FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   How Much do you really eat at Buffets ? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/1237784-how-much-do-you-really-eat-buffets.html)

kipper Aug 2, 2011 11:51 am


Originally Posted by Kevin AA (Post 16844729)
I rarely eat at a buffet. I just can't eat enough to justify the price. I'm better off ala carte.

But the joy of a buffet is that you aren't limited to 1 or 2 items, like you usually are if you order ala carte. You can have little tastes of many different things, whereas if you order ala carte, due to the price, you're going to only want to order one or two items due to price.

martinfoss Aug 2, 2011 12:25 pm


Originally Posted by Kevin AA (Post 16844729)
I rarely eat at a buffet. I just can't eat enough to justify the price. I'm better off ala carte.

At the Hilton LAX, I was trying that, by ordering an omelet for breakfast. The waitress suggested i took the buffet, as I could also order the omelet as a part of the buffet.

So instead of the omelet and my orange juice, I had omelet, orange juice, some fruit and yoghurt - and saved a few bucks :cool:

Ancien Maestro Aug 2, 2011 6:33 pm


Originally Posted by kipper (Post 16844881)
But the joy of a buffet is that you aren't limited to 1 or 2 items, like you usually are if you order ala carte. You can have little tastes of many different things, whereas if you order ala carte, due to the price, you're going to only want to order one or two items due to price.

Selection at a buffet is a draw.. the continental if very few selections which happens rarely, I ordered a la carte..

So at Fairmont Newport I ordered Eggs Benedicts a la carte 3 days in a row.. Can't remember the last time I ordered a la carte.. but there was literraly nothing left on the continental the days I was interested.. eventually brought out more food so I could feed the kids.

Kevin AA Aug 2, 2011 11:55 pm


Originally Posted by kipper (Post 16844881)
But the joy of a buffet is that you aren't limited to 1 or 2 items, like you usually are if you order ala carte. You can have little tastes of many different things, whereas if you order ala carte, due to the price, you're going to only want to order one or two items due to price.

true, I had not thought of that

kipper Aug 3, 2011 6:01 am


Originally Posted by Ancien Maestro (Post 16847925)
Selection at a buffet is a draw.. the continental if very few selections which happens rarely, I ordered a la carte..

So at Fairmont Newport I ordered Eggs Benedicts a la carte 3 days in a row.. Can't remember the last time I ordered a la carte.. but there was literraly nothing left on the continental the days I was interested.. eventually brought out more food so I could feed the kids.

It depends on the type of buffet if we're discussing only breakfasts. If it's a continental breakfast, then usually, I won't opt for that. If it's a brunch buffet with all sorts of choices, I'll opt for the buffet, because I can sample a little of everything.

Originally Posted by Kevin AA (Post 16849351)
true, I had not thought of that

For example, if you go to brunch and are given the choice of ordering standard fare from a menu, or for $1 or $2 more than your selected menu item, are given the choice of the buffet that includes your selected item and several other options, you can have your selected item, but also sample many other items, without cost limitations. :)

CMK10 Aug 3, 2011 12:38 pm


Originally Posted by kipper (Post 16844881)
But the joy of a buffet is that you aren't limited to 1 or 2 items, like you usually are if you order ala carte. You can have little tastes of many different things, whereas if you order ala carte, due to the price, you're going to only want to order one or two items due to price.

True, but 99 times out of 100 I'd rather have Eggs Benedict than a whole bunch of other stuff. Now if there's Eggs Benny on said buffet (which is sadly quite rare) then I'll gladly follow your logic.

Jay71 Aug 3, 2011 3:53 pm

The last breakfast buffet I had, I think the buffet was cheaper than ordering a la carte. I'm not that big of a breakfast eater and the selection was limited so I think I only did three quarters of a plate.
However, it did have eggs benny. While I love eggs benny, it isn't as big of a draw for me in a buffet (ie. when the they have a bunch in a heating tray) because I find the yolk regularly ends up getting overcooked sitting there (I guess unless you time it right :) ).

uk1 Aug 4, 2011 9:13 am

Anyone interested in this topic and in the UK .... or are lucky enough to be in an airport lounge with a copy ...... might like to look at Alexie Sayle's wonderful article in The Times (UK) on his passion for All You Can Eat Buffets. It's one of the funniest articles I've read. Also online on their subscription site - "How I fell in love with all you can eat bufffets ..."

It's worth the £1 trial subscription alone .....

Ancien Maestro Aug 5, 2011 2:41 am


Originally Posted by kipper (Post 16850316)
It depends on the type of buffet if we're discussing only breakfasts. If it's a continental breakfast, then usually, I won't opt for that. If it's a brunch buffet with all sorts of choices, I'll opt for the buffet, because I can sample a little of everything.

I never do continentals.. (paid continentals)

Almost paid for one at the Fairmont Newport Beach but at the last second, I ended up ordering A la carte, which I usually never do at a Fairmont neither..

kipper Aug 5, 2011 7:12 am


Originally Posted by Ancien Maestro (Post 16863524)
I never do continentals.. (paid continentals)

Almost paid for one at the Fairmont Newport Beach but at the last second, I ended up ordering A la carte, which I usually never do at a Fairmont neither..

That's about how I feel. I don't do paid continental breakfast buffets. :)

Ancien Maestro Aug 6, 2011 2:37 am


Originally Posted by kipper (Post 16864280)
That's about how I feel. I don't do paid continental breakfast buffets. :)

There is a market for continentals I don't understand.. I should ask my wife because she preferred having the continental at Newport Beach..

mookie10 Aug 6, 2011 6:24 am


Originally Posted by Peterpack (Post 16741840)
Everyone loves the idea of all you can eat, but how much do you really eat at buffets ?

I usually eat 1 plate of seafood, 2 plates of hot mains and 2 plates of desserts

2 plates of main and a dessert would be the norm - tend to go more for the quality than quantity these days, although the waist line doesn't back this up... :(

notsosmart Aug 6, 2011 8:48 am

Only time I ever eat at buffets is in Vegas (and I don't really like them) or brunch in Asia (every chance I ever get, and I like them very much ^ ^ ).

Gaucho100K Aug 6, 2011 8:58 am

In my experience, it is correct to avoid Buffets like the plague unless you are going to a high-end Hotel with the proper track record for Brunch/Buffet services and are willing to pay accordingly. I also tend to select a venue where they have free flowing Champagne from a house that I approve of, as these events for me will almost always mean the only meal of the day and at least 2 bottles of the sparkler being consumed.

Singapore is one place where I would go to one of these types of events as they have a history of quality & consistency, etc.

Eastbay1K Aug 6, 2011 12:23 pm


Originally Posted by Gaucho100K (Post 16870668)
In my experience, it is correct to avoid Buffets like the plague unless you are going to a high-end Hotel with the proper track record for Brunch/Buffet services and are willing to pay accordingly.

Even then, they are rarely excellent. They can be very good, however.

At least in the US, most / all the seafood (as someone mentioned above as being a reason to go) is usually not much better than average - snow crab legs (pre-frozen and watery), farmed shrimp, etc etc. Otherwise, the buffet would be $100+ pp.

If I go to a few buffets a year, it is a lot. 2 plates, plus dessert of some sort. There used to be a great Chinese buffet close to where I lived years ago - no, don't scream. It was a little restaurant, it was Friday only, and they were constantly bringing out small portions of freshly cooked food, and not 30 things to choose from. Then they expanded, became all buffet all the time, and xxxxxxxx, stopped going.

Alpha Aug 6, 2011 9:45 pm

I was in east Texas working on a lawsuit not long ago and I saw a restaurant offering an all you can eat catfish buffet with free wifi. Blew my mind. (I didn't go).

RichardInSF Aug 7, 2011 10:12 pm

Today's history lesson: It's a little known fact that the 23rd amendment to the constitution of the US requires all Indian restaurants to have a lunch buffet.

Ancien Maestro Aug 8, 2011 12:44 am

Any opposition to the all you care to eat style, where they serve you food at request..

Just came back from Disneyland, and we ate at Big Thunder Ranch twice in Frontier Land.. not a buffet, but the food kept coming and coming and coming..

Or does most everyone here prefer Goofy's Kitchen?

emma69 Aug 8, 2011 1:31 pm


Originally Posted by RichardInSF (Post 16878538)
Today's history lesson: It's a little known fact that the 23rd amendment to the constitution of the US requires all Indian restaurants to have a lunch buffet.

I don't mind an Indian buffet as long as it is packed (preferably with Indians!) I've been taken to a few dives (you know, in dubious strip malls, sandwiched between a phone unlocking place and an adult video store) that I would never have stopped at on my own. They have been excellent, constant stream of food coming out (and being hoovered up!), tons of fresh naan straight from the oven - fantastic! Then I've been to what I consider good Indian restaurants, that happen to do buffet rather than a la carte at lunch - and I have never been back to those places for lunch (the supper menu OTOH is great!)

darthbimmer Aug 8, 2011 1:51 pm


Originally Posted by RichardInSF (Post 16878538)
Today's history lesson: It's a little known fact that the 23rd amendment to the constitution of the US requires all Indian restaurants to have a lunch buffet.

I was among the small minority, probably less than 10%, of the US public who simply assumed that the 23rd amendment gave Washington, D.C. electoral votes in presidential elections, but then I thought about it -- I truly have never been to an Indian restaurant that lacks a buffet -- so it must be true!

Ancien Maestro Aug 9, 2011 1:41 am


Originally Posted by emma69 (Post 16882781)
I don't mind an Indian buffet as long as it is packed (preferably with Indians!) I've been taken to a few dives (you know, in dubious strip malls, sandwiched between a phone unlocking place and an adult video store) that I would never have stopped at on my own. They have been excellent, constant stream of food coming out (and being hoovered up!), tons of fresh naan straight from the oven - fantastic! Then I've been to what I consider good Indian restaurants, that happen to do buffet rather than a la carte at lunch - and I have never been back to those places for lunch (the supper menu OTOH is great!)

Ate at an Indian buffet for lunch today..

No indians to be seen.. but for very good reason.. Ramadan is happening as we speak..

RobbieRunner Aug 9, 2011 4:18 am

I really watch my diet and exercise.

I still go to "All you can eat" buffets since I can be choosy about what I get, and get it quickly.

I eat one plate of salad. One plate of hot food. Not heaping.
And I watch the carbs. Maybe 1 spoonful of desert just for a treat.

For me, it's a quick meal with convenience. Not a reason to eat like a pig.

emma69 Aug 9, 2011 1:12 pm


Originally Posted by Ancien Maestro (Post 16886233)
Ate at an Indian buffet for lunch today..

No indians to be seen.. but for very good reason.. Ramadan is happening as we speak..

Aren't the majority of Indian people Hindu?

CMK10 Aug 9, 2011 3:38 pm


Originally Posted by emma69 (Post 16889707)
Aren't the majority of Indian people Hindu?

Probably. Mr. Maestro has an affinity for the occasional non sequitor :cool:

Ancien Maestro Aug 9, 2011 11:49 pm


Originally Posted by emma69 (Post 16889707)
Aren't the majority of Indian people Hindu?

I'm about as inept telling culture as I am speaking their language..:eek:

That's what the waitress told me, why the restaurant at lunch was unusually empty.. everyone is fasting.. and likely because of Ramadan, they'll show up for supper after their modified Ramadan..

Calgary has longer days.. that is why the modified Ramadan..

emma69 Nov 4, 2011 8:36 am


Originally Posted by dobolina (Post 17390708)
Unless you need to binge eat, buffets are not the way to go. You are going to overeat, or not overeat and then overpay, and also risk eating food that is not freshly prepared. Small plates are the way to go.

You only overpay for a buffet if the price is higher than you would pay for what you eat a la carte. I've often found buffet breakfasts to be a good bet outside of North America, where coffee / juice refills are not standard - a couple of glasses of grapefruit juice (at a couple of pounds each), a couple of coffees (at a couple of pounds each), maybe a croissant with jam (4 pounds perhaps) and a bowl of fresh fruit (5 pounds perhaps), or scrambled eggs with toast and a couple of grilled tomatoes (12 pounds on the bill in my wallet), soon means that if there is an 'all in' buffet price of, say, 15 pounds, it can work out good value.

Ancien Maestro Nov 4, 2011 6:51 pm


Originally Posted by emma69 (Post 17390749)
You only overpay for a buffet if the price is higher than you would pay for what you eat a la carte. I've often found buffet breakfasts to be a good bet outside of North America, where coffee / juice refills are not standard - a couple of glasses of grapefruit juice (at a couple of pounds each), a couple of coffees (at a couple of pounds each), maybe a croissant with jam (4 pounds perhaps) and a bowl of fresh fruit (5 pounds perhaps), or scrambled eggs with toast and a couple of grilled tomatoes (12 pounds on the bill in my wallet), soon means that if there is an 'all in' buffet price of, say, 15 pounds, it can work out good value.

Generally, I find Fairmont hotels to price the a la carte higher, so that their buffets look like a reasonable deal..

I don't mind paying more for a buffet than what is normal consumption, simply for better selection.. but I would agree, there are some buffets where offerings are little value for the price charged..


Originally Posted by General_Flyer (Post 17394307)
I can't stop eating when I'm in a Buffet.. Back home, Shangri-La, Sheraton, and other hotels do these kinds of sunday brunch buffets, and their seafood selections are off the charts!

I've had to learn to stop before I'm totally full at buffets..

I grew up thinking that to get my money's worth, is to stuff yourself until you drop..

It worked in my younger years, but now that I'm 36, its not a great idea to overeat.. or finish everything that's on my plate..

General_Flyer Nov 4, 2011 7:15 pm

I can't stop eating when I'm in a Buffet.. Back home, Shangri-La, Sheraton, and other hotels do these kinds of sunday brunch buffets, and their seafood selections are off the charts!

tcl Nov 7, 2011 9:53 pm

I love European hotel breakfast buffets because I can eat what I was hoping to be able to eat whilst in Europe :D Plus, depending on my jetlag, sometimes I really do want pickled-stuffed-herring at 6am :p These buffets are generally of a high quality and I can eat as much as I'm hungry which varies according to my jetlag.

Asian afternoon tea buffets or Sunday brunch buffets with a carving station, egg station and seafood station are also at the top of my list as the food is always fresh and there is a good selection of both sweet and savory dishes. Again, I like the high quality and the mix of sweet and savory because I'm usually jetlagged to some point. At these higher-end buffets, the staff keep on eye on the food and will remove something if people are sticking their fingers in and getting gross about it.

I find regular run-of-the-mill buffets gross due to the double dipping factor. Plus the lower quality of food and incorrect holding temperatures just beg for a severe case of food poisoning. :td:

& while I'm on my rant, the grossest thing on a buffet table is the chocolate fountain. The very nature of the fountain has people sticking their sticky fingers into the chocolate. Ew!

sophiegirl Nov 12, 2011 6:35 am

Lunch and Dinner - rarely to never. And the rarely is only when someone else has selected and is paying, or am at a wedding or other social event.

Breakfast - often at hotels because that is what is most included with rate.

Brunch - not as often as I would like. I love to research great brunch buffets and enjoy with friends.

Does anyone have recommendations? :D

Orchids Nov 12, 2011 7:42 am

Park 75 at Four Seasons Atlanta. Lovely setting, get an early seating on holidays.

WildPlumYonder Nov 12, 2011 8:50 am

Unless it's a breakfast buffet at a hotel away from home, I don't eat at buffets. Even at the expensive ones, steam table food is steam-table food. Overcooked, and either soggy or dried out.

sophiegirl Nov 12, 2011 2:27 pm


Originally Posted by Orchids (Post 17436821)
Park 75 at Four Seasons Atlanta. Lovely setting, get an early seating on holidays.

Thank you. We are in ATL frequently and this is good to know....

Ancien Maestro Nov 12, 2011 4:05 pm

Just came back from Saturday Brunch (and we'll do the Sunday Brunch) at Fairmont Banff Springs Hotel..

Superb offerings at the Bow Valley Grill.. $43 per adult.. highly recommended.^

musicsic Nov 17, 2011 5:07 am

Honestly, about 4 plates which usually have pasta, shrimp, Alaskan king crab legs, prime rib, etc. Usually no salads, soups, fruits or anything healthy. Then about 2 or more plates of dessert, always getting the crêpes and several dishes of crème brûlée as well.

Whenever I'm visiting friends in CA, we usually eat at Choices, The Buffet at Pala Casino and we see who can eat the most. :D

Sure my friends and I feel horrible afterwards, but to us, that's the whole point of eating at a buffet.

Jaimito Cartero Nov 17, 2011 5:23 am


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie (Post 16755969)

Sorry you had a bad experience at the Do you attended, it hopefully should not dissuade any FT'er from experiencing one for themselves.

I've been to quite a few do's and other FF events and everyone has always been considerate during meal time. I'd say if uk1 doesn't like buffets, not to participate.

I love dim sum buffets in Asia. I had one in Jakarta last month. $7 for great shrimp, scallops and cuttlefish items, plus roasted duck and a lot of other good stuff.

Many generic US buffets are garbage. Home Town buffet is hideous. I used to go to Furr's cafeteria, but they closed most of them down. The Wynn in Vegas is quite nice. Also had an excellent one in New Orleans, one of big hotels, for Sunday brunch, and I still remember the food 15 years later.

Jaimito Cartero Nov 17, 2011 5:28 am


Originally Posted by Gaucho100K (Post 16870668)
In my experience, it is correct to avoid Buffets like the plague unless you are going to a high-end Hotel with the proper track record for Brunch/Buffet services and are willing to pay accordingly. I also tend to select a venue where they have free flowing Champagne from a house that I approve of, as these events for me will almost always mean the only meal of the day and at least 2 bottles of the sparkler being consumed.

One of my favorite continental breakfast buffets was at the EZE PH. Top quality on everything, and then as a Hyatt diamond getting a hot dish too.

Ancien Maestro Nov 17, 2011 11:12 pm

[QUOTE=Jaimito Cartero;17466699]..
I love dim sum buffets in Asia. I had one in Jakarta last month. $7 for great shrimp, scallops and cuttlefish items, plus roasted duck and a lot of other good stuff.
..QUOTE]

There is a nice dim sum buffet in a restaurant at the Calgary Chinese Cultural Centre..

Weekdays are a great price.. parking is super expensive though..

CBear Nov 18, 2011 2:48 pm

Buffets are totally wasted on me.
One plate and dessert.

Back in my waitressing days, we ran a friday lunch "buffet." Basically roast beef, mashed potatoes and gravy, rolls and various salads. Very popular with the run and eat crowd since you can be in and out 40 mins max.

I'll still go have a quick lunch with my hubby there once in a while.

GRALISTAIR Dec 15, 2011 4:02 pm

People who let their kids really waste food pi---s me off. They are "All you can eat" buffets - not "All you can waste"


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:08 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.