FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Checkpoints and Borders Policy Debate (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/checkpoints-borders-policy-debate-687/)
-   -   Bombs (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/checkpoints-borders-policy-debate/1482560-bombs.html)

eyecue Jul 5, 2013 10:38 pm

Bombs
 
http://www.cnn.com/video/?/video/bes...b-training.cnn

PTravel Jul 5, 2013 10:48 pm


Originally Posted by eyecue (Post 21048028)

Yeah, bombs are pretty bad. Too bad TSA has missed the few post-9/11 attempts at bombing aircraft, and don't have any kind of effective screening to keep them off planes.

BTW, when was it you guys finally started inspecting all air cargo that is boarded on commercial aircraft?

Yoshi212 Jul 5, 2013 11:22 pm

I bought some fireworks down in Chinatown too. Am I a terrorist?

petaluma1 Jul 6, 2013 5:20 am

Pure propaganda and fear-mongering on the part of the TSA. No, it's not "rare access" to CNN. They disseminate similar videos such as this and try to get the public to believe that all their clerks get this type of training. Completely untrue.

The explosive that could fit in the end of the barrel of a ball point pen? Guess where else that explosive could fit that the TSA would never find.

InkUnderNails Jul 6, 2013 5:31 am


Originally Posted by eyecue (Post 21048028)

I'm hearing impaired and captions don't work. I tried to find transcript. Someone provide a summary please. Looks like old guys blowing stuff up. Sounds like fun. We used to do this as kids before so many people got their panties in a bunch over explosives.

Lots of stuff blows up. Some rather spectacularly.

And no, my hearing impairment is not from blowing stuff up.

petaluma1 Jul 6, 2013 5:41 am

Here's more "rare" (or in this case, "exclusive") footage of explosives training:

http://abclocal.go.com/kabc/video?id=9008885

and more

http://www.ketv.com/news/local-news/...z/-/index.html

(This one has some verbiage, Ink, but not a transcript)

wave goodbye Jul 6, 2013 5:56 am

deleted

WillCAD Jul 6, 2013 7:11 am

Point taken. Boom bad. No boom allowed on plane.

So, TSA employees get a lovely demonstration of how powerful explosives can be. Useful to drive the point home, I suppose, since anyone who has no military or civilian explosives experience doesn't necessarily know exactly how powerful various explosives are in the wild.

Does this training include an explanation of the concept of cross-contamination, so TSOs know that they can swab just one item in a bag, not every little piece, to test for explosives residue?

Does this training include mention of the fact that there is no liquid explosive that can be mixed airside or airborne without laboratory conditions that has the slightest prayer of bringing down a plane?

Does this training include more extensive instruction in the detection and recognition of explosives, i.e. the ability to tell whether you're looking at C4, toothpaste, or cake frosting?

Does this training provide any actual training at all, or is it simply a testosterone-fueled demonstration of various things that go boom?

IrishDoesntFlyNow Jul 6, 2013 7:34 am


Originally Posted by InkUnderNails (Post 21048882)
I'm hearing impaired and captions don't work. I tried to find transcript. Someone provide a summary please. Looks like old guys blowing stuff up. Sounds like fun. We used to do this as kids before so many people got their panties in a bunch over explosives.

Lots of stuff blows up. Some rather spectacularly.

And no, my hearing impairment is not from blowing stuff up.


Ink, after each explosion the blond exclaims about how big the boom was. In the airport scenes, she explains how the big booms are why the brave checkpoint clerks have to do what they do. The entire commentary (if you can call it commentary) can be summed up in one sentence: "This is what happens when you blow up stuff, so this is why we don't want the Bad Guys to get explosives on a plane."

Pathetic.


~~ Irish

Yoshi212 Jul 6, 2013 7:40 am

I can think of only one way a TSO could determine. By tasting and confiscating the cake frosting out of an abundance of caution


Originally Posted by WillCAD (Post 21049089)
Point taken. Boom bad. No boom allowed on plane........Does this training include more extensive instruction in the detection and recognition of explosives, i.e. the ability to tell whether you're looking at [B]C4, toothpaste[B], or cake frosting?

Does this training provide any actual training at all, or is it simply a testosterone-fueled demonstration of various things that go boom?


SeriouslyLost Jul 6, 2013 8:37 am


Originally Posted by Yoshi212 (Post 21049166)
I can think of only one way a TSO could determine. By tasting and confiscating the cake frosting out of an abundance of caution

Looking at the average TSA employee that is exactly what they've been doing. Extensively. Ghods, they risk so much for us! Heart disease, diabetes, gout...

FliesWay2Much Jul 6, 2013 8:43 am


Originally Posted by MariaP (Post 21048915)
We had "bomb day" one year as part of our in-service training (local police department). While the boys ate up the testosterone rush, I found the training to be a big waste of time. Everyone knows what bombs do and what the impact is. I hope that this is not an example of what TSA considers quality training.

It's better than average training. They got to go on a field trip!

What would be far more useful training would be classes on how to actually find dangerous items but more relevant, how to use common sense to differentiate between dangerous and non dangerous items. How to use common sense when applying the rules and how to properly handle dangerous items when they are found.

Remember -- this is security theater. This time, the TSA clerks were the audience rather than the American public.

As mentioned in a previous thread, TSA has been known to confiscate liquids and gels which would have fit neatly into a one quart bag but were instead in a one gallon bag (taking up less than a quarter of it). Common sense: how does a tube of toothpaste go from innocuous to dangerous when placed in a different sized bag.

Same thing -- security theater.

Now, assuming that the toothpaste has indeed been properly identified as dangerous and possibly explosive, why is it tossed so casually in the trashcan at the checkpoint. If anyone truly thought for even one second that a confiscated gel or liquid was dangerous, the area should be evacuated, the bomb squad should be called in and the explosive should be isolated for a controlled detonation.

Same thing -- security theater.

So, you either think my item is an explosive or not. which is it?

It doesn't matter. The objective is to create and perpetuate a certain level of fear in the traveling public. This CNN fluff piece was just one aspect. It's also important to keep the fear level in the clerks as well.

On another note, I wonder if this was a TSA fluff piece that they shopped around the mainstream media until they found a taker or if it was one of those government propaganda clips made to look like a news story? I found her LinkedIn page. She's a local DC freelance reporter for CNN Newsource. She hasn't been a salaried employee of any legitimate news organization since 2009. I smell a rat -- a TSA rat.

InkUnderNails Jul 6, 2013 8:44 am


Originally Posted by IrishDoesntFlyNow (Post 21049151)
Ink, after each explosion the blond exclaims about how big the boom was. In the airport scenes, she explains how the big booms are why the brave checkpoint clerks have to do what they do. The entire commentary (if you can call it commentary) can be summed up in one sentence: "This is what happens when you blow up stuff, so this is why we don't want the Bad Guys to get explosives on a plane."

Pathetic.


~~ Irish

Cool. I knew all that. Sad that TSO's have to be "trained" to know that. Well, everything except the "brave" part. That is new knowledge.

CPT Trips Jul 6, 2013 11:11 am


Originally Posted by MariaP (Post 21048915)
We had "bomb day" one year as part of our in-service training (local police department). While the boys ate up the testosterone rush, I found the training to be a big waste of time. Everyone knows what bombs do and what the impact is. I hope that this is not an example of what TSA considers quality training.

What would be far more useful training would be classes on how to actually find dangerous items but more relevant, how to use common sense to differentiate between dangerous and non dangerous items. How to use common sense when applying the rules and how to properly handle dangerous items when they are found.

As mentioned in a previous thread, TSA has been known to confiscate liquids and gels which would have fit neatly into a one quart bag but were instead in a one gallon bag (taking up less than a quarter of it). Common sense: how does a tube of toothpaste go from innocuous to dangerous when placed in a different sized bag.

Now, assuming that the toothpaste has indeed been properly identified as dangerous and possibly explosive, why is it tossed so casually in the trashcan at the checkpoint. If anyone truly thought for even one second that a confiscated gel or liquid was dangerous, the area should be evacuated, the bomb squad should be called in and the explosive should be isolated for a controlled detonation.

So, you either think my item is an explosive or not. which is it?

You are correct. Nothing they showed on camera prepared the Airport Security Screeners to find one of those bombs or properly respond to a discovery of one. It sure would be interesting to see the "lesson plan" and the instructional objectives. It was probably fun for most Airport Security Screeners present and the guys actually blowing up things likely kept their skill set up.

Can someone remind me. Has TSA discovered any bomb or IED at a security checkpoint?

petaluma1 Jul 6, 2013 12:04 pm


Originally Posted by CPT Trips (Post 21050030)
You are correct. Nothing they showed on camera prepared the Airport Security Screeners to find one of those bombs or properly respond to a discovery of one. It sure would be interesting to see the "lesson plan" and the instructional objectives. It was probably fun for most Airport Security Screeners present and the guys actually blowing up things likely kept their skill set up.

Can someone remind me. Has TSA discovered any bomb or IED at a security checkpoint?

I've been told that, for the most part, front line clerks don't get to go on these field trips. It's for the higher ups.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:54 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.