FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Emirates | Skywards (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emirates-skywards-490/)
-   -   Op Upped...not (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emirates-skywards/1560021-op-upped-not.html)

Flywiz Mar 13, 2014 2:00 am

Op Upped...not
 
On a recent trip my return flight was in the evening. I was tracking availability and status the day before, and EF showed All Economy 0 and All Business 7. No First on this sector. So it looked as if Economy might get overbooked, and I reckoned my chances at 50-50 for an OpUp with my Gold status.

Morning of travel, my Economy pre-booked seat number disappeared from MMB. So I figured demand must be huge for Economy and hopeless for Business - why else would they OpUp 12 hours before flight time.

I checked MMB again at T-3, and my original seat had reappeared, EF showed all Business 0 and Economy 1.

In the lounge or On board, no business seats were available for upgrade.

Now I get that one of two things happened.

1. Lots of last minute Business customers turned up, or
2. Several Economy cancellations and I didn't make the cut for an OpUp. But that is unlikely since Business went full and I did see few others trying to upgrade with miles in the lounge and told it was full.

Be that as it may, and airlines do work in mysterious ways. But isn't it unusual that my seat number disappeared at T-12? Why would they start processing OpUps so early?

jackiedada Mar 13, 2014 2:37 am


Originally Posted by Flywiz (Post 22514946)
..Why would they start processing OpUps so early?

On heavily oversold flights they do that. Though all that comes to naught if a large group of Y pax fail to show up...

Havoc10G Mar 13, 2014 3:04 am

Op Upped...not
 
Maybe Y oversold so no seat available and no space in business so they offloaded a previously checked in non status passenger to give you a seat.

ukdoctor Mar 13, 2014 5:10 am

Something similar happened during a long layover in the DXB lounge. My connecting flight was full in Y and my seat number had disappeared. I was very happy and was waiting for the beep at the gate ( and for them to re print my boarding pass to J)

Sadly nothing happened and I was not opped up.

I don't check anymore and if I get an op up I just take it as a pleasant surprise .


PS: I did post about this incident which happened last year and some of the posters commented that I should have asked for a fresh boarding pass in the lounge itself. I'm not sure if that would have made a difference.:(

dubaiblue Mar 13, 2014 6:22 am

I had a flight in mid jan to LHR. As I seem to be doing way to much now, I was sitting in the lounge refreshing the mobile website looking at my booking and then bam seat went to none, big smile refreshed a few times still blank, went to gate, no beep for new boarding pass.

Got onto plane - it was EMPTY! No idea why my seat changed to empty.

But Ended up having a full row of 4 to myself and as I only wanted to sleep was kind of like an upgrade - seat was longer than even first class :)

jackiedada Mar 13, 2014 6:41 am

I had a similar incident in DXB on my last trip where I had a wait of almost 6 hours and noticed in BOM itself that the seat for my onward connection from DXB had gone to None. I went up to the F lounge attendant at DXB and requested for a new BP. They just commented that they couldn't view my seat. I waited for an hour and then as the shift changed, went up again to request a new BP. Again, they said that they couldn't view my new seat. Fortunately, when I went up to the gate I got an upgrade.

So my sense it that there might be a situation where they might have put you on a list for an op-up but not actually assigned you a seat in J, until last minute. Just a theory....

m3red Mar 13, 2014 7:35 am

you should all get the mobile boarding pass.

I clicked refresh on that in the lounge and watched it change from y to j on my recent Y trip to IST for both legs. Happened about t-45 and I then got new BP's printed.

Forget MMB that's not that reliable as we all can confirm.

ukdoctor Mar 13, 2014 7:58 am


Originally Posted by m3red (Post 22515965)
you should all get the mobile boarding pass.

I clicked refresh on that in the lounge and watched it change from y to j on my recent Y trip to IST for both legs. Happened about t-45 and I then got new BP's printed.

Forget MMB that's not that reliable as we all can confirm.

I've never used a mobile boarding pass. Can you have both mobile and paper boarding passes. The other issue is that mobile boarding passes are not accepted @DEL as everyone at the airport wants to put their stamp on it.:D

jackiedada Mar 13, 2014 8:05 am


Originally Posted by ukdoctor (Post 22516092)
I've never used a mobile boarding pass. Can you have both mobile and paper boarding passes. The other issue is that mobile boarding passes are not accepted @DEL as everyone at the airport wants to put their stamp on it.:D

At Indian airports its pretty much out of question. But even at JFK, I've not been able to get a mobile BP, maybe because my final destination in India?

Flywiz Mar 13, 2014 8:41 am


Originally Posted by m3red (Post 22515965)
you should all get the mobile boarding pass.

I clicked refresh on that in the lounge and watched it change from y to j on my recent Y trip to IST for both legs. Happened about t-45 and I then got new BP's printed.

Forget MMB that's not that reliable as we all can confirm.

Didn't know you could do that. Thanks for the tip...

m3red Mar 13, 2014 8:45 am


Originally Posted by jackiedada (Post 22516144)
At Indian airports its pretty much out of question. But even at JFK, I've not been able to get a mobile BP, maybe because my final destination in India?

I always do online check in and then get the bp by mobile. I then check in and get a boarding pass. I use the mobile bp just to check for op ups. It's literally real time!

Pretty cool.

Ozziebob Mar 13, 2014 9:28 pm


Originally Posted by m3red (Post 22515965)
you should all get the mobile boarding pass.

I clicked refresh on that in the lounge and watched it change from y to j on my recent Y trip to IST for both legs. Happened about t-45 and I then got new BP's printed.

Forget MMB that's not that reliable as we all can confirm.

I did this on the outward leg of my current trip M3RED and it worked well (thanks for the tip). Was in the F lounge at DXB, saw that the opup had come through and then went and got a new pass.

I continued on to DEL and as jackiedada states, this is not available in India, so you just have to wait and (hopefully) get surprised at the gate

ft101 Mar 13, 2014 10:39 pm


Originally Posted by Ozziebob (Post 22520648)
I continued on to DEL and as jackiedada states, this is not available in India, so you just have to wait and (hopefully) get surprised at the gate

You can still do it through the website, but don't do it through Manage A Booking.

Go to "Check In" again, even though you have already checked in. I can't remember the exact sequence, but as you progress through this you'll see your seat number and it will disappear if/when the upgrade happens.

This must be almost immediate as I entered the lounge in DXB a few months ago - no mention of upgrade. Within a few minutes I powered up my laptop and saw the changed seat info so headed back to the entrance and picked up a new Boarding Pass.

B747-437B Mar 13, 2014 10:46 pm

Or you can set up an Expertflyer alert for your already booked seat number. When they clear the seat to assign you a new one, it remains open for a brief moment until reassigned and Expertflyer will email you an alert notification. Works for me every time!

m3red Mar 13, 2014 11:25 pm


Originally Posted by B747-437B (Post 22520944)
Or you can set up an Expertflyer alert for your already booked seat number. When they clear the seat to assign you a new one, it remains open for a brief moment until reassigned and Expertflyer will email you an alert notification. Works for me every time!

That's a lot of effort though but an option where mobile bp isn't available.

eightblack Mar 13, 2014 11:58 pm


Originally Posted by B747-437B (Post 22520944)
Or you can set up an Expertflyer alert for your already booked seat number. When they clear the seat to assign you a new one, it remains open for a brief moment until reassigned and Expertflyer will email you an alert notification. Works for me every time!

Thats very clever. Never thought of it.

A351 Mar 14, 2014 12:03 am


Originally Posted by Flywiz (Post 22514946)
...
Morning of travel, my Economy pre-booked seat number disappeared from MMB. So I figured demand must be huge for Economy and hopeless for Business - why else would they OpUp 12 hours before flight time.

I checked MMB again at T-3, and my original seat had reappeared, EF showed all Business 0 and Economy 1.

In the lounge or On board, no business seats were available for upgrade.

Now I get that one of two things happened.

1. Lots of last minute Business customers turned up, or
2. Several Economy cancellations and I didn't make the cut for an OpUp. But that is unlikely since Business went full and I did see few others trying to upgrade with miles in the lounge and told it was full.

Going back to the original point of one’s seat disappearing and getting reassigned or initially assigned seat being empty when you get on the plane……
There’s another simple reason for the above….. change of equipment. When the aircraft is changed for capacity or an operational reason (e.g. from a 777-200 to 777-300ER or one type of A380 to another) (i) more seats will become available in Y and C and (ii) if the seat no you initially held is not available in the new aircraft, you may not get a seat assigned until you enter the lounge or get to the gate.

Flywiz Mar 14, 2014 1:20 am


Originally Posted by A351 (Post 22521128)
Going back to the original point of one’s seat disappearing and getting reassigned or initially assigned seat being empty when you get on the plane……
There’s another simple reason for the above….. change of equipment. When the aircraft is changed for capacity or an operational reason (e.g. from a 777-200 to 777-300ER or one type of A380 to another) (i) more seats will become available in Y and C and (ii) if the seat no you initially held is not available in the new aircraft, you may not get a seat assigned until you enter the lounge or get to the gate.

Good point. Wasn't the case in this instance though.

jackiedada Mar 14, 2014 2:11 am


Originally Posted by B747-437B (Post 22520944)
Or you can set up an Expertflyer alert for your already booked seat number. When they clear the seat to assign you a new one, it remains open for a brief moment until reassigned and Expertflyer will email you an alert notification. Works for me every time!

This may not be very reliable. EF have confirmed on this thread (Post#5) that they only check availability a couple of times a day and not every few minutes, it is quite likely that EF might not be checking during the time your seat becomes vacant. Though their comment was for Rewards availability and not seat availability, I would still doubt that for seat availability EF is 'event driven' and not 'polling' based. Nevertheless, I shall verify this on my next trip.
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emira...de-alerts.html

A351 Mar 17, 2014 3:50 am


Originally Posted by Flywiz (Post 22521316)
Good point. Wasn't the case in this instance though.

Then, the operations staff must have decided that they couldn't hold your flight for passengers from a connecting flight and off-loaded them!

This happens when:

The delayed flight was running a lot later than anticipated.

A connecting flight is put on 'hold' as it approached DXB and therefore passengers connecting won't make the connection in time.

A connecting flight was re-assigned a new gate at a different terminal to the original (e.g. from A to B) or off-gate parking (this could add a good 30 to 45 min delay)!

In the 'good old days', EK would have held the departing flight for passengers connecting from a delayed one but no more! If a departing flight is delayed, it will miss it's allocated take-off slot. Getting a new one will depend on not only the availability of a new one but also the landing slot at the destination based on the new arrival time. You can imagine the domino effect this will have!

You were very unlucky!

LE4603 Mar 18, 2014 5:16 am


Originally Posted by A351 (Post 22537232)
.....In the 'good old days', EK would have held the departing flight for passengers connecting from a delayed one but no more! If a departing flight is delayed, it will miss it's allocated take-off slot. Getting a new one will depend on not only the availability of a new one but also the landing slot at the destination based on the new arrival time. You can imagine the domino effect this will have!....

While I am sure this may sometimes be the case, it is definitely not always the case. I have been on a few flights that have been delayed for connecting passengers, the last one was a couple of months ago DXB-BHX, where the flight crew (during their normal welcome message) apologised for the late departure (about 20mins) of the plane, and confirmed it was due to waiting for some connecting passengers.

Am sure it doesn't always happen, but it definitely does happen sometimes.

Budley Mar 19, 2014 1:23 am

Very surprised on my recent trip to DUB (BKK-DXB-DUB-DXB-BKK). Was op-upped to J BKK-DXB and DXB-BKK and used miles to upgrade DUB-DXB.

So all in all very nice and I didn't bother checking in advance one little bit. Life's too short for that. But I was told on entry to the lounge in Terminal C, a couple of hours before the flight to BKK (a 380), that I had been op-upped

Que Sera, Sera.

ft101 Mar 19, 2014 1:16 pm


Originally Posted by Budley (Post 22549813)
Very surprised on my recent trip to DUB (BKK-DXB-DUB-DXB-BKK). Was op-upped to J BKK-DXB and DXB-BKK and used miles to upgrade DUB-DXB.

Quite amazing for someone who posted less than 5 weeks ago:


Originally Posted by Budley (Post 22352182)
I've been Skywards Gold for several years now, but with the continuing decimation of Skywards, I don't think I will bother to attain Gold (or even Silver) for next year (I have about 19,000 status miles so far this year, and no plans for further travel on EK).



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:59 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.