FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Cruises (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cruises-179/)
-   -   Transatlantic Crossing (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cruises/1715186-transatlantic-crossing.html)

YVR Cockroach Jul 18, 2019 5:53 pm

I was booked for a Suez transit (Malta to Pot Klang, Malaysia) but the shipping line route ships direct from Savannah to Port Klang (long diversion) because fuel prices were so low in the latter half of 2015.


Originally Posted by Hoyaheel (Post 31302225)
Maybe large ships are not vulnerable to attack as small ships and don't require the stringent safety measures?....ked at before...

Really depends on how high open access points are from water level. The ones most easily hijacked are ships that sit low and go slow (such as oil tankers and bulk carriers).or cruise ships with low decks or other low entry points (such as marinas on the back of cruise ships). I noted that the stern of larger cruise ships where the sailors will throw out mooring lines- lowest open access point - are now caged in to make access there more difficult. They have to get up to main deck which is at least 30-40' above water. Large container ships are hard to hijack as the lowest entry point is still 40' above water line and can go fast too.


Now I wanna go see what other lines offer cruises through that area, if any of the mass markets are doing it. I typically see the mass markets who do Asia repo from Japan to Alaska but this isn't something I've loo
Quite a few luxury lines were doing this route this past spring: I counted at least 10 ships of which 2-3 were luxuries and premiums. May not be luxury but Ponant seems to do it eastbound in the summer. There's a Viking ship headed west in August this year and next, an Azamara in August, and a Silver Sea headed east next May..

james318 Jul 20, 2019 11:50 am

I just booked my first TA crossing. 06/11/2020 from BCN-NYC. I am looking forward to it! Carnival Radiance (which is the old Carnival Victory after a major overhaul). Solo in a balcony cabin. In celebration of my 40th birthday (well, I will be home in time for the actual birthday.)

The ship will be miserably full, but should still be fun.

Janae Powell Jul 30, 2019 7:16 am

Too afraid of water, I wish I could go as well :(

Global Adventurer Jul 30, 2019 7:23 am


Originally Posted by Janae Powell (Post 31358534)
Too afraid of water, I wish I could go as well :(

I'm afraid of water too. So much, that I'm afraid to even try to swim. Never learnt. But, as long as I can wear a life jacket the entire time (small boats), or have them readily available on a large ship I'm okay. But, I prefer to fly or take a bus or train:)

Randyk47 Jul 30, 2019 7:23 am


Originally Posted by Janae Powell (Post 31358534)
Too afraid of water, I wish I could go as well :(

You sound like my brother-in-law. He is so afraid of water he won’t get within three feet of our pool when he visits. No way I could get him on a cruise.

747FC Jul 30, 2019 8:15 am


Originally Posted by Janae Powell (Post 31358534)
Too afraid of water, I wish I could go as well :(

Janae, The good news is that as long as you refrain from entering the ship's swimming pool or bathtub, your risk of drowning on a cruise is miniscule: https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/21/e1/e43.full

Global Adventurer Aug 3, 2019 10:37 am


Originally Posted by Randyk47 (Post 31299070)


We did Rome to Dubai so pretty close to the same itinerary. The main hook for us were the two stops in Egypt, Alexandria to get to Cairo and Safaga to get to Luxor, and a stop in Aqaba to get to Petra. I agree with 747FC that the slow cruise through the Suez Canal was fascinating. Having been through the Panama Canal I can now say I’ve done them both.

I finally decided to just book a 20 night cruise from Dubai to Venice. It goes through the Suez Canal, Muscat, Petra, Athens, Dubrovnik (2nd visit), and several other coastal cities and of course Venice(2nd visit).

It's through MSC, one of the lowest ranking cruise lines :).....but, I'm going for the port stops... don't much care about the reported passenger issues or rooms. But, I did book a oceanview room considering the number of days at sea. Otherwise, an interior room would have been sufficient.

Randyk47 Aug 3, 2019 11:14 am


Originally Posted by Global Adventurer (Post 31374705)
I finally decided to just book a 20 night cruise from Dubai to Venice. It goes through the Suez Canal, Muscat, Petra, Athens, Dubrovnik (2nd visit), and several other coastal cities and of course Venice(2nd visit).

It's through MSC, one of the lowest ranking cruise lines :).....but, I'm going for the port stops... don't much care about the reported passenger issues or rooms. But, I did book a oceanview room considering the number of days at sea. Otherwise, an interior room would have been sufficient.

Great cruise! The port stops do make it well worth it. Mrs K has mild claustrophobia so no interior or even ocean view cabins for us. From cruise #1 20+ years ago we’ve always had a verandah. I share your concern about MSC though I’ve read they are doing better with their Caribbean cruises with staff, meals, entertainment, etc., better suited for the typical demographics of a Caribbean cruise. Still some mixed reviews but better than they were years ago. Maybe some of those improvements are spilling over to their other itineraries.

Hopefully flying into Dubai is better than flying out. It is huge and busy. Didn’t help that our flight was a 1:30 AM departure. We’d paid for and kept our hotel room until 10:30 PM so not totally beat but not great either. I probably wouldn’t do it again unless it was another spectacular itinerary.



Global Adventurer Aug 3, 2019 11:27 am


Originally Posted by Randyk47 (Post 31374814)


Great cruise! The port stops do make it well worth it. Mrs K has mild claustrophobia so no interior or even ocean view cabins for us. From cruise #1 20+ years ago we’ve always had a verandah. I share your concern about MSC though I’ve read they are doing better with their Caribbean cruises with staff, meals, entertainment, etc., better suited for the typical demographics of a Caribbean cruise. Still some mixed reviews but better than they were years ago. May pebble some of those improvements are spilling over to their other itineraries.

Hopefully flying into Dubai is better than flying out. It is huge and busy. Didn’t help that our flight was a 1:30 AM departure. We’d paid for and kept our hotel room until 10:30 PM so not totally beat but not great either. I probably wouldn’t do it again unless it was another spectacular itinerary.


Thank you for your input. I have another three month trip to Dubai in November. I can attest to the large volume of people in DXB. Last time I reserved a fast track service through marhaba on my departure. It surely reduced my stress level.

I am definitely looking forward to this cruise. Been wanting to go back to Venice and also to visit Petra and Muscat...a three for one:)

mahasamatman Aug 3, 2019 12:22 pm


Originally Posted by Randyk47 (Post 31374814)
May pebble some of those improvements are spilling over to their other itineraries.

Your spell checker did a real number on this sentence to the point where I can't parse it at all. What is it supposed to be?

Randyk47 Aug 3, 2019 12:26 pm


Originally Posted by mahasamatman (Post 31375021)
Your spell checker did a real number on this sentence to the point where I can't parse it at all. What is it supposed to be?

I hate spell checker sometimes. I fixed it....I hope.

mahasamatman Aug 3, 2019 6:20 pm


Originally Posted by Randyk47 (Post 31375032)
I hate spell checker sometimes. I fixed it....I hope.

It certainly makes sense now. Thanks.

747FC Aug 3, 2019 9:41 pm


Originally Posted by Global Adventurer (Post 31374859)
Thank you for your input. I have another three month trip to Dubai in November. I can attest to the large volume of people in DXB. Last time I reserved a fast track service through marhaba on my departure. It surely reduced my stress level.

Highly recommend Marhaba Fast Track for anyone flying into DBX. They greet you at the jetway, push you through private immigration line (really no line), and help navigating baggage claim and customs.

mahasamatman Aug 4, 2019 8:51 am


Originally Posted by YVR Cockroach (Post 31294511)
As for Celebrity, be prepared for poor food offerings if you're not in their suite or Aqua/spa cabin classes with attendant exclusive restaurants.

For what it's worth, we've found Celebrity dining to be comparable to Princess and Cunard.

YVR Cockroach Aug 4, 2019 9:49 am


Originally Posted by mahasamatman (Post 31377662)
For what it's worth, we've found Celebrity dining to be comparable to Princess and Cunard.

In the MDR or the suite/spa/extra cost DRs (on Celebrity and also on Cunard)? Princess MDR was a big letdown 3 years ago but the cruise was short. I could even believe Celebrity MDRs were good in the past but not when more acreage and kitchen space/staff have been carved out to create special DRs and kitchens for suite and spa class pax. My experience on the Millennium puts HAL way in the front by comparison (IMHO the single-class MDR.helps keep quality up for all).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 2:06 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.