Changing money at Shanghai airport rip off
#2
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Derbyshire, UK
Programs: FB Platinum
Posts: 520
2) If you are happy to keep your $ and take it back home with you - ATM
Loads of threads here about which banks will change Forex for RMB and which ATMs work with overseas Credit Cards
The money exchange booths in airports are, without exception, a very poor option
nickyboy
#5
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: MEL
Programs: BA Gold; VA Velocity Gold; LH FTL; Marriott Gold; ICHG Platinum AMB; Hilton Gold
Posts: 5,393
Chinese currency is regulated and that includes the level of commission you get charged. If you insist on carrying lots of cash around with you and exchanging it, then do so in relatively large amounts to minimise the currency hit. Your hotel and any banks you deal with will usually charge the same commission fee.
Note that in order to change anything back, you have to produce the receipts you got when you obtained the RMB in the first place. No receipt = not able to change back (or doing so on the black market for an inferior rate).
ATMs are everywhere in the cities, and will take most ATM card and credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, Cirrus, Plus, Discover are all widely accepted, Amex can also be used). The commission you pay will be lower. The only downside of ATMs is that an ATM receipt cannot be used to change back to your home currency, so don't withdraw more than you need.
It's bureaucratic I know, but this is China and it is the way things work. I currently have to do tax returns on a monthly basis, which I can assure you is as much fun as it sounds...
Note that in order to change anything back, you have to produce the receipts you got when you obtained the RMB in the first place. No receipt = not able to change back (or doing so on the black market for an inferior rate).
ATMs are everywhere in the cities, and will take most ATM card and credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, Cirrus, Plus, Discover are all widely accepted, Amex can also be used). The commission you pay will be lower. The only downside of ATMs is that an ATM receipt cannot be used to change back to your home currency, so don't withdraw more than you need.
It's bureaucratic I know, but this is China and it is the way things work. I currently have to do tax returns on a monthly basis, which I can assure you is as much fun as it sounds...
#6
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 42,031
#7
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: CGK SIN PER ORD
Programs: UA 1K MM, Hyatt Plat
Posts: 2,813
Same thing I noticed. I always keep at least 250 rmb in my travel wallet in the event I need to take a cab to Puxi/Pudong instead of the Maglev. The rate I got at Le Meridien when I stayed this past trip was far better than the airport rate and without the 50rmb fee too.
#8
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: PVG SIN
Posts: 79
To get the best fx rate, one should be on the look out for guys lurking around most banks in shanghai. They have minimal english skills but sufficient to ask if you would like to exhange money. They basically take money out of their bank account straight away when you provide them with your fx currency, after agreeing on the rate.
Changing money at the airport would be the last resort and a total rip off.
Changing money at the airport would be the last resort and a total rip off.
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 38,410
To get the best fx rate, one should be on the look out for guys lurking around most banks in shanghai. They have minimal english skills but sufficient to ask if you would like to exhange money. They basically take money out of their bank account straight away when you provide them with your fx currency, after agreeing on the rate.
Changing money at the airport would be the last resort and a total rip off.
Changing money at the airport would be the last resort and a total rip off.
#10
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Providence, Rhode Island
Posts: 35
Of course, the person in the booth can't tell which cash was exchanged, and which was withdrawn, so exchange your first hundred at a bank somewhere, and withdraw the rest. Just don't lose the receipt
#11
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 5
We had to exchange money at the airport, too, and paid the RMB 50 fee. At other places you have to ask. Some banks charge the fee and some don' t. If I remember correctly the fee can even be lower than RMB 50. I think one bank wanted to have RMB 25.
The good thing about hotels is that they are not as picky as banks. In banks your dollars have to be without any failure. One of my bills has been declined, because it was ripped a little bit. That was accepted at my hotel. But you do not get a second chance with money which has hand writings on it.
And it is even easier to fill in the form at hotels. Once I had to fill in the form several times. You are not allowed to:
- make a cross (tick the field instead)
- the $ character needs to be in front of the number, not behind
- do not correct anything
- use the american format for number 7 (without the second horizontal line)
Felt like an idiot and bank employees did not want to fill in the form for me either. My friends were so upset, not only because of this, but also because of the way the clerk spoke to us, that they called for the manager. Then everything was easier and quicker and they even apologized.
The good thing about hotels is that they are not as picky as banks. In banks your dollars have to be without any failure. One of my bills has been declined, because it was ripped a little bit. That was accepted at my hotel. But you do not get a second chance with money which has hand writings on it.
And it is even easier to fill in the form at hotels. Once I had to fill in the form several times. You are not allowed to:
- make a cross (tick the field instead)
- the $ character needs to be in front of the number, not behind
- do not correct anything
- use the american format for number 7 (without the second horizontal line)
Felt like an idiot and bank employees did not want to fill in the form for me either. My friends were so upset, not only because of this, but also because of the way the clerk spoke to us, that they called for the manager. Then everything was easier and quicker and they even apologized.
#12
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 42,031
#14
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: SFO, SJC
Programs: DL G, UA G, IHG SA
Posts: 132
forget about the airport exchange place
discover card is widely accepted in china just like a local credit card and it does not charge any exchange fee
you can also use bank card from bank of america to withdraw cash in local currency, again no exchange fee but need to find the right atm to use
discover card is widely accepted in china just like a local credit card and it does not charge any exchange fee
you can also use bank card from bank of america to withdraw cash in local currency, again no exchange fee but need to find the right atm to use
#15
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 42,031
forget about the airport exchange place
discover card is widely accepted in china just like a local credit card and it does not charge any exchange fee
you can also use bank card from bank of america to withdraw cash in local currency, again no exchange fee but need to find the right atm to use
discover card is widely accepted in china just like a local credit card and it does not charge any exchange fee
you can also use bank card from bank of america to withdraw cash in local currency, again no exchange fee but need to find the right atm to use