FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Asia (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asia-460/)
-   -   Best city in Asia to live as a base for SE Asia travel (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asia/1298386-best-city-asia-live-base-se-asia-travel.html)

CrazyInteg Feb 16, 2012 9:31 am


Originally Posted by in2it54 (Post 18011480)
I reckon he's chasing a lifestyle thing - not primaryily a CBD and airport.

What does this mean? I don't know what a "lifestyle thing" is.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
Are the airport taxis controlled by mafias, and whats the fare like for a short ride out of the airport permeter ?

How are the public transport like, and is it easy to get around the island ?

How is the food in Bali compared with Bangkok, Singapore or Kuala Lumpur ?

How are medical facilities as compared with Bangkok, Singapore or Kuala Lumpur ?

Can somebody please answer these questions regarding Bali?

smith80678 Feb 16, 2012 9:33 am


Originally Posted by dsquared37 (Post 18019351)
MNL, CGK and SGN don't hold a candle to BKK. Sorry.

MNL cant hold a candle? Not if you are a single man:cool:;)

CrazyInteg Feb 16, 2012 9:39 am


Originally Posted by smith80678 (Post 18027215)
MNL cant hold a candle? Not if you are a single man:cool:;)

Does marital status have an effect on finding a hub for SE Asian travel? The OP has already stated they are married with two young children.

illinidad Feb 16, 2012 2:43 pm

Answers to questions about DPS
 

Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
And how many hours to Hanoi ?

Per Kayak.com, looks like about 6 hours, not including layover time. I checked going through SIN, which is about 2hr from DPS. SIN to HAN is about 3.5 hrs.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
How are the fares out of DPS as compared to BKK or SIN ?

Dunno. See www.kayak.com or your favorite travel site/agent.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
Are the airport taxis controlled by mafias, and whats the fare like for a short ride out of the airport permeter ?

No idea about the mafia question, nor the cab fare. My suggestion to the OP (and anyone else) is to hire a car for a day if you need to do any significant driving. The car should come with a driver. Strongly suggest you NOT drive yourself there.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
How are the public transport like, and is it easy to get around the island ?

Don't really know that much about the public transport in Bali (buses mainly, there are no trains like the MRT in SIN), but if you're staying in Kuta, Sanur or Nusa Dua, or other fairly populated area, its easy to get a cab to/from the airport. Of course, your hotel may also offer a shuttle. Within each area, I think there is enough transport to get you around that area. Nusa Dua for example, has frequent shuttles to and from the hotels the little shopping/dining plaza and the golf course. It's when you want to go from one to the other where I think its best to have your own vehicle.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
How is the food in Bali compared with Bangkok, Singapore or Kuala Lumpur ?

Don't know anything about BKK, but I think Bali is a little more limited than SIN and KUL. In SIN, you can get just about anything you're looking for - Japanese, Indian, American, Italian, French, etc. etc. - and at many different price points. Bali has a pretty wide variety too, which is obviously driven by the tourists. But, quality is more varied. There are also Russian restaurants there. I mentioned in a previous post that many Javanese do not like local Balinese food - at least, those that I know. I think its relatively bland compared to some of the spicy dishes you can get in Java.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
How are medical facilities as compared with Bangkok, Singapore or Kuala Lumpur ?

Never had to use them in DPS, so not speaking from experience, but I think they are adequate for minor issues (simple ER cases) and to stabilize a patient in more serious cases prior to flying out to get care from a specialist in say, SIN, DRW, maybe CGK.


Originally Posted by mario33 (Post 18000090)
...But suggesting DPS as a base to travel around SE Asia is pure lunacy !

Strongly disagree. Maybe for you it is, but a decent case can be made for DPS. See my earlier post about this. At least one other post has mentioned pretty low airfares vs. Oz at least. So there are definitely pluses to DPS.

yosithezet Feb 16, 2012 4:48 pm


Originally Posted by illinidad (Post 18029349)
At least one other post has mentioned pretty low airfares vs. Oz at least.

Airfares need to be compared to BKK, KUL, SIN not Oz. Oz isn't even in the running.

HKtraveller Feb 16, 2012 5:41 pm

For airfares SIN is definitely the best, as Tiger is more often than not significantly cheaper than Airasia.
One example: HKG/MFM-SIN-SGN is at times half the price of HKG/MFM-BKK-SGN (I live in Hong Kong)
even KUL-SIN-final destination could be an economic option.

dsquared37 Feb 16, 2012 5:45 pm


Originally Posted by smith80678 (Post 18027215)
MNL cant hold a candle? Not if you are a single man:cool:;)

OP is going with family.

I think we're all aware there's something to go to MNL for. Food, history, safety are not on that list.

dsquared37 Feb 16, 2012 5:46 pm

[QUOTE=illinidad;18024909]First, hope this is a fantastic experience for your family, especially the children. What great memories this will make.[quote]

Agreed.


Originally Posted by illinidad (Post 18024909)
Geographically, HKG or TYO just don't cut it as a base for SEAsia. Makes no sense to me...You'd just spend too much time in the air....

Interesting to see that MNL got a few mentions. Geographically, it's also probably a bit far away to use as a base. And the safety issues? Definitely a black mark....

DPS is a very intruiging suggestion.

Why? DPS has few direct flights. It's on the edge of SE Asia in the same way the HKG is on the edge - and you outright cut HKG from your list. Getting to BKK, SGN, HAN, VTE, RGN, KUL from DPS is at least as long as HKG or MNL and yet you knocked both of those off your list.

DPS would be a great place for OP to visit in their 3 months, I don't see it as a feasible hub.


Originally Posted by illinidad (Post 18024909)
KUL doesn't seem like a bad choice. I don't know it nearly as well as SIN, but I agree with the positive comments about the flavorful food, it has many modern conveniences you're going to want at your base, and it's pretty safe. Plus it is pretty cheap.

KUL isn't a bad choice. I'd rate it second to BKK. :D


Originally Posted by illinidad (Post 18024909)
The other thing that I noted as I read through the thread is that no one has mentioned possible culture shock issues. I know you didn't mention it, and its likely you have far more awareness than most Americans, but this is something to think about since your base will be 'home'.

Culture shock that a 3 month visit begets is very different from that an expat learns about.


Originally Posted by illinidad (Post 18024909)
Having been an expat, the newness and wonder of being immersed in a new and totally different culture (Indonesia)....Fortunately, the national language uses Roman letters, so at least I could read signs and hazard a guess at pronunciation, possibly meaning. But Thai? Forget it.

Pronunciation can be problematic, it's why I learned to read Thai. :D

Understandably this is not an option for the normal tourist, but there are many people who have lived in Thailand for years and barely know how to introduce themselves in Thai. For what OP desires to do the language barrier won't be problematic in Thailand.

bryannn Feb 16, 2012 5:51 pm


Originally Posted by yosithezet (Post 18019603)
Your nationality clouds your judgement because although you've spent so many years outside of the Philippines you speak the language, blend in and have a better ability to understand the unspoken nuances of behaviour than someone who has never spent time in the Philippines. This influences your sense of personal safety and ability to determine what is acceptable from a hygiene perspective and generally navigate the city/country. You have a better idea of what is going on around you.

I lived in Israel for many years. I speak Hebrew. My sense of personal security and my ability to navigate society is very different than a first time visitor. I have spent a great deal of time in India and Thailand over the past number of years. There are points where the lack of ability to speak the local languages can be an issue, but generally my ability to navigate and assess my surroundings is much better than someone who is on their first or second short trip.

A number of years ago I went on a business trip to Holland. It was the first time I was in a country where I could read the latin characters but had no idea what they said. I had to make my way from Schipol to a place called 's-Hertogenbosch by train. Generally Holland is a fairly safe place. I blend in. But the lack of language and inability to understand what I was reading gave me an uneasy feeling that I needed to ask much more often whether I was heading to the right place. When I finally arrived at 's-Hertogenbosch I found out that while I was trying to pronounce 's-Hertogenbosch the Dutch call the place "Den Bosch". So you can imagine a Dutch person that hadn't lived in Holland for many years would still have a much more comfortable experience than I had. The way you experience the Philippines is very different to the way a couple with young children who have never spent time there will experience it. They may have trouble getting their head around the signs that say "Please check your firearms before entering". Maybe they should avoid Texas as well. ;)

"'s Hertogenbosch" and "Den Bosch" are interchangeable, unlike, for instance, 's Gravenhage and Den Haag ("The Hague"), where 's Gravenhage is considered antiquated.

But yeah, it's a real bummer the way road signs don't reflect the dual name situation. It must be horrendous to be driving around endlessly trying to find "Den Bosch", which your map says is right there, but meanwhile it's nowhere to be found on any road sign.

TrueBlueFlyer Feb 16, 2012 11:44 pm


Originally Posted by bryannn (Post 18030421)
But yeah, it's a real bummer the way road signs don't reflect the dual name situation. It must be horrendous to be driving around endlessly trying to find "Den Bosch", which your map says is right there, but meanwhile it's nowhere to be found on any road sign.

This can happen in other places too, including Singapore where New Bridge Road is briefly Eu Tong Sen Street :)

jpatokal Feb 17, 2012 3:46 am


Originally Posted by TrueBlueFlyer (Post 18031835)
This can happen in other places too, including Singapore where New Bridge Road is briefly Eu Tong Sen Street :)

Nope -- it looks like a single ordinary road to us mere mortals, but New Bridge Rd is the southbound lanes, and Eu Tong Sen St is the northbound lanes! :eek:

TrueBlueFlyer Feb 17, 2012 4:03 am


Originally Posted by jpatokal (Post 18032348)
Nope -- it looks like a single ordinary road to us mere mortals, but New Bridge Rd is the southbound lanes, and Eu Tong Sen St is the northbound lanes! :eek:

with a covered canal in the middle?

jpatokal Feb 17, 2012 8:54 pm


Originally Posted by TrueBlueFlyer (Post 18032382)
with a covered canal in the middle?

Yup!

bazers Mar 8, 2013 9:51 am

Thought I should give an update. We did make the trip and decided on Kuala Lumpur for our main "hub" as we traveled around SE Asia for 4 months.

From our base, we did trips to Thailand, Indonesia, Cambodia, Vietnam, Singapore and the island of Borneo (Malaysian side).

For our circumstance we felt like we made a great choice. We did Singapore (a lot more expensive - yet nice) and Bangkok (dirty, crazy and a bit cheaper).

KUL had a lot to offer our family and we didn't get bored. We found a furnished condo 100 yards from the Petronas Towers so we were able to walk to shops and restaurants and taxis are very reasonable. English is widely spoken and the variety of cultures kept things interesting. There were a number of different holidays/festivals while we were there.

We used Air Asia (I think we had 10 different RT flights) and they were a great airline. Clean, never once late. I signed up for their email newsletter so I got notified when they were running a sale. For the really cheap tickets you need to book quite a bit in advance. KUL is their hub so it was non-stop flights everywhere we went.

Thanks to everyone who gave meaningful advice which helped us plan our trip.

yosithezet Mar 8, 2013 10:43 am

Thanks for updating. Glad to hear you had a great time!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:17 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.