Community
Wiki Posts
Search

JFK ... staff issues - just a one off ?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Nov 18, 2018, 2:03 am
  #16  
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 5,596
Originally Posted by TheBigRat
Apologies for the lack of detail — I have no wish to get staff disciplined for poor attitude when we’ve all had bad days. Its also not been my regular experience at JFK but this was a noticeable difference from previous visits from 3 separate staff / conversations.

An example would be this very flat response - and by no means the worst...

Me: “ no smiles today? “
Dead pan and reply “ why woiuld I smile, I work for BA”

If it was just my experience then I’ll leave it be - and if it happens again, I’ll escalate - I just wondered if anyone else felf the same change in attitude I have experienced.

Cabin crew on the flight were fantastic.


What would you say if he replied "I've hurt my back.I'm going to the Doctor later."
nancypants likes this.
rapidex is offline  
Old Nov 18, 2018, 2:45 am
  #17  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Cambridgeshire
Programs: BA Gold, VS Gold, UA Silver, Marriott LTP, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 233
Thanks for the insights - just to clarify a few assumptions being made..

1. I should have been clearer - this was not an opening line, but part of a conversation.
2. It was a male and someone I have spoken to on prior occasions.
3. No-one has commented on his response - I guess you had to be there to realise the tone and way it was delivered.
4. As far as escalating - I mentioned this was one of three interactions from 3 different people.
5. I fly back and forth to the US ( NYC alone around 5 times a year) as mentioned multiple times a year and have been doing so for 30 years, lived there and am aware of cultural differences. So, I have a basis for comparison.
6. Attitude - as mentioned in my post - wasnt solely directed at me.

Given that none of the recent posters have commented on their T7 interactions recently changing - which was the ask of the orginal post - I’ll see how my next trip goes in a couple of weeks time.

Thanks all
TheBigRat is offline  
Old Nov 18, 2018, 2:46 am
  #18  
 
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: London
Programs: BAEC
Posts: 77
With that line it sounds like you got the customer service you deserved. I’d count myself lucky they didn’t react in a far more negative way.
RyanLHR is offline  
Old Nov 18, 2018, 2:50 am
  #19  
Suspended
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Canada, USA, Europe
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 31,452
“...my mother passed away yesterday.”
nancypants likes this.
LondonElite is offline  
Old Nov 18, 2018, 3:07 am
  #20  
 
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 6,349
No excuse for poor attitude however sometimes what we consider a sociable comment can get a bit dull if the agent gets it several times a day.

Just chalk it down to experience and move on. Otherwise expect to get a canned reply from CS which will wind you up even more.
TheBigRat and nancypants like this.
simons1 is offline  
Old Nov 18, 2018, 5:18 am
  #21  
 
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: London, UK
Programs: BA GGL
Posts: 1,577
If someone that you're apparently familiar enough with to ask "No smiles today?" isn't smiling, a more human approach might have been, "How're you doing?" or "How's it going?" or, at the more intrusive end of the spectrum without being rude, "Everything alright?"

This is, assuming that your motivation was to find out why this person wasn't smiling, and not merely demanding your customer service-mandated BA-brand smile from the crew.
armouredant is online now  
Old Nov 29, 2018, 4:23 pm
  #22  
 
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: London
Programs: Qantas Platinum, United Premier 1K, HSBC Premier, AVIS President's Club, Marriott Bonvoy Platinum
Posts: 100
Originally Posted by TheBigRat
Apologies for the lack of detail — I have no wish to get staff disciplined for poor attitude when we’ve all had bad days. Its also not been my regular experience at JFK but this was a noticeable difference from previous visits from 3 separate staff / conversations.

An example would be this very flat response - and by no means the worst...

Me: “ no smiles today? “
Dead pan and reply “ why woiuld I smile, I work for BA”

If it was just my experience then I’ll leave it be - and if it happens again, I’ll escalate - I just wondered if anyone else felf the same change in attitude I have experienced.

Cabin crew on the flight were fantastic.



I think that's some fantastic dry British wit (from an American no less) in response to a question that is objectively annoying.
nufnuf77 likes this.
warreng is offline  
Old Nov 29, 2018, 4:56 pm
  #23  
 
Join Date: Nov 2016
Location: London
Programs: BA, Marriott, Starwood, Hyatt
Posts: 44
Flew back from JFK yesterday on BA178. I found all the BA JFK staff very efficient and pleasant.
hammers2958 is offline  
Old Nov 29, 2018, 4:57 pm
  #24  
Hilton Contributor Badge
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: ±38,000 feet
Programs: LH HON, BA GGL, AF Plat, EK Plat
Posts: 6,426
Originally Posted by warreng
I think that's some fantastic dry British wit (from an American no less) in response to a question that is objectively annoying.
Completely agree, those are the kind of interactions I love with BA staff, not the robotic smile and customer is always right bs I get from QR...
nufnuf77 is offline  
Old Nov 29, 2018, 6:35 pm
  #25  
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: London/NYC
Programs: BA GFL/GGL/CCR, SPG Plat for Life, HHDiamond, xG Aegean, Avis President's Circle
Posts: 26
I too have noticed a sad abatement in the manner of dealing with the passengers by the BA staff (outsourced or otherwise) at JFK T7.
For those of us travelling on the JFK-LHR route regularly, it was positively reassuring to spot recognisable faces and to be welcomed with warmth and familiarity.

On a recent visit, I had a likewise unpleasant exchange with a check-in agent at the F section at JFK T7.
All I was asking of the agent was to print a traditional boarding pass (the BA electronic passes do not display "TSA Pre-Check").

The agent then started to ask me some unusual security questions, apparently due to the fact that I was seated in 63A.
I said I had already answered those questions electronically when checking in on-line.

Apparently I had to be asked them in person or my boarding pass would not be issued.
Well, I said that I already had the boarding pass issued in my phone. Had I not wanted the Pre-Check-valid paper boarding pass, I wouldn't have even stopped by the check-in desk.

The agent persevered. A colleague of theirs was (a trainee?) by their side. I was very much aware of the fact that the agent was making some sort of a point in front of him.

The agent didn't know I was on the Gold Guest List and she didn't know I had access to the Concorde Room.
I refrained from making an entitled remark about it in front of a trainee (?); I thought it was BA T7 management's fault, not necessarily that of an undertrained agent, to have failed to spot these.
I am very self-conscious when it comes to exuding any semblance of a DYKWIA moment. Or at least I think I am.

However, at the end of this unpleasant "re-check-in process", I said to the agent, as amicably as I could , how lovely it used to be to go through the T7 check-in when you were greeted like an old friend.
The agent's reply was: "I've been working for BA for 30 years and I don't know you".
I said "thank you" and walked away.

The new security queue for J/F is hopelessly mismanaged. You're supposed to push in through in between the Y passengers who have queued in the regular queue for God knows how long.
The TSA agent could not tell me what the rules of joining the queue were.
"Just push in" he said. It felt wrong to be doing it and it appeared rather thoughtless of BA to be putting their "valued customers" in such a position.

The F lounge was a zoo, with lots of Iberia and JAL status passengers awaiting their respective flights. The temporary dining room was even more chaotic than the F lounge itself.
I spotted one BA JFK old-timer at the CCR. There were also familiar faces among the waiting staff there who were probably the loveliest people I met at T7 that evening.
Everyone else was new; they made it acutely, if inadvertently, obvious that they couldn't not care less.

I felt somewhat embarrassed by the former fine bastion of British hospitality now
being stripped off of its grace, cordiality and poise.
All in all, it left me with a depressing feeling of a not-so-gradual decline.

I am not looking forward to passing through there again tomorrow night. I bet BA have not Pre-Check enabled their electronic boarding passes yet. Quelle surprise!
MGUK is offline  
Old Nov 29, 2018, 10:05 pm
  #26  
 
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: Scotland
Posts: 377
Originally Posted by MGUK
I too have noticed a sad abatement in the manner of dealing with the passengers by the BA staff (outsourced or otherwise) at JFK T7.
For those of us travelling on the JFK-LHR route regularly, it was positively reassuring to spot recognisable faces and to be welcomed with warmth and familiarity.

On a recent visit, I had a likewise unpleasant exchange with a check-in agent at the F section at JFK T7.
All I was asking of the agent was to print a traditional boarding pass (the BA electronic passes do not display "TSA Pre-Check").

The agent then started to ask me some unusual security questions, apparently due to the fact that I was seated in 63A.
I said I had already answered those questions electronically when checking in on-line.

Apparently I had to be asked them in person or my boarding pass would not be issued.
Well, I said that I already had the boarding pass issued in my phone. Had I not wanted the Pre-Check-valid paper boarding pass, I wouldn't have even stopped by the check-in desk.

The agent persevered. A colleague of theirs was (a trainee?) by their side. I was very much aware of the fact that the agent was making some sort of a point in front of him.

The agent didn't know I was on the Gold Guest List and she didn't know I had access to the Concorde Room.
I refrained from making an entitled remark about it in front of a trainee (?); I thought it was BA T7 management's fault, not necessarily that of an undertrained agent, to have failed to spot these.
I am very self-conscious when it comes to exuding any semblance of a DYKWIA moment. Or at least I think I am.

However, at the end of this unpleasant "re-check-in process", I said to the agent, as amicably as I could , how lovely it used to be to go through the T7 check-in when you were greeted like an old friend.
The agent's reply was: "I've been working for BA for 30 years and I don't know you".
I said "thank you" and walked away.

The new security queue for J/F is hopelessly mismanaged. You're supposed to push in through in between the Y passengers who have queued in the regular queue for God knows how long.
The TSA agent could not tell me what the rules of joining the queue were.
"Just push in" he said. It felt wrong to be doing it and it appeared rather thoughtless of BA to be putting their "valued customers" in such a position.

The F lounge was a zoo, with lots of Iberia and JAL status passengers awaiting their respective flights. The temporary dining room was even more chaotic than the F lounge itself.
I spotted one BA JFK old-timer at the CCR. There were also familiar faces among the waiting staff there who were probably the loveliest people I met at T7 that evening.
Everyone else was new; they made it acutely, if inadvertently, obvious that they couldn't not care less.

I felt somewhat embarrassed by the former fine bastion of British hospitality now
being stripped off of its grace, cordiality and poise.
All in all, it left me with a depressing feeling of a not-so-gradual decline.

I am not looking forward to passing through there again tomorrow night. I bet BA have not Pre-Check enabled their electronic boarding passes yet. Quelle surprise!
https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/show...&postcount=529
argonath is offline  
Old Nov 29, 2018, 11:17 pm
  #27  
Suspended
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Canada, USA, Europe
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 31,452
Originally Posted by MGUK
I too have noticed a sad abatement in the manner of dealing with the passengers by the BA staff (outsourced or otherwise) at JFK T7.
For those of us travelling on the JFK-LHR route regularly, it was positively reassuring to spot recognisable faces and to be welcomed with warmth and familiarity.

On a recent visit, I had a likewise unpleasant exchange with a check-in agent at the F section at JFK T7.
All I was asking of the agent was to print a traditional boarding pass (the BA electronic passes do not display "TSA Pre-Check").

The agent then started to ask me some unusual security questions, apparently due to the fact that I was seated in 63A.
I said I had already answered those questions electronically when checking in on-line.

Apparently I had to be asked them in person or my boarding pass would not be issued.
Well, I said that I already had the boarding pass issued in my phone. Had I not wanted the Pre-Check-valid paper boarding pass, I wouldn't have even stopped by the check-in desk.

The agent persevered. A colleague of theirs was (a trainee?) by their side. I was very much aware of the fact that the agent was making some sort of a point in front of him.

The agent didn't know I was on the Gold Guest List and she didn't know I had access to the Concorde Room.
I refrained from making an entitled remark about it in front of a trainee (?); I thought it was BA T7 management's fault, not necessarily that of an undertrained agent, to have failed to spot these.
I am very self-conscious when it comes to exuding any semblance of a DYKWIA moment. Or at least I think I am.

However, at the end of this unpleasant "re-check-in process", I said to the agent, as amicably as I could , how lovely it used to be to go through the T7 check-in when you were greeted like an old friend.
The agent's reply was: "I've been working for BA for 30 years and I don't know you".
I said "thank you" and walked away.

The new security queue for J/F is hopelessly mismanaged. You're supposed to push in through in between the Y passengers who have queued in the regular queue for God knows how long.
The TSA agent could not tell me what the rules of joining the queue were.
"Just push in" he said. It felt wrong to be doing it and it appeared rather thoughtless of BA to be putting their "valued customers" in such a position.

The F lounge was a zoo, with lots of Iberia and JAL status passengers awaiting their respective flights. The temporary dining room was even more chaotic than the F lounge itself.
I spotted one BA JFK old-timer at the CCR. There were also familiar faces among the waiting staff there who were probably the loveliest people I met at T7 that evening.
Everyone else was new; they made it acutely, if inadvertently, obvious that they couldn't not care less.

I felt somewhat embarrassed by the former fine bastion of British hospitality now
being stripped off of its grace, cordiality and poise.
All in all, it left me with a depressing feeling of a not-so-gradual decline.

I am not looking forward to passing through there again tomorrow night. I bet BA have not Pre-Check enabled their electronic boarding passes yet. Quelle surprise!
As a frequent traveller you should know that, in virtually any interaction with check-in staff, you'll be asked for your passport and some security questions. The fact that you've already answered these online doesn't make a difference (and also suggests that they were not 'unusual' questions.) Arguing with, or pointing out logical flaws to, these staff members is successful roughly zero percent of the time. Sometimes we are all a bit more DYKWIA than we (like to think we) are.
NickB likes this.
LondonElite is offline  
Old Nov 30, 2018, 12:12 am
  #28  
 
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 6,349
Originally Posted by MGUK
I too have noticed a sad abatement in the manner of dealing with the passengers by the BA staff (outsourced or otherwise) at JFK T7.
For those of us travelling on the JFK-LHR route regularly, it was positively reassuring to spot recognisable faces and to be welcomed with warmth and familiarity.

On a recent visit, I had a likewise unpleasant exchange with a check-in agent at the F section at JFK T7.
All I was asking of the agent was to print a traditional boarding pass (the BA electronic passes do not display "TSA Pre-Check").

The agent then started to ask me some unusual security questions, apparently due to the fact that I was seated in 63A.
I said I had already answered those questions electronically when checking in on-line.

Apparently I had to be asked them in person or my boarding pass would not be issued.
Well, I said that I already had the boarding pass issued in my phone. Had I not wanted the Pre-Check-valid paper boarding pass, I wouldn't have even stopped by the check-in desk.

The agent persevered. A colleague of theirs was (a trainee?) by their side. I was very much aware of the fact that the agent was making some sort of a point in front of him.

The agent didn't know I was on the Gold Guest List and she didn't know I had access to the Concorde Room.
I refrained from making an entitled remark about it in front of a trainee (?); I thought it was BA T7 management's fault, not necessarily that of an undertrained agent, to have failed to spot these.
I am very self-conscious when it comes to exuding any semblance of a DYKWIA moment. Or at least I think I am.

However, at the end of this unpleasant "re-check-in process", I said to the agent, as amicably as I could , how lovely it used to be to go through the T7 check-in when you were greeted like an old friend.
The agent's reply was: "I've been working for BA for 30 years and I don't know you".
I said "thank you" and walked away.

The new security queue for J/F is hopelessly mismanaged. You're supposed to push in through in between the Y passengers who have queued in the regular queue for God knows how long.
The TSA agent could not tell me what the rules of joining the queue were.
"Just push in" he said. It felt wrong to be doing it and it appeared rather thoughtless of BA to be putting their "valued customers" in such a position.

The F lounge was a zoo, with lots of Iberia and JAL status passengers awaiting their respective flights. The temporary dining room was even more chaotic than the F lounge itself.
I spotted one BA JFK old-timer at the CCR. There were also familiar faces among the waiting staff there who were probably the loveliest people I met at T7 that evening.
Everyone else was new; they made it acutely, if inadvertently, obvious that they couldn't not care less.

I felt somewhat embarrassed by the former fine bastion of British hospitality now
being stripped off of its grace, cordiality and poise.
All in all, it left me with a depressing feeling of a not-so-gradual decline.

I am not looking forward to passing through there again tomorrow night. I bet BA have not Pre-Check enabled their electronic boarding passes yet. Quelle surprise!
Sad but not a surprise really. Generally I would suggest this is the outcome of years of downsizing, outsourcing, dumbing down, removal of any discretion etc which has taken everything to the lowest denominator. The price we pay for air fares which in real terms are probably the lowest ever.

Most staff with any experience have long since gone (probably as they can do better elsewhere) and you are left with minimum wage, entry level staff who are just there to follow a process. So tbh I'm not surprised they couldn't care less about the customer experience.

On the other hand I did see that airport workers in NY now have a minimum wage of $15 which is the highest anywhere in US.....
simons1 is offline  
Old Nov 30, 2018, 12:50 am
  #29  
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: London/NYC
Programs: BA GFL/GGL/CCR, SPG Plat for Life, HHDiamond, xG Aegean, Avis President's Circle
Posts: 26
Originally Posted by LondonElite
As a frequent traveller you should know that, in virtually any interaction with check-in staff, you'll be asked for your passport and some security questions. The fact that you've already answered these online doesn't make a difference (and also suggests that they were not 'unusual' questions.) Arguing with, or pointing out logical flaws to, these staff members is successful roughly zero percent of the time. Sometimes we are all a bit more DYKWIA than we (like to think we) are.
I have never experienced these when asking for a reprint of a boarding pass (not talking about the ID check). One has to take a lot from the TSA staff, most of us just get on with it. But are these the standards we should accept as a norm at the BA First Class check-in at JFK? From what LondonElite suggesting, yes.

It’s a sad state of affairs if an expression of surprise is perceived as a DYKWIA fit. In the future I’ll just act as I would if I were flying Aeroflot in the 1970’s, which, toutes proportions gardées, says it all.
MGUK is offline  
Old Nov 30, 2018, 12:58 am
  #30  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: SE1, London
Posts: 23,418
To be honest, on my infrequent visits, I’ve never been wowed by the attitude of the T7 staff.
Swanhunter is offline  


Contact Us - Manage Preferences - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.