Delta Q&A Meeting with Execs - NOTES
#16
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: LAX/BOS/HKG/AMS/SFO...hmm, I need a life.
Programs: United1K, AA ExPlAAt, DL MM/Gold, Hilton Diamond, Avis First
Posts: 13,316
Yes, and for all the folks here who were worried that the customers at the event would hurt DL's feelings...um, DL is acknowledging that there are issues just as one would expect. "Public Delta Bashing"? It is the public who pays DL and the Public who, I am sure DL execs will tell you, SHOULD point out loudly what is wrong. The alternative is for the public to quietly go away and that is exactly what DL does not want.
#17
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Under an ORD approach path
Programs: DL PM, MM. Coffee isn't a drug, it's a vitamin.
Posts: 12,935
Wirelessly posted (Propel: SAMSUNG-SGH-I617/1.0 Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows CE; IEMobile 7.6))
IIRC, the word "outrageous" was Richard Anderson's, so it really is a major technical issue to fix it.
IIRC, the word "outrageous" was Richard Anderson's, so it really is a major technical issue to fix it.
#18
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2008
Programs: Formaldehyde Medallion DL DieMiles
Posts: 12,646
Was there any indication that DL management now appreciates that substantive, mid-year devaluations of the FF program (i.e., removing benefits that someone spent a year qualifying for) is not a way to win friends and influence loyalty (other than in the wrong direction)?
#19
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 1,604
Count me as one of those that has quietly gone away.
After being a NW Plat since 2004 (and coming up on 2,000,000 BIS miles since I joined WP in 1983) I just came to the conclusion that DL simply did not want my business.
As any MBA will tell you, when you have bad news:
1) Tell it all
2) Tell it fast
3) Be honest with the customer from the get-go
Delta did none of this.
As so many people here have pointed out, all Delta had to do was send out a letter (no email) stating:
1) DL has had to look at new and different ways to generate revenue to stay in business, including various fees for revenue and non-revenue tickets
2) Skymiles generates substantial revenue, both from selling miles and generating fees
3) We do not wish to alienate our best customers, so we are looking for ways to reduce or eliminate the negative impact on our current Platinum DL/NW members. This will likely include the addition of a 4th higher level tier that will include most of the benefits that DL/NW Platinum members used to enjoy, along with some additional benefits that Platinum Elites should find desirable.
We appreciate your continuing loyalty to Delta ... blah, blah.
I think a letter like this would have eliminated most of the anger and silent hostility .. and there would not have been all of those NW threads about status matching to other carriers (which a lot of us have done, myself included) or how many miles we burned off at Perksaver levels before the big devaluation came (again, myself included).
All in all, very sad, as it appears that JeffBob et al is starting to get the message, but it seems a little late.
After being a NW Plat since 2004 (and coming up on 2,000,000 BIS miles since I joined WP in 1983) I just came to the conclusion that DL simply did not want my business.
As any MBA will tell you, when you have bad news:
1) Tell it all
2) Tell it fast
3) Be honest with the customer from the get-go
Delta did none of this.
As so many people here have pointed out, all Delta had to do was send out a letter (no email) stating:
1) DL has had to look at new and different ways to generate revenue to stay in business, including various fees for revenue and non-revenue tickets
2) Skymiles generates substantial revenue, both from selling miles and generating fees
3) We do not wish to alienate our best customers, so we are looking for ways to reduce or eliminate the negative impact on our current Platinum DL/NW members. This will likely include the addition of a 4th higher level tier that will include most of the benefits that DL/NW Platinum members used to enjoy, along with some additional benefits that Platinum Elites should find desirable.
We appreciate your continuing loyalty to Delta ... blah, blah.
I think a letter like this would have eliminated most of the anger and silent hostility .. and there would not have been all of those NW threads about status matching to other carriers (which a lot of us have done, myself included) or how many miles we burned off at Perksaver levels before the big devaluation came (again, myself included).
All in all, very sad, as it appears that JeffBob et al is starting to get the message, but it seems a little late.
Last edited by Orwaid; Jun 28, 2009 at 3:46 pm Reason: spelling
#20
Suspended
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: SEA
Programs: UA Silver, BA Gold, DL Gold
Posts: 9,779
Thanks for the update. Not sure there is anything earth-shattering, but I appreciate the focus given to the PMUs. I'm not among the crowd that considers them worthless, but would certainly welcome any extra flexibility/savings I can get.
#21
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: MSP
Programs: Fallen Plats, ex-WN CP, DYKWIW; still a Hilton Diamond & Club Cholula™ R.I.P. Super Plats
Posts: 25,415
SHOULD point out loudly what is wrong
In terms of making my points & getting my answers, I feel that I succeeded 100%. I distributed 60 copies of The Merger as Viewed by NW Frequent Flyers on the tables prior to the meeting. I did it this way to avoid wasting any floor time getting bogged down in details. Anyone who was interested could read it. Most people were reading it. Jeff appeared to be reading it.
Jeff's presentation was largely directed at the subject (FF program integration) that I wanted to hear about. I don't have to like the results, but I definitely got my explanations. I took notes on items of interest to NW elites & posted them on NW forum immediately after the Q&A.
Bottom line is, (1) they already know we're unhappy, (2) we now better understand why they made us unhappy, and (3) they're unlikely to do much, if anything, to make us happier.
We also had a lot of fun for 3 days.
Is there anything I should add to this?
#22
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: VPS
Programs: DL DM/2MM, Etihad Gold, HHonors Diamond, SPG Gold
Posts: 4,787
In terms of making my points & getting my answers, I feel that I succeeded 100%. I distributed 60 copies of The Merger as Viewed by NW Frequent Flyers on the tables prior to the meeting. I did it this way to avoid wasting any floor time getting bogged down in details. Anyone who was interested could read it. Most people were reading it. Jeff appeared to be reading it.
Jeff's presentation was largely directed at the subject (FF program integration) that I wanted to hear about. I don't have to like the results, but I definitely got my explanations. I took notes on items of interest to NW elites & posted them on NW forum immediately after the Q&A.
Bottom line is, (1) they already know we're unhappy, (2) we now better understand why they made us unhappy, and (3) they're unlikely to do much, if anything, to make us happier.
Jeff's presentation was largely directed at the subject (FF program integration) that I wanted to hear about. I don't have to like the results, but I definitely got my explanations. I took notes on items of interest to NW elites & posted them on NW forum immediately after the Q&A.
Bottom line is, (1) they already know we're unhappy, (2) we now better understand why they made us unhappy, and (3) they're unlikely to do much, if anything, to make us happier.
#23
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: LAX/BOS/HKG/AMS/SFO...hmm, I need a life.
Programs: United1K, AA ExPlAAt, DL MM/Gold, Hilton Diamond, Avis First
Posts: 13,316
Have to disagree here. First & foremost, this was a FlyerTalk DO. We're there to meet new people, make new friends, have fun & party. Anybody who's there to to rock the boat will find him/herself ostracized & out on the sidewalk while the party continues.
In terms of making my points & getting my answers, I feel that I succeeded 100%. I distributed 60 copies of The Merger as Viewed by NW Frequent Flyers on the tables prior to the meeting. I did it this way to avoid wasting any floor time getting bogged down in details. Anyone who was interested could read it. Most people were reading it. Jeff appeared to be reading it.
Jeff's presentation was largely directed at the subject (FF program integration) that I wanted to hear about. I don't have to like the results, but I definitely got my explanations. I took notes on items of interest to NW elites & posted them on NW forum immediately after the Q&A.
Bottom line is, (1) they already know we're unhappy, (2) we now better understand why they made us unhappy, and (3) they're unlikely to do much, if anything, to make us happier.
We also had a lot of fun for 3 days.
Is there anything I should add to this?
In terms of making my points & getting my answers, I feel that I succeeded 100%. I distributed 60 copies of The Merger as Viewed by NW Frequent Flyers on the tables prior to the meeting. I did it this way to avoid wasting any floor time getting bogged down in details. Anyone who was interested could read it. Most people were reading it. Jeff appeared to be reading it.
Jeff's presentation was largely directed at the subject (FF program integration) that I wanted to hear about. I don't have to like the results, but I definitely got my explanations. I took notes on items of interest to NW elites & posted them on NW forum immediately after the Q&A.
Bottom line is, (1) they already know we're unhappy, (2) we now better understand why they made us unhappy, and (3) they're unlikely to do much, if anything, to make us happier.
We also had a lot of fun for 3 days.
Is there anything I should add to this?
Yes, and for all the folks here who were worried that the customers at the event would hurt DL's feelings...um, DL is acknowledging that there are issues just as one would expect. "Public Delta Bashing"?
Mike, I did not mean "loudly" at the event itself...and my point was that it is an unfounded fear that the event would be an angry mob there to "bash" DL. I was trying to point out that the "loud" complaints here on FT are what do eventually get to the AL management. I point to the decision earlier this year to reverse a program change, driven (IMHO) by the "loudness" here on FT. There is nothing wrong with voicing our opinions here as that is what the FT board is for and eventually it gets heard by DL. I think there are folks here who equate the complaints here with "Bashing" and I argue it is not at all...it is honesty.
Last edited by avidflyer; Jun 28, 2009 at 5:44 pm
#24
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Under an ORD approach path
Programs: DL PM, MM. Coffee isn't a drug, it's a vitamin.
Posts: 12,935
CEO and Senior Leader Review of Program benefits, line by line
Direction from CEOs to pursue Best of Best Program which would have resulted in $200M in dis-synergies
Recommended Best in Class, while trying to offset some of the $200M in dis-synergies
1. Fee Huge revenue impact ($160M swing) in whether we take DL or NW fee structure:
- Not a top 10 customer benefit or primary purchase
Make the difficult decision to increase the NW fee structure rather than find financial benefit in other more valuable benefits (e.g. upgrades) DL will not abolish the unlimited complementary upgrade benefit customer benefit outweighs the financial benefit.
Direction from CEOs to pursue Best of Best Program which would have resulted in $200M in dis-synergies
Recommended Best in Class, while trying to offset some of the $200M in dis-synergies
1. Fee Huge revenue impact ($160M swing) in whether we take DL or NW fee structure:
- Not a top 10 customer benefit or primary purchase
Make the difficult decision to increase the NW fee structure rather than find financial benefit in other more valuable benefits (e.g. upgrades) DL will not abolish the unlimited complementary upgrade benefit customer benefit outweighs the financial benefit.
To expand on your point above... this is based on my flawed memory, hope I got the gist of it correct. Right from the start Anderson asked Jeff and Bob to prepare a comparison chart of every feature in the SM and WP programs, and how they stacked up to the industry. The chart was about 5 pages long, complete and detailed. They started by trying to pick the best in each category, but hit snags. Some were due to delta's rez system not having the hooks on which to hang some NW features (and if they chose NW's rez system, it would have been the same problem with DL features)... the cost and time of allocating resources to change that just doesn't hunt.
As to the change fees, they wanted to get rid of those, till they saw the numbers. Those fees generate a huge amount of money for DL, the biggest chunk of the $160M that me4yankees refers to. If they eliminated that income, they'd have to balance with lots of other changes to make up the difference, and, as mentioned, that isn't in the top 10 of concerns in customer surveys. It's only a very small percentage of customers who make multiple changes to award itins.
Those changes are costly. When you cancel or change an award ticket, the flights you release do NOT go back into award inventory. They go into general inventory, which the computer then divvies up and allocates to whichever fare bucket it chooses. So, you've removed both the original and your new seat from the total award availability. Change again, and another seat gets taken out of the award system. Book seats with the intention of changing, and you're taking away availability from others. That is a contributing factor (maybe a small one, but it is) to the perceived poor availability.
Why doesn't the released seat go back into award availability? Because at any given time, they want the computer to assess demand and allocate seating accordingly. We don't like it, but it makes sense from a business/revenue standpoint, especially for a company with such thin margins and high operational costs.
Hope this clarifies some things, and also gives you a sense of how open and detailed Jeff, Josh and Bob were in their presentation.
#25
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Brooklyn, NY
Programs: DL DM; UA; AA
Posts: 446
Here's to hoping we hear some good news in this department before too long.
#26
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Programs: DL Silver, UA Silver, Marriott Lifetime Silver, IHG Plat, Hilton Silver
Posts: 5,695
As to the change fees, they wanted to get rid of those, till they saw the numbers. Those fees generate a huge amount of money for DL, the biggest chunk of the $160M that me4yankees refers to. If they eliminated that income, they'd have to balance with lots of other changes to make up the difference, and, as mentioned, that isn't in the top 10 of concerns in customer surveys. It's only a very small percentage of customers who make multiple changes to award itins.
#27
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Highland PArk,IL,USA -- AA Lifetime Platinum, IHG Plat, UA Silver, Hilton Gold, Radisson Gold, Marriott Lifetime Titanium
Posts: 2,366
As to the change fees, they wanted to get rid of those, till they saw the numbers. Those fees generate a huge amount of money for DL, the biggest chunk of the $160M that me4yankees refers to. If they eliminated that income, they'd have to balance with lots of other changes to make up the difference, and, as mentioned, that isn't in the top 10 of concerns in customer surveys. It's only a very small percentage of customers who make multiple changes to award itins.
OR... Maybe they are counting the salaries of the people they can RIF due to not having to answer the phones.
I have not seen anyone complain about a fee to redeposit, there are 40,000 that do not even cancel before the flight, who knows how many do cancel prior to the actual flight.
I can only speak for myself, they have lost many thousands of dollars from my flying and people I've already pulled that travel with me... All for a silly 5 or 6 $50 change fees.
They are jumping over a dollar to pick up a dime.
#28
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Under an ORD approach path
Programs: DL PM, MM. Coffee isn't a drug, it's a vitamin.
Posts: 12,935
A lot of people even request redeposits after the flight has departed.
I view this differently than you, but I see a change and a redeposit as being very similar; they certainly have a similar effect on the overall system and award availability, and processing costs are similar. To me it's nit picking to separate them, but to people who do those changes a lot I'm sure they are entirely different animals.
I guess they did the math, and decided it's better to tick those few individuals who do lots of changes, and thereby lose a few thousand in business, rather than to lose a hundred million in revenue. They indicated that when they ran the numbers they were quite surprised at how large the amounts are.
Last edited by Gargoyle; Jun 28, 2009 at 6:53 pm
#29
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: ORF
Programs: Delta Diamond Charter Member/1.8MM, IHG Spire Elite
Posts: 876
Regarding the 4th Tier, was there any talk about using the 2009 SM to qualify for the 2010 program? BTW, thanks sharing what you learned, from the pics it looks like you guys had a lot of fun.
#30
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: The best state in the USA - Florida!
Programs: Marriott Titanium/LT Plat, AS MVP75K, AA PlatPro, UA Premier, Disney AP
Posts: 14,495
4th tier will launch on March 1, 2010 based on how many MQMs are earned during the 2009 Calendar Year.