FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Nickel and Dimed. What would you do? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/1501896-nickel-dimed-what-would-you-do.html)

cblaisd Sep 14, 2013 8:13 am

Civility alert! :)

Posts deleted that were unnecessarily personalized.

cblaisd
Moderator, Dining Buzz

LarkSFO Sep 14, 2013 11:04 pm


Originally Posted by wpxstar (Post 21426072)
I'm with you on this. My pet peeve is that 20% is the "new norm". In my opinion, 15% on a large bill for only 3 people people is plenty. Now if it was a party of 5-6 and up, then there might be some upward wiggle room.

Also, in the OP's case, if he ordered 2 bottles of wine, I would deduct those out to some extent since I don't believe someone should be paid more simply bc they poured me a glass from an $80 bottle and not a $20 bottle.

The club soda charge was a bad case of nickle and diming imho. Not much can be done but it woudl effect my opinion of whether or not to return to that establishment.

End rant. :D

20% is the norm. Not the new norm (In the US).

Why is 15% OK on a 'large bill for only 3 people'?

And for those who think you do not need to tip 20% on expensive bottles of wine: Waiters and Waitresses need to 'tip out' all of the staff that assist and support them throughout their shift. All of these assistants (food runners / expediters, busboys, host staff, service bartender) know what your gross sales were for the evening, and the assumption is that you earned more or less 20% of that number in tips.

They get their share of that number as a part of the waitpersons 'tip out'.

If the waitperson consistently says 'I got stiffed by my customers', the assistants either assume they are lying, or an awful waitperson.

Either way, the waitperson gets less enthusiastic support from the team when they don't tip out on their full gross, which makes their ability to serve their customers more difficult.

Which makes our experience as customers less enjoyable.

So, tip well! :)

VivoPerLei Sep 14, 2013 11:33 pm


Originally Posted by LarkSFO (Post 21446570)
20% is the norm. Not the new norm (In the US).

Why is 15% OK on a 'large bill for only 3 people'?

And for those who think you do not need to tip 20% on expensive bottles of wine: Waiters and Waitresses need to 'tip out' all of the staff that assist and support them throughout their shift. All of these assistants (food runners / expediters, busboys, host staff, service bartender) know what your gross sales were for the evening, and the assumption is that you earned more or less 20% of that number in tips.

They get their share of that number as a part of the waitpersons 'tip out'.

If the waitperson consistently says 'I got stiffed by my customers', the assistants either assume they are lying, or an awful waitperson.

Either way, the waitperson gets less enthusiastic support from the team when they don't tip out on their full gross, which makes their ability to serve their customers more difficult.

Which makes our experience as customers less enjoyable.

So, tip well! :)

As long as tipping is arbitrary people can't be guilted into tipping more than what they feel is reasonable. If so many people depend on those tips something is wrong with the system. Make it mandatory then. I have no problem whatsoever with those restaurants in London that do so.

nerd Sep 14, 2013 11:45 pm


Originally Posted by LarkSFO (Post 21446570)
20% is the norm. Not the new norm (In the US).

And, speaking for the rest of us: Yes - 15% is still the norm (less if not earned, more if exceptionally so). ;)

CDTraveler Sep 15, 2013 12:37 am


Originally Posted by LarkSFO (Post 21446570)
20% is the norm. Not the new norm (In the US).

Only in the media is 20% the norm, and frankly I'm tired of "tip creep" because some new article says X% is what we should all be doing now or we're bad customers who don't appreciate how difficult life is for waitstaff.


Originally Posted by LarkSFO (Post 21446570)
So, tip well! :)

A tip is a reward for good to excellent service. I tip according to service received, and will continue to do so no matter what journalists and bloggers have to say about what percent they think we should be handing over without regard to the quality of the service.

uk1 Sep 15, 2013 2:05 am


Originally Posted by CDTraveler (Post 21446773)
Only in the media is 20% the norm, and frankly I'm tired of "tip creep" because some new article says X% is what we should all be doing now or we're bad customers who don't appreciate how difficult life is for waitstaff.

A tip is a reward for good to excellent service. I tip according to service received, and will continue to do so no matter what journalists and bloggers have to say about what percent they think we should be handing over without regard to the quality of the service.

^

blackdawn2 Sep 15, 2013 8:37 am

20% is NOT the new norm or I'm a Senator from Missouri :td: :mad:

LarkSFO Sep 15, 2013 9:03 am


Originally Posted by blackdawn2 (Post 21447822)
20% is NOT the new norm or I'm a Senator from Missouri :td: :mad:

Wow!

A Senator on FlyerTalk?

Blunt or McCaskill?

:)

Flubber2012 Sep 15, 2013 4:32 pm

Your were not nickle and dimed. You where charged for what you ordered. The waiter might have been able to comp you the carbonated water, he might not have.

In the US, tips are expected when you go to any table service restaurant.

You tipped 15%, what I consider to be the minimum.

Your were not nickle and dimed; the waiter was not stiffed.

What was the point of this post?

Flubber2012 Sep 15, 2013 4:37 pm


Originally Posted by blackdawn2 (Post 21447822)
20% is NOT the new norm or I'm a Senator from Missouri :td: :mad:

Get your head out of the stand.

I find it paradoxical that, in cheaper restaurants, 15% is the norm, resulting in a lower tip for the server. They might not have to perform as sophisticated a service, changing silverware, folding napkins, etc. but the check is usually fairly low. I tend to tip at least 20% at these places for that reason. If my tab is very low, I'll tip at least $3.

In higher priced places, 20% is the norm. If you won't pay that for a tip, please use the cheaper places (Denny's, Red Lobster, etc.).

As you go even higher, the expectation is over 20%.

You cheapskates may think otherwise but you're just being stingy.

That's how I roll.

squeakr Sep 15, 2013 5:07 pm

I tend to tip generously
 
But here in SF if the resto charges for Healthy SF separately, I tip more like 14-15% and not 18-20.

flyboy60 Sep 15, 2013 5:25 pm


Originally Posted by Flubber2012 (Post 21449654)
Get your head out of the stand.

I find it paradoxical that, in cheaper restaurants, 15% is the norm, resulting in a lower tip for the server. They might not have to perform as sophisticated a service, changing silverware, folding napkins, etc. but the check is usually fairly low. I tend to tip at least 20% at these places for that reason. If my tab is very low, I'll tip at least $3.

In higher priced places, 20% is the norm. If you won't pay that for a tip, please use the cheaper places (Denny's, Red Lobster, etc.).

As you go even higher, the expectation is over 20%.

You cheapskates may think otherwise but you're just being stingy.

That's how I roll.

[Removed quote of now-deleted material

Sorry, I tip 15-17% generally, and 20% for excellent or exceptional service. For poor service, I might drop it to 12%. And I'm happy to dine wherever I please.

And you can feel free to make up for my stinginess any time you wish - I'm fine with that. :D

cblaisd Sep 15, 2013 5:51 pm

Apparently the earlier note was not understood.

cblaisd
Moderator, Dining Buzz


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 3:31 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.