FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Cathay Pacific | Cathay (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-cathay-487/)
-   -   business class lounge pass on ID ticket (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-cathay/1814951-business-class-lounge-pass-id-ticket.html)

rienhart87 Jan 12, 2017 10:43 pm

business class lounge pass on ID ticket
 
Hi guys!

I have a question regarding business class lounge pass. I have 1 lounge pass after I passed 200 club points last year. I would like to use it as the validity period is almost over.

I have an upcoming flight to Delhi (CX695) and I will be traveling with my friend. We bought the ticket separately since he was not able to confirm whether he will go to Delhi or not when I made the purchase. I will be in J and he will be in Y. However, he's on ID ticket as he is a staff with another airline. His confirmation whether he gets a seat or not will only happen at check-in.

So, the question is, can I use my one business class lounge pass for him even though he's on ID ticket (standby)? I understand that this lounge pass request must be submitted online and not during check-in so that during check-in, his reservation will be tied with the lounge pass.

By virtue of CX's own wording, my friend should be eligible for this lounge pass because he is traveling on the same flight with me (MP member) and the flight is operated by CX/KA. However, I have heard from other friends that whenever they travel on CX on ID ticket, they are not eligible for lounge access even when they are in J or F cabin.

Anyone with similar experience? Thanks in advance!

QRC3288 Jan 12, 2017 10:56 pm

I cannot fully answer your question about how to "print out" the lounge pass for an ID passenger as part of the additional tier benefits.

However, I can confirm one element of your question: ID pax can indeed use the lounge in other situations. Nothing in the OW or CX status rules prevents ID pax from using the lounge, provided they are entitled outside of their possession of an ID J class / F class ticket.

What I mean by the above paragraph is ID passengers aren't prohibited from using the lounge....just they can't access it due to their ticket. So they need another way.

For example, if you have a friend flying on any OW airline on an ID ticket, and you're entitled to guest someone in by virtue of your status, this is no problem - you may guest your friend in (provided they're on a OW ticket). Or, if an ID passenger also happens to have status (SL, GO, DM, etc.), then he/she can access the lounge due to the elite status entitlement. ID pax can't access the lounge even if flying J or F alone, but if their status permits it or are guested in, they can.

So I don't see why an ID passenger in theory can't use the lounge pass as you're asking. However, given CX forces you to use the online system and the system has to "print out" the pass automatically, it does seem more difficult. My *bet* is for the confirmed ID tickets, which staff usually know about ~24 hours before, then it will work. This occurs when the flights are widddeee open and CX has no problem confirming the ID pax boarding pass early on. However, more often the staff must go to the airport to get their ticket, and I'm not sure if the CX check-in agents at the staff counter will issue the lounge pass. They are notoriously...unhelpful to their own staff.

rienhart87 Jan 12, 2017 11:15 pm

I see! Thank you QRC3288 Your explanation regarding staff travel and lounge access by virtue of elite status makes sense.. Unfortunately my friend is not CX staff and he does not have OW status. Only with ST and *A. I guess I will just have to see until 24 hours prior to departure whether he gets the seat or not then I will try to go online and redeem the lounge pass.

He just checked and Y class still has about 100 seats free for Jan 31 departure so I will cross my fingers :)

QRC3288 Jan 13, 2017 12:24 am


Originally Posted by rienhart87 (Post 27753207)
He just checked and Y class still has about 100 seats free for Jan 31 departure so I will cross my fingers :)

yes, as long as he gets his confirmation and boarding pass early, I don't think there will be any problem.

i also think there SHOULD be a reasonable chance it works even if the ticket is issued at the staff check-in desk at the airport, because even staff ID tickets are issued proper Amadeus or whatever booking records. So you have a record locator number, ticket number, etc. This is all you need to enter when you're allocating your lounge pass benefit.

The #1 most obvious problem is just that the flight fills up a bit more, and CX decides not to release ID tickets until the last minute, as they frequently do. He obviously can't enjoy the lounge if he receives his boarding pass 40 minutes before departure.

For #2, which is if CX releases the ticket to him early but they play games or try to deny the lounge benefit because he's on a staff ticket...I could totally see this happening. CX has a notoriously toxic culture towards how CX treats their fellow ID ticket-holders, particularly younger ones. Both at the check-in process and on-board. It's bizarre and a terrible reflection on the entire company's culture, but that's just how they do it...and I'll let other smarter posters than me opine.

rienhart87 Jan 13, 2017 1:01 am

Once again, I really appreciate your feedback here QRC3288. I just tried to input his 160- ticket number and redeem the lounge pass for my friend. Website says, it's only available 48 hours prior to the flight.

Right now it will be a wait and see game ;) And if the staff indeed play games on me, I will remember your advices

flytoomuch1 Jan 13, 2017 4:37 pm

Unless CX is very different from other airlines, staff are prohibited from using lounges on staff travel tickets.
When travelling on staff travel, even if the passenger has status every airline I know of prohibits them using the lounge.
The only exception is duty travel where their level in the business allows lounge access for work travel.

QRC3288 Jan 13, 2017 5:13 pm


Originally Posted by flytoomuch1 (Post 27757590)
Unless CX is very different from other airlines, staff are prohibited from using lounges on staff travel tickets.
When travelling on staff travel, even if the passenger has status every airline I know of prohibits them using the lounge.
The only exception is duty travel where their level in the business allows lounge access for work travel.

Without offense, I can confirm what you're writing is completely inaccurate for CX. I have no idea about other airlines, but this is the CX forum. Everything I wrote about the situation with CX ID tickets and lounges is accurate.

cxfan1960 Jan 13, 2017 5:21 pm


Originally Posted by flytoomuch1 (Post 27757590)
Unless CX is very different from other airlines, staff are prohibited from using lounges on staff travel tickets.
When travelling on staff travel, even if the passenger has status every airline I know of prohibits them using the lounge.
The only exception is duty travel where their level in the business allows lounge access for work travel.

That's what I think too, but not sure about this case as it is "paid for" by a normal passenger - better check with CX.

I suggest OP writes MPC.

QRC3288 Jan 13, 2017 5:42 pm


Originally Posted by cxfan1960 (Post 27757763)
That's what I think too, but not sure about this case as it is "paid for" by a normal passenger - better check with CX.

I suggest OP writes MPC.

I can assure you ID passengers are permitted in the HKG lounges provided it isn't their underlying ticket that gives them permission. (aka, holding an ID or ID F ticket is NOT grounds for entry to the lounge, as expected).

ID passengers CAN be guested in, or they can be allowed in by virtue of their elite status (if they have it). Without going into details, I am 100% certain about this for CX. I have no idea about other airlines.

I will add, it would be circumventing their own MPC T&C if they prohibited who I can guest in, or if an ID passenger has status but is denied entry under certain ticket types. The MPC T&C are extensive, and extremely clear on entry criteria to lounges: excluding ID passengers (or other fare types) is not one of the myriad rules. The lounge entrant must be flying on CX or KA, or other OW carriers. The cheapest fanfares are, in some cases, virtually the same price as ID tickets fyi. CX doesn't deny a DM entry to the lounge because he's on a fanfare.

Anyway, academic/theoretical arguments aside I am 100% positive about this in reality.

bhyq Jan 13, 2017 9:12 pm


Originally Posted by QRC3288 (Post 27757836)
I can assure you ID passengers are permitted in the HKG lounges provided it isn't their underlying ticket that gives them permission. (aka, holding an ID or ID F ticket is NOT grounds for entry to the lounge, as expected).

ID passengers CAN be guested in, or they can be allowed in by virtue of their elite status (if they have it). Without going into details, I am 100% certain about this for CX. I have no idea about other airlines.

I will add, it would be circumventing their own MPC T&C if they prohibited who I can guest in, or if an ID passenger has status but is denied entry under certain ticket types. The MPC T&C are extensive, and extremely clear on entry criteria to lounges: excluding ID passengers (or other fare types) is not one of the myriad rules. The lounge entrant must be flying on CX or KA, or other OW carriers. The cheapest fanfares are, in some cases, virtually the same price as ID tickets fyi. CX doesn't deny a DM entry to the lounge because he's on a fanfare.

Anyway, academic/theoretical arguments aside I am 100% positive about this in reality.

This is indeed 100% accurate. Even on an ID ticket if the ticket holder is a MPO member by virtue of their status they are afforded lounge access. They can also be guested in within someone else's entitlement.

However unless the flights empty you'll probably get a boarding pass at T-40 and have to run to gate 71!

jagmeets Jan 13, 2017 9:18 pm


Originally Posted by QRC3288 (Post 27757736)
Without offense, I can confirm what you're writing is completely inaccurate for CX. I have no idea about other airlines, but this is the CX forum. Everything I wrote about the situation with CX ID tickets and lounges is accurate.

Isn't our forum ambassador a status holder - or was, for a while after taking up employment with CX and able to use the status benefits?

brunos Jan 13, 2017 11:15 pm


Originally Posted by flytoomuch1 (Post 27757590)
Unless CX is very different from other airlines, staff are prohibited from using lounges on staff travel tickets.
When travelling on staff travel, even if the passenger has status every airline I know of prohibits them using the lounge.
The only exception is duty travel where their level in the business allows lounge access for work travel.

This is not correct.
I have frequently guested staff friends traveling on the same flight in the F lounge based on my OWE card.
Their ID ticket (J or F) does not give them access to a lounge. But nothing "prohibit" them lounge access. They can be guested.

rienhart87 Jan 15, 2017 8:10 pm

Thanks everyone for your opinions and feedback regarding my question! I really appreciate it! Let's see what will happen :) I will update this thread again. I have also sent an e-mail to MPC and we'll see what they reply

QRC3288 Jan 15, 2017 8:22 pm


Originally Posted by rienhart87 (Post 27767208)
Thanks everyone for your opinions and feedback regarding my question! I really appreciate it! Let's see what will happen :) I will update this thread again. I have also sent an e-mail to MPC and we'll see what they reply

the posts above implying ID passengers can't use the lounge are just flat-out incorrect information.

but specifically for the lounge pass benefit, I am interested to see what happens because nobody has posed this question before, and the lounge pass benefit is such a new thing.

The T&C for the lounge passes do indeed have exclusions (non OW passengers, for example), but ID passengers aren't one of the exclusions. Technically, I dont think CX has solid grounds to exclude them - they never told us members, for example, certain types of CX tickets were excluded prior to us spending more on CX. Not to mention, ID passengers can already access the lounges if guested in or if they have status. Both of these points I'm certain about.

However, I don't have first-hand knowledge about the lounge passes, as I haven't tried to redeem lounge passes for ID ticket holders. I *think* entitlement will follow CX's logic above, which is: "ID passengers do not get lounge entitlement with J or F ID tickets like normal tickets do. However, 1.) MPC elite members can access lounges regardless of underlying ticket fare provided they are flying a OW carrier (no exclusion of certain ticket types, even super discount ones like ID), and 2.) MPC elite members can guest people in, provided the guest is flying on a OW carriers (no exclusion of certain ticket types, including cheap ones like ID, again). If CX were to selectively prohibit certain types of tickets from lounge access from folks they've already granted access/guesting rights to under their own rules (DM, GO, etc.), they are basically violating their own T&C. This logic *should* hold true for the lounge passes, but let's see what happens. We all know non-OW tickets aren't allowed in. I *wish* that wasn't true, I frequently have colleagues and friends traveling *A and whatnot, but at least we know those are the rules. For ID passengers, this has never been prohibited. If CX went that route another concern of mine would be fanfares - as I mention above, sometimes they are as cheap (and occasionally even cheaper) than ID tickets.

I think the main roadblock will just be the A counters where staff check-in, and if your friend encounters a jerk/uninformed person working the desk. I bet it could get resolved at the end of the day, but time isn't your friend since presumably he's only going to show up a few hours before the flight.

Doraemat Jan 16, 2017 4:42 am


Originally Posted by QRC3288 (Post 27757836)
I can assure you ID passengers are permitted in the HKG lounges provided it isn't their underlying ticket that gives them permission. (aka, holding an ID or ID F ticket is NOT grounds for entry to the lounge, as expected).

ID passengers CAN be guested in, or they can be allowed in by virtue of their elite status (if they have it). Without going into details, I am 100% certain about this for CX. I have no idea about other airlines.

I will add, it would be circumventing their own MPC T&C if they prohibited who I can guest in, or if an ID passenger has status but is denied entry under certain ticket types. The MPC T&C are extensive, and extremely clear on entry criteria to lounges: excluding ID passengers (or other fare types) is not one of the myriad rules. The lounge entrant must be flying on CX or KA, or other OW carriers. The cheapest fanfares are, in some cases, virtually the same price as ID tickets fyi. CX doesn't deny a DM entry to the lounge because he's on a fanfare.

Anyway, academic/theoretical arguments aside I am 100% positive about this in reality.

I can back up QRC3288 - what he says is correct.

I have guested in a travelling companion who was travelling on an ID ticket (J class - not that it matters) into the Pier F class lounge last year with no issues. I have also guested a travelling companion on an ID ticket in outports too - Ho Chi Minh City, London.

QCR3288 is absolutely correct that ID pax are not entitled to lounge access by virtue of their class of travel, but they can access the lounge if they are entitled to access due to some other reason (such as being guested in).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:45 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.