date: Feb 2012
Programs: Flying Blue Platinum, Le ClubAccor Gold
Posts: 776
There is more than a little ambiguity as to where the voucher can be used.
I'm not sure what "it can be used to purchase an Air France or KLM ticket using AF/KL/DL/VS fares."
Then at the bottom it says "VALID ON AF/KL/DL/VS FOR 1 YEAR.."
Can it be used for a DL domestic flight?
I'm not sure what "it can be used to purchase an Air France or KLM ticket using AF/KL/DL/VS fares."
Then at the bottom it says "VALID ON AF/KL/DL/VS FOR 1 YEAR.."
Can it be used for a DL domestic flight?
#12
Join Date: Mar 2018
Programs: FB Plat, *A Gold
Posts: 367
#13
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
The voucher can only be redeemed while completing and paying for any booking made on the website of either AF or KL, and neither AF nor KL sell standalone domestic DL flights on their websites (such flights are only sold by AF/KL in conjunction with transatlantic flights)
#14
Join Date: Nov 2021
Programs: FB
Posts: 193
The voucher can only be redeemed while completing and paying for any booking made on the website of either AF or KL, and neither AF nor KL sell standalone domestic DL flights on their websites (such flights are only sold by AF/KL in conjunction with transatlantic flights)
With non-refundable vouchers, this could be a PITA.
#15
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Jnb
Programs: FB PFL
Posts: 68
change flight on web, get a refund, call plat line, pay for the change..
Was just trying to change the return leg of a JNB BCN online. All good , I even get a small refund. except.. upon validating, I get the OOoooops.. there was a problem, call us. So I called Plat line and there I was told I had to pay 60 euros to change the return flight... I politely emailed them screen grabs of the online change offer. even then, they held their position, to a point I find almost offensive, being PFL...
Dear Mr. ,
I am sorry if my explanation was not clear for you.
You can rebook your return flight against 30.43eur fare difference per ticket or cancel tickets completely, refund them and book new tickets with Lufthansa.
Sincerely yours,
Platinum Service Line
I don't really care about the 30 euros per ticket, but it's just a matter of principle. #Whenthelefthanddoesntknowwhattherighthandisdoing ..
Dear Mr. ,
I am sorry if my explanation was not clear for you.
You can rebook your return flight against 30.43eur fare difference per ticket or cancel tickets completely, refund them and book new tickets with Lufthansa.
Sincerely yours,
Platinum Service Line
I don't really care about the 30 euros per ticket, but it's just a matter of principle. #Whenthelefthanddoesntknowwhattherighthandisdoing ..