FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Canada (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/canada-462/)
-   -   Transit in YYZ without clearing Immigrations? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/canada/1024173-transit-yyz-without-clearing-immigrations.html)

TravellinHusker Dec 5, 2009 3:59 pm

Transit in YYZ without clearing Immigrations?
 
A colleague who is a native of Peru needs to travel to Europe and is curious if she can fly on AC on the nonstop from LIM to YYZ then connect to MUC or FRA without clearing immigrations and customs. Has YYZ become a transit-friendly airport?

Stranger Dec 5, 2009 4:47 pm

/ 05DEC09 / 2346 UTC



National Peru (PE) /Transit Canada (CA)
Destination Germany (DE)
ALSO CHECK DESTINATION INFORMATION BELOW


Canada (CA)


Visa required.

Additional Information:

- Visitor seeking entry may be required to produce documentary
evidence to establish, to the satisfaction of an immigration

officer,For details, click here
Warning:
- Visitors not complying with entry requirements may be
refused admission into Canada and deported at carrier's
expense. For details, click here


Germany (DE)



Passport required.
- Passports and/or passport replacing documents must be valid
for the period of intended stay.

Visa required.

Minors:
- Minors aged up to/incl. 15 years of age may be included in
the passport of a parent or guardian, provided
For details, click here
Additional Information:

- Visitors must hold visible means of support, onward/return
tickets or evidence of continuing journey by other means of

transport and/or other documents required for next
destination.

For details, click here
Warning:
- Passports must be signed by the bearer. Passports that do
not contain the signature of the bearer, will not be
considered as a valid travel document and the traveller
shall be considered as inadmissible into Germany.
- The Schengen agreement went into effect on March 26, 1995.
For details, click here
- Non-compliance with the entry/transit requirements (incl.
forged documents and unsigned passports) results in:
For details, click here

CHECK TINEWS/N1 - SCHENGEN ANNOUNCES NEW VISA EXEMPTIONS,
EFFECTIVE 19 DECEMBER 2009



Timaticweb Version 1.3
05 December 2009

Jalinth Dec 5, 2009 4:51 pm

See this link.
http://www.airportwayfinder.com/wayfinders/yyz/?v=3_6
Go to
"Terminal 1 Connections" and then "International to International" for the video.

Your friend will go through "Customs B" - generally a cursory customs/immigration check. So more transit friendly than the US, but not as friendly as Europe.
But this only works if your friend arrives in Terminal 1 and their bags are checked through to Europe.

Hope this helps

FlyerGoldII Dec 5, 2009 7:02 pm

The question if one is from a country who needs a visa when entering Canada; does that person still need a visa when going through customs B, for such type of international flight to internation flight transit?

speaker Dec 5, 2009 8:06 pm


Originally Posted by FlyerGoldII (Post 12933329)
The question if one is from a country who needs a visa when entering Canada; does that person still need a visa when going through customs B, for such type of international flight to internation flight transit?

http://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/travel-vo...t-iiv-eng.html
http://www.cic.gc.ca/English/departm...2009-07-30.asp

It appears that one may only transit without a Visa if the USA is your origin or destination, and if one is a national of certain countries, flying on certain airlines, arriving at certain times... And so, regardless of whether or not "Intl-to-Intl" without a visa is permitted, neither Air Canada or LAN are participating airlines.

FlyerGoldII Dec 5, 2009 9:18 pm


Originally Posted by speaker (Post 12933551)
http://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/travel-vo...t-iiv-eng.html
http://www.cic.gc.ca/English/departm...2009-07-30.asp

It appears that one may only transit without a Visa if the USA is your origin or destination, and if one is a national of certain countries, flying on certain airlines, arriving at certain times... And so, regardless of whether or not "Intl-to-Intl" without a visa is permitted, neither Air Canada or LAN are participating airlines.

where is the list of approved airlines, participating in this program?

speaker Dec 6, 2009 5:27 am


Originally Posted by FlyerGoldII (Post 12933825)
where is the list of approved airlines, participating in this program?


At this time, the program only applies to nationals of the Philippines, Indonesia, Thailand and Taiwan who hold valid U.S. visas and who are travelling through the Vancouver International Airport to and from the United States on a participating airline. Currently, the following airlines are eligible to participate in the program: Philippine Airlines, China Airlines and Cathay Pacific Airways.
http://www.cic.gc.ca/English/departm...2009-07-30.asp
I just noticed it only works at YVR too... so this option is a really moot point for the OP

FlyerGoldII Dec 6, 2009 6:33 am

So in Toronto, it means that the visa requirements whether one goes through Customs A, and enters the landside of the airport, or goes through Customs B, and stays airside, are identical?

californiadreamin' Dec 6, 2009 11:02 am


Originally Posted by FlyerGoldII (Post 12934941)
So in Toronto, it means that the visa requirements whether one goes through Customs A, and enters the landside of the airport, or goes through Customs B, and stays airside, are identical?

You are, in fact, entering Canada either way.

Triley Dec 6, 2009 12:17 pm


Originally Posted by californiadreamin' (Post 12935874)
You are, in fact, entering Canada either way.

But if you're only staying in Canada for a matter of a few hours, and you're not leaving the secure area, then what is the point of requiring a visa? It's just a waste of personnel time, for them having to process the visa, as well as the traveler's time and money.

Maybe some day more airlines will be added to the exempt list.

californiadreamin' Dec 6, 2009 10:22 pm


Originally Posted by Triley (Post 12936196)
But if you're only staying in Canada for a matter of a few hours, and you're not leaving the secure area, then what is the point of requiring a visa? ...

What if you surreptitiously don't fly out? Oe, what if all passengers, with whom you are co-mingling, have to leave the gate area due to IROPs?

28isGreat Dec 7, 2009 9:44 am


Originally Posted by californiadreamin' (Post 12938807)
What if you surreptitiously don't fly out? Oe, what if all passengers, with whom you are co-mingling, have to leave the gate area due to IROPs?

A normal international transit area doesn't allow you to leave the gate area without going through customs/immigration. (I believe this is the case in YYZ T1, though I've never gone through it.) And because of this, most airports that I have used that have this (*outside* of North America!) don't bother processing you when you are in transit.

hjohnson Dec 7, 2009 10:01 am


Originally Posted by californiadreamin' (Post 12935874)
You are, in fact, entering Canada either way.

The exception to this rule is if you're flying Intl->USA at YYZ. You go directly to US Immigration, and never talk to a Canadian border agent.

californiadreamin' Dec 8, 2009 1:41 am

Lest the OP become confused by these two examples of altered circumstances:


Originally Posted by hjohnson (Post 12941086)
The exception to this rule is if you're flying Intl->USA at YYZ. You go directly to US Immigration, and never talk to a Canadian border agent.

In fact one must still satisfy Canadian immigration requirements. There is no inherent visa/passport waiver for this connection. If the USA declines to accept you, they will "send" you to Canada.



Originally Posted by 28isGreat (Post 12940995)
A normal international transit area doesn't allow you to leave the gate area without going through customs/immigration. (I believe this is the case in YYZ T1, though I've never gone through it.) And because of this, most airports that I have used that have this (*outside* of North America!) don't bother processing you when you are in transit.

The Eurpean model doesn't exist here. Interesting anecdote your comment may be, but the OP will not gain from it as the model at YYZ, which you say you have never gone through (T1 at least), is in fact closer to the "normal international transit area" for North America than not.

yyzvoyageur Dec 8, 2009 5:21 am

Yes, a transit visa would have to be obtained in advance from a Canadian mission abroad. There is no fee for this service.

yyzvoyageur Dec 8, 2009 5:22 am


Originally Posted by Triley (Post 12936196)
But if you're only staying in Canada for a matter of a few hours, and you're not leaving the secure area, then what is the point of requiring a visa?

"I'm refugee, I'm refugee!"

antirealist Dec 8, 2009 9:07 am

The town of Gander used to do quite well from this phenomenon as a result of refueling stops at YQX. Then the feds started to require visas, and the whole refugee thing dried up.

bocastephen Jun 16, 2011 2:34 pm

Not sure if this has been addressed elsewhere but I want to be totally clear on the process before I buy the AC Z class ticket for my client:

From AC's website, I already know my client (holding a PRC passport and US visa) can fly from PVG to BOS connecting at YYZ without needing a Canadian transit visa, but it's the other direction I want to clarify - can they fly BOS-YYZ-HKG with a layover at YYZ without needing a Canadian transit or entry visa and does the AC check-in staff at BOS know this?

We can't hold the ticket too long and it's the last Z seat - so if someone can offer advise on this quickly, it would be greatly appreciated.

B1 Jun 16, 2011 2:42 pm


Originally Posted by bocastephen (Post 16573687)
Not sure if this has been addressed elsewhere but I want to be totally clear on the process before I buy the AC Z class ticket for my client:

From AC's website, I already know my client (holding a PRC passport and US visa) can fly from PVG to BOS connecting at YYZ without needing a Canadian transit visa, but it's the other direction I want to clarify - can they fly BOS-YYZ-HKG with a layover at YYZ without needing a Canadian transit or entry visa and does the AC check-in staff at BOS know this?

We can't hold the ticket too long and it's the last Z seat - so if someone can offer advise on this quickly, it would be greatly appreciated.

They must enter Canada for a purpose that is declared on the TDC that they fill out and hand to an agent of the CBSA when they arrive at YYZ. It is their judgement that makes the decision and there is no process of appeal. In addition, the airline can decide if they are eligible for entry and may refuse their boarding the flight. It is a question if the US Visa is acceptable as the basis for entry to Canada. Once they are admitted to Canada for the flight they are in an area that has no security for exiting. Thus, it is wise to get a ruling in writing from the Canadian Consulate in Boston. Since there are flights from the US to Hong Kong, there is no real reason to go through Canada except for the fare and the risk would not be worth the saving.

bocastephen Jun 16, 2011 2:45 pm


Originally Posted by B1 (Post 16573736)
They must enter Canada for a purpose that is declared on the TDC that they fill out and hand to an agent of the CBSA when they arrive at YYZ. It is their judgement that makes the decision and there is no process of appeal. In addition, the airline can decide if they are eligible for entry and may refuse their boarding the flight. It is a question if the US Visa is acceptable as the basis for entry to Canada. Once they are admitted to Canada for the flight they are in an area that has no security for exiting. Thus, it is wise to get a ruling in writing from the Canadian Consulate in Boston. Since there are flights from the US to Hong Kong, there is no real reason to go through Canada except for the fare and the risk would not be worth the saving.

I found this online...but I want to make sure the AC agents at BOS will not have an issue and deny boarding.



What's New

Great News! Canada Transit Without Visa!

Effective March 27, 2011, Air Canada will be participating in the Canada Transit Without Visa Program (TWOV). Consequently, citizens of China who are in direct transit through either Toronto Pearson (YYZ) or Vancouver (YVR) on their way to or from the United States will not be required to obtain a Canadian temporary resident visa.

Let Air Canada be your preferred airline to Canada!

Customer Eligibility:

Nationals of China
Travelling from China to the United States via Vancouver (YVR) or Toronto (YYZ)
Must hold a valid Chinese passport
Must hold a valid US visa
Must travel on an Air Canada-operated non-stop flight to Vancouver (YVR) or Toronto (YYZ), departing Beijing (PEK), Hong Kong (HKG) or Shanghai (PVG)
Must hold a confirmed onward ticket to the US within the same day of arrival and within the scheduled hours of the USITPC*
Round-trip ticket
*USITPC Scheduled Hours: Toronto (YYZ): 04:30 - 21:00; Vancouver (YVR): 04:30 - 20:30

See links below for more detailed information:
http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/departm...uthorities.asp

Air Canada China Call Center: 400 811 2001
Website: www.aircanada.com

Clipper801 Jun 16, 2011 2:51 pm


Originally Posted by bocastephen (Post 16573756)
I found this online...but I want to make sure the AC agents at BOS will not have an issue and deny boarding.

It does say to or from the USA according to the AC web site:

http://www.aircanada.com/en/news/110328.html?src=hp_wn



Easier transit between certain Asian countries and the U.S.
In accordance with the Canadian government’s Transit without Visa (TWOV) program, citizens of certain Asian countries who are transiting through Vancouver International or Toronto Pearson International airports to or from the US are not required to obtain a Canadian temporary resident visa, provided:

They are travelling to Canada on an Air Canada or Air Canada Express (operated by Jazz only) flight,
They hold a valid passport from their country,
They hold a US visa that is valid upon their arrival in the US.
The TWOV program applies to the following passengers only:

Citizens from Indonesia, the Philippines, Taiwan (Chinese Taipei) and Thailand
Citizens of China who are travelling from Beijing, Hong Kong or Shanghai.
We invite you to learn more about visa and travel document requirements.


dan1431 Aug 7, 2012 8:05 am

Sorry to bump up an older thread, but I was truly unsure of the proper thread for my question.

My cousin just booked a ticket EWR-YYZ-CLE on the outbound (used Expedia) UA to YYZ and AC to CLE and then called me (I am resident travel guru in the family) to inquire how Immigration and Customs would work in Canada (and I guess the USA though he is a USA citizen so they really cannot deny him access to the USA) as he is connecting in Canada to fly what is essentially a domestic ticket.

He stumped me as I never even considered nor experienced such an itinerary in my life, so I am going to the real experts FTers for the answer.

Is my cousin able to stay in transit or must he clear Canadian Immigrations and Customs and then USA Immigration and Customs before boarding his flight to CLE?

Thanks,
Dan

bocastephen Aug 7, 2012 9:54 am


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 19074710)
Sorry to bump up an older thread, but I was truly unsure of the proper thread for my question.

My cousin just booked a ticket EWR-YYZ-CLE on the outbound (used Expedia) UA to YYZ and AC to CLE and then called me (I am resident travel guru in the family) to inquire how Immigration and Customs would work in Canada (and I guess the USA though he is a USA citizen so they really cannot deny him access to the USA) as he is connecting in Canada to fly what is essentially a domestic ticket.

He stumped me as I never even considered nor experienced such an itinerary in my life, so I am going to the real experts FTers for the answer.

Is my cousin able to stay in transit or must he clear Canadian Immigrations and Customs and then USA Immigration and Customs before boarding his flight to CLE?

Thanks,
Dan

Upon arrival in YYZ, just follow the signs for USA Connections - there may be a very quick doc check by Canadian immigration, but he will pre-clear US immigration before going to the departure gate.

FLLDL Aug 7, 2012 8:26 pm


Originally Posted by bocastephen (Post 19075380)
Upon arrival in YYZ, just follow the signs for USA Connections - there may be a very quick doc check by Canadian immigration, but he will pre-clear US immigration before going to the departure gate.

Are flights US-Canada-US permitted? I thought there was some sort of arcane rule against this?

bocastephen Aug 7, 2012 8:46 pm


Originally Posted by FLLDL (Post 19079101)
Are flights US-Canada-US permitted? I thought there was some sort of arcane rule against this?

If the flights span multiple tickets (US-CAN ticket 1, CAN-US ticket 2), there is no problem....US-CAN-US or CAN-US-CAN on one ticket is a no-no.

dan1431 Aug 8, 2012 7:33 am


Originally Posted by FLLDL (Post 19079101)
Are flights US-Canada-US permitted? I thought there was some sort of arcane rule against this?

So you mean as one of the "Freedoms of the Air" which set forth the rights of airlines to enter each others airspace?

I did not see the construction of the fare, but I wonder, could EXPEDIA sell a ticket that is not legal routing-wise?

Dan

bocastephen Aug 8, 2012 12:32 pm


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 19081205)
So you mean as one of the "Freedoms of the Air" which set forth the rights of airlines to enter each others airspace?

I did not see the construction of the fare, but I wonder, could EXPEDIA sell a ticket that is not legal routing-wise?

Dan

If you check the Expedia confirmation, there might two Eticket numbers listed -if not, and they somehow constructed a cabotage itinerary, there will be a hefty debit memo in their future.

dan1431 Aug 8, 2012 1:49 pm

I checked the itin and it is one ticket on UA stock.

First Seg is UA operated
Second Seg is AC operated

Dan

dan1431 Aug 8, 2012 1:54 pm

Either way I advised my cousin to call EXPEDIA and see what is up.

My cousin called EXPEDIA and spoke with an outsourced call center employee who apparently said, "that since he (my cousin) is an American he is free to fly wherever he wants", which did not exactly answer my cousins question.

He pressed the outsourced call center employee who finally put him on-hold, came back and offered him a refund since he was unable to determine if the routing was legal or not and the outsourced employee admitted it looked funny to him too.

Now my cousin needs to find a better (or at least more legal route) between EWR-CLE as currently UA wants over $600 for the route.

Dan

bocastephen Aug 8, 2012 3:15 pm


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 19083967)
Either way I advised my cousin to call EXPEDIA and see what is up.

My cousin called EXPEDIA and spoke with an outsourced call center employee who apparently said, "that since he (my cousin) is an American he is free to fly wherever he wants", which did not exactly answer my cousins question.

He pressed the outsourced call center employee who finally put him on-hold, came back and offered him a refund since he was unable to determine if the routing was legal or not and the outsourced employee admitted it looked funny to him too.

Now my cousin needs to find a better (or at least more legal route) between EWR-CLE as currently UA wants over $600 for the route.

Dan

I wouldn't call Expedia - I would call United and ask for a supervisor to review the ticket and determine if it's approved for travel. Don't mention routing issues or cabotage - let them make a determination on their own and request the record be documented accordingly.

If UA balks at the ticket, then go back to Expedia and demand a refund


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:28 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.