FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Continental OnePass (Pre-Merger) (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/continental-onepass-pre-merger-488/)
-   -   Is Copa leaving ST (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/continental-onepass-pre-merger/847088-copa-leaving-st.html)

nsabo Jul 21, 2008 7:31 am

Is Copa leaving ST
 
Is Copa leaving SkyTeam with CO now that CO had sold its remaining shares in Copa.

sbm12 Jul 21, 2008 7:45 am


Originally Posted by nsabo (Post 10072089)
Is Copa leaving SkyTeam with CO now that CO had sold its remaining shares in Copa.

Nothing has been publicly stated that I'm aware of. Some of us think that Copa will stick with Continental since they share a program and it would be difficult to split it off and change everything to a different system. Some think that *A won't want Copa because of overlap. We'll find out eventually.

colpuck Jul 21, 2008 8:07 am

Overlap?

* Air Canada
* Air China
* Air New Zealand
* ANA
* Asiana Airlines
* Austrian
* bmi
* EgyptAir
* LOT Polish Airlines
* Lufthansa
* Scandinavian Airlines
* Shanghai Airlines
* Singapore Airlines
* South African Airways
* Spanair
* SWISS
* TAP Portugal
* THAI
* Turkish Airlines
* United
* US Airways

* Regional Members
* Adria Airways
* Blue1
* Croatia Airlines

None of those airlines have a strong Central or South American operation. I would think OW wouldn't want Copa or Aero Republica because of overlap. ST would probably like to keep them just as much as *A would like to get them.

nsabo Jul 21, 2008 8:15 am

Using SJO I would like to see them both in SkyTeam.

Clarkcc1 Jul 22, 2008 9:40 am


Originally Posted by colpuck (Post 10072257)
Overlap?

* Air Canada
* Air China
* Air New Zealand
* ANA
* Asiana Airlines
* Austrian
* bmi
* EgyptAir
* LOT Polish Airlines
* Lufthansa
* Scandinavian Airlines
* Shanghai Airlines
* Singapore Airlines
* South African Airways
* Spanair
* SWISS
* TAP Portugal
* THAI
* Turkish Airlines
* United
* US Airways

* Regional Members
* Adria Airways
* Blue1
* Croatia Airlines

None of those airlines have a strong Central or South American operation. I would think OW wouldn't want Copa or Aero Republica because of overlap. ST would probably like to keep them just as much as *A would like to get them.

*A needs Copa BAD! or TACA... central/south america is a wide open huge gaping hole with *A. My tons of miles with UA are worthless when I'm trying to do IAD-LIM.

With Copa still one with CO because of OnePass, they'll either switch to *A, or incur the costs of developing their own FF program. I personally hope to see them with *A!

J.Edward Jul 22, 2008 9:58 am


Originally Posted by nsabo (Post 10072288)
Using SJO I would like to see them both in SkyTeam.

Both CO and CM (Copa) stay in SkyTeam or stay in the same alliance (i.e. *A)?

craz Jul 22, 2008 12:04 pm


Originally Posted by Clarkcc1 (Post 10078496)
*A needs Copa BAD! or TACA... central/south america is a wide open huge gaping hole with *A. My tons of miles with UA are worthless when I'm trying to do IAD-LIM.

With Copa still one with CO because of OnePass, they'll either switch to *A, or incur the costs of developing their own FF program. I personally hope to see them with *A!


although Taca is not a * member , Taca is a partner with UAL, so at least UAL miles can be used to fly on TA, maybe even other *A partner miles as well.

vsevolod4 Jul 22, 2008 3:46 pm

I agree it makes sense for COPA to tag along with *A. This would give *A a much stronger Central/Latin American presence than it has, and make up for some of the void that RG's implosion left behind.

This would leave Central/North Africa and Oz as the biggest holes in *A (and biggest areas of relative strength for ST and OW, respectively).

ConciergeMike Jul 22, 2008 3:53 pm

UA conf. call today said that *A is "aggresively" looking for a Latin/Central America member. Um, duh.

Osk Aug 4, 2008 5:04 pm

Well CO has sold its remaining in CM, at this time CM needs to decide what want to do if either follow CO or stay in the Skyteam. i personally think Copa would be in a better position with CO because both airlines have the same both FF and livery. we have to also remmember that CO is cutting some routes in LA and Copa can be useful to cover those routes with codeshare.

regards

HobokenFlyer Aug 4, 2008 5:37 pm

liveries can be changed...just ask US Air.ways.black.white, etc.

sbm12 Aug 4, 2008 7:03 pm


Originally Posted by Osk (Post 10148984)
Well CO has sold its remaining in CM, at this time CM needs to decide what want to do if either follow CO or stay in the Skyteam. i personally think Copa would be in a better position with CO because both airlines have the same both FF and livery. we have to also remmember that CO is cutting some routes in LA and Copa can be useful to cover those routes with codeshare.

regards

Welcome to FlyerTalk!!

Forget the livery. There's no need to change it if they split, though they could if they want to.

The real cost for Copa leaving would be in starting up a new FF program or in switching to a different partner's program. Either of those would require a substantial infrastructure investment, which is why I don't think it will happen.

Osk Aug 5, 2008 2:21 pm


Originally Posted by sbm12 (Post 10149583)
Welcome to FlyerTalk!!

Forget the livery. There's no need to change it if they split, though they could if they want to.

The real cost for Copa leaving would be in starting up a new FF program or in switching to a different partner's program. Either of those would require a substantial infrastructure investment, which is why I don't think it will happen.

Exactly.
I wonder what Copa would need to get in Star Alliance as an official member.

Could Copa continue its codeshares with AM y KLM if leave the Skyteam:confused:

thank you

regards

craz Aug 5, 2008 3:09 pm


Originally Posted by Osk (Post 10154462)
Exactly.
I wonder what Copa would need to get in Star Alliance as an official member.

Could Copa continue its codeshares with AM y KLM if leave the Skyteam:confused:

thank you

regards

Recently I wanted to get a different flight time between CDG and BUD on a free tkt, checking the AF website I saw flights that worked great for me but CO said they couldnt book it for me using my Miles.

turns out its an AF code-share flight (with an AF flight#) but the Metal is Malev. AF = ST, MA = OW . So if AF sells code shares on another Alliances Partner why cant CM?

MarkXS Aug 5, 2008 3:39 pm


Originally Posted by craz (Post 10154754)
Recently I wanted to get a different flight time between CDG and BUD on a free tkt, checking the AF website I saw flights that worked great for me but CO said they couldnt book it for me using my Miles.

turns out its an AF code-share flight (with an AF flight#) but the Metal is Malev. AF = ST, MA = OW . So if AF sells code shares on another Alliances Partner why cant CM?

I highlighted the reason - it was right in what you wrote.
Airlines can SELL flights on airlines that are not alliance partners but with which they might have a bilateral agreement. AF->MA is that.

Airlines cannot do awards on airlines which aren't part of the airline with the miles (in your case, CO) award program.

It's not a distributive relationship.
CO->AF and AF->MA does NOT imply CO->MA for awards.

I'm guessing you could redeem AF/KL FlyingBlue miles for that MA flight, because AF partners with MA on that route. Just like I could redeem NW miles for a AMS-BUD NW codeshare on MA.

You had a free ticket using OnePass miles. You can only redeem on airlines that are award partners in the CO OnePass program. "Partner of another partner" does not count. By definition, any airline in the same alliance is an award partner. So any flight operated by a ST member is in theory available to you with CO miles (if it has award availability, of course). Also, as a CO member you have the ability to redeem on some non-Skyteam airlines that CO cut a separate deal with. You can redeem on Qantas and Virgin Atlantic from your CO program in Skyteam. I cannot from my NW program in Skyteam. That's because this scenario has nothing to do with Skyteam.

But now that I answered this, what the heck does your question have to do with the topic of the thread, which is about Copa remaining in Skyteam or going to *A?

To veer back on-topic, as a high-leve UA/*A elite and low-level NW/ST elite, I hope CO brings CM along for the ride. *A needs more help in Latin America than Skyteam does. CO itself will help a lot, but it would be nice to keep CM too. Though if ST wants to keep them, I'm thinking that their ST Associate status could easily enough be transferred to the New Delta and they would adopt SkyMiles (or SkyPerks or whatever it becomes) as their program, with a specially-negotiated one-time transfer opportunity for CO OP members who had earned miles on CM flights or who had joined via CM. This affiliation transfers for associates are not unknown; isn't one of the upcoming new ST associates originally sponsored by AZ but has been transferred to sponsorship through AF instead?

craz Aug 5, 2008 4:22 pm


Originally Posted by MarkXS (Post 10154927)
I highlighted the reason - it was right in what you wrote.
Airlines can SELL flights on airlines that are not alliance partners but with which they might have a bilateral agreement. AF->MA is that.

Airlines cannot do awards on airlines which aren't part of the airline with the miles (in your case, CO) award program.

It's not a distributive relationship.
CO->AF and AF->MA does NOT imply CO->MA for awards.

I'm guessing you could redeem AF/KL FlyingBlue miles for that MA flight, because AF partners with MA on that route. Just like I could redeem NW miles for a AMS-BUD NW codeshare on MA.

You had a free ticket using OnePass miles. You can only redeem on airlines that are award partners in the CO OnePass program. "Partner of another partner" does not count. By definition, any airline in the same alliance is an award partner. So any flight operated by a ST member is in theory available to you with CO miles (if it has award availability, of course). Also, as a CO member you have the ability to redeem on some non-Skyteam airlines that CO cut a separate deal with. You can redeem on Qantas and Virgin Atlantic from your CO program in Skyteam. I cannot from my NW program in Skyteam. That's because this scenario has nothing to do with Skyteam.

But now that I answered this, what the heck does your question have to do with the topic of the thread, which is about Copa remaining in Skyteam or going to *A?

To veer back on-topic, as a high-leve UA/*A elite and low-level NW/ST elite, I hope CO brings CM along for the ride. *A needs more help in Latin America than Skyteam does. CO itself will help a lot, but it would be nice to keep CM too. Though if ST wants to keep them, I'm thinking that their ST Associate status could easily enough be transferred to the New Delta and they would adopt SkyMiles (or SkyPerks or whatever it becomes) as their program, with a specially-negotiated one-time transfer opportunity for CO OP members who had earned miles on CM flights or who had joined via CM. This affiliation transfers for associates are not unknown; isn't one of the upcoming new ST associates originally sponsored by AZ but has been transferred to sponsorship through AF instead?

Boy did you go OT!

heres the quote I was referring to by OSK "could Copa continue its codeshares with AM y KLM if they leave SkyTeam :confused:?"

I answered that AF has codeshares with OW partners, so if AF does then why shouldnt CM beable to do the samething. Im sure I could have gotten the AF/MA flight if I was purchasing a tkt. Dont think CO would have given me credit for it or at least no EQMs, dont know dont really care. Only wanted to show that AF has codeshares with another carrier from another alliance

smitopher Aug 5, 2008 7:17 pm


Originally Posted by MarkXS (Post 10154927)
So any flight operated by a ST member is in theory available to you with CO miles (if it has award availability, of course).

Uhm... Nope.

I tried to get from AUS to CGK (Jakarta). Korean, AF and KLM have service to CGK and they all exclude CGK as an award destination with NonePass miles from North America. The reservation line said that ST partners can AND DO exclude flights for ST partner awards. I ended up using EVA at a higher reward level, 160K vs. 120K

Osk Sep 24, 2008 2:51 pm

I was seeing this in another thread in other foroum


Continental Airlines, Inc. and Compania Panamena de Aviacion, S.A.

September 5, 2008

Re: Additional Codesharing

This is to notify the Department, pursuant to condition (b) of Statement of Authorization 98-65, that Continental and COPA intend to begin codeshare service on the following route segments no earlier than 30 days from the date of this notice:

Panama City-Aruba (CO* on COPA)
-Santa Cruz, Bolivia (CO* on COPA)
-Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago (CO* on COPA)

COPA is already operating Panama City-Port of Spain service, and it will institute Panama City-Santa Cruz and Panama City-Aruba service in December.

Continental holds authority to place its designator code on flights operated by COPA in foreign air transportation "between points in the United States and points worldwide." (See Statement of Authorization No. 98-65, July 9, 1998 and Notice of Action Taken, Docket OST-2005-20122, March 1, 2005) COPA holds authority to offer the proposed service. (See Order 1998-3-16 and renewal application pending in Docket OST-1997-2675).
what is your opinion??
is there any possibility that CM follow to CO after have signed this codesharing?
for me this is a signal that CM might follow CO, althought the only thing that we can do at this time is to speculate on how both CO and CM move beteewen each other.

regadrs

sbm12 Nov 22, 2008 8:50 am

Finally some reasonably solid evidence that CM is likely to make the leap to *A along with CO:

Copa chief executive Pedro Heilbron, meanwhile, said on the sidelines of the forum that the Panamanian carrier has decided to leave SkyTeam and is in exclusive talks with Star.

Heilbron says Copa has no "commercial choice" but to leave SkyTeam because its main partner, Continental, decided earlier this year to leave SkyTeam for Star. Continental sponsored Copa's entrance into SkyTeam. Continental is scheduled to formally leave SkyTeam for Star late next year but Heilbron says "we have some time" to decide what it should do.

"We're looking at all our options," he says. "We won't rush it."

But those options do not include staying in SkyTeam or joining oneworld, according to Heilbron. So it seems the only thing Copa needs to decide is whether it should join Star as a full or regional member and when it should make the switch. Copa is now an affiliate of SkyTeam rather than a full member.
Good news for CO folks who have grown accustomed to having CM as part of their program, and vice versa.

wolfie_cr Nov 22, 2008 1:18 pm

yeehaw

bigbird090 Nov 22, 2008 4:59 pm

Hopefully they won't go with a TACA-style mileage plan. Hope they at least go with an alliance (hopefully *alliance)

sbm12 Nov 22, 2008 5:05 pm


Originally Posted by bigbird090 (Post 10797016)
Hopefully they won't go with a TACA-style mileage plan. Hope they at least go with an alliance (hopefully *alliance)

They are going to keep OnePass and come over to *A. Did you read my post from earlier this afternoon??


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:21 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.