Foreign exchange rates discussion [FOREX]--all cards
#76
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 3,380
either way.. is there an arbitrage opportunity here?
Probably not?
(theory)MC transactions uses the actual transaction date, and fxrate on transaction date is 'live'.
(theory)Visa transactions uses posting date(+1-3 days) and fxrate on posting date is based on 'live' data from 1-3 days ago
then the two would be using the same/similar rates (with minor differences)?
(do remember that your (live) fx rate from chase visa card might not be exactly the same as the visa rate)
Probably not?
(theory)MC transactions uses the actual transaction date, and fxrate on transaction date is 'live'.
(theory)Visa transactions uses posting date(+1-3 days) and fxrate on posting date is based on 'live' data from 1-3 days ago
then the two would be using the same/similar rates (with minor differences)?
(do remember that your (live) fx rate from chase visa card might not be exactly the same as the visa rate)
Last edited by paperwastage; Jun 1, 2015 at 7:49 am
#77
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: too far from the airport
Posts: 3,298
So MC better than Visa overall, which was my experience as well (Visa Ink vs Barclays AAdvantage MC). But what about Amex? The Platinum version and Gold Premier Rewards, which as of June 1st has no forex fee? How do they compare with MC and Visa? So far I have one transaction to compare with Visa: on the same day (June 1st), the same item purchased twice, cost $3.78 on the Platinum Amex and $3.79 on a Marriott Visa. I realize it's a small amount (the original cost was in CAD), but it would be nice to have more points of comparison.
#78
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 3,380
So MC better than Visa overall, which was my experience as well (Visa Ink vs Barclays AAdvantage MC). But what about Amex? The Platinum version and Gold Premier Rewards, which as of June 1st has no forex fee? How do they compare with MC and Visa? So far I have one transaction to compare with Visa: on the same day (June 1st), the same item purchased twice, cost $3.78 on the Platinum Amex and $3.79 on a Marriott Visa. I realize it's a small amount (the original cost was in CAD), but it would be nice to have more points of comparison.
if anyone finds one, let me know, and I can update the script
#79
Moderator
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Miami, Mpls & London
Programs: AA & Marriott Perpetual Platinum; DL & HH Gold
Posts: 48,954
https://global.americanexpress.com/m...pe=&Face=en_EU
You can use the Foreign Transaction Calculator below to provide an indication of the rate you will receive when using your American Express Card to make purchases in a different currency.
Rates are available for transactions made after 1st November 2009 and shall be available for 13 months after the processing date.
If you are using your Card to withdraw cash from an ATM, an additional fee will apply. Please refer to your Express Cash terms and conditions for further details.
The reference exchange rate is refreshed each morning for foreign currency transactions that are processed until the next day's rates are made available. The rate that is provided may not necessarily be the rate that will be applied to transactions that you make during that period. The rate applied to transactions that you make will be the rate applicable during the period when we receive the transaction for processing. Fluctuations may be significant. For more information, please refer to your terms and conditions.
Rates are available for transactions made after 1st November 2009 and shall be available for 13 months after the processing date.
If you are using your Card to withdraw cash from an ATM, an additional fee will apply. Please refer to your Express Cash terms and conditions for further details.
The reference exchange rate is refreshed each morning for foreign currency transactions that are processed until the next day's rates are made available. The rate that is provided may not necessarily be the rate that will be applied to transactions that you make during that period. The rate applied to transactions that you make will be the rate applicable during the period when we receive the transaction for processing. Fluctuations may be significant. For more information, please refer to your terms and conditions.
#80
Suspended
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Bay Area
Programs: DL SM, UA MP.
Posts: 12,729
Made a 10€ charge on Sapphire Preferred and got a notification on Chase iOS app of a $11.39 charge.
Checked x-rates.com right away and the rate was $1.126.
So Chase or Visa is sticking in about 1%.
Wonder if I use chase Freedom whether they will impose 3% or 4%.
Checked x-rates.com right away and the rate was $1.126.
So Chase or Visa is sticking in about 1%.
Wonder if I use chase Freedom whether they will impose 3% or 4%.
#81
Suspended
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Bay Area
Programs: DL SM, UA MP.
Posts: 12,729
Forex rates from Belgium
Have made about 6 charges in 3 days, ranging from train ticket kiosks to supermarkets. Most in Brugge but one at BRU.
The 3 cards I've used are suppose to be zero FTF: BofA Cash Rewards Visa ( grandfathered from Schwab visa), Chase Sapphire Preferred Visa and First Tech World Choice Master Card.
The rate I'm being charged is consistently 3-3.5 cents over the rate that Google returns when you search 'euro to dollar'.
For instance, i was charged $1.17-1.175 on 8/25 and 8/26 when the official rate was around $1.14 on those dates.
Just now, I was charged over 1.15 when Google is showing $1.12. The XE app for my iPhone is showing $1.1247.
I'm used to maybe a cent more when making charges in Europe. This is my first visit to Belgium so maybe the cc network here is imposing something?
One POS offered me DCC but I chose the Euros amount, not the USD amount.
The 3 cards I've used are suppose to be zero FTF: BofA Cash Rewards Visa ( grandfathered from Schwab visa), Chase Sapphire Preferred Visa and First Tech World Choice Master Card.
The rate I'm being charged is consistently 3-3.5 cents over the rate that Google returns when you search 'euro to dollar'.
For instance, i was charged $1.17-1.175 on 8/25 and 8/26 when the official rate was around $1.14 on those dates.
Just now, I was charged over 1.15 when Google is showing $1.12. The XE app for my iPhone is showing $1.1247.
I'm used to maybe a cent more when making charges in Europe. This is my first visit to Belgium so maybe the cc network here is imposing something?
One POS offered me DCC but I chose the Euros amount, not the USD amount.
#82
Moderator
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Miami, Mpls & London
Programs: AA & Marriott Perpetual Platinum; DL & HH Gold
Posts: 48,954
I suggest you review this thread:
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/chase...nge-rates.html
Part of the problem is figuring out the date on which the exchange rate is set. It is generally not the date on which you made the purchase.
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/chase...nge-rates.html
Part of the problem is figuring out the date on which the exchange rate is set. It is generally not the date on which you made the purchase.
Last edited by mia; Aug 27, 2015 at 12:45 pm
#83
Suspended
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Bay Area
Programs: DL SM, UA MP.
Posts: 12,729
With the Chase and BofA Visa cards, the posting of the transaction was instant. I'm getting an alert on my iPhone right away.
Now maybe the merchant is using the exchange rate from a day or two ago but I'm seeing that the Euro peaked at around $1.16 around 8/23 yet I'm being charged over 1.17 on 8/25 and 8/26?
And over 1.15 this evening, around 19:00 CET.
Now maybe the merchant is using the exchange rate from a day or two ago but I'm seeing that the Euro peaked at around $1.16 around 8/23 yet I'm being charged over 1.17 on 8/25 and 8/26?
And over 1.15 this evening, around 19:00 CET.
#84
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Canada
Programs: BA Gold (OWE), Star Alliance Gold, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 2,194
With the Chase and BofA Visa cards, the posting of the transaction was instant. I'm getting an alert on my iPhone right away.
Now maybe the merchant is using the exchange rate from a day or two ago but I'm seeing that the Euro peaked at around $1.16 around 8/23 yet I'm being charged over 1.17 on 8/25 and 8/26?
And over 1.15 this evening, around 19:00 CET.
Now maybe the merchant is using the exchange rate from a day or two ago but I'm seeing that the Euro peaked at around $1.16 around 8/23 yet I'm being charged over 1.17 on 8/25 and 8/26?
And over 1.15 this evening, around 19:00 CET.
#85
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: RDU
Posts: 812
With the Chase and BofA Visa cards, the posting of the transaction was instant. I'm getting an alert on my iPhone right away.
Now maybe the merchant is using the exchange rate from a day or two ago but I'm seeing that the Euro peaked at around $1.16 around 8/23 yet I'm being charged over 1.17 on 8/25 and 8/26?
And over 1.15 this evening, around 19:00 CET.
Now maybe the merchant is using the exchange rate from a day or two ago but I'm seeing that the Euro peaked at around $1.16 around 8/23 yet I'm being charged over 1.17 on 8/25 and 8/26?
And over 1.15 this evening, around 19:00 CET.
#86
Suspended
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Bay Area
Programs: DL SM, UA MP.
Posts: 12,729
Hmm maybe the amount will change between when the transactions are pending vs. when they're on my statement permanently.
But I certainly don't recall such a large delta, though maybe the FX has been more volatile this week than usual.
But I certainly don't recall such a large delta, though maybe the FX has been more volatile this week than usual.
#87
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 1
http://usa.visa.com/personal/card-be...calculator.jsp
Put in your info. Things to know: If you charge on a Saturday, most likely you will get the rate you see on that day. Visa rates are the same Sat - Mon.
Put in your info. Things to know: If you charge on a Saturday, most likely you will get the rate you see on that day. Visa rates are the same Sat - Mon.
#88
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 3,380
Date, Visa ->, Visa <-, Mastercard ->, Mastercard <-
20150817,1.118988,0.893664632686,1.11240025941,0.8 98957
20150818,1.112589,0.898804500134,1.10930048621,0.9 01469
20150819,1.109489,0.901315830982,1.10480024659,0.9 05141
20150820,1.113689,0.897916743364,1.11640036797,0.8 95736
20150821,1.124688,0.889135475794,1.13055029536,0.8 84525
20150822,1.139286,0.877742726585,,
20150823,1.139286,0.877742726585,,
20150824,1.139286,0.877742726585,,
20150825,1.171083,0.853910440165,1.15709938327,0.86423
20150826,1.162484,0.860226893445,1.15180037917,0.8 68206
20150827,1.156184,0.864914235104,1.13389998095,0.8 81912
20150828,1.136486,0.879905251802,,
20150829,1.131087,0.884105289867,,
20150830,1.131087,0.884105289867,,
20150831,1.131087,0.884105289867,,
from the other thread - observations:
(theory)MC transactions uses the actual transaction date, and fxrate on transaction date is 'live'.
(theory)Visa transactions uses posting date(+1-3 days) and fxrate on posting date is based on 'live' data from 1-3 days ago
20150817,1.118988,0.893664632686,1.11240025941,0.8 98957
20150818,1.112589,0.898804500134,1.10930048621,0.9 01469
20150819,1.109489,0.901315830982,1.10480024659,0.9 05141
20150820,1.113689,0.897916743364,1.11640036797,0.8 95736
20150821,1.124688,0.889135475794,1.13055029536,0.8 84525
20150822,1.139286,0.877742726585,,
20150823,1.139286,0.877742726585,,
20150824,1.139286,0.877742726585,,
20150825,1.171083,0.853910440165,1.15709938327,0.86423
20150826,1.162484,0.860226893445,1.15180037917,0.8 68206
20150827,1.156184,0.864914235104,1.13389998095,0.8 81912
20150828,1.136486,0.879905251802,,
20150829,1.131087,0.884105289867,,
20150830,1.131087,0.884105289867,,
20150831,1.131087,0.884105289867,,
from the other thread - observations:
(theory)MC transactions uses the actual transaction date, and fxrate on transaction date is 'live'.
(theory)Visa transactions uses posting date(+1-3 days) and fxrate on posting date is based on 'live' data from 1-3 days ago
#89
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: IAH
Posts: 362
The amount definitely changes for me between when I get the alert/email from Chase at the time of transaction to when it finally settles a day or two later. So don't rely on the amount quoted in the alert. It's usually not a large change, but it does change.
#90
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Kobe, Japan
Programs: Bonvoy Platinum, IHG Diamond, Hyatt Discoverist
Posts: 1,531
After a lot of overseas spending I wanted to see which card was best, but my Chase Sapphire online account only shows the USD spending, with no rate, meaning I have to dig through receipts. After asking they said the rates are only on the monthly printed statements, which they said they could send me on request. Seems like an intentional hurdle to me.
At the present time, we do not display the foreign
exchange rate from the Chase.com website and this
information can only be found on the monthly statement for
your account. I sincerely apologize for any inconvenience
this may cause.
At the present time, we do not display the foreign
exchange rate from the Chase.com website and this
information can only be found on the monthly statement for
your account. I sincerely apologize for any inconvenience
this may cause.