FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Asia (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asia-460/)
-   -   3 weeks between Bali, Java, KK (Sabah)-is this possible? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asia/1381211-3-weeks-between-bali-java-kk-sabah-possible.html)

susiesan Aug 26, 2012 2:05 pm

3 weeks between Bali, Java, KK (Sabah)-is this possible?
 
I got so much help last year from FT members who helped plan our China trip, I wanted to seek help from the with the beginning stages of a trip to Indonesia and Malaysia next year. I'd like to have a route mapped out before I try to get award seats. Ni hao to Jiejie and moondog!)

Here are some specs to work with:
I am planning to travel in Sept. 2013, after Ramadan, before the rainy season in Indonesia.
I will be using AA miles to fly on CX in J or F so we will pass through Hong Kong. If I have to stopover here for 1 or 2 nights inbound or outbound due to flight connections that would be fine. I have not been to Hong Kong since the handover.
I'd like to fly into DPS and out of KK, or the other way around if possible. I'd buy flights for cities in between.

So let's say we flew to DPS, stayed on Bali 5-7 days, then flew to Yogyakarta for 2-3 nights, then flew to KK for 2-4 nights. In Sabah I'd like to go to one of the eco lodges for a few nights.

Is this too much to cram into 2 1/2 weeks? Should we stick to Bali and Java?
Should I save Borneo for another trip?

I've done some checking on how one flies between KK and either DPS or YOG. I'm not finding any direct flights.

Thanks in advance for any help in the preliminary stages of another of Susie's excellent adventures.

ryandelmundo Aug 30, 2012 10:44 pm

The 5-7 days in Bali and 2-3 in Yogja sounds about right. Flights are all direct and plentiful.

Any travel away from the usual tourist spots takes time. 100km drives take 8 hours. Stuff stops working for no reason. Flights are canceled. If you head over to KK, 2-4 nights is probably not enough, you'll waste most of your time in transit. If you decide to give it a go (hey it's some adventure!) be sure to do it first in case something happens.

Make sure to push your trip at least a week after Ramadan. Everyone in Indo goes home and they'll be coming back to work after that so transport can be congested. Ramadan isn't a bad time to travel either, Bali is empty of most local tourists (although August is high season for the Aussies), and you'll get a different slice of life in Java and KK.

Your total trip is 14 days, that's about the minimum you'd want to spend after the 36 hrs it'll take you to get here from the US.

Peace!

susiesan Aug 31, 2012 9:08 am

I've been looking at flights from Yogyakarta to KK. I would have to transit through Jakarta or KUL. I cannot find any direct flights to KK from anywhere except CGK. It looks like this would chew up a good portion of a day. What would be another place on Java to spend a few days? I can end my trip to fly KA back to Hong Kong from DPS, Surabaya, or Jakarta.

Would it make sendose to stay on Bali the first 3 nights near a beach, then fly to Java and spend a week there between 2 cities, then fly back to Bali and spend 3 days at Ubud, then fly home form DPS?

Should I save Borneo for another trip? I have found out since the OP that I cannot stopover in Hong Kong or anywhere else if I use AA miles for this trip. Bummer. Hong Kong is out.

eponymous_coward Aug 31, 2012 1:06 pm


Originally Posted by susiesan (Post 19228995)
Would it make sende to stay on Bali the first 3 nights near a beach, then fly to Java and spend a week there between 2 cities, then fly back to Bali and spend 3 days at Ubud, then fly home form DPS?

Why waste a day in transit when you're already going to be in Bali at the start of things? Do you really like the idea of flying on Indonesian puddle jumper flights that much? :confused:

I'd probably do AA portions of the trip as a (in effect) an open-jaw of USA-HKG-DPS//SUB-HKG-USA.

And as I mentioned, if you're willing to spend a relatively small amount of BA miles (12.5K in Y pp, AMEX has a MR->BA bonus right now), you could bake in a HKG stopover on the return by having BA handle the SUB-HKG segment. (You may also need to do this on your MCI-AA hub segment; I very much doubt there's an MCI-DPS AND SUB-MCI through fare; AA awards need a through fare to redeem an award. I think the easiest way to get around that is redeem 4.5K BA miles pp for MCI-ORD or vv.)

The other possibility is timing your flights such that you can get close to a full day in HKG. I've sort of done that on an upcoming AS redemption where I wanted more destinations than I could reasonably squeeze in one redemption:

SEA-SFO(AS)-HKG(CX) in F
a day in HKG
HKG-BKK on CX in C, BA redemption @ 15K miles (but in effect 10K AMEX MR because of a bonus ;))
day or two in BKK
a week in the Andaman coast of Thailand and Malaysia, I'll fly into Penang, Langkawi or Phuket, this is TBD
end up in Penang, fly back PEN-HKG(this is back on the AS CX F award)
overnight in HKG
HKG-SFO//OAK-SEA (yes, I actually have to take BART to OAK to fly home without a 7 hour layover in SFO :rolleyes:)

susiesan Aug 31, 2012 1:44 pm

more good ideas for Susie
 

Originally Posted by eponymous_coward (Post 19230571)
Why waste a day in transit when you're already going to be in Bali at the start of things? Do you really like the idea of flying on Indonesian puddle jumper flights that much? :confused:

I'd probably do AA portions of the trip as a (in effect) an open-jaw of USA-HKG-DPS//SUB-HKG-USA.

And as I mentioned, if you're willing to spend a relatively small amount of BA miles (12.5K in Y pp, AMEX has a MR->BA bonus right now), you could bake in a HKG stopover on the return by having BA handle the SUB-HKG segment. (You may also need to do this on your MCI-AA hub segment; I very much doubt there's an MCI-DPS AND SUB-MCI through fare; AA awards need a through fare to redeem an award. I think the easiest way to get around that is redeem 4.5K BA miles pp for MCI-ORD or vv.)

The other possibility is timing your flights such that you can get close to a full day in HKG. I've sort of done that on an upcoming AS redemption where I wanted more destinations than I could reasonably squeeze in one redemption:

SEA-SFO(AS)-HKG(CX) in F
a day in HKG
HKG-BKK on CX in C, BA redemption @ 15K miles (but in effect 10K AMEX MR because of a bonus ;))
day or two in BKK
a week in the Andaman coast of Thailand and Malaysia, I'll fly into Penang, Langkawi or Phuket, this is TBD
end up in Penang, fly back PEN-HKG(this is back on the AS CX F award)
overnight in HKG
HKG-SFO//OAK-SEA (yes, I actually have to take BART to OAK to fly home without a 7 hour layover in SFO :rolleyes:)

You are right about the Indonesian puddle jumpers. I will try to plan my exit from java from SUB or CGK to save time.

AA has a fare MCI-DPS and SUB-MCI. The US flights are on AA and the TPC and into/out of Indonesia are on CX. I would be doing it like an open jaw, with 2 one way redemptions.

I'll look at the BA avios idea for getting the Hong Kong stay. I have plenty of MR points I can transfer to BA and already have an account set up that is empty of avios.

Thanks eponymous. More good ideas. FT people always have the best advice.

Too much travel Aug 31, 2012 8:44 pm

Given that you aren't travelling until September 2013, you should by then also have the option of getting from Bali/Java to KK via Malaysia Airlines, which should be in Oneworld by then, though obviously one won't be able to redeem points on them until they formally join sometime around the end of this year.

dowi Sep 1, 2012 10:46 am

well that's right, you don't need to waste the time to transit everywhere if your first 3 nights and you end your last 3 days in Bali before going home.
you can just adjust whether you will stay in Bali from the beginning or the end of your days-trip

susiesan Sep 1, 2012 1:23 pm


Originally Posted by Too much travel (Post 19232587)
Given that you aren't travelling until September 2013, you should by then also have the option of getting from Bali/Java to KK via Malaysia Airlines, which should be in Oneworld by then, though obviously one won't be able to redeem points on them until they formally join sometime around the end of this year.

I probably wouldn't use Malaysian for the TPAC flights because the flight from LAX-KUL-DPS has a stop in NRT where the CX flights are nonstop from LAX or SFO. And as I will begin the trip in MCI and have to stop in DFW to connect to the west coast, the less total travel time the better.

Malaysian doesn't fly KK-DPS direct, only through KUL. That would use up a full day of traveling. Air Asia has 1 flight a day on T, Th, Sat to KK from Jakarta, AK 6713 leaving at 7:20 pm. I'd have to find a flight from DPS or YOG on another airline that wouldn't have too much time on the ground transferring. I'd have to claim the luggage in Jakarta and recheck on to KK. I imagine I'd need to allow at least 2 hours as the departing flight is international.

Any suggestions of airlines to do this? Is it worth spending some time in Jakarta, maybe 1 or 2 nights?

eponymous_coward Sep 2, 2012 9:44 am


Originally Posted by susiesan (Post 19235681)
I probably wouldn't use Malaysian for the TPAC flights because the flight from LAX-KUL-DPS has a stop in NRT where the CX flights are nonstop from LAX or SFO. And as I will begin the trip in MCI and have to stop in DFW to connect to the west coast, the less total travel time the better.

Malaysian doesn't fly KK-DPS direct, only through KUL. That would use up a full day of traveling. Air Asia has 1 flight a day on T, Th, Sat to KK from Jakarta, AK 6713 leaving at 7:20 pm. I'd have to find a flight from DPS or YOG on another airline that wouldn't have too much time on the ground transferring. I'd have to claim the luggage in Jakarta and recheck on to KK. I imagine I'd need to allow at least 2 hours as the departing flight is international.

Any suggestions of airlines to do this? Is it worth spending some time in Jakarta, maybe 1 or 2 nights?

You can get to Brunei nonstop from Surabaya on Royal Brunei...

susiesan Sep 2, 2012 12:33 pm


Originally Posted by eponymous_coward (Post 19239226)
You can get to Brunei nonstop from Surabaya on Royal Brunei...

Looked it up. Plugged in April dates. Here's the schedule SUB-KK
BI 796 6:30am-9:40am Brunei stop
BI 823 11:35am-12:15 pm

Reverse KK-SUB
BI 826 7:30 pm-8:10pm Brunei
BI 795 9:40pm-11:50pm

Price on their web site is $225 one way now. I can leave KK for the US on CX as part of my award ticket. I have to think about whether I want to spend all of the 2 1/2 weeks in Indonesia or combine with Sabah.

What alliance is Royal Brunei part of? Maybe I can get a separate award to cover the flights.

eponymous_coward Sep 2, 2012 8:42 pm


Originally Posted by susiesan (Post 19240077)
Looked it up. Plugged in April dates. Here's the schedule SUB-KK
BI 796 6:30am-9:40am Brunei stop
BI 823 11:35am-12:15 pm

Reverse KK-SUB
BI 826 7:30 pm-8:10pm Brunei
BI 795 9:40pm-11:50pm

Price on their web site is $225 one way now. I can leave KK for the US on CX as part of my award ticket. I have to think about whether I want to spend all of the 2 1/2 weeks in Indonesia or combine with Sabah.

What alliance is Royal Brunei part of? Maybe I can get a separate award to cover the flights.

Not part of an alliance.

dsrfews Jan 10, 2013 3:02 am


Originally Posted by eponymous_coward (Post 19241910)
Not part of an alliance.

I agree!:D

Sam Bee Jan 14, 2013 2:52 am

If you're desperate to see Borneo - what about... Indonesian Borneo :confused:

It's 2/3 of the island, far less touristy than Sabah & Sarawak. And you can schedule in an easy trip, From Yogya it's an easy trip to Semarang where you can fly to Pangkalan Bun, then head up to Camp Leakey Orangutan Sanctuary, perhaps staying in a Klotok in the middle of Borneo overnight. I think now there are flights from Surabaya as well.

Lots of amazing things to see and do, research needed though.

OK, there are no 500+ room 5* hotels like in KK, but are these the reasons why people go to Borneo :confused:

P.S Who did you find KK-Jakarta flights through - I didn't think there was anything non-stop? Also, look at MI for connections from SUB to BKI. Or even Air Asia....

mario33 Jan 14, 2013 3:38 am


Originally Posted by Sam Bee (Post 20042424)
OK, there are no 500+ room 5* hotels like in KK, but are these the reasons why people go to Borneo :confused:..

Availability of comfortable accommodation & tourist infrastructure would determine which side of the border most tourist would go to. Trust me, I would rather spend an extra day flying, if I can be assure of 4-5 star accommodation and all the conveniences of a modern living rather than stay in some dusty cowboy town.

jiejie Jan 14, 2013 10:55 am


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 20042511)
Availability of comfortable accommodation & tourist infrastructure would determine which side of the border most tourist would go to. Trust me, I would rather spend an extra day flying, if I can be assure of 4-5 star accommodation and all the conveniences of a modern living rather than stay in some dusty cowboy town.

I wouldn't. I'm into dusty cowboys. I can be comfortable after I'm old.

Sam Bee Jan 15, 2013 6:23 am


Originally Posted by jiejie (Post 20044552)
I wouldn't. I'm into dusty cowboys. I can be comfortable after I'm old.

Quite!

This is Borneo we are talking about. Does that word in it's own right not bring up evocative images of jungles, rivers, Orang Utans, journeys and expeditions.

The world is sufficiently blighted by massive identikit concrete hotels. Spirit of adventure vs world of bland.

mario33 Jan 15, 2013 8:21 am


Originally Posted by Sam Bee (Post 20050075)
This is Borneo we are talking about. Does that word in it's own right not bring up evocative images of jungles, rivers, Orang Utans, journeys and expeditions.
.

Sure but if you can experience all that; plus having a nice hotel to go back to at the end of he day, where you are comfortable eating at local restaurants, where English is widely understood/spoken, where the roads are in decent conditions and you can move around comfortably; its not surprising why many choose to experience Borneo on this side of the border.

Sam Bee Jan 15, 2013 8:56 am


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 20050680)
Sure but if you can experience all that; plus having a nice hotel to go back to at the end of he day, where you are comfortable eating at local restaurants, where English is widely understood/spoken, where the roads are in decent conditions and you can move around comfortably; its not surprising why many choose to experience Borneo on this side of the border.

Yes. I read that BKI is Saga's 2nd biggest long haul destination after Florida. It's fine as long as people are aware of the sheer volume of numbers of tourists they will see on Turtle Island, that Sepilok feels like visiting a zoo at times.

It's sanitised. And if that is what you want, great. If you have your own visions of what you expect Borneo to be like, you probably will be dissappointed.

mario33 Jan 15, 2013 9:46 am


Originally Posted by Sam Bee (Post 20050880)
. If you have your own visions of what you expect Borneo to be like, you probably will be dissappointed.

My vision of Borneo is destruction of rain forests and oil palm plantations :rolleyes:

And for the orang utan experience, I much prefer Semengoh near Kuching over Sipolok. No it's not a zoo, its a real jungle but because its so close to Kuching where there is a Hilton, a Pullman, a Four Points etc its probably not 'Borneo' enough for some ;)

jiejie Jan 15, 2013 9:52 am


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 20051204)
My vision of Borneo is destruction of rain forests and oil palm plantations :rolleyes:

And for the orang utan experience, I much prefer Semengoh near Kuching over Sipolok. No it's not a zoo, its a real jungle but because its so close to Kuching where there is a Hilton, a Pullman, a Four Points etc its probably not 'Borneo' enough for some ;)

Precisely. There's little chance someone like me would make the effort to go to Borneo and then end up staying in hotels like these, at least as a tourist without the need for business-related functionality. I'd at least look for something more local and more independent.

I see that your "vision of Borneo" must not include enriching 5* building absentee owners based in country capitals, and multinational operators, at the expense of local operators. Hmm..... Thread doesn't need to veer too far into the political, but just sayin'.

Sam Bee Jan 15, 2013 11:32 am

I'm just planning my (2nd) Kalimantan trip (which is why I poked my nose in). I'm planning on hiring a Klotok, and sleeping on it just outside Camp Leakey.

Means I get to jungle trek with the Orangs at sunrise before any other tourists arrive. I imagine it'll be amazing sleeping outside on a thin mat under nothing but a mosquito net on a boat on a river in the heart of Borneo!

I'll pick my lovely plush comfortable hotel afterwards near Borobudur. Not Amanjiwo or Losari (or whatever the new name is) as i've done them. Considering Plataran (anyone?). Either way, it won't have a business centre, a coachload of blue rinse, and with a bit of luck no mobile phone reception!

mario33 Jan 15, 2013 7:39 pm


Originally Posted by jiejie (Post 20051260)
I see that your "vision of Borneo" must not include enriching 5* building absentee owners based in country capitals, and multinational operators'.

These 5 star buildings are also providing jobs for the locals, many who used to work in places like KL or Singapore are able to return home and have a long term career in hospitality and close to their families at the same time.

And generally international hotel operators look after their employees better than local operators.

mario33 Jan 15, 2013 7:44 pm


Originally Posted by Sam Bee (Post 20051955)
Means I get to jungle trek with the Orangs at sunrise before any other tourists arrive. I imagine it'll be amazing sleeping outside on a thin mat under nothing but a mosquito net on a boat on a river in the heart of Borneo!

Hope that the mosquitoes and leeches will be kind to you ;)

BTW you shouldn't use the term 'orang' on its own, it means people and you see more of them in KK city centre.

jiejie Jan 15, 2013 11:48 pm


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 20055213)
These 5 star buildings are also providing jobs for the locals, many who used to work in places like KL or Singapore are able to return home and have a long term career in hospitality and close to their families at the same time.

And generally international hotel operators look after their employees better than local operators.

Talk about trying to defend a position with specious reasoning and unsupported assertions! Never mind, this entire discussion is a completely unproductive threadjack and doesn't add enlightenment to the OP's original question....and is now irrelevant anyway since the OP has now amended her trip plans and moved on to another thread.

mario33 Jan 16, 2013 12:56 am


Originally Posted by jiejie (Post 20056626)
Talk about trying to defend a position with specious reasoning and unsupported assertions! Never mind, this entire discussion is a completely unproductive threadjack and doesn't add enlightenment to the OP's original question....and is now irrelevant anyway since the OP has now amended her trip plans and moved on to another thread.

You have your point of view, and I have mine. If you want to give your money to the smaller operators that's your prerogative. But please do not impose your 'Americanised' views on others, which is always support the small guys.

I am looking at the bigger picture here; the smaller local operators will not give the local workers the sort of training nor exposure for them to take on bigger roles later in their career. And for most local workers I have met (including those in Borneo) it's a privilege for them to be working for some big American chains. And these jobs are actually keeping them at home ! Otherwise they would be in Singapore or somewhere in the middle east.

Sam Bee Jan 16, 2013 5:51 am


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 20055243)
Hope that the mosquitoes and leeches will be kind to you ;)

BTW you shouldn't use the term 'orang' on its own, it means people and you see more of them in KK city centre.

Thank you. I also know what Utan means. Years of living and working in Indonesia means my Bahasa is passable. I'm happy with my context!

I also try and support small local entrepreneurs where I can, especially in Indonesia which thrives off village economies. Rather than multicorps that send their profits back to shareholders back in Europe / America thanks (i'm not American btw).

But as jiejie rightly points out this is threadcreep, apologies. I might post a picture I have of a leech on my right testicle from Sumatra to bring it back onto topic.

mario33 Jan 17, 2013 7:03 am


Originally Posted by Sam Bee (Post 20057667)
Thank you. I also know what Utan means. Years of living and working in Indonesia means my Bahasa is passable.

For more reason you should use the correct term !

It's very annoying listening to some 'bule' use the term 'orang' to describe 'orang utan' as if its the correct and accepted term. The next time I am in London, I should probably ask for directions to Buckingham..... you know the one where the Queen lives ....


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:55 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.