Declined for Amex Green card
I applied online for the new Amex Green 45k offer with private browsing. I got the "We're sorry, XXXXX. We can't approve your application at this time" message. I called in and the agent could give me no info on what specifically was the issue, said I get a letter with more info and suggested trying again after 30 days. All he could say was base on my credit report and my account open/close I was not eligible for a signup bonus. He couldn't even confirm if a hard credit check was done or not.
Currently I have 1 Amex card, have only closed 1 (business) card with Amex a year ago, I have excellent credit score, have had a handful personal and biz cards on credit report, only at 2/24 with Chase. Have recent mortgage and car loan on credit report so maybe Amex see risk here? Has anyone else experienced this and is there anything that can be done to get approved? This is the first card I have ever been declined on from any bank and the lack of transparency from Amex is frustrating! |
As the agent told you, you will receive a written notice.
Not worth 10 seconds of your time speculating about the reason(s) until you have read that letter carefully. Perhaps it's an error and you can get it corrected and the card issued. Perhaps you don't meet Amex's underwriting for the card so you've been properly denied. Why not come back here once you have your letter. |
This also just happened to me. I normally never have any issues getting approved with ANY issuer (except 5/24). Am curious if anyone else has this problem.
|
AMEX Green
Might want to pull your credit report from Credit Karma and see. If you have an established history with AMEX, should be no hard pull.
I was under the impression AMEX charge cards, especially the Green was much easier to be approved vs the AMEX credit cards. good luck. |
Originally Posted by 3sgtekb
(Post 31938496)
....curious if anyone else has this problem.
|
Originally Posted by Often1
(Post 31867330)
As the agent told you, you will receive a written notice.
Not worth 10 seconds of your time speculating about the reason(s) until you have read that letter carefully. Perhaps it's an error and you can get it corrected and the card issued. Perhaps you don't meet Amex's underwriting for the card so you've been properly denied. Why not come back here once you have your letter. Another DP. My friend also applied for Amex Green card and was denied for it for the same reason. He has had about 4 new personal cards in last 6 months and has never even had an Amex card. |
Originally Posted by flyguy6
(Post 31945637)
My friend also applied for Amex Green card and was denied for it for the same reason.
|
My impression is that AmEx puts a lot of weight on your previous history/experience with them. A recent slightly late payment that AmEx didn't even report could cause trouble. They also might not like the recently closed account.
Do you know for sure whether you were denied the bonus or the card itself? |
Originally Posted by Steve M
(Post 31946085)
If you don't (yet) know the reason for your denial, how do you know that your friend got denied for the same reason you did?
According to my friend he was to told it was due to too many recent inquires by the phone rep. He is waiting on the letter. Update, I received my denial letter.
Originally Posted by MSPeconomist
(Post 31946118)
My impression is that AmEx puts a lot of weight on your previous history/experience with them. A recent slightly late payment that AmEx didn't even report could cause trouble. They also might not like the recently closed account.
Do you know for sure whether you were denied the bonus or the card itself? https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...ec0481135b.jpg |
Originally Posted by flyguy6
(Post 31946627)
I received my denial letter..
|
Originally Posted by mia
(Post 31946821)
Too many new bank card accounts. That's reasonably specific.
|
Originally Posted by Steve M
(Post 31947013)
... and is a different reason than what his friend was reportedly told over the phone.
All he said was that he was denied for the "same" reason, being the accounts open / close. |
Originally Posted by Gasolin
(Post 31948512)
What do you mean? I don't think the reason of his friend was specified.
All he said was that he was denied for the "same" reason, being the accounts open / close. |
Any idea what is considered too many new bank cards? From what I have read there an no well understood rule on what Amex considers too many (unlike Chase 5/24).
Here are my number on Experian. I am surprised to see that my business card are showing up here too. Total Experian inquires: 15 Bank card inquires: 6 |
Thats crazy cause they are handing out that Amex green card like candy compared to their other offerings. Probably best to cool off on applications for a while.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 9:40 pm. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.