Last edit by: corporate-wage-slave
Link to Text of the regulations in PDF format
Downgrades: Mennens case - calculation formula is in this post
787 cancellations due to Trent engine issues - CEDR ruling information from the post in the 2018 thread and onwards.
Downgrades: Mennens case - calculation formula is in this post
787 cancellations due to Trent engine issues - CEDR ruling information from the post in the 2018 thread and onwards.
The 2019 BA compensation thread: Your guide to Regulation EC261/2004
#391
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Brighton. UK
Programs: BA Gold / VS /IHG Diamond & Ambassador
Posts: 14,176
Hi guys,
just wondering if I and my wife are due anything.
BA LHR to Philly, delayed due to mechanical, around 3+ hours, sitting on the plane...
while on the plane, a medical issue with one of the passengers.. not sure what happen
Arrived Philly too late to make connection to ATL,
spent the night at hotel (BA provided)
Booked on AA the following day..
so arrived at our final destination about 26 hours later
thanks in advance
just wondering if I and my wife are due anything.
BA LHR to Philly, delayed due to mechanical, around 3+ hours, sitting on the plane...
while on the plane, a medical issue with one of the passengers.. not sure what happen
Arrived Philly too late to make connection to ATL,
spent the night at hotel (BA provided)
Booked on AA the following day..
so arrived at our final destination about 26 hours later
thanks in advance
BA will try and allocate the total delay to (a) the mechanical issue and (b) the medical issue. You would need the delay caused bu the tech issue to be over the EU 261 limit as the medical delay would be excluded from the delay time.
If you give the date of the flight and it's in the last week or so the actual times will be on sites like flight radar.
#392
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Brighton. UK
Programs: BA Gold / VS /IHG Diamond & Ambassador
Posts: 14,176
Downgrade and delay in replying
What is supposed to happen if it takes them more than 7 days, or if it takes them more than 7 days to reply to my complaint?
I suppose I should be entitled to additional compensation but if so, how much?
2. If an operating air carrier places a passenger in a class lower than that for which the ticket was purchased,
it shall within seven days, by the means provided for in Article 7(3), reimburse...
What is supposed to happen if it takes them more than 7 days, or if it takes them more than 7 days to reply to my complaint?
I suppose I should be entitled to additional compensation but if so, how much?
2. If an operating air carrier places a passenger in a class lower than that for which the ticket was purchased,
it shall within seven days, by the means provided for in Article 7(3), reimburse...
TBH nothing happens to BA. You could complain to the CAA who would do absolutely zilch despite being the regulator responsible for enforcing E U261.
#393
Join Date: Jun 2013
Location: Roswell, GA
Programs: AA EXP 2.8m,Lifetime PLT, Hilton Diamond, IHG PlLT, SPG Gold
Posts: 3,191
It is delay on arrival that matters (difference between actual and scheduled) not departure
BA will try and allocate the total delay to (a) the mechanical issue and (b) the medical issue. You would need the delay caused bu the tech issue to be over the EU 261 limit as the medical delay would be excluded from the delay time.
If you give the date of the flight and it's in the last week or so the actual times will be on sites like flight radar.
BA will try and allocate the total delay to (a) the mechanical issue and (b) the medical issue. You would need the delay caused bu the tech issue to be over the EU 261 limit as the medical delay would be excluded from the delay time.
If you give the date of the flight and it's in the last week or so the actual times will be on sites like flight radar.
will check
#394
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: Shoreham By Sea
Programs: BAEC Gold
Posts: 1,316
Could someone let me know if my thinking is correct that I could be due either 300 Euro or 600 Euro due to the delay I’m experiencing today.
Ticketed with BA but on AA metal all the way. DUB - CLT - DFW - ICT
My flight leaving the EU (DUB to CLT) was on time but my flight from CLT to DFW was delayed 2 and a half hours which meant I missed the DFW to ICT leg. The CLT DFW delay started small, then got bigger. As soon as the estimated arrival time was after the scheduled departure of my DFW to ICT leg I spoke with the lounge agent who re ticketed me on the later flight.
The original flight to ICT was scheduled to arrive at 1959. The new flight (currently at DFW for it) is scheduled to arrive at 2347.
I think I’m entitled to EU261 as this is a through ticket from Ireland and I’m on a EU ticket (BA 125) although travelling from the EU I’m not sure that’s even relevant.
On a side note, even if the trip is eligible, I’ve no idea for the delay other than being told it’s due to a late inbound aircraft. How to I check the reason?
Ticketed with BA but on AA metal all the way. DUB - CLT - DFW - ICT
My flight leaving the EU (DUB to CLT) was on time but my flight from CLT to DFW was delayed 2 and a half hours which meant I missed the DFW to ICT leg. The CLT DFW delay started small, then got bigger. As soon as the estimated arrival time was after the scheduled departure of my DFW to ICT leg I spoke with the lounge agent who re ticketed me on the later flight.
The original flight to ICT was scheduled to arrive at 1959. The new flight (currently at DFW for it) is scheduled to arrive at 2347.
I think I’m entitled to EU261 as this is a through ticket from Ireland and I’m on a EU ticket (BA 125) although travelling from the EU I’m not sure that’s even relevant.
On a side note, even if the trip is eligible, I’ve no idea for the delay other than being told it’s due to a late inbound aircraft. How to I check the reason?
#395
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: London, UK
Programs: BA GGL
Posts: 1,577
It's eligible in that you departed from the EU, but the (root) cause of the delays that affected you might be a factor. Also, requesting a reroute can complicate matters. That said, if you're delayed at your final destination, which it sounds like you will be, I would claim EC261 compensation and see what AA say, then decide based on their response how to proceed.
#396
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: Shoreham By Sea
Programs: BAEC Gold
Posts: 1,316
It's eligible in that you departed from the EU, but the (root) cause of the delays that affected you might be a factor. Also, requesting a reroute can complicate matters. That said, if you're delayed at your final destination, which it sounds like you will be, I would claim EC261 compensation and see what AA say, then decide based on their response how to proceed.
The delayed flight was AA665 on 16/5 if anyone knows how to look up a reason for a delay.
#397
Ambassador, British Airways; FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Leeds, UK
Programs: BA GGL/CCR, GfL, HH Diamond
Posts: 42,888
#398
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: London, UK
Programs: BA GGL
Posts: 1,577
Code:
clt 301p c19 dfw c26 c c29 453p 603p c c6 clt b b14 936p 7clt/auto reaccom dly flt completed see n*p3aa0665clt16may *1342*crcymg 3clt/etd1729 lat-late arrv a/c due to prior air traffic delays *1603 4clt/out1737 off1746 *1646 5dfw/flt 0665 stub orig pln dep dfw etd 1803 -- dfw .rmks ftwdp dunning *1403 3dfw/etd1815 mtr-delay due to a/c maintenance *1809 4dfw/out1811 off1827 *1827 2dfw/in1912 *1912 2clt*/in2135 *2035
#399
Join Date: May 2017
Posts: 2,016
Downgrade and delay in replying
What is supposed to happen if it takes them more than 7 days, or if it takes them more than 7 days to reply to my complaint?
I suppose I should be entitled to additional compensation but if so, how much?
2. If an operating air carrier places a passenger in a class lower than that for which the ticket was purchased,
it shall within seven days, by the means provided for in Article 7(3), reimburse...
What is supposed to happen if it takes them more than 7 days, or if it takes them more than 7 days to reply to my complaint?
I suppose I should be entitled to additional compensation but if so, how much?
2. If an operating air carrier places a passenger in a class lower than that for which the ticket was purchased,
it shall within seven days, by the means provided for in Article 7(3), reimburse...
#400
Join Date: May 2019
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC Silver
Posts: 5
I'm after some advice on how best to proceed with a claim I'm making. Details as follows:
Date: 5th May 2019
Flight: BA208 (MIA to LHR)
Scheduled departure time: 20.40
Scheduled arrival time: 10.25 (6th May 2019)
Actual departure time: 01.24 (6th May 2019)
Actual arrival time information:
Wheels touched down: 14.15 (6th May 2019)
On the stand: 14.22 (6th May 2019)
Jet bridge attached: 14.26 (6th May 2019)
Actual delay on arrival time: 4 hours, 1 minute.
I know this is the time the jet bridge was attached as I was watching it from the upper deck while checking my iPhone which has it's time automatically synchronised.
As I disembarked from the plane, I spoke to the CSM asking for confirmation from him what time the jet bridge was attached, and he claimed "by my watch it was 5 minutes ago" approximately 2 minutes after disembarking began. It seems clear as day that BA have done this on purpose to avoid paying the full €600 pp compensation.
I've followed standard protocol and raised a case with customer relations and was pleasantly surprised with the initial response as BA didn't try and claim the delay was out of their control. They have however as expected, disappointingly tried to claim the delay was under 4 hours. They have said they will pay the reduced compensation amount of €300 pp (as per eu261 guidelines).
I've gone back to them to re-iterate that as the jet bridge wasn't attached and the door wasn't opened in time, the full compensation is payable but am sure they will just deny it.
Firstly, please can someone confirm my understanding of the delay regulation/compensation amount is correct, and should be €600 pp in this case?
And secondly, any advice on how best to proceed would be greatly appreciated.
BizBoy
Date: 5th May 2019
Flight: BA208 (MIA to LHR)
Scheduled departure time: 20.40
Scheduled arrival time: 10.25 (6th May 2019)
Actual departure time: 01.24 (6th May 2019)
Actual arrival time information:
Wheels touched down: 14.15 (6th May 2019)
On the stand: 14.22 (6th May 2019)
Jet bridge attached: 14.26 (6th May 2019)
Actual delay on arrival time: 4 hours, 1 minute.
I know this is the time the jet bridge was attached as I was watching it from the upper deck while checking my iPhone which has it's time automatically synchronised.
As I disembarked from the plane, I spoke to the CSM asking for confirmation from him what time the jet bridge was attached, and he claimed "by my watch it was 5 minutes ago" approximately 2 minutes after disembarking began. It seems clear as day that BA have done this on purpose to avoid paying the full €600 pp compensation.
I've followed standard protocol and raised a case with customer relations and was pleasantly surprised with the initial response as BA didn't try and claim the delay was out of their control. They have however as expected, disappointingly tried to claim the delay was under 4 hours. They have said they will pay the reduced compensation amount of €300 pp (as per eu261 guidelines).
I've gone back to them to re-iterate that as the jet bridge wasn't attached and the door wasn't opened in time, the full compensation is payable but am sure they will just deny it.
Firstly, please can someone confirm my understanding of the delay regulation/compensation amount is correct, and should be €600 pp in this case?
And secondly, any advice on how best to proceed would be greatly appreciated.
BizBoy
Last edited by bizboy; May 17, 2019 at 4:26 am Reason: Corrected times
#401
Ambassador, British Airways; FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Leeds, UK
Programs: BA GGL/CCR, GfL, HH Diamond
Posts: 42,888
I'm after some advice on how best to proceed with a claim I'm making. Details as follows:
Date: 5th May 2019
Flight: BA208 (MIA to LHR)
Scheduled departure time: 20.40
Scheduled arrival time: 10.25 (6th May 2019)
Actual departure time: 01.24 (6th May 2019)
Actual arrival time information:
Wheels touched down: 16.15 (6th May 2019)
On the stand: 16.22 (6th May 2019)
Jet bridge attached: 16.26 (6th May 2019)
Actual delay on arrival time: 4 hours, 1 minute.
I know this is the time the jet bridge was attached as I was watching it from the upper deck while checking my iPhone which has it's time automatically synchronised.
As I disembarked from the plane, I spoke to the CSM asking for confirmation from him what time the jet bridge was attached, and he claimed "by my watch it was 5 minutes ago" approximately 2 minutes after disembarking began. It seems clear as day that BA have done this on purpose to avoid paying the full €600 pp compensation.
I've followed standard protocol and raised a case with customer relations and was pleasantly surprised with the initial response as BA didn't try and claim the delay was out of their control. They have however as expected, disappointingly tried to claim the delay was under 4 hours. They have said they will pay the reduced compensation amount of €300 pp (as per eu261 guidelines).
I've gone back to them to re-iterate that as the jet bridge wasn't attached and the door wasn't opened in time, the full compensation is payable but am sure they will just deny it.
Firstly, please can someone confirm my understanding of the delay regulation/compensation amount is correct, and should be €600 pp in this case?
And secondly, any advice on how best to proceed would be greatly appreciated.
BizBoy
Date: 5th May 2019
Flight: BA208 (MIA to LHR)
Scheduled departure time: 20.40
Scheduled arrival time: 10.25 (6th May 2019)
Actual departure time: 01.24 (6th May 2019)
Actual arrival time information:
Wheels touched down: 16.15 (6th May 2019)
On the stand: 16.22 (6th May 2019)
Jet bridge attached: 16.26 (6th May 2019)
Actual delay on arrival time: 4 hours, 1 minute.
I know this is the time the jet bridge was attached as I was watching it from the upper deck while checking my iPhone which has it's time automatically synchronised.
As I disembarked from the plane, I spoke to the CSM asking for confirmation from him what time the jet bridge was attached, and he claimed "by my watch it was 5 minutes ago" approximately 2 minutes after disembarking began. It seems clear as day that BA have done this on purpose to avoid paying the full €600 pp compensation.
I've followed standard protocol and raised a case with customer relations and was pleasantly surprised with the initial response as BA didn't try and claim the delay was out of their control. They have however as expected, disappointingly tried to claim the delay was under 4 hours. They have said they will pay the reduced compensation amount of €300 pp (as per eu261 guidelines).
I've gone back to them to re-iterate that as the jet bridge wasn't attached and the door wasn't opened in time, the full compensation is payable but am sure they will just deny it.
Firstly, please can someone confirm my understanding of the delay regulation/compensation amount is correct, and should be €600 pp in this case?
And secondly, any advice on how best to proceed would be greatly appreciated.
BizBoy
I just want to check you mention Scheduled arrival time: 10.25 (6th May 2019) and Wheels touched down: 16.15 (6th May 2019). Isn't that already over 4 hours late regardless of how quickly you got on to the stand and the doors were open?
#402
Join Date: May 2019
Location: London, UK
Programs: BAEC Silver
Posts: 5
Apologies - I had scribbled times down and on typing up in 24 hour format, made mistakes. I've editted my post above to correct the mistakes.
#403
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: Shoreham By Sea
Programs: BAEC Gold
Posts: 1,316
Thanks for the replies. Email sent to AA
#404
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Berlin
Programs: BA Gold; Accor Plat; IHG Diamond-Amb; Meliá & HH & Marriott Gold
Posts: 5,447
I'd be grateful for advice/pointers on the following.
Earlier this month, BA took us from FRA to JFK without any problems. However, the first flight of our return journey from IAH was cancelled after the incoming plane was damaged. BA's IAH team was very good about letting us know what was happening and also quickly arranged a hotel and bus. ^ (They must have been having a challenging day, as BA's earlier LHR-IAH-LHR rotation had also been cancelled).
As of the following morning, BA had not offered us new flights. That's not surprising, as it was a very heavy travel day on all carriers. So we made our own alternative arrangements (UA miles: IAH-ORD-FRA).
My understanding is that a plane being damaged by airport is not an extraordinary circumstance, so EC261/2004 should apply. I'm guessing that we should ask for this and a partial refund for the cancelled segments in the same message, correct?
Can anyone point me to guidance on calculating the refund due? Our receipt only shows the total price for the return journey. Thanks.
Earlier this month, BA took us from FRA to JFK without any problems. However, the first flight of our return journey from IAH was cancelled after the incoming plane was damaged. BA's IAH team was very good about letting us know what was happening and also quickly arranged a hotel and bus. ^ (They must have been having a challenging day, as BA's earlier LHR-IAH-LHR rotation had also been cancelled).
As of the following morning, BA had not offered us new flights. That's not surprising, as it was a very heavy travel day on all carriers. So we made our own alternative arrangements (UA miles: IAH-ORD-FRA).
My understanding is that a plane being damaged by airport is not an extraordinary circumstance, so EC261/2004 should apply. I'm guessing that we should ask for this and a partial refund for the cancelled segments in the same message, correct?
Can anyone point me to guidance on calculating the refund due? Our receipt only shows the total price for the return journey. Thanks.
#405
Community Director
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Norwich, UK
Programs: A3*G, BA Gold, BD Gold (in memoriam), IHG Diamond Ambassador
Posts: 8,473
I'd be grateful for advice/pointers on the following.
Earlier this month, BA took us from FRA to JFK without any problems. However, the first flight of our return journey from IAH was cancelled after the incoming plane was damaged. BA's IAH team was very good about letting us know what was happening and also quickly arranged a hotel and bus. ^ (They must have been having a challenging day, as BA's earlier LHR-IAH-LHR rotation had also been cancelled).
As of the following morning, BA had not offered us new flights. That's not surprising, as it was a very heavy travel day on all carriers. So we made our own alternative arrangements (UA miles: IAH-ORD-FRA).
My understanding is that a plane being damaged by airport is not an extraordinary circumstance, so EC261/2004 should apply. I'm guessing that we should ask for this and a partial refund for the cancelled segments in the same message, correct?
Can anyone point me to guidance on calculating the refund due? Our receipt only shows the total price for the return journey. Thanks.
Earlier this month, BA took us from FRA to JFK without any problems. However, the first flight of our return journey from IAH was cancelled after the incoming plane was damaged. BA's IAH team was very good about letting us know what was happening and also quickly arranged a hotel and bus. ^ (They must have been having a challenging day, as BA's earlier LHR-IAH-LHR rotation had also been cancelled).
As of the following morning, BA had not offered us new flights. That's not surprising, as it was a very heavy travel day on all carriers. So we made our own alternative arrangements (UA miles: IAH-ORD-FRA).
My understanding is that a plane being damaged by airport is not an extraordinary circumstance, so EC261/2004 should apply. I'm guessing that we should ask for this and a partial refund for the cancelled segments in the same message, correct?
Can anyone point me to guidance on calculating the refund due? Our receipt only shows the total price for the return journey. Thanks.
However, in terms of compensation under article 7, this does become more difficult if you don’t actually take the delayed flight (and you need to determine if this was really a cancellation, and not just a delay). You’re probably then into arguing that the delay was long enough to count as a cancellation and that BA didn’t take all reasonable measures to get you home - leaving you no option but to make your own arrangements. You’d have to give more, pretty precise, details before anyone could even give an opinion on that. Even then, you would certainly have to go to court and I’d expect BA to defend it rather than settle - so be prepared to have to spend half a day or more in court, and that you might well lose.
If you have evidence from BA that they did actually cancel the flight then article 7 sounds like it’s in scope and you’ll have no issue with the 600 Euros.
Last edited by NWIFlyer; May 20, 2019 at 4:21 am