BA crew (including Captain) not enforcing face mask rules
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC GGL/CCR; TK Elite; ITA Executive; Hilton Diamond; Marriott Bonvoy Platinum
Posts: 1,509

Couple of weeks ago I flew to CAI, 4h30m flight - not one of my best flights.
Last man onboard - as usual - however upon boarding I found out a lady was sitting in my seat (1A) without wearing any face mask.
She was reluctant and disappointed to go back to her seat, 2D, next to her friend in 2F (without a facemask either) when the CSM asked her to move to her assigned seat. Her brother was sitting in 1C, with a facemask covering his chin only. All three of them in their early 30s.
I then sat down in 1A and started wiping the armrests as somebody else sat in my seat before, without wearing a face mask. Doors were still open as there were a couple of passengers missing so I went to the galley and politely asked the CSM to kindly ask 1C, 2D and 2F to wear their facemasks. So he did however facemasks stayed on their mouth and nose for less than 1 minute only. We were still on the ground, doors still open. I went back to the galley and informed the CSM that they removed their masks again. At that point the CSM said he couldn't do anything (although the party did not have any exemption from wearing a mask, he said). Fine, I asked to speak to the Captain who promptly came out of the flight deck and spoke to me in the galley. He said he could not enforce the mask rule onboard either. This for me is hard to believe as (a) masks are mandatory on public transport in the UK and (b) the Captain is in charge of the flight, by law.
I went back to my seat and the lady in 2F started shouting at me in English and Arabic saying her friend in 2D is a "Royal" (FYI from the Middle East) and can sue me (?!?!), not sure for what reason. I just replied "wear your f***ing mask" (excuse my French). I was angry as I do not tolerate people who intentionally do not sit in their assigned seat and do not take COVID seriously. Then in fact the lady in 2D threatened to sue me upon landing. None of them were Prems, nor Golds (when I spoke to the CSM he had his iPad open and passengers sorted by CIV).
End of the story, I went back to my seat and wore a second facemask on top of my first one. For the entire duration of the flight the trio did not wear any facemask.
I really had to get to CAI that evening, otherwise I would have offloaded myself from that flight. I politely asked the CSM to provide me with both his and the Captain's details and so he did.
I am planning to send feedback to BA.
What would you have done in a similar situation?
Last man onboard - as usual - however upon boarding I found out a lady was sitting in my seat (1A) without wearing any face mask.
She was reluctant and disappointed to go back to her seat, 2D, next to her friend in 2F (without a facemask either) when the CSM asked her to move to her assigned seat. Her brother was sitting in 1C, with a facemask covering his chin only. All three of them in their early 30s.
I then sat down in 1A and started wiping the armrests as somebody else sat in my seat before, without wearing a face mask. Doors were still open as there were a couple of passengers missing so I went to the galley and politely asked the CSM to kindly ask 1C, 2D and 2F to wear their facemasks. So he did however facemasks stayed on their mouth and nose for less than 1 minute only. We were still on the ground, doors still open. I went back to the galley and informed the CSM that they removed their masks again. At that point the CSM said he couldn't do anything (although the party did not have any exemption from wearing a mask, he said). Fine, I asked to speak to the Captain who promptly came out of the flight deck and spoke to me in the galley. He said he could not enforce the mask rule onboard either. This for me is hard to believe as (a) masks are mandatory on public transport in the UK and (b) the Captain is in charge of the flight, by law.
I went back to my seat and the lady in 2F started shouting at me in English and Arabic saying her friend in 2D is a "Royal" (FYI from the Middle East) and can sue me (?!?!), not sure for what reason. I just replied "wear your f***ing mask" (excuse my French). I was angry as I do not tolerate people who intentionally do not sit in their assigned seat and do not take COVID seriously. Then in fact the lady in 2D threatened to sue me upon landing. None of them were Prems, nor Golds (when I spoke to the CSM he had his iPad open and passengers sorted by CIV).
End of the story, I went back to my seat and wore a second facemask on top of my first one. For the entire duration of the flight the trio did not wear any facemask.
I really had to get to CAI that evening, otherwise I would have offloaded myself from that flight. I politely asked the CSM to provide me with both his and the Captain's details and so he did.
I am planning to send feedback to BA.
What would you have done in a similar situation?

#2
Ambassador: Emirates Airlines
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 18,162
Wow - you don't half have some good stories from your travels with BA! A quick search of your posts brings back all sorts of escapades.

#3
Moderator: British Airways Executive Club
Join Date: Jan 2009
Programs: Battleaxe Alliance
Posts: 22,098
That's a bit of an awkward one, although I would have been rather miffed at the selfishness of the group in refusing to wear a mask when everyone else was complying.
Unless it was a genuine mistake, to me, sitting in 1A when not assigned and being reluctant to move showed what kind of person she was - probably a selfish, potential abuser of her privileged position, taking it for granted that everyone else has to put up with whatever she does, which is something I find very hard to tolerate (I am a firm believer in privileges being accompanied by extra duties and obligations to do my best to do the right thing), so I would probably have liked to quietly address the matter in some ways, without making crew members' life harder (they are in a difficult position).
There is a limit to what crew members can do once they take off (a bit difficult to chuck them off), so I probably would have ended up shutting up and putting up, but probably quietly documented the whole thing, talked to the crew, recognised their difficult position, and with their cooperation wrote a complaint about passenger behaviour to BA, even though I would also assume that nothing would be done about it, and it amounts to nothing more than venting on my side.
I would not want the crew members to get into trouble with the company in any way, hence any complaint I submit will only be with crew members' cooperation, and if they had any concerns that they'd end up with issues, I'd even refrain from filing a complaint entirely, because I totally understand they've been put in a really difficult position and I have no intention of risking them being blamed. It would be the passengers I'm annoyed with, not the crew, and I don't want any comeback for the crew. However, if the airline would back them (crew) up, and my complaint triggers more support for the crew in enforcing mask wearing, then I'd be happy.
(My annoyance will not have been out of fear of catching Covid, but rather, that they were abusing their privileged position, basically.
Now, if I owned the airline and I were the captain, my response would have been entirely different! I'd have asked them twice, warned them once, and if no compliance, would have landed somewhere really obscure and chucked them off with pleasure, and sod the consequence.)
Unless it was a genuine mistake, to me, sitting in 1A when not assigned and being reluctant to move showed what kind of person she was - probably a selfish, potential abuser of her privileged position, taking it for granted that everyone else has to put up with whatever she does, which is something I find very hard to tolerate (I am a firm believer in privileges being accompanied by extra duties and obligations to do my best to do the right thing), so I would probably have liked to quietly address the matter in some ways, without making crew members' life harder (they are in a difficult position).
There is a limit to what crew members can do once they take off (a bit difficult to chuck them off), so I probably would have ended up shutting up and putting up, but probably quietly documented the whole thing, talked to the crew, recognised their difficult position, and with their cooperation wrote a complaint about passenger behaviour to BA, even though I would also assume that nothing would be done about it, and it amounts to nothing more than venting on my side.
I would not want the crew members to get into trouble with the company in any way, hence any complaint I submit will only be with crew members' cooperation, and if they had any concerns that they'd end up with issues, I'd even refrain from filing a complaint entirely, because I totally understand they've been put in a really difficult position and I have no intention of risking them being blamed. It would be the passengers I'm annoyed with, not the crew, and I don't want any comeback for the crew. However, if the airline would back them (crew) up, and my complaint triggers more support for the crew in enforcing mask wearing, then I'd be happy.
(My annoyance will not have been out of fear of catching Covid, but rather, that they were abusing their privileged position, basically.
Now, if I owned the airline and I were the captain, my response would have been entirely different! I'd have asked them twice, warned them once, and if no compliance, would have landed somewhere really obscure and chucked them off with pleasure, and sod the consequence.)
Last edited by LTN Phobia; Jan 5, 21 at 3:23 am

#4
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC GGL/CCR; TK Elite; ITA Executive; Hilton Diamond; Marriott Bonvoy Platinum
Posts: 1,509
You are right but that's because I usually only report on here what I think is bad behavior - and pre-COVID I was on quite a few flights every month.

#5
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: London N8
Programs: BA (LTG), Miles&More (whatever the lowest level is), Oyster card (zones 1-2)
Posts: 832
Sending out the batsignal for the C-W-S de-escalation protocol to be enacted

#6
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: BER
Programs: BA GGL, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 1,808
for the topic: complain about it. BA has an email address for that. I would not make a fuzz about it whilst onboard out of two reasons. (1) Usually ppl don't rethink their actions cause you tell them they might be wrong. (2) it may cause further problems.

#7
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC GGL/CCR; TK Elite; ITA Executive; Hilton Diamond; Marriott Bonvoy Platinum
Posts: 1,509
to me, sitting in 1A when not assigned and being reluctant to move showed what kind of person she was - probably a selfish, potential abuser of her privileged position, taking it for granted that everyone else has to put up with whatever she does, which is something I find very hard to tolerate (I am a firm believer in privileges being accompanied by extra duties and obligations to do my best to do the right thing), so I would probably have liked to quietly address the matter in some ways, without making crew members' life harder (they are in a difficult position).

#8
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC GGL/CCR; TK Elite; ITA Executive; Hilton Diamond; Marriott Bonvoy Platinum
Posts: 1,509

#9
Join Date: Feb 2009
Programs: Mucci, BA, Hilton.
Posts: 1,156
To the OP it is difficult. The longer this goes on the more unreasonably angry I get to non-mask wearers in public. I think you are entirely correct to feel aggrieved however little can/will be done. Personal accountability seems to be a thing of the past. The response from BA will be interesting if you can report back?

#10
Moderator: British Airways Executive Club
Join Date: Jan 2009
Programs: Battleaxe Alliance
Posts: 22,098

#11
Moderator, Iberia Airlines, Airport Lounges, and Ambassador, British Airways Executive Club
Join Date: Feb 2010
Programs: BA Lifetime Gold; Flying Blue Life Platinum; LH Sen.; Hilton Diamond; Kemal Kebabs Prized Customer
Posts: 61,107
In terms of de-escalation, I did really like the post that young KARFA put out in a slightly different context. While it's good to encourage people to do the right thing, and sometimes people genuinely have forgotten to get the mask in place, nevertheless this is ultimately about personal responsibility. You can allow yourself to get tied in knots about this but frankly it's bad for your soul. The best you can do is to lead by good example, safe in the sure and certain knowledge that you are on side of the angels.
That said, I would have just offloaded myself. If you do that then the captain would have some explaining to do. There are very, very few things in life that can't wait 24 hours.

#12
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: UK
Programs: Lemonia. Best Greek ever.
Posts: 2,196
Reading other airline sites/threads, it would appear that most of the USA airlines are far stricter, and often/always offload folk who will not wear their mask properly.
I think that CWS is right. If the staff will not enforce the rule, then self-off loading is required.
I would report this to BA and think about calling the media.
I think that CWS is right. If the staff will not enforce the rule, then self-off loading is required.
I would report this to BA and think about calling the media.

#13
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC GGL/CCR; TK Elite; ITA Executive; Hilton Diamond; Marriott Bonvoy Platinum
Posts: 1,509
Yes, I did think "oh no, just what we need today".
In terms of de-escalation, I did really like the post that young KARFA put out in a slightly different context. While it's good to encourage people to do the right thing, and sometimes people genuinely have forgotten to get the mask in place, nevertheless this is ultimately about personal responsibility. You can allow yourself to get tied in knots about this but frankly it's bad for your soul. The best you can do is to lead by good example, safe in the sure and certain knowledge that you are on side of the angels.
That said, I would have just offloaded myself. If you do that then the captain would have some explaining to do. There are very, very few things in life that can't wait 24 hours.
In terms of de-escalation, I did really like the post that young KARFA put out in a slightly different context. While it's good to encourage people to do the right thing, and sometimes people genuinely have forgotten to get the mask in place, nevertheless this is ultimately about personal responsibility. You can allow yourself to get tied in knots about this but frankly it's bad for your soul. The best you can do is to lead by good example, safe in the sure and certain knowledge that you are on side of the angels.
That said, I would have just offloaded myself. If you do that then the captain would have some explaining to do. There are very, very few things in life that can't wait 24 hours.

#14
Join Date: May 2014
Posts: 6,861
Having asked the OH, BA crews have limited powers on mask wearing: they can ask the offender twice, then the CSM has the faculty of giving some sort of final warning and then the non-masker might get banning. But knowing as I do that even people who assaulted crews didn't get banned... it's a loooooooooong shot. And, of course, somebody could say "I'm exempt" and BA crews can do nothing but comply. They don't even need to provide proof.

#15
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2014
Location: UK
Programs: BA Gold
Posts: 11,632
What's the latest point you can request an off load ? Presumably only to the point the jet bridge moves away ?
