Impact of GST
So what is happening with hotel & restaurant prices now that GST will start in a few days' time? Does the final total cost go up, down or stay the same?
Do some taxes disappear and get replaced by GST? |
28% on hotels charging >5000 INR/night, 18% on a/c restaurants. Enjoy!
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/...w/58757234.cms |
Originally Posted by oliver2002
(Post 28482032)
28% on hotels charging >5000 INR/night, 18% on a/c restaurants. Enjoy!
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/...w/58757234.cms I anticipate some creativity from businesses. Restaurants that split into a food selling business and into a nearby seating business. Hotels that lower their rates but then charge for compulsory "incidentals" like getting electricity in the room, sheets, maid service, and so on. |
Originally Posted by oliver2002
(Post 28482032)
28% on hotels charging >5000 INR/night, 18% on a/c restaurants. Enjoy!
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/...w/58757234.cms Incidentally I recall reading that the tax rates for hotels priced up to INR 7,500 will be 18% - is that correct? |
Originally Posted by puchong
(Post 28482862)
However, considering the plethora of taxes currently in place (e.g. luxury tax), what will the NET impact be? Presumably (hopefully) these extraneous taxes will then die? And what about the 'Swachh' tax for a non-swachh India?
|
Originally Posted by oliver2002
(Post 28482032)
28% on hotels charging >5000 INR/night, 18% on a/c restaurants. Enjoy!
|
Originally Posted by oliver2002
(Post 28482032)
28% on hotels charging >5000 INR/night, 18% on a/c restaurants. Enjoy!
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/...w/58757234.cms |
I just checked rates for a few SPG hotels around Delhi. The 4P Delhi Airport correctly charges 9% GST onlyon a base rate of INR 5,700 and the Westin Gurgaon correctly charges 28% GST only on a base rate of INR 8,100.
Contrary to this, the Park New Delhi charges 15% Luxury Tax on a Rack Rate of Rs 5,999 + "Krishi Kalyan" tax of 0.3% All these were for stays in October! PS. What happens to F&B charges - are these matched to the GST rates applicable to the rooms at the property? If so, what happens if the hotel has some rooms below the INR 7,500 slab and other rooms above that level? So what rate do you pay for a cup of coffee at the restaurant? |
F&B should get the 18% like A/C restaurants? Here in Germany we also have a plethora of different VAT rates for different services, the hotels split it all out in line items that all get different VAT rates.
|
Originally Posted by Keyser
(Post 28490287)
if you take away the luxury tax then the taxes amount will pretty much stay the same as it was before....
|
Originally Posted by Travelmic
(Post 28521152)
My knowledge was that the previous taxes were making around 18%. So for the hotels above 7500 rs, the increase would be 10% (new GST: 28% vs. old taxes 18%).
the vat was 1.25%, the service tax was 8.4% & the luxury tax was 10%....but the luxury tax was calculated on rack rate.... so lets suppose the room rate was inr 7.5k & the rack rate of that room was inr 12k....so all taxes combined would come to inr 1,923.75 which would be roughly 26%.... it would differ from room to room depending on the rack rate but at the end of the day the places that charged luxury tax would end up charging roughly between 25-30% of your eventual room rate.... |
Originally Posted by Keyser
(Post 28521205)
it wasn't exactly 18% of the room rate....it was a bit more complicated than that....
the vat was 1.25%, the service tax was 8.4% & the luxury tax was 10%....but the luxury tax was calculated on rack rate.... so lets suppose the room rate was inr 7.5k & the rack rate of that room was inr 12k....so all taxes combined would come to inr 1,923.75 which would be roughly 26%.... it would differ from room to room depending on the rack rate but at the end of the day the places that charged luxury tax would end up charging roughly between 25-30% of your eventual room rate.... very good explanation. Are tourist have to pay more than Indian residents for hotels and other things? :confused: |
Originally Posted by TheMadeTraveler
(Post 28521964)
@Keyser
very good explanation. Are tourist have to pay more than Indian residents for hotels and other things? :confused: |
Originally Posted by Keyser
(Post 28521205)
it wasn't exactly 18% of the room rate....it was a bit more complicated than that....
the vat was 1.25%, the service tax was 8.4% & the luxury tax was 10%....but the luxury tax was calculated on rack rate..... Is the new VAT applied on rack or actual rates - in Delhi and elsewhere? |
Originally Posted by puchong
(Post 28528853)
Am I wrong that the luxury tax on rack rate racket was only prevalent in Delhi, while other metros charged it on the actual rate paid?
Originally Posted by puchong
(Post 28528853)
Is the new VAT applied on rack or actual rates - in Delhi and elsewhere?
for example, lets supposed the rack rate for a particular room is inr 10k but the hotel is offering that room for inr 5k....the highest rate bracket of 28% will apply (because the rack rate is over inr 7.5k) but will only be charged on the room rate which is inr 5k.... |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:59 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.