FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Shake Shack vs In N Out (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/1236736-shake-shack-vs-n-out.html)

gaobest Dec 9, 2024 2:23 pm

I love Super Duper that if my family is at one of the major chains then I just won’t eat there. I’ll sit & wait.

ElevatorEnthusiast Dec 10, 2024 1:25 am

The chicken sandwiches at Shake Shack locations in East and Southeast Asia really are something else. Such great chicken - especially in Japan. Definitely exceeds the quality of the Chicken Shacks in the US.

Eastbay1K Dec 10, 2024 8:02 am


Originally Posted by ElevatorEnthusiast (Post 36727555)
The chicken sandwiches at Shake Shack locations in East and Southeast Asia really are something else. Such great chicken - especially in Japan. Definitely exceeds the quality of the Chicken Shacks in the US.

The chicken sandwiches (and I've tried a few) have been disappointing.

ILuvParis Dec 10, 2024 9:26 am


Originally Posted by mcditolla (Post 16793800)
Hate to admit it as a So-Cal, but Shake Shack is better. Grew up eating In n Out so it still is the comfort food out of the two, but SS wins.

Wonder if they will make it to the West Coast before In makes it to the east. FWIW, Thomas Keller digs In n Out and will even serve it at staff functions.


Far better, but admittedly, very expensive. Chase frequently has 10% off deals with certain credit and debit cards, which helps a bit. (But, aren't there several Shake Shacks in the LA area?)

work2fly Dec 10, 2024 9:34 am

I've been less than impressed with Shake Shack as compared to In-N-Out, but I've only been to one location, so maybe that's why. I can usually find a BOGO burger special on Uber Eats.

mjm Dec 10, 2024 9:38 am

Shake Shack's fries are far superior, but the burgers at In 'n' Out are miles ahead.

gaobest Dec 10, 2024 2:53 pm


Originally Posted by mjm (Post 36728366)
Shake Shack's fries are far superior, but the burgers at In 'n' Out are miles ahead.

super duper in sf is so good that I just eschew both chains. That said I tend to only get a cheeseburger at original joes and that is maximum monthly and maybe 4-8 times a year. I love cheeseburgers and have a caloric fear of eating even a 4-oz sized burger.

meijiem Dec 10, 2024 6:26 pm


Originally Posted by pseudoswede (Post 36726097)
We went to Shake Shack last weekend. Five burgers, three fries, and two shakes. 75 bleepin' dollars! In-N-Out would've been half that price. Yes, SS burgers and fries are better, but I'm not sure if they're worth twice the price. SS burgers are also the same size, if not slightly smaller, than In-N-Out burgers now.

I think shake shack burgers are smaller diameter but denser and still more hefty. At least, the Calorie load sure feels higher! 😋

Eastbay1K Dec 10, 2024 9:41 pm


Originally Posted by mjm (Post 36728366)
Shake Shack's fries are far superior, but the burgers at In 'n' Out are miles ahead.

Glad you still remember what miles are ;). I'll definitely agree with you on the fries. Burger? They're different and I give the Shake Shack an edge . But the honest truth (sad but one must emphasize that the truth is honest these days) is that over my lifetime, I doubt I've had more than a dozen of either.
​​​​​

​​​​​​

mjm Dec 10, 2024 11:53 pm


Originally Posted by Eastbay1K (Post 36729808)
Glad you still remember what miles are ;). I'll definitely agree with you on the fries. Burger? They're different and I give the Shake Shack an edge . But the honest truth (sad but one must emphasize that the truth is honest these days) is that over my lifetime, I doubt I've had more than a dozen of either.
​​​​​

​​​​​​

Who? The Who. I Can See For Miles and miles and miles...... ;)

Yeah it is not a world class burger, neither is really. For really great burgers, curiously Tokyo has the best I have ever had due to seeking to imitate then elevate. Still California has a distinct edge on burgers (given our BBQ outside 361 days a year weather) over anything out of the East Coast. At least it is not that smash style of the Shake Shack. Really, really do not get the appeal of the sloppiness of that style. And I think in fact they are not even seeking that. All the grease makes it fall apart perhaps. My OCD run rampant I guess.

Eastbay1K Dec 11, 2024 9:03 am


Originally Posted by mjm (Post 36729997)
Who? The Who. I Can See For Miles and miles and miles...... ;)

Yeah it is not a world class burger, neither is really. For really great burgers, curiously Tokyo has the best I have ever had due to seeking to imitate then elevate. Still California has a distinct edge on burgers (given our BBQ outside 361 days a year weather) over anything out of the East Coast. At least it is not that smash style of the Shake Shack. Really, really do not get the appeal of the sloppiness of that style. And I think in fact they are not even seeking that. All the grease makes it fall apart perhaps. My OCD run rampant I guess.

I'll eat either, as well as Habit, for a convenient quick meal, especially if someone else makes the suggestion and I don't want to be the naysayer. (I'd most likely be picking something local and more interesting - but even then, I'll sometimes succumb to one of the big chains, especially if some adult beverage or another needs some quick absorption ;) ) Meanwhile, In N Out reminds me of Coors when I was growing up. (Now, you're thinking, where could EB1K possibly be going with this?) Coors was once a regional western beer and when relatives would visit from parts east, they'd have to go get themselves some Coors. I probably tasted it first when I was a single digit age and my opinion of it never changed - but it was a thing to do when traveling west. In N Out is the same thing - like a cult pilgrimage, although tastier, and can make for a nice layover activity near LAX or SFO. I doubt you'll ever see "runs" to Shake Shack as an airport layover activity.

work2fly Dec 11, 2024 9:36 am

Better Coors than Oly :D

That was some nasty beer that didn't deserve wider distribution.

ElevatorEnthusiast Dec 11, 2024 9:42 am


Originally Posted by Eastbay1K (Post 36730811)
I'll eat either, as well as Habit, for a convenient quick meal, especially if someone else makes the suggestion and I don't want to be the naysayer. (I'd most likely be picking something local and more interesting - but even then, I'll sometimes succumb to one of the big chains, especially if some adult beverage or another needs some quick absorption ;) ) Meanwhile, In N Out reminds me of Coors when I was growing up. (Now, you're thinking, where could EB1K possibly be going with this?) Coors was once a regional western beer and when relatives would visit from parts east, they'd have to go get themselves some Coors. I probably tasted it first when I was a single digit age and my opinion of it never changed - but it was a thing to do when traveling west. In N Out is the same thing - like a cult pilgrimage, although tastier, and can make for a nice layover activity near LAX or SFO. I doubt you'll ever see "runs" to Shake Shack as an airport layover activity.

I ran to Shake Shack in the Singapore Changi Airport Jewel as an airport layover activity, so YMMV...

SPN Lifer Dec 13, 2024 4:58 am


Originally Posted by Eastbay1K (Post # 26) (Post 36730811)
Coors was once a regional western beer and when relatives would visit from parts east, they'd have to go get themselves some Coors. I probably tasted it first when I was a single digit age and my opinion of it never changed - but it was a thing to do when traveling west. In N Out is the same thing - like a cult pilgrimage, although tastier, and can make for a nice layover activity near LAX or SFO.

As a Midshipman First Class returning to Annapolis after our winter break, I brought back four six-packs of Coors in a seabag. One can somehow opened enroute to BAL (as BWI was called in those days), but the other 23 cans were popular at our monthly First Class (senior) dinner with the USNA 32nd Company Officer. :cool: 🍺

Keowns900 Dec 13, 2024 8:00 pm

In and Out Fries are only tolerable when you have the "Extra Well Done" Even then they are pretty naff. I like In and out burgers as they have a healthy dose on onions which I love.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:23 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.