ETIHAD versus Emirates
#16
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Dubai, UAE
Programs: Skywards Plat, Etihad Gold, Aerosvit Gold, Virgin Silver, AA lifetime Gold, Sirius Gold
Posts: 1,229
I've not flown either, but friends who have rate EY over EK.
Sorry to hijack thr thread, but I'm thinking of using EY from SYD-LHR next year in F.. ANyone here know what the SPA hours are in the AUH F lounge? I'd love to use the SPA for a massage or some treatment if possible, but don't know if it's operational at the times I"d be going through.. Can anyone enlighten me?
Sorry to hijack thr thread, but I'm thinking of using EY from SYD-LHR next year in F.. ANyone here know what the SPA hours are in the AUH F lounge? I'd love to use the SPA for a massage or some treatment if possible, but don't know if it's operational at the times I"d be going through.. Can anyone enlighten me?
Last edited by mrtdxb; Nov 7, 2010 at 10:24 am Reason: expand post slightly.
#17
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: OSL
Programs: BA Gold | SK Gold | A3 Gold
Posts: 4,553
The one reason I fly Emirates over Etihad is my AVOD didn't work on an entire JFK-DXB flight, and I had to resort to chatting with crew and pax for the entire duration. On the same trip I visited their old J lounge at AUH and it absolutely put me off getting status with them. Oh another thing, they don't do priority check in or boarding for Silvers!
I guess some other, more valid, reasons, are that they only have 3x a week to SIN while EK have 21x a week, which means it's always easier to get a seat on EK and fly whenever I want instead of doing overnighters on EY.
#19
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Middle Earth, and often worse
Programs: BAEC Silver, A3 Gold
Posts: 2,217
I fly Etihad almost weekly. The business class lounge in AUH is fine, but tends to get very crowded.
I've not flown them in business, but economy class is very good. I've flown Emirates in business and if you get a flat bed it's great. But the recliner seats in Emirates business are pretty poor. Economy in Emirates is similar to economy in Etihad.
I've not flown them in business, but economy class is very good. I've flown Emirates in business and if you get a flat bed it's great. But the recliner seats in Emirates business are pretty poor. Economy in Emirates is similar to economy in Etihad.
Emirates in 3 different economy flights has not given me anything outstanding. Their flights are crowded in economy and the bathroom availability is an issue. In fact, on the last flight (LHR-DXB) they were just .....rdly with libations and I had to ask several times before they even gave me some wine - which I received after the meal, instead of enjoying it with the meal.
I never had a problem on 4 sectors with Etihad and was pleasantly surprised at their level of service and assessibility to toilets in economy (even though the 4 sectors were full in economy), and I have NEVER had any problem with BA - ever. In fact for a while BA was upgrading me from WT+ into business class at no additional cost to me. Consequently, I naturally think highly of their service - even on short hauls (LHR-Warsaw).
Go with Etihad instead of Emirates! JMHO :-)
#20
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: MAN, HKG, DOH, MNL
Programs: QR Gold
Posts: 491
I am currently sat in DOH flying with QR when i was thinking of switching airlines Etihad seem good and after the good reviews i might have to take a look. Or am i crazy?
BTW I used to like EK but they have gone down hill over the past few years in Y (only fly Y).
BTW I used to like EK but they have gone down hill over the past few years in Y (only fly Y).
#21
Original Poster
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 15
#22
Original Poster
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 15
I've not flown either, but friends who have rate EY over EK.
Sorry to hijack thr thread, but I'm thinking of using EY from SYD-LHR next year in F.. ANyone here know what the SPA hours are in the AUH F lounge? I'd love to use the SPA for a massage or some treatment if possible, but don't know if it's operational at the times I"d be going through.. Can anyone enlighten me?
Sorry to hijack thr thread, but I'm thinking of using EY from SYD-LHR next year in F.. ANyone here know what the SPA hours are in the AUH F lounge? I'd love to use the SPA for a massage or some treatment if possible, but don't know if it's operational at the times I"d be going through.. Can anyone enlighten me?
Up until 09.30pm the SPA was quite busy but then the masseuses were hanging around.....no clients. Also the QUIET ROOM was available.
For our long layover on the way back to EU (7 hrs!) we have now requested a room at the Airport Hotel in order to make sure we get some rest.
Frankly - we like the Emirates lounge over the Etihad lounge.
The flat beds were great at J! But those seats are narrow.
Despite Emirates doesn't offer yet real flat beds at J e definitely will choose Emirates over Etihad because we can fly out of DUS directly to OZ instead of undertaking the effort to ride a train to FRA to catch Etihad.
If they would fly out of DUS - that's another story.
Instead of twice/day out of FRA in my view it would make sense to add DUS to the map a couple of times/week.
Etihad also can't work out what LACTO-OVO-VEGETARIAN meals mean. We got VEGAN again. No airline is cmpable of doing it. Have been trying that for 20plus years - never worked out
Besides the real flat beds - Etihad isn't any better than Emirates in our opinion but it's good to have made that experience.
#23
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: ZYR, BRU
Programs: QR Silver
Posts: 132
I've had a lot of trouble with malfunctioning entertainment systems when I first started flying EY, but not recently. Compared to early days, service in economy is no longer over the top (only one full meal on a 6 to 7 hr flight instead of 2, normal cutlery instead of super heavy,...), entertainment system have clearly gotten much better, ... Unfortunately seat pitch has diminished and their 777 are now 10 abreast instead of 9 before, there also used to be a "premium economy" section on some of their older leased A330s, not on their newer ones
Emirates isn't an option for met, but next year Qatar will start flying to BRU, might give them a try, their economy seating seems to be much better, fairly important for me as I'm a bit of a POS (don't usually need a seatbelt extender, and I fit between the armrest, but its not comfortable and I tend to obstruct the aisles a bit).
#24
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: India
Programs: Bonvoy Lifetime Titanium, IHG Plat, HH Gold, Trident Plat, DL Diamond, AI Maharajah
Posts: 29,673
#25
Join Date: May 2008
Programs: EY-Gold LH-SEN AA-Gold HHonors-Gold National-ES
Posts: 1,520
We came from FRA at roughly 08.00pm and the lounge was extremely crowded. Some sections wee really looking sad/bad (compared that to the Irish Pub at Dubai Intl.).
Up until 09.30pm the SPA was quite busy but then the masseuses were hanging around.....no clients. Also the QUIET ROOM was available.
For our long layover on the way back to EU (7 hrs!) we have now requested a room at the Airport Hotel in order to make sure we get some rest.
Frankly - we like the Emirates lounge over the Etihad lounge.
The flat beds were great at J! But those seats are narrow.
Despite Emirates doesn't offer yet real flat beds at J e definitely will choose Emirates over Etihad because we can fly out of DUS directly to OZ instead of undertaking the effort to ride a train to FRA to catch Etihad.
If they would fly out of DUS - that's another story.
Instead of twice/day out of FRA in my view it would make sense to add DUS to the map a couple of times/week.
Etihad also can't work out what LACTO-OVO-VEGETARIAN meals mean. We got VEGAN again. No airline is cmpable of doing it. Have been trying that for 20plus years - never worked out
Besides the real flat beds - Etihad isn't any better than Emirates in our opinion but it's good to have made that experience.
Up until 09.30pm the SPA was quite busy but then the masseuses were hanging around.....no clients. Also the QUIET ROOM was available.
For our long layover on the way back to EU (7 hrs!) we have now requested a room at the Airport Hotel in order to make sure we get some rest.
Frankly - we like the Emirates lounge over the Etihad lounge.
The flat beds were great at J! But those seats are narrow.
Despite Emirates doesn't offer yet real flat beds at J e definitely will choose Emirates over Etihad because we can fly out of DUS directly to OZ instead of undertaking the effort to ride a train to FRA to catch Etihad.
If they would fly out of DUS - that's another story.
Instead of twice/day out of FRA in my view it would make sense to add DUS to the map a couple of times/week.
Etihad also can't work out what LACTO-OVO-VEGETARIAN meals mean. We got VEGAN again. No airline is cmpable of doing it. Have been trying that for 20plus years - never worked out
Besides the real flat beds - Etihad isn't any better than Emirates in our opinion but it's good to have made that experience.
#26
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 226
Dubai and Abu Dhabi are both in the same country. Do you have a different perception of Abu Dhabi in this regard?
#27
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: London
Programs: Skyteam & BAEC Silv, EY Gold, IHG Plat
Posts: 70
Pardon my ignorance, but isn't a LACTO-OVO-VEGETARIAN just a normal veggie? Are you saying you asked for a veggie meal and got Vegan? I would be annoyed if that happened to me. EY do a veggie option on their menu for anyone that wants it I think, and you can ask for it during the normal meal service without pre- ordering. (I always go for the meat options though )
#28
Join Date: May 2005
Location: NYC
Posts: 1,755
Pardon my ignorance, but isn't a LACTO-OVO-VEGETARIAN just a normal veggie? Are you saying you asked for a veggie meal and got Vegan? I would be annoyed if that happened to me. EY do a veggie option on their menu for anyone that wants it I think, and you can ask for it during the normal meal service without pre- ordering. (I always go for the meat options though )
#29
Original Poster
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 15
descending, not really. I have experienced DUBAI reps at several exhibitions but never ever dealt with Abu Dhabi reps. Need to do a research on that in order to answer ur question.
#30
Original Poster
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 15