Hilton Garden Inn Hong Kong Mongkok {HKG}
#286
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: ORD, HKG
Programs: UA*G, AA Emerald, HHonors Diamond, Hyatt globalist
Posts: 10,272
My opinions are mine. Yours are yours. I therefore am not "wrong". Furthermore this is not a hotel in the U.S. so that comparison falls on deaf ears. I AM saying that it is the worst Hilton family hotel breakfast experience that I have had. Period. The egg "cook" was pathetic. Period. Now, moving on..
Last edited by ORDnHKG; Jan 17, 2019 at 11:52 pm
#287
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Phuket
Programs: SQ *Gold, BA, QR, EY, Hilton Diamond, IHG Plat, Marriott Gold, Amex Plat
Posts: 5,264
In your words "Not recommended" and implying even starbucks are better than this is like saying everyone should avoid and skip this breakfast all together. Even though this is not a hotel in the US but it follows the basics of what HGI in the US provide, as it reflects on the price point as well. Just same name but different country doesnt mean it will be entirely different not unless they are charging $200+ a night consistent like Courtyard Hong kong, then you will have an exec lounge with breakfast, afternoon tea and evening reception
#288
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: ORD, HKG
Programs: UA*G, AA Emerald, HHonors Diamond, Hyatt globalist
Posts: 10,272
With Hong Kong there are so many food choices that include plenty walking distance from HGI, i am shocked you would rather go to starbucks for unfulfilling and overpriced breakfast.
Last edited by ORDnHKG; Jan 18, 2019 at 8:46 am
#289
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Phuket
Programs: SQ *Gold, BA, QR, EY, Hilton Diamond, IHG Plat, Marriott Gold, Amex Plat
Posts: 5,264
I didnt say i recommend the breakfast, it is acceptable, consider HGI is a primarily US brand, and HGI‘s breakfast in the US are quite consistent with their standard in every property. HGI Hong Kong breakfast is more than enough except it failed in orange juice, you certainly can‘t compare to the breakfast in Hilton, Sheraton, or Conrad as HGI is not at the level, HGI should always compare to mid range brands like courtyard, four points, holiday inn express, and best western plus, perhaps your expectation of HGI is too high.
With Hong Kong there are so many food choices that include plenty walking distance from HGI, i am shocked you would rather go to starbucks for unfulfilling and overpriced breakfast.
With Hong Kong there are so many food choices that include plenty walking distance from HGI, i am shocked you would rather go to starbucks for unfulfilling and overpriced breakfast.
#290
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Las Vegas
Programs: United Platinum, IHG Spire Ambassador, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 284
Just spent 4 nights in the hotel. As a diamond got upgraded to the deluxe harbor view. Foggy for the first 2 days, couldn't see the harbor at all...finally caught a view on my 3rd day. While not a lie, you're nowhere near the harbor, so don't be misled into thinking you're near the waterfront.
The room was small but clean, and the breakfast was acceptable. I like the Mongkok area, and it's a rather short walk to the MTR station, so personally the value for money was there for me.
I had great interaction with the staff - front desk, breakfast, and housekeeping staff were all super friendly.
My only complaint was the thinness of the walls - most nights my neighbors went to sleep before I did, but on my second night there were some rather loud adult activities going on in the room next to mine. Luckily for me, my neighbor's middle name wasn't "stamina," and a few minutes later all was quiet.
I'd probably stay here again, but I wouldn't rave about it to anyone. 3.5/5.
The room was small but clean, and the breakfast was acceptable. I like the Mongkok area, and it's a rather short walk to the MTR station, so personally the value for money was there for me.
I had great interaction with the staff - front desk, breakfast, and housekeeping staff were all super friendly.
My only complaint was the thinness of the walls - most nights my neighbors went to sleep before I did, but on my second night there were some rather loud adult activities going on in the room next to mine. Luckily for me, my neighbor's middle name wasn't "stamina," and a few minutes later all was quiet.
I'd probably stay here again, but I wouldn't rave about it to anyone. 3.5/5.
#291
Join Date: Jul 2009
Programs: DL PM, HH Diamond, Marriott Plat, AA, WP
Posts: 840
My only complaint was the thinness of the walls - most nights my neighbors went to sleep before I did, but on my second night there were some rather loud adult activities going on in the room next to mine. Luckily for me, my neighbor's middle name wasn't "stamina," and a few minutes later all was quiet.
While I found the hotel perfectly satisfactory, the staff professional, the breakfast acceptable (but boring), and the area safe; I would not want to explain to my young daughter why those young ladies in white blouses and black shorts are sitting out there each evening as you walk back to the HGI.
Of course, when you stay at a higher end hotel in Hong Kong, you just see higher end ladies in the evening.
#292
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Las Vegas
Programs: United Platinum, IHG Spire Ambassador, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 284
Lol! This happened to me as well, and those walls are thin. Judging by the lady's overly enthusiastic exclamations, I hazard my neighbor invited someone up from the lineup on the next block that appears after the 'home depot' stores close.
While I found the hotel perfectly satisfactory, the staff professional, the breakfast acceptable (but boring), and the area safe; I would not want to explain to my young daughter why those young ladies in white blouses and black shorts are sitting out there each evening as you walk back to the HGI.
Of course, when you stay at a higher end hotel in Hong Kong, you just see higher end ladies in the evening.
While I found the hotel perfectly satisfactory, the staff professional, the breakfast acceptable (but boring), and the area safe; I would not want to explain to my young daughter why those young ladies in white blouses and black shorts are sitting out there each evening as you walk back to the HGI.
Of course, when you stay at a higher end hotel in Hong Kong, you just see higher end ladies in the evening.
They don't seem to approach any tourists at all - we were two males - so while I certainly wouldn't want to explain it to a young daughter what's going on, at least it's not as in your face as some other places.
#293
Despite reading about those 'interesting' activities, I am wondering how's this hotel suited for end of the year for the NYE's celebration/fireworks - was thinking about the Sheraton, but I guess prices will be absurd. I know the HGI is not at the harbour, but seems to be walkable from googlemap.
As for the 'activities', wonder why the hotel does not have more restrictive policy for them - even it might not be followed - they should put up signs that only registered guests are allowed into the guest rooms at any time. This will at least make those into these activities think twice before bringing someone up.
I've stayed before at the Courtyard (which I put into the same category as the HGI), the building quality was much better, therefore I've expected the same for the HGI - but rather not amused with these thin walls.
Cheers!
As for the 'activities', wonder why the hotel does not have more restrictive policy for them - even it might not be followed - they should put up signs that only registered guests are allowed into the guest rooms at any time. This will at least make those into these activities think twice before bringing someone up.
I've stayed before at the Courtyard (which I put into the same category as the HGI), the building quality was much better, therefore I've expected the same for the HGI - but rather not amused with these thin walls.
Cheers!
#294
Ambassador, British Airways; FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Leeds, UK
Programs: BA GGL/CCR, GfL, HH Diamond
Posts: 42,888
Despite reading about those 'interesting' activities, I am wondering how's this hotel suited for end of the year for the NYE's celebration/fireworks - was thinking about the Sheraton, but I guess prices will be absurd. I know the HGI is not at the harbour, but seems to be walkable from googlemap.
I guess you could walk it but since the MTR will run all through the night on NYE you can just get that back up to Mong Kok.
#295
I will check out other properties either in the area or outside since now I know that the metro will be running the whole night. Can't see myself paying that much for what I consider a mouse hole. Will continue to check out the prices once in a while.. but gosh..even for NYE...if this was around the Sydney harbour area I would imagine,...
Cheers!
#296
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: HH Diamond, Marriott Gold, IHG Gold, Hyatt something
Posts: 33,533
Thanks for the info. I did a quick check and my gosh.. prices are already at 2770++ HKD per night (or 30k points) and you need to book it for 2 nights min starting from the 30th
I will check out other properties either in the area or outside since now I know that the metro will be running the whole night. Can't see myself paying that much for what I consider a mouse hole. Will continue to check out the prices once in a while.. but gosh..even for NYE...if this was around the Sydney harbour area I would imagine,...
I will check out other properties either in the area or outside since now I know that the metro will be running the whole night. Can't see myself paying that much for what I consider a mouse hole. Will continue to check out the prices once in a while.. but gosh..even for NYE...if this was around the Sydney harbour area I would imagine,...
#297
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Las Vegas
Programs: United Platinum, IHG Spire Ambassador, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 284
Despite reading about those 'interesting' activities, I am wondering how's this hotel suited for end of the year for the NYE's celebration/fireworks - was thinking about the Sheraton, but I guess prices will be absurd. I know the HGI is not at the harbour, but seems to be walkable from googlemap.
As for the 'activities', wonder why the hotel does not have more restrictive policy for them - even it might not be followed - they should put up signs that only registered guests are allowed into the guest rooms at any time. This will at least make those into these activities think twice before bringing someone up.
I've stayed before at the Courtyard (which I put into the same category as the HGI), the building quality was much better, therefore I've expected the same for the HGI - but rather not amused with these thin walls.
Cheers!
As for the 'activities', wonder why the hotel does not have more restrictive policy for them - even it might not be followed - they should put up signs that only registered guests are allowed into the guest rooms at any time. This will at least make those into these activities think twice before bringing someone up.
I've stayed before at the Courtyard (which I put into the same category as the HGI), the building quality was much better, therefore I've expected the same for the HGI - but rather not amused with these thin walls.
Cheers!
#298
Used to be MBS PremExec
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Saginaw, MI (MBS)
Programs: UA 1K 1.9MM, Marriott Titanium w/Lifetime Plat, Hilton LIfetime ♢, National Exec, Amex Plat
Posts: 5,722
I've stayed here 5 times now, most recently earlier this month.
I received 3 welcome gifts as a Diamond...The microfiber towel (mine too was more of a dusty gray color versus the gold one shown here, probably differentiated because of being a Diamond, versus Gold). Also received one of those stick-on-the-back cellphone stands and I honestly can't remember the 3rd thing at the moment. All were emblazoned with the HH logo.
I was upgraded a 'junior suite'. It's about 20% larger than their standard rooms and is more of a studio 'suite'--I'd say it's a stretch to call it a suite, as there's no divider, no separate room, no sofa bed, and is probably still smaller than your standard suburban hotel room in the US. There are only 2 of these Junior Suites in the whole hotel, on the 20th (top) floor. I've also stayed in their big suite as well, only one on property also on the 20th floor (to the far right as you exit the elevators)...That one is indeed bigger, about 2.2X bigger than the standard room as it does have a separate living room, rather large bathroom and great corner windows facing 2 directions.
I too had the 'comped fridge of drinks', although this time I had 6 cans of various things, which did match my contents in previous stays. One beer, the rest soft drinks.
They changed the 'welcome meal' for Diamonds. Previously it was a choice of two entree-sized dishes, with the fried noodles actually being an outstanding dish that I was looking forward to enjoying one night. This time I was less than impressed and selected the dim sum, which ended up being 3-4 pieces that didn't taste spectacular.
I actually thought breakfast improved in the 6 months since I had been there last. In 5 days, I saw more rotation this time than over previous stays. Eggs weren't horrible and contrary to the welcome meal, the dim sum was pretty good. I found the coffee to actually be very good, as it is in most western hotels in HK/China these days. Made on a per-cup basis from an espresso machine. It's strong and flavorful.
...Then again, I'm relatively easy to please.
Contrary to others, I'm constantly hounded by the touts when I walk Soy Street after dark. Always getting asked if I want "nice girl" by the girls' handlers.
I received 3 welcome gifts as a Diamond...The microfiber towel (mine too was more of a dusty gray color versus the gold one shown here, probably differentiated because of being a Diamond, versus Gold). Also received one of those stick-on-the-back cellphone stands and I honestly can't remember the 3rd thing at the moment. All were emblazoned with the HH logo.
I was upgraded a 'junior suite'. It's about 20% larger than their standard rooms and is more of a studio 'suite'--I'd say it's a stretch to call it a suite, as there's no divider, no separate room, no sofa bed, and is probably still smaller than your standard suburban hotel room in the US. There are only 2 of these Junior Suites in the whole hotel, on the 20th (top) floor. I've also stayed in their big suite as well, only one on property also on the 20th floor (to the far right as you exit the elevators)...That one is indeed bigger, about 2.2X bigger than the standard room as it does have a separate living room, rather large bathroom and great corner windows facing 2 directions.
I too had the 'comped fridge of drinks', although this time I had 6 cans of various things, which did match my contents in previous stays. One beer, the rest soft drinks.
They changed the 'welcome meal' for Diamonds. Previously it was a choice of two entree-sized dishes, with the fried noodles actually being an outstanding dish that I was looking forward to enjoying one night. This time I was less than impressed and selected the dim sum, which ended up being 3-4 pieces that didn't taste spectacular.
I actually thought breakfast improved in the 6 months since I had been there last. In 5 days, I saw more rotation this time than over previous stays. Eggs weren't horrible and contrary to the welcome meal, the dim sum was pretty good. I found the coffee to actually be very good, as it is in most western hotels in HK/China these days. Made on a per-cup basis from an espresso machine. It's strong and flavorful.
...Then again, I'm relatively easy to please.
Contrary to others, I'm constantly hounded by the touts when I walk Soy Street after dark. Always getting asked if I want "nice girl" by the girls' handlers.
Last edited by MBS MillionMiler; Jan 23, 2019 at 8:26 am
#299
Join Date: Jul 2009
Programs: DL PM, HH Diamond, Marriott Plat, AA, WP
Posts: 840
Of course, a hotel guest can bring his or her own guests to their room, you expect that any time you rent a room. However, the white and black 'uniforms' are awfully easy to spot. At luxury hotels in HK, it's just that you will find taller, more beautiful, dressed-to-the-nines ladies waiting at the elevator banks for their 'hosts' to collect them.
#300
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Programs: TK Elite, Hilton Diamond, BA Silver
Posts: 967
We stayed here a few weeks ago. Also got the towel, meal and drinks voucher as a Diamond member.
The dimsum was very good. I can´t remember the other choice.
Drinks were served with nuts
Towel
The dimsum was very good. I can´t remember the other choice.
Drinks were served with nuts
Towel