FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Asiana | Asiana Club (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asiana-asiana-club-614/)
-   -   Share trading halted [Asiana financial troubles] (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asiana-asiana-club/1961997-share-trading-halted-asiana-financial-troubles.html)

AlwaysFlyStar Mar 21, 2019 11:59 pm

Share trading halted [Asiana financial troubles]
 
According to Reuters,

The Korea Exchange has suspended trading in shares of Asiana Airlines Inc, after an auditor for South Korea’s second-biggest carrier said it lacked enough information to judge its value.
Kind of curious if this means anything or if it is just some oversight.

corbomite Mar 22, 2019 7:57 am

Given that the local accounting firms are usually very, very cozy with the chaebols here, it means that the constant dumpster fire that is Asiana's finances has turned out to be something even worse.

Kacee Mar 23, 2019 1:22 am


Originally Posted by corbomite (Post 30916692)
Given that the local accounting firms are usually very, very cozy with the chaebols here, it means that the constant dumpster fire that is Asiana's finances has turned out to be something even worse.

PWC are the auditors. Asian Fails to Get Accounting Sign-Off. Article quotes Moody's:


"We can’t rule out the possibility of liquidity risks growing, as this undermines the credibility of its accounting information, and therefore its access to the capital market,” Moody’s Investor Service’s South Korean unit wrote in a note, saying it will consider lowering its rating of Asiana’s credit."

buffegg Mar 23, 2019 2:29 pm


Originally Posted by Kacee (Post 30919570)
PWC are the auditors. Asian Fails to Get Accounting Sign-Off. Article quotes Moody's:

Hmmm wonder if I should credit to Turkish instead of chasing lifetime gold with Asiana

1353513636 Mar 24, 2019 3:05 pm

I imagine this has more to do with embezzling or misappropriation of funds from OZ to other Kumho Group ventures than an indication that Asiana suspending operations is imminent. Far more likely to suspend operations IMO is WOW Air.

stupidhead Mar 25, 2019 9:36 am


Originally Posted by buffegg (Post 30921383)
Hmmm wonder if I should credit to Turkish instead of chasing lifetime gold with Asiana

Considering OZ is generating a good US$650 million in cash a year from operating activities, I highly doubt they're anywhere near going under. That is, if they stop messing about in businesses they have no business being in and of course, assuming their financials are accurate.

Gasolin Mar 26, 2019 7:54 am

https://www.reuters.com/article/asia...-idUSL3N21D01H

Asiana Airlines Fettered by Excessive Aircraft Leasing Costs - ??????? - BusinessKorea

This is sad, I think OZ has done a wealth of good for people who don't want to fly KE for personal reasons.
With revised numbers hiking the debt to equity ratio, and rating agencies potentially downgrading to non-investment grades, it would create an impossible situation for OZ.

Why lease that many planes though?

nanyang Mar 27, 2019 12:10 pm


Originally Posted by Gasolin (Post 30931183)
https://www.reuters.com/article/asia...-idUSL3N21D01H

Asiana Airlines Fettered by Excessive Aircraft Leasing Costs - ??????? - BusinessKorea

This is sad, I think OZ has done a wealth of good for people who don't want to fly KE for personal reasons.
With revised numbers hiking the debt to equity ratio, and rating agencies potentially downgrading to non-investment grades, it would create an impossible situation for OZ.

Why lease that many planes though?

Some of those figures in that latter article simply do not make sense.

As such, leasing a high % of your a/c is not a problem (look at IndiGo, VietJet Air and so on). BTW, I assume we are talking about operating leases. Gives an airline a lot of flexibility, no need to arrange debt, possibly quicker access to growth capacity, reduces residual value risk etc. etc. Airlines can also make nice upfront profits from sale-and-leasebacks. Plus there is plenty of competition in the leasing market, so airlines can actually get some really attractive deals.

Very few airlines globally are investment grade. I'm not sure whether local ratings (e.g. KIS) are 100% comparable to S&P, Fitch, Moody's.

The Korean airline industry is very unique.

Gasolin Mar 28, 2019 12:09 am


Originally Posted by nanyang (Post 30936074)
Some of those figures in that latter article simply do not make sense.

As such, leasing a high % of your a/c is not a problem (look at IndiGo, VietJet Air and so on). BTW, I assume we are talking about operating leases. Gives an airline a lot of flexibility, no need to arrange debt, possibly quicker access to growth capacity, reduces residual value risk etc. etc. Airlines can also make nice upfront profits from sale-and-leasebacks. Plus there is plenty of competition in the leasing market, so airlines can actually get some really attractive deals.

Very few airlines globally are investment grade. I'm not sure whether local ratings (e.g. KIS) are 100% comparable to S&P, Fitch, Moody's.

The Korean airline industry is very unique.

KIS is Moody's. Not sure about the other one.

nanyang Mar 29, 2019 3:12 am


Originally Posted by Gasolin (Post 30938016)
KIS is Moody's. Not sure about the other one.

The point being local ratings are not necessarily comparable to the ratings of big 3.

I recall KE and OZ had local ratings (KIS, KR, NICE) of A- / BBB+ (in that ballpark) a few years ago. By conventional credit metrics, can't imagine the big 3 would have rated them anywhere close.

SPlDER Mar 29, 2019 8:12 am

What are the comments of the Korean media ? How serious is risk of collapse ?
Do you think it's time to start crediting miles to other FFP ?

Gasolin Mar 29, 2019 8:29 am


Originally Posted by nanyang (Post 30942018)
The point being local ratings are not necessarily comparable to the ratings of big 3.

I recall KE and OZ had local ratings (KIS, KR, NICE) of A- / BBB+ (in that ballpark) a few years ago. By conventional credit metrics, can't imagine the big 3 would have rated them anywhere close.

KIS is MIS in Korea and they rate the Korean counterparties for Moody's so their rating is Moody's rating.

Gasolin Mar 29, 2019 11:49 am


Originally Posted by SPlDER (Post 30942677)
What are the comments of the Korean media ? How serious is risk of collapse ?
Do you think it's time to start crediting miles to other FFP ?

Well I think it's tough but they will find a way out. It looks like the CEO resigned to protect the group? And apparently they asked for help with liquidity to the KDB.
If Asiana goes down, the mother group Kumho will probably go down as well, hence the decision of the CEO.

corbomite Mar 29, 2019 8:42 pm


Originally Posted by SPlDER (Post 30942677)
What are the comments of the Korean media ? How serious is risk of collapse ?
Do you think it's time to start crediting miles to other FFP ?

Asiana definitely falls under the definition of TBTF in Korea, I expect that the Industrial Bank of Korea will step in if .... does indeed hit the fan. If Asiana fails, then the entire Gumho group fails and that would be political suicide for the current government.

nanyang Apr 1, 2019 2:08 am


Originally Posted by Gasolin (Post 30942730)
KIS is MIS in Korea and they rate the Korean counterparties for Moody's so their rating is Moody's rating.

I do not believe the rating scale to be the same (could be wrong, but remember looking into this some years ago). BTW, tried to find the rating on Moody's and could not. How do they list it?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:31 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.