Luggage lost ahead of pre-clearance inspection - bizarre experience
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jun 2020
Location: BOS
Programs: AA EXP, Hilton DMD, Hyatt Glob, Hertz PC
Posts: 266
Luggage lost ahead of pre-clearance inspection - bizarre experience
Not sure whether this belongs in the AA or AY forum, or elsewhere, but heres some travel hell:
Late 2019, I was flying YUL-JFK-HEL-SIN on the AY ex-Canada J fare.
Checked in 3 hours early at YUL for the feeder, and was (for no apparent reason) flagged for secondary inspection by the global entry passport control agent.
But by this point, AA had already lost my luggage.
The inspection of course could not take place until my luggage was found. Also, border control did not allow me to leave the holding pen to call AA or talk to an agent on site. By the time the bags were located (several hours later), the feeder was long gone.
The AAgents tried to rebook me on BA that night, but AY refused to allow this, stating that the ticket would be cancelled for no refund as I had been marked as a no-show. AY customer service was absolutely impossible to work with, and meanwhile, AA was unable to communicate the reason I had missed the flight. (It did not help that AY claimed to not be able to read the notes in the reservation.)
AY eventually said that AA would have to reissue the outbound on their own stock, in order for the return to be protected. AA refused, stating that the baggage issue was caused by the airport, and is not our responsibility. (I am skeptical of this, as I thought that baggage issues lie with the airline.) They did rebook me on the feeder for the next day, but no further.
The OW desk (I was PLAT at the time) was also unable to get through to AY also, at least in the time I spent on the line with them.
The next day, and after double-digit hours on the phone and being on first-name basis with every AAgent at YUL, I boarded the feeder, still not sure what to expect at JFK. Mysteriously, BPs printed just as they were supposed to this time on blueberry backdrop.
A year later, and I still have not been able to solve the mystery of how I was rebooked. Was I saved by some AY version of the Flat Tire Rule? Its also possible it was done in error by one of the AY agents.
AA wont talk to me about this when I write them, I just get autoreplies (TSA lines can be long.. etc). They also politely declined to cover the hotel the night I was stranded at YUL. I was at least pleased that the miles for JFK-HEL-SIN ended up double posting, so I figure we can call it even.
So Im wondering, is there any precedence for this? Has this happened to any of you? I havent been able to find anything on what the procedure should be if luggage is lost ahead of a pre-clearance inspection.
There are of course many additional infuriating details I had to leave out for the sake of readability.
Late 2019, I was flying YUL-JFK-HEL-SIN on the AY ex-Canada J fare.
Checked in 3 hours early at YUL for the feeder, and was (for no apparent reason) flagged for secondary inspection by the global entry passport control agent.
But by this point, AA had already lost my luggage.
The inspection of course could not take place until my luggage was found. Also, border control did not allow me to leave the holding pen to call AA or talk to an agent on site. By the time the bags were located (several hours later), the feeder was long gone.
The AAgents tried to rebook me on BA that night, but AY refused to allow this, stating that the ticket would be cancelled for no refund as I had been marked as a no-show. AY customer service was absolutely impossible to work with, and meanwhile, AA was unable to communicate the reason I had missed the flight. (It did not help that AY claimed to not be able to read the notes in the reservation.)
AY eventually said that AA would have to reissue the outbound on their own stock, in order for the return to be protected. AA refused, stating that the baggage issue was caused by the airport, and is not our responsibility. (I am skeptical of this, as I thought that baggage issues lie with the airline.) They did rebook me on the feeder for the next day, but no further.
The OW desk (I was PLAT at the time) was also unable to get through to AY also, at least in the time I spent on the line with them.
The next day, and after double-digit hours on the phone and being on first-name basis with every AAgent at YUL, I boarded the feeder, still not sure what to expect at JFK. Mysteriously, BPs printed just as they were supposed to this time on blueberry backdrop.
A year later, and I still have not been able to solve the mystery of how I was rebooked. Was I saved by some AY version of the Flat Tire Rule? Its also possible it was done in error by one of the AY agents.
AA wont talk to me about this when I write them, I just get autoreplies (TSA lines can be long.. etc). They also politely declined to cover the hotel the night I was stranded at YUL. I was at least pleased that the miles for JFK-HEL-SIN ended up double posting, so I figure we can call it even.
So Im wondering, is there any precedence for this? Has this happened to any of you? I havent been able to find anything on what the procedure should be if luggage is lost ahead of a pre-clearance inspection.
There are of course many additional infuriating details I had to leave out for the sake of readability.
#2
Used to be 'Travelergcp'
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: New Orleans
Programs: AA Plat, Marriott Gold, Hyatt Globalist
Posts: 2,823
AA is always quick to remind you that customs and immigration delays aren’t their problem. I doubt you’ll get anywhere with this.
Can you claim the hotel on travel insurance via a credit card?
Can you claim the hotel on travel insurance via a credit card?
#4
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: NRT / HND
Programs: AA EXP, NH Plat, Former UA 1K
Posts: 5,562
I've never used pre-check in Canada as a point of origin, only as a connection, but on a transit, you wait near transit security until your bags come up on a video screen and identify them and then proceed to US immigration. I suppose if the officer wants to do an inspection then they order it at that point. Sounds as if the process must be similar for passengers originating at the pre-check airport from the account of the OP.
#5
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: ORD
Programs: AA, UA, GE
Posts: 5,115
I've never used pre-check in Canada as a point of origin, only as a connection, but on a transit, you wait near transit security until your bags come up on a video screen and identify them and then proceed to US immigration. I suppose if the officer wants to do an inspection then they order it at that point. Sounds as if the process must be similar for passengers originating at the pre-check airport from the account of the OP.
The last time I checked my bags at a preclearance airport for direct entry to the US was in July 2019 at YYZ. It was a very smooth process. I do not remember CBP looking at my luggage on a monitor. But I am a GE member and that may change the procedure for baggage screening.
#6
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
Air carriers, including AA and AY are set up to handle post-travel issues as complaints which are then dealt with through a customer service gesture, reimbursement or compensation. There is really no "discussion" to be had and, if there ever was, the details of it are likely long lost or certainly not in any active session.
Indeed OP's checked bag would have physically gone through a unified system at YUL and that is all part of CSBA and CBP for pre-clearance. Highly unlikely that AA had anything to do with that unless it mistagged the bag (which OP would have seen when it was retrieved). As the operating carrier on the day of travel, it was down to AA, if anybody, to rebook. It apparently took the initial "legal" position that it did not cause the delay or no show and that it thus had no obligation to reroute.
My guess is that OP rightly pestered enough people that someone got through to someone sufficiently senior to override the system and either permit the rebooking at one or both carriers. Who did what likely is not easily traceable without a forensic audit and for all OP knows, whoever did it does not particularly want their actions to be subject to criticism.
Presuming that OP's local expenses were covered by travel insurance there is not much to be done here and likely nowhere to solidly pin the blame.
Indeed OP's checked bag would have physically gone through a unified system at YUL and that is all part of CSBA and CBP for pre-clearance. Highly unlikely that AA had anything to do with that unless it mistagged the bag (which OP would have seen when it was retrieved). As the operating carrier on the day of travel, it was down to AA, if anybody, to rebook. It apparently took the initial "legal" position that it did not cause the delay or no show and that it thus had no obligation to reroute.
My guess is that OP rightly pestered enough people that someone got through to someone sufficiently senior to override the system and either permit the rebooking at one or both carriers. Who did what likely is not easily traceable without a forensic audit and for all OP knows, whoever did it does not particularly want their actions to be subject to criticism.
Presuming that OP's local expenses were covered by travel insurance there is not much to be done here and likely nowhere to solidly pin the blame.
#7
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Canada, USA, Europe
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 31,452
I have not pre-cleared at YUL, but many times at YYZ and, from memory, it seems particularly difficult to lose luggage in that arrangement. I'm curious how exactly this happened. Does anyone have any photos of the setup?
#8
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: Paradise
Posts: 1,616
It is done this way for a few reasons, namely so that bags can be properly screened/x-rayed before they enter US customs area. Anything illegal/restricted is noted and the bag flagged until the person steps in front of a agent, where questioning begins before being taken for a secondary screening.
#10
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
I'm not so sure that it is AA which handles those bags at that stage, e.g. CBSA to Pre-Clearance. As between CBSA, CBP and whatever contractor they use to schlep bags onto and off various belts, who knows.
#11
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Phoenix, AZ
Programs: HH Gold, AA Gold
Posts: 10,451
OP, the answer is NO. You will never find out exactly what happened, because honestly it sounds like nobody knows exactly what happened. Assuming AA tagged your bags correctly (if you kept your bag tag receipts, you can verify this), then they somehow got lost in the airport luggage system. It is unfortunate, but things like this happen. It sounds like the AAgents worked hard to get you out that day, but AY was uncooperative.
#12
Original Poster
Join Date: Jun 2020
Location: BOS
Programs: AA EXP, Hilton DMD, Hyatt Glob, Hertz PC
Posts: 266
Wow, these are all really good points! Thank you!
Ive had extraordinarily good luck over the years, but of course this was one of the few big trips I charged to the AMEX Platinum before they added trip delay reimbursement. I ended up writing it off as a business expense.
Dont know much about the setup, but heres a thing:
The officer pulled up pictures of each of my two bags and asked me to confirm they were mine. One of them had a green checkmark in the upper left corner. But the other had a grey X instead. Not sure what that means. Im GE fwiw.
Should have gone into more detail on how it happened: My bags were tagged correctly, but were loaded on the plane without being scanned. (Someone mentioned that they had been having trouble with the scanner)
So when CBP called for them, they were not where the system thought they were, and nobody bothered to look on the plane, where they were hiding the whole time. Only until I no-showed did they check on the plane to pull the bags.
There was certainly pestering! I could definitely see this, that one person may have been my secret savior here.
I think this sums it. AY was hellacious. I hope to never run afoul of them again. I was really floored, because I had heard great things about their customer service, and figured a biz ticket with OW status would be better protected in the event of failures. In my experience, AA has always been great about fixing messes and protecting connections, so Im somewhat surprised there too.
I sort of wonder if AY was hoping that AA would pay up (since they technically created the problem by losing track of the bags), and when they didnt relented and rebooked my itinerary to avoid chargeback/legal action etc. Or perhaps AA did secretly pay after enough pestering and realizing they screwed up.
Ive pretty much found peace with the fact Ill probably never know what actually happened. But I definitely will be avoiding any itinerary that mixes AA and AY (or any airline and AY).
I also wonder if, had this happened at an AA hub and not an outstation, this would have all been tied up in a little bundle in a matter of minutes.
The officer pulled up pictures of each of my two bags and asked me to confirm they were mine. One of them had a green checkmark in the upper left corner. But the other had a grey X instead. Not sure what that means. Im GE fwiw.
Should have gone into more detail on how it happened: My bags were tagged correctly, but were loaded on the plane without being scanned. (Someone mentioned that they had been having trouble with the scanner)
So when CBP called for them, they were not where the system thought they were, and nobody bothered to look on the plane, where they were hiding the whole time. Only until I no-showed did they check on the plane to pull the bags.
My guess is that OP rightly pestered enough people that someone got through to someone sufficiently senior to override the system and either permit the rebooking at one or both carriers. Who did what likely is not easily traceable without a forensic audit and for all OP knows, whoever did it does not particularly want their actions to be subject to criticism.
OP, the answer is NO. You will never find out exactly what happened, because honestly it sounds like nobody knows exactly what happened. Assuming AA tagged your bags correctly (if you kept your bag tag receipts, you can verify this), then they somehow got lost in the airport luggage system. It is unfortunate, but things like this happen. It sounds like the AAgents worked hard to get you out that day, but AY was uncooperative.
I sort of wonder if AY was hoping that AA would pay up (since they technically created the problem by losing track of the bags), and when they didnt relented and rebooked my itinerary to avoid chargeback/legal action etc. Or perhaps AA did secretly pay after enough pestering and realizing they screwed up.
Ive pretty much found peace with the fact Ill probably never know what actually happened. But I definitely will be avoiding any itinerary that mixes AA and AY (or any airline and AY).
I also wonder if, had this happened at an AA hub and not an outstation, this would have all been tied up in a little bundle in a matter of minutes.
#13
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Houston, TX, USA
Programs: UA 1K, AA Lifetime Platinum, DL Platinum, Honors Diamond, Bonvoy Titanium, Hertz Platinum
Posts: 7,954
Nearly a year later, you're just now coming to peace with not knowing what actually happened? I can only imagine the amount of effort and angst you've invested in this situation over the past year. Give it up and move on with life. As others have alluded to, once your immediate ticketing problem was resolved, it's unlikely that you'll ever find out exactly what happened and how it got fixed. Aside from a mild curiosity, I don't see how it much matters Assuming that all the carriers involved are happy with the resolution in terms of everyone getting paid, it's unlikely that any customer service inquiry is going to yield any answers. They're not going to take the trouble to try to figure out who did what a year ago when there's really no issue pending.
#14
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: MSP/BUF/BNA/LFT
Programs: AA Plat, Priority Club Gold, Choice Privileges Gold
Posts: 1,223
Wow, these are all really good points! Thank you!
Ive had extraordinarily good luck over the years, but of course this was one of the few big trips I charged to the AMEX Platinum before they added trip delay reimbursement. I ended up writing it off as a business expense.
Dont know much about the setup, but heres a thing:
The officer pulled up pictures of each of my two bags and asked me to confirm they were mine. One of them had a green checkmark in the upper left corner. But the other had a grey X instead. Not sure what that means. Im GE fwiw.
Should have gone into more detail on how it happened: My bags were tagged correctly, but were loaded on the plane without being scanned. (Someone mentioned that they had been having trouble with the scanner)
So when CBP called for them, they were not where the system thought they were, and nobody bothered to look on the plane, where they were hiding the whole time. Only until I no-showed did they check on the plane to pull the bags.
There was certainly pestering! I could definitely see this, that one person may have been my secret savior here.
I think this sums it. AY was hellacious. I hope to never run afoul of them again. I was really floored, because I had heard great things about their customer service, and figured a biz ticket with OW status would be better protected in the event of failures. In my experience, AA has always been great about fixing messes and protecting connections, so Im somewhat surprised there too.
I sort of wonder if AY was hoping that AA would pay up (since they technically created the problem by losing track of the bags), and when they didnt relented and rebooked my itinerary to avoid chargeback/legal action etc. Or perhaps AA did secretly pay after enough pestering and realizing they screwed up.
Ive pretty much found peace with the fact Ill probably never know what actually happened. But I definitely will be avoiding any itinerary that mixes AA and AY (or any airline and AY).
I also wonder if, had this happened at an AA hub and not an outstation, this would have all been tied up in a little bundle in a matter of minutes.
Ive had extraordinarily good luck over the years, but of course this was one of the few big trips I charged to the AMEX Platinum before they added trip delay reimbursement. I ended up writing it off as a business expense.
Dont know much about the setup, but heres a thing:
The officer pulled up pictures of each of my two bags and asked me to confirm they were mine. One of them had a green checkmark in the upper left corner. But the other had a grey X instead. Not sure what that means. Im GE fwiw.
Should have gone into more detail on how it happened: My bags were tagged correctly, but were loaded on the plane without being scanned. (Someone mentioned that they had been having trouble with the scanner)
So when CBP called for them, they were not where the system thought they were, and nobody bothered to look on the plane, where they were hiding the whole time. Only until I no-showed did they check on the plane to pull the bags.
There was certainly pestering! I could definitely see this, that one person may have been my secret savior here.
I think this sums it. AY was hellacious. I hope to never run afoul of them again. I was really floored, because I had heard great things about their customer service, and figured a biz ticket with OW status would be better protected in the event of failures. In my experience, AA has always been great about fixing messes and protecting connections, so Im somewhat surprised there too.
I sort of wonder if AY was hoping that AA would pay up (since they technically created the problem by losing track of the bags), and when they didnt relented and rebooked my itinerary to avoid chargeback/legal action etc. Or perhaps AA did secretly pay after enough pestering and realizing they screwed up.
Ive pretty much found peace with the fact Ill probably never know what actually happened. But I definitely will be avoiding any itinerary that mixes AA and AY (or any airline and AY).
I also wonder if, had this happened at an AA hub and not an outstation, this would have all been tied up in a little bundle in a matter of minutes.
#15
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: NYC
Programs: AA 2MM, Bonvoy LTT, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 14,620
Are the AA staff in YUL outsourced? I don't really get why they didn't just make the changes and reissue the ticket themselves. They have control of the ticket on day of departure and AY is a JV partner so it is not that big of a deal. I think you just encountered some poorly trained staff.
JV may or may not apply depending on the fare. This sounds like a fare published only by AY.
If OP still have the boarding passes for the rebooked flights, it would show the ticket number. If the number starts with 001 then it meant AA rebooked on their own stock.